"Great Settlement"

Summary

"Great Settlement" – The Five (June 11, 2026)

Podcast: The Five (FOX News Podcasts)
Episode Theme: The hosts tackle the breaking news of a potential U.S.-Iran settlement, racial controversy surrounding the Carmelo Anthony case, debates over kids’ rights and activism at ICE facilities, and a new poll on Americans’ attitudes about living abroad, with the show's characteristic mix of debate and humor.

---

Main Episode Overview

The panel leads with President Trump’s announcement of a “great settlement” with Iran, debating its implications, likelihood of success, and political fallout. The discussion moves to the Carmelo Anthony trial and claims of racial bias, with deep dives into trial facts and media narratives. Later, they analyze Ms. Rachel’s controversial visit to an ICE detention facility and the political symbolism of children's entertainers. The show ends with lighter segments, including a poll on Americans wanting to live abroad, and their iconic rapid-fire round.

---

1. Trump’s Iran Settlement Announcement

Timestamps: [01:02]–[13:22]

Key Points & Insights

• Trump's Announcement: President Trump claims a deal with Iran is imminent, focusing on ensuring Iran "will never have a nuclear weapon".
  • Quote (Trump, 01:29): “Much most importantly, we have a deal that Iran will never have a nuclear weapon, which was the whole purpose...It was a very big thing...Should be done pretty quickly.”
• Political and Military Analysis:
  • Economic Pressure: The panel agrees that Iran is seriously weakened economically, but skeptical about the regime’s pain tolerance.
    • Dana Perino (02:59): “Iran has to be hurting economically, but the regime itself is willing to withstand a ton of pain...But hopefully it will work out.”
  • Hostage Analogy: Paul Moro compares the scenario to a hostage negotiation, with the Iranian people as hostages and the IRGC as the perpetrator.
    • Paul Moro (04:05): “This thing is a hostage negotiation, right? And the hostages are the Iranian people...The best threat we have is we’re going to take Carg Island...So where does that leave you?”
  • Deal Skepticism: Concerns persist about verification and the cycle of near-deals.
    • Jessica Tarlov (09:10): “At least 37 times, actually, we have been down this road.”
  • Market Response: Jesse Waters connects market surges to potential peace.
    • Jesse Waters (08:52): “The market loves it. Oil's down into the 80s. The market was up, what, 900 points today?”
• Underlying Themes: Distrust of Iranian compliance, the necessity of “trust but verify,” and debates over putting “real muscle” behind any deal.

Notable Quotes & Humor

• Greg Gutfeld (06:24): “One of the benefits of Trump is he keeps the end game to himself. It drives his adversaries crazy, but it causes everybody here to speculate...Next thing you know, we’re drinking and using narcotics, and then we end up homeless and living in Seattle.”
• Jessica Tarlov (11:01): “I walk alone on my path and what I’m saying is rooted in what reporters from the region are putting out there...Donald Trump needs this deal done. He doesn’t have the appetite for the war himself anymore.”

---

2. Carmelo Anthony Trial & Racial Controversy

Timestamps: [14:04]–[24:34]

