Is content marketing still relevant in 2024? In this podcast episode, inspired by one of our listeners and insights from marketing guru Rand Fishkin, we dive into how the content marketing landscape has evolved, the challenges of achieving visibility,...
Loading summary
A
Welcome to the Digital Marketing Podcast brought to you by targetinternet.com hello, and welcome back to the Digital Marketing Podcast. My name is Kieran Rogers.
B
I'm Louise Crossley.
C
And I'm Daniel Rolls.
A
And today we are asking, is content marketing dead?
C
No, it's not. Thank you very much for listening to the Digital Marketing Podcast. I know, actually. Okay, let's say where this one came from, really. Das Dowding, who is a listener of the podcast, we did a previous one from Australia as well, did a previous episode and we had talked about 10x content and we kind of obviously credited Rand with it coming up with this 10x content thing ages ago. And she went, well, yeah. But Rand has since come out and said that he doesn't think it really works anymore. So I just want to read you the quote. So he's asked, does 10x content still work? The idea you can do exceptional content, it will stand out. It will create all those great signals that the Google algorithm is looking for. And Randy came out, said when he was asked about this, said, God, I wish I could say yes. I wish the answer was yes. But if you look at what does well and what's popular, you'll see it's not ton at 10x.
A
Right.
C
So I think it would be disingenuous to recommend that as a tactic. It used to be a really good way to outrank your competition at Google, producing things that were way better quality, way more in depth, way more data, way more richness, way better visualized. All those kinds of things used to drive a lot better rankings in search. That's not the case anymore. Now it's a really, and it is a valid point because I do this exercise in the training course where I say, go and find the five best bits of content that are out there. And everyone comes out and says, yeah, but the five best bits of content aren't at the top of Google. Like, we've had to go all sorts of different levels to find this stuff. And the problem kind of is that the Google ranking factors, whatever they may be, aren't necessarily putting what's best at top. They're kind of because of the fact of, like, domain authority. And it's not just about links, but a trusted website that's had millions of visitors for years and years and years, and there's millions of links coming through to it. When they publish something that seems to outweigh a lot of the user signals in terms of how long people are staying on that content and the engagement it seems to have. And all that kind of stuff as well. And to some extent there's only so much Google can do in terms of understanding that content. But it is true that it's not always the very best staff that's at top of Google. Now I'm still going to argue that that approach can work well if you combine it with some other, some other factors. You know, making something exceptional, making a great user experience. We should still focus on that. But this sent me down a bit of a rabbit hole and I was watching some other videos that Rand has produced and Rand, thank you and we will, we're going to promote Spark Toro a fair bit in this because as I thank you for kind of taking us down this kind of rabbit hole as well. And actually Spark Toro Ran's tool and website is actually a partial, a bit of a solution to this as well. But basically RAM was arguing two things, one about a zero click world and this, this reflective of what we all do, saying the social platforms have algorithms now that actively encourage you not to add links to your posts. They'll actually give posts less visibility if they have outbound links because they want, they want you to stay on the platform and consume more content and consume more advertising. Right. That's, that's what they want. But actually there's a user behavior piece to this as well. If I'm in LinkedIn, I can't be bothered to click to an external website. If I'm in, you know, anywhere else, I can't be bothered to link somewhere else to read something very often, not always.
A
What does that say about the state of recruitment in the world right now?
C
LinkedIn is not about recruitment. I will have you so. How dare you, sir? I'm a huge fan of LinkedIn. Do you know what? It's interesting with LinkedIn that that's where we get most of our engagement, really positive engagement. And I was speaking to Kelvin from Brighton SEO and he was saying this year, the first year, because Brighton SEO was kind of launched on Twitter, it was a huge thing and he said it's dead on Twitter now. It's just all linked in the engagement and this was the year that kind of proved it. So I have Nothing said against LinkedIn or there is a lot of dross stuff on there, but it's great for it.
A
It is great for recruiting though, and YouTube people that can't actually be bothered to click. That's all I'm saying. That's all I'm saying.
