The Dollop Episode 713: Henry Hudson – Part Two

Released: December 16, 2025
Hosts: Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds

Episode Overview

In this comedic deep-dive, Dave and Gareth continue their exploration of the life and misadventures of the infamous explorer Henry Hudson. Part Two picks up as Hudson sails into what is now the Hudson River, blending fact, legend, and the hosts’ pointed humor. Through historical records and folklore, the episode skewers Hudson’s disastrous leadership, colonial violence, and the myths spun around his legacy—all while spotlighting the absurdity of history’s “winners.” The tone is sharp, self-aware, and at times (intentionally) absurd, trading off between deadpan and satire.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. The Catskill Gnome Legend and Hudson’s Arrival

• Timestamp: 02:15–14:34
  • Dave opens with Hudson’s 1609 arrival in New York Harbor and shares a Native American legend claiming that gnomes inhabited the Catskill Mountains.
  • The tale: At night, Hudson and his men follow mysterious music ashore and encounter dancing, metal-working gnomes who draw them into a night of drinking and bowling.
  • The comic riff centers around the gnomes’ potent liquor, which transforms the crew into gnome-like creatures for the night:

    “Their heads had swollen to twice the normal size, and their eyes were small and pig like, and their bodies had shortened…” — Dave [10:01]

  • Hosts lampoon justice for gnomes, the transformation, and whether they would personally want to “get gnomed.”

    “I would be like, hey, what do you guys say we get tiny today?” — Gareth [11:26]

  • They riff on the recurring legend that every 20 years, Hudson returns to bowl with the gnomes, imagining how news coverage might handle the event.

2. Back to Historical Reality: Violence and the Native Encounter

• Timestamp: 16:41–18:48
  • The narrative pivots sharply: A local thief steals from Robert Jewett (one of Hudson’s men), prompting Jewett to shoot and kill the man, followed by the ship’s cook killing a native.
  • This violence instigates a serious confrontation as native Montauks pursue the Half Moon with over a hundred men, but the outgunned canoes are devastated by European firepower.
  • The hosts directly address the recurring theme of colonial atrocities, acknowledging the “bad timeline” that history rode:

    “It would be fantastic to live on the timeline where... It’s always the Bad timeline.” — Gareth [18:49]

3. Hudson’s Dubious Navigation and Questionable Decisions

• Timestamp: 19:18–27:32
  • After failing to find a Westward passage, Hudson heads back—contradicting his contract with the Dutch.
  • There’s speculation (and host mockery) regarding whether Hudson was a spy for England or simply incompetent/negligent.
  • The hosts joke that perhaps Hudson just didn’t want to return to his wife—or felt trapped by the Dutch or English authorities.
  • The Dutch, angry at his detour, hold Hudson’s wife and child as leverage. His correspondence becomes a bizarre game of international chicken.

4. The Fourth Voyage and Dysfunctional Crew

• Timestamp: 27:32–39:26
  • Hudson is eventually released from house arrest and is bankrolled for a fourth voyage to explore the “Northwest Passage.”
  • His new ship is laughably tiny, with 23 men crammed aboard—many sleeping on the freezing deck.
  • Jewett is back as first mate “for the spark,” plus a malicious new crewmaster, Henry Green—a self-sabotaging choice.
  • Dysfunction quickly engulfs the crew, with Green brawling with the beloved ship’s barber-surgeon and everyone suspecting spies.

5. Endless Ice, Mutiny, and Leadership Breakdown

• Timestamp: 31:32–36:44
  • The journey through Hudson Strait (ominously dubbed “the Furious Overfall”) becomes a deadly farce:

    “It’s a nightmare... But they don’t know where they’re going.” — Dave [34:43]

  • Months of fruitless icy wandering breed deep fractures. Jewett uncovers Green as Hudson’s spy and is tried for mutiny, but Hudson has little authority and eventually pardons all involved, just to preserve manpower.