Key Points & Insights

• Crockett’s Claims: Outgoing Rep. Jasmine Crockett insists racial bias factored in Anthony’s conviction and sentencing.
  • Jasmine Crockett (14:30): “A lot of people don’t know what it is to live as a black person in this country. The fact that there was little to no mercy seen or humanity seen…”
• Facts vs. Narrative:
  • Jury & Evidence: Paul Moro explains legal reasoning, focusing on the self-defense standard, the size and use of the knife, and the role of race in jury selection.
    • Paul Moro (15:17): “Your reaction has to be commensurate to the threat that you perceive. That’s going to be an objective standard.”
  • Defense Shortcomings: Panelists note the defense’s lack of character witnesses and possible appeal points.
    • Jessica Tarlov (17:59): “He had a fully intact family...why didn’t we at least hear from both of his parents?...You would expect [it], especially when someone is looking at potentially spending 35 years behind bars.”
• Broader Commentary:
  • Racial Lens: Gutfeld asserts that media and activists would treat a crime differently if the racial roles were reversed.
    • Greg Gutfeld (21:31): “If this were in reverse, they would George Floyd the crap out of it. Fact is, we have an incredibly low bar for black leftist commentary.”
  • Victim vs. System: Discussion highlights how perceptions of systemic bias and individual acts are filtered through political narratives.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Jesse Waters (19:49): “Why would Carmelo Anthony be scared? ...Nine out of ten blacks who are killed are killed by other blacks...This is a low crime area. Like, no one carries a knife. Who carries a knife, 5 inch blade, to a track meet?”
• Paul Moro (23:51): “And remember something else? When Carmelo was taken into custody...He put his hands on me and that was the warning that he gave...That’s an awfully low bar to stab somebody in the heart.”

---

3. Ms. Rachel’s ICE Facility Protest

Timestamps: [25:27]–[32:10]

Key Points & Insights

• Ms. Rachel’s Visit: The children’s YouTube star protests at a New Jersey ICE facility, drawing fierce criticism and sparking debate about kids’ rights, activism, and the use of children's programming for political messaging.
  • Jesse Waters (25:27): “Miss Rachel acting more like Ms. Rachel, 13...accusing the Trump administration of terrorizing children and singing some nursery rhymes for all the murderers, rapists and pedos inside.”
• Government Response: DHS insists family separation claims are overstated, reiterating protocols to keep families together or safely sponsor children.
  • Mark Wayne Mullen (26:23): “We found 146,000 kids so far...We still have nearly 300,000 missing.”
• Political & Cultural Divide:
  • Activist or Indoctrinator? Gutfeld and Moro argue Ms. Rachel is trying to manipulate children politically, comparing her to drag queens at libraries or the propagandist content in Teen Vogue.
    • Greg Gutfeld (28:12): “She’s a Trojan horse that exploits the benign, innocent nature of a kids show host because that way every time you scrutinize her political mission, you look like the bad guy.”
  • Left vs. Right Narrative: Repeated analogies are drawn between leftist causes and the use of children as political symbols.
    • Paul Moro (31:36): “This is the equivalent of the drag queens at the library...This is indoctrination, period. End of story.”

Notable Quotes & Highlights

• Greg Gutfeld (29:55): “I think it's pretty clear Greg will not be showing Ms. Rachel to his child anytime soon.”
• Dana Perino (30:09): “Ms. Rachel has a different job, right? Her job is to educate kids and teach them some language. If she wants to get involved in politics, well, then this is what you’re going to get.”
• Jessica Tarlov (27:09): “My older daughter was a huge Ms. Rachel enthusiast...her videos are beloved. Her politics more divisive to some people, but there are kids in these facilities and I’m for kids having access to nursery rhymes and good entertainment.”

---

4. Would Americans Move Abroad?

Timestamps: [33:55]–[38:10]

Key Points & Insights

• New Poll: 55% of Democrats reportedly would prefer to live abroad rather than in the U.S.; only 10% of Republicans agree.
  • Paul Moro (33:55): “A new poll found that 55% of Democrats would rather...live in a different country than the United States.”
• Patriotism & Privilege: Panelists discuss American exceptionalism, suggesting that talk of leaving is often the luxury of the rich.
  • Jesse Waters (34:21): “America, if we lose an American anywhere...the President of the United States will get on the phone...and that's the kind of country you want to live in.”
  • Greg Gutfeld (37:01): “The person who says, 'I’m going to live abroad instead of America' is the first person when they arrive in France to look for a McDonald’s or a Home Depot.”
• Comparative Living: Dana Perino recounts how Europeans visiting the U.S. express awe at American prosperity and livability.