C
Well, I, I think there's this thing of actually just we've Become quite lazy in the way we use social platforms. So from the point of view of, you know, we're in TikTok, we're doom scrolling, we're in reveals, we're doing the same thing, we're going through and it's like it's, we are expecting bite sized content, but the fact is that it is a bit of a zero click world now as ran says, because 70% of clicks through to websites, roughly according to the data they have from Spot toe, are coming from search engines. But we're not spending 70% of our time on search engines. We're spending most of our time consuming media on social websites and YouTube and podcasts and all that kind of stuff as well.
B
And I think now it's about 40% of all searches that are done are done on social media platforms anyway.
C
Okay, so that's, that's a really interesting one as well. That fills me with horror as well in that, you know, depends what you say. If you're searching for fashion or you're searching for, you know, health and fitness, I, I, if you're searching for news, I find that really disturbing. But let's not go down that. But I mean more of the fact that actually if, if search is driving the traffic but we're spending our time elsewhere, what it kind of shows us is this zero click behavior is, is part of it. The algorithms are part of it, AI results are part of it. Where you go to the search engine, you get your answer, you don't need to click on anything as well. So it's user behavior, it's algorithms, it's AI results. So it means we're just not clicking. Well, if you don't click, then it's very hard for me to work out that you saw this social stuff, this media, this content, or you listen to the podcast and then you went through and did something. Podcasting is particularly challenging for this because I can forever say go to targetinternet.com podcast for the show notes. And people like, I'm all right, cheers. I'm listening to a podcast. I'm not going to do that. So and, and realistically there will be a handful that do, but it's going to be a very, we know that, you know, 100 and 100,000 odd listeners each time and actually it's a tiny percentage that end up on the website. I mean it's brilliant. They do.
A
I just want to give a shout out to those people I have. We love you.
C
Yeah, right, exactly.
A
Don't like working today, so.
C
Yeah. And go tigerinternet.com and sign up immediately. So it's that whole piece of okay, that's the real behavior, that's the realistic thing. Which means that actually attribution modeling and attribution becomes nonsense. So tell us the story, anonymize it, but tell us the story that you told us before we came on this.
A
So I'm just gonna chip in my 5 Pennisworth.
C
Cool then.
A
And I wanna start it by saying, Rand, I love you. I love your work.
C
But Rand, I also want to say before you came on the call, he was saying Rand has got much more handsome as he's got older. He's a silver fox.
A
He is.
C
He is.
A
He's just grown. Let's not go into that. But yeah, okay. I. Some, some men don't age well, do they? But I think Rand is one of those.
C
There's two middle aged men on this call. Be gentle.
A
I'm looking at you, looking at you on, on the podcasting app right now. Yeah. And you, you, yeah, you race well as well.
C
I wonder where that was going then. I was quite, I was quite nervous then.
B
I feel like you backtrack then.
C
Yeah, so do I. I think there was a lot of backtracking going on.
A
Maybe a little bit.
C
Anyway. Go on.
A
Yeah. You've got to survive, haven't you? Gotta survive so that. I just think the danger is that maybe there's a danger of Rand throwing the baby out with the bath water. Like because I, I granted. And actually it's not a criticism because actually I get where you're coming from on it, Rand. Like it's not what you think it is as basically what you're saying. But I do still believe that good content does do well. What's interesting though is I think it like there's so many more variables now in how Google ranks stuff. Right. So if you've got a lot of competition in quite a niche space or even quite a popular space, actually the more competition there is, I think Google will behave in different ways. I'm certainly still seeing plenty of evidence that user bank behavior gets results wild.
C
Yeah, I still think that. Dwell time.
A
Yeah.
C
Scrolling.
A
Not only that, you know, when you have a page that's ranking really well very often it's because it has a really good hook. It's not because you outperform all the competition in that space with backlinks. Blah, blah, blah. Got a really, really good, good, good, good clip. I was looking at some data for a campaign which is like a, a free diagnostic test, right? And the results this SEO team had had through promoting a free diagnostic test were off the charts. Like they, in six months they've gone from like zero searches to like 1.4 million kind of views and kind of 24,000 clicks, you know, from, to go from nothing to that in such a short period. And all they'd actually done is they just put the word free next to the keyword everybody was searching for for this diagnostic test. And they'd also followed, you know, some of the other things we recommend you do. So you know, putting your keyword into the URL, putting it into the page title and putting it into the H1 tag. Yeah, old school but simple things. And actually in this instance where it's quite a niche term but there's a lot of people searching for that diagnostic test. It was having phenomenal results and there's no way they have more backlinks and stuff but they do have a lot of traffic and their click through rate was very, very high. I could see that because they shared with me their, their Google search console results. So I'd like there's a lot of like wiggle room for variables within this.