6. Catastrophic Winter: Starvation, Death, and Petty Feuds

• Timestamp: 52:06–66:44
  • The crew is trapped in Arctic winter, forced to build makeshift shelters and hunt for survival as men die of cold and exposure.
  • Petty grievances reign: Hudson gives the coat of a dead man directly to Green, sparking outrage. When Green befriends the carpenter, Hudson jealously reclaims the coat in a sitcom-worthy episode.
  • Starvation grows dire—food dwindles to “frogs and moss,” and when a native attempts to help, Hudson is so insulting that no further help comes.
  • The hosts riff relentlessly on the miseries of eating moss and frozen frogs, and on Hudson’s inability to lead or show gratitude.

7. The Final Mutiny and Abandonment of Hudson

• Timestamp: 76:52–79:16
  • When the ice thaws, the crew demands to return home, but Hudson dithers, possibly searching for imagined treasure.
  • On June 22nd, the men mutiny, marooning Hudson, his son, and their loyalists in a small boat with scant or (in some accounts) no supplies.
  • The hosts sarcastically narrate the transfer of “supplies,” casting doubt that any mercy was offered.

8. Aftermath: The Mutineers’ Fate and Hudson’s Legacy

• Timestamp: 80:03–88:51
  • Under Green’s “command,” the mutineers fare little better. Most, including Green and Jewett, die by starvation or are killed by Inuits after a bungled trade.
  • Only eight men survive, limping back to England on a diet of “bird bones fried in candle grease.” They’re charged with mutiny but are ultimately acquitted after seven years, due to possessing valuable colonial intelligence.
  • Meanwhile, Hudson’s wife, destitute, doggedly pursues compensation, ultimately securing enough funds to launch a successful trading venture to India—becoming wealthy herself despite the patriarchal system.
  • The episode closes by reflecting on Hudson’s posthumous fame and the irony that so much of North America is named for a man characterized here as a “halfwit douchebag.”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• The Gnome Legend:

  “Wouldn’t that be amazing, though, if you could turn into a gnome?” — Dave [08:59] “You'd be able to tell how drunk your friend is by how small he is.” — Gareth [11:32]

• On Colonial Violence:

  “It would be fantastic to live on the timeline where... It’s always the Bad timeline. We just always killed all of them.” — Gareth [18:49]

• Hudson’s Leadership:

  “He obviously didn’t care about his wife and kid, or he would have gone West.” — Dave [24:33]

• On Starvation and Petty Feuds:

  “All they could find to eat were frogs and moss, which is actually a nice salad.” — Dave [66:55] “Would you care for some frogs and moss?” — Gareth [67:01] “He [Hudson] gave the coat to Green... which is cool. No, awesome. It’s like a thrift shop.” — Dave [57:40, 57:53]

• The Final Mutiny:

  “They forced Henry and the other prisoners onto a small boat... some versions have them putting Henry in the small boat with no supplies and just telling them to fuck off.” — Dave [77:30]

• Hudson’s Historical Impact:

  “It's insane how much of our things are named after... a halfwit douchebag.” — Dave [90:01] “History is written down by the winners... but this guy is a fucking loser.” — Gareth [90:12]

Important Timestamps

• Gnome legend/the party: 02:15–14:34
• Colonial violence/Native encounter: 16:41–18:48
• Mutiny and trial at sea: 31:32–39:26
• Arctic catastrophe/starvation: 52:06–66:44
• Petty crew grudges (the coat): 63:00–65:35
• Frogs and moss for dinner: 66:57–67:38
• Final mutiny and marooning: 76:52–79:16
• Hudson’s wife’s revenge/triumph: 84:00–85:13
• Reflection on memorializing losers: 88:04–90:12

Structure & Tone

• The discussion is irreverent, bouncing between historical exposition, comic riffing, and modern day analogies.
• Hosts mock maritime leadership as a high school popularity contest, unravel gnome lore with straight-faced absurdity, and treat historic facts with comedic skepticism.

Closing Thoughts

This episode of The Dollop serves as a comedic yet pointed indictment of both the myth-making around American colonizers and the mechanics of historical memory. Hudson is lampooned as a bungling egotist whose failures set into motion consequences—good, ill, and ridiculous—for centuries. The show drives home how history routinely immortalizes the wrong people, and does so with the kind of sharp wit and improvisational banter that makes The Dollop a mainstay for fans of history and comedy.