Memorable moments

• Jessica Tarlov (35:17): “I am a New Yorker. I plan on staying here, much to Greg’s chagrin.”
• Paul Moro (38:10): “We are only as virtuous as our options.”

---

5. Rapid-Fire & Lighthearted Final Segment

Timestamps: [38:30]–End

• Texting Etiquette: Is it ever appropriate to text after midnight? The crew jokes about late-night messages and the etiquette thereof.
  • Greg Gutfeld (39:30): “If you get a midnight text...the first thing you’re going to hear is your spouse going, 'Who is that?' And then you’re screwed.”
• Smartphone Addiction: Paul Moro likens his phone to “the mistress I never agreed to…an Eastern European escort that won’t leave me alone.”
• Final Jokes: Bears, Lysol, and mock sponsorships cap off the show’s signature irreverence.

---

Memorable Quotes by Timestamp & Speaker

• On Iran:
  • “Much most importantly, we have a deal that Iran will never have a nuclear weapon, which was the whole purpose...” — Donald Trump (01:29)
  • “You only really have two options from where I sit...endless bombing campaign...or boots on the ground behind the inspections.” — Paul Moro (04:05)
• On Carmelo Anthony Case:
  • “Your reaction has to be commensurate to the threat that you perceive. That’s going to be an objective standard.” — Paul Moro (15:17)
  • “If this were in reverse, they would George Floyd the crap out of it.” — Greg Gutfeld (21:31)
• On Ms. Rachel & Political Indoctrination:
  • “She’s a Trojan horse that exploits the benign, innocent nature of a kids show host...” — Greg Gutfeld (28:12)
• On Patriotism and Privilege:
  • “America, if we lose an American anywhere...the President of the United States will get on the phone...and that's the kind of country you want to live in.” — Jesse Waters (34:21)
  • “Seasoned traveler, always has a lot of gratitude for having America as their home to return to.” — Greg Gutfeld (37:01)

---

Summary Table of Important Segments

| Segment Topic | Timestamps | Key Panelists | |------------------------------------|--------------|--------------------------| | Iran Settlement & Aftermath | 01:02–13:22 | Trump (clip), Dana, Paul, Jesse, Jessica, Greg | | Carmelo Anthony Case & Race | 14:04–24:34 | Dana, Paul, Jessica, Jesse, Greg, Jasmine Crockett (clip) | | Ms. Rachel at ICE, Child Advocacy | 25:27–32:10 | Jesse, Paul, Jessica, Dana, Greg, Mark Wayne Mullen (clip) | | Americans Open to Living Abroad | 33:55–38:10 | Jesse, Paul, Jessica, Dana, Greg | | Lighthearted Rapid-Fire & Wrap-up | 38:30–41:43 | All panelists |

---

Conclusion

This episode delivers classic “Five” fare: acerbic banter, pointed political commentary, and the interplay of skepticism, humor, and partisanship. The Iran deal dominates, dissected from all angles; the Carmelo Anthony case reveals deep rifts in social and legal analysis; and the segments about Ms. Rachel and American patriotism reinforce ongoing debates about activism and national identity.

---

For listeners seeking sharp takes on breaking stories with a side of humor and debate, this episode is quintessential "The Five".

Transcript

[Narrator]

Can we do it with the career you hadn't imagined was the one that powers your biggest dreams. Accounting isn't just about numbers. It's about creating your path. Imagine using accounting to call the shots off the field for the next big game. Support your favorite stars world tour, empower your community, or spark your own business idea. Accounting is the switch that lights up endless possibilities, your dreams, your future. Visit jointaccountingplus.com to see how accounting turns on the possibilities.

[Jesse Waters]

So good, so good, so good.