C
Search console has done a thing now where they give you like a highlight summary when you go in there and it says you got 20,000 views a month, 30,000 40,000 and then it will show you top content. And they have little badges, you know, high dwell time. So they are really and they are seeing that as important. So I still think, yeah, look great. Content that drives engagement is never going to be a bad thing. It will hurt research rankings, it will help with user engagement and so on as well. But with the attribution side of things. Tell us that story that you told us.
A
Yes, sorry, I digressed. So a team that I've been working with were doing like a social media campaign. They haven't advertised on social media for ages and the campaign went out to Instagram and a little bit on Facebook as well. And the results really astounded us in that, you know, we were getting a lot of engagement and actually the cost per acquisition as an E commerce site, cost per acquisition was, was way lower than I've seen it in the past. Like I know previously they'd had problems with their acquisition costs being like 38 pound 45 when their average order value is much lower than that. That's bad. You don't ever want to see that.
C
Not a good way to run a business.
A
Yes. How you lose money. Hand of a fist. So they sort of turned their back on social media advertising as a result of that. But time's gone on and they're looking to have another crack at it. So they did, and they've used some much more modern ad units to what they were using and they got these quite impressive results and a really cheap cost per clicks, et cetera, et cetera. But what was really interesting is the revenue shot up, like it doubled overnight when this campaign started running. So they were a little bit like, well, it can't be that because we've got the pixel set up and we've got the tracker set up and we're just not seeing, you know, that level of sales coming through the social media campaign. Like, what? What could it be? And there really wasn't any answers. We did lots of digging and they couldn't find an answer to it. Actually. What, what their account manager did was he turned the advert off. I love for 24 hours.
C
The best way of testing is it having a pattern switch off.
A
I know it was a ballsy move because the revenue shot down from like three grand a day to like six, seven hundred pounds a day. And it's like, oh, could it be that? Or is that just, you know, just a bad day? So turn it back on. Sure enough, revenue shot back up. Right. So, I mean, we've known for a long time that people see stuff and actually, you know, some of these channels can be fantastic at getting impressions out there, but people clock it, they don't necessarily click. So that's always been a problem, particularly with display campaigns, for example. Right. You know, you see, you see billboard advertising all the time. You can't click on it because it's, you know, the other side of the street. But you clock it and, you know, you're thinking about, you know, whatever washing powder or clothing brand or whatever it is that's been promoted to you. It kind of gets under your skin, doesn't it? And I think there's an element of that. It's that. But you've got an amazing way of like getting in front of the right audience. It's not like a billboard where everybody sees it and you sort of paying for a share of everybody's eyeballs. You know, you can target with this stuff, but the truth of the matter is, even with, you know, all meta's great work that they've done and improving their pixel and the accuracy of that, there's still just this massive missing gap. But it just doesn't make sense to me. But I don't quite understand why it's happening. Let's talk about but it's definitely happening.
