The Digital Marketing Podcast: Life After Third-Party Cookies – What’s Next for Data-Driven Marketing?
Released on September 27, 2024
Hosts: Ciaran Rogers, Daniel Rowles, and Louise Crossley
Guests: Colin Greaves (Managing Director, Experian Marketing Services UK & Ireland) and Danny Holmes (Consulting Lead, Experian Marketing Services)
Introduction
In this insightful episode of The Digital Marketing Podcast, host Daniel Rowles delves into the evolving landscape of digital marketing in the wake of the impending demise of third-party cookies. Joined by Colin Greaves and Danny Holmes from Experian Marketing Services, the discussion unpacks the complexities surrounding third-party cookies, their deprecation, and the future of data-driven marketing.
Understanding Cookies: First-Party vs. Third-Party
Daniel Rowles initiates the conversation by highlighting the confusion many marketers face regarding third-party cookies. He emphasizes the need for clarity as the industry grapples with the phasing out of these cookies.
Colin Greaves provides a foundational understanding:
"They started off as fairly benign things, literally going back 25 years or more...to collect information to enable that consumer to have a better experience on a website." [04:04]
He distinguishes between first-party cookies, which enhance user experience on a specific website without sharing data externally, and third-party cookies, which track user behavior across multiple sites, thereby creating comprehensive consumer profiles.
The Decline of Third-Party Cookies
Colin Greaves elaborates on the reasons behind the decline:
"Regulators and privacy groups have been pushing back against the constant tracking enabled by third-party cookies." [06:15]
He explains how browsers like Firefox and Safari have already limited or blocked third-party cookies, and how Google’s Chrome is now giving consumers the choice to enable them, signaling an inevitable phase-out.
Danny Holmes adds further context:
"Around 50% of the open web is already cookieless...the addressable audience by cookies is smaller than many think." [08:45]
He emphasizes that reliance on third-party cookies is decreasing both due to consumer behavior and technical limitations, urging the industry to pivot towards more privacy-centric solutions.
Impact on Advertisers, Publishers, and Consumers
The deprecation of third-party cookies presents distinct challenges for different stakeholders:
-
Advertisers:
- Loss of Data: Reduced visibility into user behaviors hampers targeting and campaign measurement.
- Measurement Challenges: Difficulty in tracking cross-channel user journeys disrupts performance analytics.
-
Publishers:
- Revenue Decline: Targeted advertising drives ad demand; without it, publishers face potential revenue drops.
- Alternative Revenue Streams: Necessitates exploration of subscription models or other monetization strategies.
-
Consumers:
- Privacy Enhancements: Improved privacy but potentially less personalized online experiences.
Danny Holmes summarizes the repercussions:
"If publishers don't find alternatives to support audience targeting, they might have to turn to other commercial models such as subscription paywalls." [12:30]
Regulatory Landscape
Colin Greaves discusses the complex regulatory environment:
"There is no global standard coming from regulators. The UK’s CMA has influenced Google, but global consensus is lacking." [13:15]
He notes the balancing act regulators face between ensuring data privacy and fostering digital economy growth, highlighting the absence of a unified global regulatory framework.
Emerging Solutions
Addressing the void left by third-party cookies, several alternative strategies are emerging:
-
First-Party Data:
- Advantages: Accurate, consented, rich in consumer behavior insights.
- Challenges: Scalability, especially for sectors like FMCG without direct consumer relationships.
-
Alternative Identifiers:
- Deterministic: Based on authenticated data like emails (e.g., hashed email addresses).
- Probabilistic: Utilizes signals like IP addresses to identify users without explicit authentication.
Danny Holmes explains:
"Alternative identifiers offer a privacy-centric approach, either through deterministic methods like hashed emails or probabilistic signals such as IP addresses." [16:00]
-
ID Graphs:
- Functionality: Connect various identifiers (e.g., IP, mobile ad IDs) to create comprehensive user profiles.
- Complexity: Requires substantial infrastructure and compliance checks.
-
Data Clean Rooms:
- Purpose: Secure environments for data collaboration, enriching data access without compromising privacy.
- Utility: Enhances insight generation and activation across channels.
-
Contextual Advertising:
- Mechanism: Targets ads based on current webpage content rather than user history.
- Limitations: May lack precision in audience targeting and scalability.
-
Cohorting:
- Strategy: Groups individuals based on shared interests or behaviors without tracking individuals.
- Example: Targeting groups who have purchased holidays to upsell insurance.
Experian’s Approach and Solutions
Danny Holmes introduces Experian’s innovative solutions tailored for a cookieless world:
"Experian recently launched our own solution which we refer to as our linkage capability, Consumer Sync." [26:22]
Consumer Sync connects a diverse range of offline and online identifiers to provide a holistic view of consumers, enabling:
- Omnichannel Marketing: Seamless targeting across digital and offline channels.
- Audience Insights: Enhanced demographic, behavioral, and attitudinal data covering 52 million UK adults.
- Scalable Solutions: Flexible integration to adapt to market shifts and ensure compliance with privacy standards.
Danny Holmes further elaborates:
"Consumer Sync can associate offline IDs to households, then attach IDs usable for targeting digital channels such as Connected TV." [27:10]
This solution not only bridges the gap left by third-party cookies but also enriches existing data assets, ensuring marketers can continue to target effectively without compromising privacy.
Future-Proofing Strategies
To navigate the post-cookie era, marketers should consider the following:
-
Prioritize Privacy:
- Always place consumer privacy at the forefront of data strategies.
- Ensure compliance with regulations like GDPR.
-
Embrace Scale and Flexibility:
- Adopt solutions that offer scalable data capabilities.
- Remain adaptable to evolving market conditions and technological advancements.
-
Foster Collaboration:
- Engage with industry bodies like the IAB to stay informed about emerging standards and solutions.
- Collaborate with data providers and technology partners to leverage diverse capabilities.
-
Experiment and Test:
- Allocate budgets for testing new approaches.
- Continuously evaluate the effectiveness of adopted strategies to refine and optimize campaigns.
Colin Greaves advises:
"Set aside some budget to understand what the different options are. Test them and see what works for you." [24:30]
Conclusion
As third-party cookies fade away, the digital marketing landscape is poised for significant transformation. This episode underscores the importance of adapting to privacy-centric solutions, leveraging rich first-party data, and embracing innovative technologies like ID graphs and data clean rooms. Experian’s Consumer Sync exemplifies how organizations can harness comprehensive data insights to maintain effective marketing strategies in a cookieless world.
For marketers seeking to future-proof their strategies, the key lies in prioritizing privacy, fostering collaboration, and remaining agile in adopting and testing new solutions. As Colin Greaves aptly summarizes:
"Have the consumer at the front of your mind and think about privacy in everything that you do." [23:10]
Further Resources
Listeners are encouraged to explore additional resources and detailed references provided in the show notes at targetinternet.com/forward/podcast. For more information on Experian’s marketing solutions, visit their website or reach out directly via the contact details provided in the podcast notes.
This summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from the episode, offering marketers a comprehensive overview of the shift away from third-party cookies and the emerging strategies to thrive in a data-driven, privacy-centric digital ecosystem.