[Nordstrom Rack Announcer]

New markdowns up to 70% off are at Nordstrom Rack stores now. Stock up and save big on shoes, tops, dresses, accessories and more must haves for summer. Join the NordicLub to unlock exclusive discounts. Shop new arrivals first and more. Plus buy online and pick up at your favorite Rack store for free. Great brands, great prices. That's why you rack foreign.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Gutfeld along with Paul Moro, Jessica Tarlov, Jesse Waters and a banana slug is her beanbag chair. Dana Farino the five. President Trump calling off a third wave of strikes on Iran tonight, saying that a deal is in place and the signing will potentially occur over the weekend in Europe with JD Vance to be present. Hopefully both sides will be satisfied.

[Donald Trump]

I know you'll never be satisfied, but that's okay. That doesn't bother you at all? We just made a great settlement of the war with Iran and we're going to be subject to finalization of documents, which should get done over the next few days. Probably have a signing maybe in Europe. Much most importantly, we have a deal that Iran will never have a nuclear weapon, which was the whole purpose of what we had to go through to get this. So it was a very big thing. But we have a signing soon and the documents are in pretty final shape. So we'll see. We'll see. Very good. Should be done. That should be done pretty quickly. I won't be able to be there, but JD Will be their vice president and some of the people, Steve Woodkoff did a great job.

[Greg Gutfeld]

And why is Trump so confident of a deal?

[Donald Trump]

Because they've taken a pounding. They've taken a pounding like very few people could take. And they want to make the deal a lot more than I do.

[Greg Gutfeld]

So, Dana, we feel like we go down this road a lot.

[Dana Perino]

Every Thursday night or Friday morning.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Yes, exactly. And I know that our complaints are part of it is due to our attention spans. But I mean, you could argue that the longer it goes on, the worst condition Iran is in and Trump knows that. So what do you make of this?

[Dana Perino]

I think that is certainly true that Iran has to be hurting economically, but the regime itself is willing to withstand a ton of pain and they don't care about their people. We know that President Trump cares more about their people than they care about themselves, but. So it feels like we've been in this doom loop on the one yard line for three months. And I hope that it is true that they could get a deal that if it meets those criteria that the President wants, although then you get into the difficult thing of confirming that they're not doing everything that they've always been doing, and you get back to trust but verify, which I think will be a part of the document. We don't have all of the details yet. So Iran is really good too, about letting the President get out there and say, we're very close, we got a deal, and then they do something like shoot down a helicopter. I was like, well, okay, now, now we're back in the doom loop again, but hopefully it will work out.

[Greg Gutfeld]

I'm.

[Dana Perino]

I can be optimistic as well.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Why can't you? Because right now we're in this. We're in control. I only wish I had an analogy to use in this case, Paul.

[Paul Moro]

Yeah, so I think it would be helpful. We were talking about this off the air, folks. I think it would be helpful to frame this in a. And from where I sit, this thing is a hostage negotiation, right? And the hostages are the Iranian people. The department in this instance is the IRGC and 4 million besieged thugs. That's the paramilitaries. Now, we don't want to kill the hostage, obviously here, right? But we got to get rid of the perp somehow or other. I think we're past that. We've gotten to the point now that the best threat we have is we're going to take Carg Island. What does that mean? That means essentially a staging SWAT right outside the door. And you're saying, no food, no water. And we're right here, guys, we're ready to come in, but we're not coming in yet because Carg island is not the mainland. So where does that leave you? This is why, in my estimation, that the administration has rightly sort of skewed or shifted, I should say, the focus to purely the nukes. And that puts you then in a little bit of a Hobson's Choice. He's been saying it's just the nukes. That's all we care about. You then only really have two options from where I sit. Number one, you're in an endless bombing campaign that is informed by your intelligence, aerial photography, satellites, and what the Israelis and the Gulf allies will give you, just inevitably, that's going to fail at some point, because you're not going to have all the intel. They're going to have hidden sites like they always do, and they know we're coming this time. This ain't like the last time when we came in with the ghost bombers. And you can't have one of those bombers go down over Iran, because the next day, Chinese, North Koreans, Iranians and Russians will all have that technology. So then what's left? Trust but verify. Boots on the ground, of a sort. But it has to have real muscle. The UN is not that muscle. They've never been trustworthy on this issue. The Iranians, obviously are not. They had, what, 11 bombs worth of enriched uranium ready to go, a missile that could go 2,000 miles, that they weren't supposed to have. They can't be trusted. And so we either have to accept that this is about as good as we're going to get, or we're gonna have to put real muscle boots on the ground behind the inspections, otherwise this is gonna go on forever.