C
Because I'm seeing it some simple things, right? So one multi device journeys, you're seeing things one device, you're not logged into Facebook on both of them or you're not logged into Google on both of them. So you can't track across the devices. The loss of cookies where we're not getting those third party cookies. But also you know, if you've got an ad blocker it might be that it's blocking you actually going through and tracking into analytics opt ins where people are going to websites, they're not opting for the cookies increasingly and you're finding that you're not going to track them through to websites. That doesn't work for analytics as well. If there is no click through, if you never clicked, you've just got a view of that particular ad, then it may be you can't, you certainly can't track it through to web analytics. It may show up within the analytics for Facebook or LinkedIn or something like that as well. So if you look at all those factors, it looks like if there's no click through, someone just arrived from thin air on your website, they've just suddenly magically appeared. But actually we all know that everything we do every day is being influenced by what we're engaging with, what people say to us. The problem with all of this as well is that you go, well they saw the ad, they didn't click but then we got some search traffic so it must have been the ad. It might have only been. They took any notice of the ad because their friend spoke to them about it in the pub the night before. So I always try and say to people and I always quote you Kieran saying we're trying to measure the least wrong thing. Yeah, it's very true and actually quite often it means that we don't really know and there isn't and you can't untangle the human brain. I mean we can't map at the moment the neural networks in our brain and how they work and what's triggering them and maybe we'll be able to do that in the future. So what it means and what Rand said and this really resonates with me, he said, well marketing in 24 is like marketing in 1964 kind of thing. In that think about advertising used to work, you'd come up with an incredible concept, something that really resonated with your target audience, the kind of Mad Men era. And you would come up with this thing and you'd get it in the right place for the right people at the right time and they would see it and then they would go and buy your product in the shop. So they'd see the TV ad and they'd go and buy it. You kind of in a way need to start thinking a little bit like that. But then you think, we'll take a really journalistic approach. If you're going to write some content, you wouldn't read a newspaper where they were writing articles going, yeah, I think that there's something going on somewhere. It's like they've gone off and they've researched it and they've. The barrier to entry to writing a newspaper is that you've got the distribution, that kind of stuff. But it's the journalists, it's the investigative journalists, it's the people that are on the ground looking at things. It's all that is that research. So there should be a barrier to you creating your content. If it took you three minutes to create your content in ChatGPT, I'm pretty sure anyone could do that. So there's not much value. PR becomes important public relations. The idea that there are people talking about your stuff, they're mentioning it in places, whether that's tv, magazine, website, you know, suddenly PR comes. Now we've got an interview coming up that I'm going to record next week with a digital PR company and they're saying, how does digital PR different for pr? What's its role in search optimization? Because I think it's a really powerful area at the moment, getting people speaking about you. Now, it's no different, that's no difference to influencer marketing. It's just that the influencers here are magazine editors or TV channel executives or someone that owns a website.
A
Really it is different in that you've got people that actually have influence.
C
Well, I would say that that's how influencer marketing should work. I'm not even going to get you going on this. They word of mouth. I want people talking about my stuff. How am I going to get them to actually talk about it, to care about it enough? We found really interesting for us. So if you don't know, we have taken our Target into our learning platform, targetinternet.com and we've started just as part of that. You get a free masterclass every month. It's a half day online course. So for 20 quid a month you get the whole platform and you're getting half a day training, which is crazy value. But people are like, wow, that's, that's Pretty full. And they started people talking about it and they're telling and they're recommending it to each other as well. So actually that for us has been the little word of mouthpiece that's really started things to work.
B
That's, that's, that's the, that's the goal though, isn't it? Like, that's gold dust. Like advocates people online and offline talking about your brand that you've actually not influenced or paid them to do.
C
Exactly.
B
But they're just so loyal to you and love your product that much.
C
Yeah. And that's what amplifies stuff. And that's what we've started seeing is like, okay, I didn't know this person, didn't even know they were, they were doing this stuff, but they're suddenly telling all their friends to do it as well.
A
Right. I mean, I've always looked at the literal meaning of the phrase remark. Like if something is remarkable, it's because it's so good that you actually comment.
C
You remark on it.
A
You remark on it. Right. And I think sometimes we forget that, but that's really what we're talking about here. And actually, you know, so, okay, Rand, you know, Google's algorithm is ignoring a lot of remarkable content out there because it's looking maybe at other metrics in certain spaces and, and that's, that's by and by. But you remember, like, remember the whole world isn't about digital. You know, that whole word of mouth thing is massive. You know, years ago I worked at Lizelle Lizelle, amazing British beauty company. And they never did any advertising, not for years and years and years. Like first 15 years, advertising wasn't allowed. What they wanted to do was to ensure, okay, the money normally a beauty company would spend in, in, in advertising, we're going to spend it on rewarding our customers. I said loads of gift with product and gift with purchase and unexpected gifts and.
C
Yeah, and it was unexpected. I remember this.
A
It was. And the word of mouth was off the charts. Like that was where all of our customers come from. Our customers so loved what we did. The products were very good and to this day still are. Right. But you know that that was how it works. This is really good. And recommended it and that took on a life of its own. We once did a thing where we looked to find the most influential customer and it was a little old lady in a, in a street in Manchester somewhere and we invited her to a glitzy event and she thought there'd been a horrible mistake because I don't really buy much, really. We were like, oh, no, there's no mistake at all. You've actually recommended us to so many people in your area. We actually charted, you know, we showed her the map with all the pins and all the different people that she'd introduced and it was off the charts. Good. And she was, you know, she was really astounded.