[Greg Gutfeld]

See, I told you he was gonna mention Hobson's choice.

[Dana Perino]

Yeah. Who is Hobson?

[Greg Gutfeld]

Who is Hobson?

[Paul Moro]

You're asking me? I just looked that up.

[Jesse Waters]

Come on.

[Greg Gutfeld]

So, Jesse, you know, Jesse, you know, one of the benefits of Trump is he keeps the end game to himself. It drives his adversaries crazy, but it causes everybody here to speculate, you know, and then that makes us impatient, and then we get jaded, and then we start watching sports. Next thing you know, we're drinking and using narcotics, and then we end up homeless and living in Seattle. What is your take on this latest development?

[Jesse Waters]

My take is Trump is such a tease, and I fall for it every time, but this time I think it's real. This time I think it's real. The last two days, I think, woke the Iranians up. Greg, remember when you got beat up in high school?

[Greg Gutfeld]

It never happened.

[Jesse Waters]

You'd be getting hit for about a month straight every single day. Then the bully would stop and he'd take a break. That's the ceasefire. And then all of a sudden, after a couple months, boom, Boom. And it hurts more the second time because you remember how painful it was. And that's what happened. We resumed major combat operations for the last 48 hours. And that was it. Plus Trump's tongue. He basically said, we're gonna keep bombing them until they sign. They didn't like that. And then he said, do you know where the gay Ayatollah is? He goes, I'm not gonna tell you if I know or not, but I know. And then he said, oh, you know what? Openly speculating about seizing Carg Island. He'd never really done that before. And then apparently he called them last night and said, we're gonna hit you tonight, and we're gonna hit you here, and you're gonna hit you here. And there's nothing you can do about it because we own the skies. It's not over till it's over. Someone said that the fat lady hasn't sung yet, because until you deal with the dust, it's war. So you can sign a document, you can open up the straight, but until we watch the dust get downgraded to zero, the war is still on. Because I think what's happening now is you're gonna have the IAEA have to sit there and see and witness them take this thing down to zero. We have spies in the Atomic Energy Agency, so we'll see it, and we can see it from the Space Force. But until that happens, this worst still on. But right now it looks good, and I'm pretty happy with it. The market loves it. Oil's down into the 80s. The market was up, what, 900 points today? I think the market knows what's happening. And if JD Is going to sign this thing in Europe, he better be back next week because he's on this show and he has to do the View. So hurry it up.

[Greg Gutfeld]

I think he's more worried about the View than Iran.

[Jesse Waters]

What's more dangerous?

[Greg Gutfeld]

Well, they could sit on him. So, Jessica, do you agree with everything Jesse said? It looks good, Cautiously optimistic.

[Jessica Tarlov]

It did not say cautiously.

[Jesse Waters]

I'm cautiously.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Yeah.

[Jesse Waters]

We've been down this road before.

[Jessica Tarlov]