C
Well, it's like a thousand Truth and sing, Right. Rather than trying to get a million followers, just one at a time, try and work out the advocates. I've worked out now as well. If you said to me you can spend ten pounds on paid search or you could spend ten pounds or giving people merchandise. Yeah, I'll give merchandise. Because people like, oh, look, I've got a mug, I've got a memory stick, I've got a sticker, whatever it is. And actually there's a little bit of a delight in there as well. That was Jay Swedelson. That was his thing that, the thing Inbound, just giving away tons of T shirts and stickers. It was a frenzy. I mean, literally, like, it was the biggest thing that happened at inbound. And it was just freebies, free stuff.
A
I never, never forget Kelvin's stunt with the. The gun that launched T shirts into the audience.
C
That T shirt gun was invariably a disaster because it would, like, it just wouldn't work and it would shoot things like into the front row. But, yeah, but it was a good. It was a good thing. We talked about it in the podcast interview recently.
B
That's why as well, when you see someone talking about your brand online, you should never ignore it. Because if someone talks about your brand online and generates you, you know, however many views they have, if you then even as simple as sending them some, like, free merchandise or you invite them into their head office. Everyone has an ego and they want to share stuff, don't they? And it's really cool. So they're going to share that. And then people are going to look at that and say, this is what can happen if I talk about that brand online.
A
So why wouldn't you want to really reward people that think you're remarkable? Yeah, because that's what we're talking about here. So now I'm all on board with that.
C
Well, we did a simple thing. We said if you review the podcast, so targetinternet.com forward/review, we will take a photo of it and we'll send you some merchandise. No, just as a thank you. Good or bad review, whatever you leave us. And I think like a load of tens and tens of people did it. It wasn't hundreds of thousands or anything crazy, but literally just you saw our rankings in Google up and our Spotify rankings go up off the back of it almost immediately. So it doesn't take a huge amount of advocacy to make a big difference from that point of view. So the other thing I'd say is guerrilla marketing. Like coming up with some wild things that you can do, which is kind of PR over again to some extent, but like coming up with a stunt or something that gets lots of people talking about it can be a good way of doing it as well.
B
Did you see the guerrilla marketing for the new Smile movie?
C
No.
B
So they basically sent a bunch of people out into public in like high profile areas.
C
This is a horror movie, isn't it? And it's going to be creepy. Yeah.
B
So it was, I think it was at like a baseball match or something that they knew it was being streamed on tv.
C
And they had crazy smiles on their faces.
B
They'd bought two seats like right behind where the TV was. And they didn't have like anything on their face, but they were just smiling at people in a really scary way. And they didn't break character for like hours. And everyone on TV was like, oh my God, what's going on? But it obviously got loads of people talking about it.
A
As a student, I learned if you just smile when you're on the underground, it clears the space and you can sit down.
C
I think that might have been you drinking your pint of milk, but that's another entire story as well.
A
We're not going there. Well, we are going there. Okay, go on, go there. You're gonna have to now. Otherwise they think I'm really weird as opposed to just thinking I'm weird.
C
I don't think that's going to help if I do explain it. But Kieran, when he's cold on a nice hot day, he likes to drink like a pint of a carton of milk.
A
When I'm hot. When I'm hot, like cold milk is great. I grew up on it.
C
Yeah. And everyone gets a bit of a. That man's drinking. It's like eating slice meat out of a packet on the train. It's one of those things that gives people a kick a little bit.
A
It's a big social faux par. I learned no one likes. Yeah. Drinking milk out of a carton in public is a. It's. It's a social, like, don't go near this guy.
B
Oh, you do it in public?
C
Yeah. On the train. Sitting on the train.
A
Let's get this in context.
C
All the time, every day.
A
I did it once and I told Daniel a story because I thought it was really remarkable. And Daniel was like, well, yeah, no brainer, of course. That's really weird. Yeah, yeah.
B
I would probably move out the way.
C
Yeah.