At least 37 times, actually. We have been down this road of we're almost out of deal. I'm glad that you said that we're in a war, though, because the President says that we're not, so that Congress can't assert their right to actually decide whether we should go to war or not. So I'm glad you've broken with him on that. It is, though, Greg, the first time that you have actually told the truth about the conversation in the Green Room room that you were having, Paul, for the setup. But I have a different hostage to bring to the table, which is the Strait of Hormuz. So, yes, the end game is, of course, you want to take care of the nuclear dust and Iranian aspirations to have a nuclear weapon. But the Strait of Hormuz is the linchpin of this and it has been since Iran predictably closed it. And that's really what needs to get open. I mean, the longer that this goes on, the more damage that we see. I mean, issues like a couple of days ago, US Strikes took out three Indian nationals who were on a tanker that was going through. We can't have stuff like that happening. It makes people who are already angry at us even more angry at this point in terms of how Iran is faring, of course it is not all sunshine and roses and they're having the best time and there's a huge economic toll and there has been a military toll to some degree, but I think it's quite, quite clear degree.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Well, but I'm being, I know what you're doing. I'm letting you condition this stuff with the greatest words. You know, a little bit here, a little bit there. Well, they don't have an air force.

[Jessica Tarlov]

But then, I mean, Laura Ingraham even a couple nights ago asked on her show she had a guest on who said if, if we obliterated them, then how are they striking us? They have been able to rebuild and rearm certainly faster than we thought could happen.

[Greg Gutfeld]

There has been, there are some missiles and drones. We can't stop them. All right, that's the only car they have left.

[Jessica Tarlov]

Yes, we have no problem. Everything has gone exactly to and you're absolutely right. I'm just trying to also know what

[Greg Gutfeld]

you're trying to keep you on the path to truth.

[Paul Moro]

Jessica.

[Jessica Tarlov]

I walk alone on my path and what I'm saying is rooted in what reporters from the region are putting out there and even questions that some of Trump's biggest supporters are asking. We also know on the domestic level that Donald Trump needs this deal done. He doesn't have the appetite for the war himself anymore. He said as much. The Republican Party doesn't. They're breaking with him more than they have before because they have concerns at home. People are saying it's $4 G. Democrats are now up 10 points on the generic ballot. His approval is in the mid-30s. Inflation, 4.2% outpacing wages. The toll of this war is too much for him to bear electorally and for what he's interested anymore. And so maybe we get to a deal from this. But it's just a memorandum of understanding at this point. And Iran and Israel were key linchpins to making this come to fruition, are out there signaling that they're not interested in what at least is being proposed for Saturday in Europe for J. Vance. I guess he misses the UFC fight, though, which is.

[Greg Gutfeld]

I think everybody.

[Jessica Tarlov]

Well, can he get back? He's going to sign Saturday. Get back.

[Jesse Waters]

Yeah, he'll get.

[Jessica Tarlov]

I think Trump was like, I would rather go to the UFC fight than stand around here while would they probably won't sign the same.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Well, everybody wants this finished, especially the Gulf states. But no one is really rallying to the Iranian side except the American left and the difference between Chinese. Well, obviously same.

[Jessica Tarlov]

Oh, I'm sorry, I forgot I missed my cue on that one.

[Paul Moro]

Hey, look, let's remember something else too. This is the first administration to actually push this to a record.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Say. Exactly. This is the thing that drives me crazy. Democrats and media do not include the context when. When they talk about economic figures, they never bring up context. When they talk about Iran, they forget 50 years where they. Where they caused terrorism around the world, where they threatened to blow up a.

[Jessica Tarlov]

That's why we had them in a deal that Trump. We had enriched uranium at 3.5% levels and then it got up to 60% after he ripped up the deal in 2018.

[Jesse Waters]

Will you say thank you after this is over and you get a deal and you get the uranium. Would you say thank you to who? To the president and Pete Hegseth. If you annihilate most of their military and get the dust, will you say thank you?

[Greg Gutfeld]

All right.

[Jesse Waters]

You won't say thank you. Wow, that sounds honest.

[Greg Gutfeld]

I guess we know what side she's on. America.

[Jesse Waters]

Yeah. Oh, K. Ron Tarlov. All right.

[Greg Gutfeld]

He's back in the headlines. Turn up racial outrage over the Carmelo Anthony case.

[Ad Announcer]

Cheers to America's 250th birthday. Get 20% off your first purchase at foxnewswineshop.com with code FNRADIO 2020 discount, excludes wine club offers and cannot be combined with any other promotion. Expires July 31, 2026. Must be 21 or older to order. Please drink resp. Responsibly.