A
The thing is, right, and I don't get this, but why is milk cheaper than water? Like it's more expensive than the water is more expensive than milk. It makes no sense to me at all.
C
I agree, I agree. Let's not get into supply chain, different podcast.
A
I'm trying to justify drinking milk on a hot day.
C
I understand. It's okay.
A
It's not, it's not helping me, is it really?
C
Email is another one. Right. So we've gone on about email and how fantastic email can be and still it needs to be a really big part of your strategy. You can attribute email a lot better because the fact that actually you will see the clicks and you'll be able to kind of channel it and you've got that two way communication. So using your social to drive email subscribers is a really powerful tactic. We mentioned it a few times, but I think there's an opportunity in there to do this and to get a little bit more attribution as well. So what we're really looking to do is just influence future behavior. And I think this is, and this is where Rand was talking about because it connects up to sales message, which is actually Spark Toro. If you go to Spark Toronto and say, I want people interested in digital marketing, it will tell you the YouTube channels, the Reddit group, the, the podcast, the websites, the social influencers they're following, that's where you need your stuff. You need it in those channels. So they're coming across it and then that's going to drive the behavioral change as well. So I think I kind of like this because it stops lazy marketing because it's just like, well, I'm just going to put a lot of money into paid stuff and I'm not going to be creative, I'm not going to be journalistic, I'm not going to be exceptional in my content quality. So is content marketing dead? No, of course it's not. Great content will always be great content. And actually I need to look at how much we're consuming in social media and so on. But I do think the current thing is, the current way of doing it is quite often broken. And you only need to go back to that Neil Patel quote that we picked up at Imbella 65% of content gets zero engagement.
A
So there's a lot of noise now about AI slop as well, isn't it? This is like a new phrase that's come into my world recently and it's like you start to see it everywhere.
C
Actually and it just is too easy to create the content. And you know, it was always the case that if you could pump content out, people would do it. And Google's having to get smarter and smarter to it as well. So what's the message from all this? Take a step back and actually go through and think, right, what could I do that's really going to have an impact? Can I be in those places where my target audience is? What's going to resonate with them? What can I create that is exceptional? I still think that 10x is a great way of thinking about that, but you've got to be in the right place. And you might not be able to attribute it, but you should see results.
A
Newsflash. It's always been like this, always since Mark Zoo began. Like you have to stand out in some way. Like you have to be relevant. You have to still be able to help people or solve their problems.
C
So just a finishing point, we have got these masterclasses that now part of the target Internet membership and we have got one coming up on content strategies. We have a content marketing and content strategy one coming up. We've got a digital strategy one I think literally next week we've got a chat GPT one.
B
Yes, Monday. So be quick.
C
Yeah, exactly. So if you go to target Internet.com you sign up for a 6 or a 12 month membership. Now if you do a monthly membership you do get access but not until you've been a member for six months. So you can come and sign up for those. You then go into timetable, you've got all of the forward and you can just book in to whatever you want to book into. Unlimited amount of masterclasses you can attend as they're on every month. Plus you've got all the normal content, 200 bits of E learning that's updated constantly. The only place you can get all 400 of the podcasts are news, updates and all that. That kind of good stuff as well. If you don't want to do that, just sign up to the newsletter, targetinternet.com newsletter and that's where we put out loads of exclusive stuff that you can get access to as well.
B
There's also just on the topic, our live session for November is on content marketing. So if you just wanted to get further insight.
A
Yeah.
C
So these live sessions are quick, one hour bite size session so you can dip in, get the latest trends, but also ask questions. So they are two ways. It's a really good opportunity. If you've got a particular content marketing challenge, you can, you can jump into those as well.
A
And you never know. If you pick the right one, I might turn up and start handing out free virtual cartons of milk.
C
Well, that's going to put people off. Cheers, Kiri.
B
Now we're going to get no attendees.
C
Yeah, that's great, thanks. I tell you what, maybe you're going to tend to give out some target Internet merchandise.
A
Yeah, all right, we'll do that. Let's do that.
C
We'll get you along to the next one then as well. So I think what we're going to try to do as well is do a few of these. We'll get all three of us on. So if you want to pick our brains live, we can do that. But generally the masterclasses are me, by the way. So if you want to come along, you can have a chat with me on that as well. So as ever, thank you for listening to the digital marketing podcast. We will speak to you next time. For more episodes resources to leave a review or to get in contact, go to targetinternet.com podcast.
The Digital Marketing Podcast
Release Date: October 25, 2024
Hosts: Ciaran Rogers, Daniel Rowles, Louise Crossley
In this episode of The Digital Marketing Podcast, hosts Ciaran Rogers, Daniel Rowles, and Louise Crossley delve into the provocative question: Is Content Marketing Dead? The discussion navigates through evolving digital landscapes, changing algorithms, and shifting consumer behaviors to assess the current state and future of content marketing.
The conversation begins with a critical examination of the 10x content strategy, a concept popularized by Rand Fishkin, which advocates creating content that is ten times better than the competition.
Ciaran Rogers references a significant shift in Rand Fishkin's perspective:
“[01:12] Ciaran Rogers: 'Rand has since come out and said that he doesn't think it really works anymore...'"
Rand Fishkin expressed skepticism about the continued effectiveness of the 10x content approach, noting that exceptional content no longer guarantees top rankings on Google as it once did.
The hosts agree that while producing high-quality, in-depth content remains valuable, its ability to singularly boost search rankings has diminished due to more complex and varied Google ranking factors.
Building on the previous point, the hosts discuss how Google's algorithms have become more sophisticated, prioritizing factors beyond just content quality. These include:
Daniel Rowles emphasizes:
“[08:08] Daniel Rowles: 'Dwell time, scrolling...'"
These engagement indicators suggest that Google values how users interact with content, making user experience as important as content depth.
The episode addresses the concept of a zero-click world, where users obtain answers without clicking through to external websites. This phenomenon is exacerbated by:
Louise Crossley highlights the implications:
“[04:52] Louise Crossley: 'It fills me with horror...'"
She expresses concern that the best content is not always the most visible on search engines, emphasizing the challenge of reaching audiences in an environment where traditional SEO tactics are less effective.
The hosts explore the complexities of attribution modeling in today's fragmented digital ecosystem. Factors contributing to attribution difficulties include:
Ciaran Rogers remarks:
“[06:21] Ciaran Rogers: 'Attribution modeling becomes nonsense...'"
He underscores the difficulty in attributing conversions to specific marketing efforts when users' paths to purchase are multifaceted and often non-linear.
Despite the challenges, the episode underscores the enduring power of word-of-mouth and advocacy in driving brand engagement and growth. Effective strategies include:
Louise Crossley shares a success story:
“[16:58] Louise Crossley: 'But they're just so loyal to you and love your product that much.'"
She illustrates how genuine advocacy can amplify brand reach without direct marketing expenditures.
The discussion transitions to guerrilla marketing, emphasizing creative and unconventional tactics to generate buzz. Examples include:
Daniel Rowles reflects on guerrilla marketing:
“[20:55] Daniel Rowles: 'They had crazy smiles on their faces...'"
He recounts how such tactics can lead to significant online discussions and heightened brand visibility.
Despite debates about its efficacy, the hosts collectively assert that exceptional content remains a cornerstone of effective digital marketing. Key takeaways include:
Ciaran Rogers concludes:
“[24:24] Ciaran Rogers: 'Take a step back and actually go through and think, right, what could I do that's really going to have an impact...'"
He advocates for a holistic and thoughtful approach to content creation, emphasizing strategic dissemination to maximize impact.
In wrapping up, the hosts reaffirm that content marketing is far from dead, but its landscape has evolved. Success now requires adaptability, creativity, and an integrated approach that leverages both traditional and innovative marketing tactics.
They also promote Target Internet's masterclasses, offering resources and live sessions to help marketers navigate these changes and refine their strategies.
Final Thoughts from Ciaran Rogers:
“[24:54] Ciaran Rogers: '...good content will always be great content...'"
He reinforces the enduring value of quality content while acknowledging the need to adapt to new marketing paradigms.
For listeners seeking to deepen their understanding and application of the discussed strategies, Target Internet offers a suite of masterclasses and a comprehensive membership platform. Upcoming sessions include:
Additional resources and live session registrations are available at TargetInternet.com.
This episode provides a nuanced exploration of the current state of content marketing, balancing skepticism with optimism and offering actionable insights for marketers navigating an increasingly complex digital environment.