[Dana Perino]

Lawyers for Carmelo Anthony are filing a notice to appeal his conviction. That comes just one day after he was sentenced to 35 years in prison for stabbing and killing 17 year old Austin Metcalf at a track meet last year. But remember Jasmine Crockett? She is not accepting the verdict. The outgoing Texas congresswoman is suggesting race played a role in the case and its outcome. And here she is talking to TMZ and her podcast.

[Jasmine Crockett]

Listen. A lot of people don't know what it is to live as a black person in this country. The fact that there was little to no mercy seen or humanity seen. When this black boy said that, I was scared. Was it a switch? I don't know what he had. It was like a, it seemed like it was a multi tool, almost like a Swiss army. Yeah, like with the little scissors and everything and whatever. So it was small? Well, I would argue the size of it alone. You wouldn't even think it's a deadly wedding if a 300 pound man is beating me like on top of me and beating me down. I, I'm not limited to fist, Paul.

[Dana Perino]

She is a lawyer. She apparently didn't look at any of the facts of the evidence of the case before she commented.

[Paul Moro]

Yeah, I mean she may not be limited to fists, but she's clearly limited because that is just a complete, like just a countermand of everything that went on in the courtroom. The idea that she can argue that the size of the knife, which is not in dispute, it was recovered. The fact that she could somehow argue that because of its size it can't be considered a deadly weapon, which is what she was doing there, despite the fact that it killed the victim. I mean it's just a basic algebraic logic here. Now look, there's no winners in this story. We've all been through that aspect of it. I don't understand what was on. According to all the reporting, this kid Carmelo had a job, he had a good grade point average, he came from a good family. I don't know what the hell he was thinking. But the facts have spoken. He went into the tent, he has a knife for some reason in a bag. Remember, under Texas law, there's two metrics here that matter. Number one, you can't use self defense if you provoke the incident. All right, that part may be succeeded, maybe failed. We don't know what the jury thought. But the second piece, and that's kind of what she's talking about here, definitely failed. Which is that your reaction has to be commensurate to the threat that you perceive. And that's going to be an objective standard. You just can't say the guy was white and he was big, so I thought he was going to kill me. No, the facts have to matter. And then you stab the guy in the chest. Now let's go real quick to the appeal. The appeal is going to center on. It's going to be due process stuff. Miranda, they always throw that in. But what it's going to come down to is the following. Did the exemption of the three black Females who were educators, was that cover just to get three blacks off the jury? That's it. If the argument of the prosecution, which was, no, we didn't want teachers, if that holds the day, then the appeal will fail. And know that the appeals courts generally give great deference to the trial court judge in making that assessment. That's the assessment that the trial court judge would have done. He would have said, is this a. Are they just trying to get rid of three black jurors? And the way that they look at that is to say, are there similarly situated people who are on the jury? That is to say, a white teacher, an Asian teacher, et cetera? Short of that, I expect the appeal to fail. I have questions, though. I wonder, was there a plea offer? You didn't get a lot of character stuff. And I go back to what I opened this segment with, which I'm sorry, but I just got to go to it. I don't understand. The kid, from all intents for, had a great life ahead of him. What was he thinking? What's he walking around with a knife at a track meet? That aspect of it, I have to say, tugs at me a little bit. I find it a mystery.

[Dana Perino]

And the defense, Jessica, didn't really seem to do that great a job.

[Jessica Tarlov]

No.

[Dana Perino]

They didn't even call anybody.

[Jessica Tarlov]

No. And then, I mean, to your point, what you already brought up of the character witnesses, where he just had his mother and for, like, 10 minutes, he had a fully intact family with a dad who's out there advocating for him in press conferences, doing interviews, like, why didn't we at least hear from both of his parents? He was a good kid, part of this team, you know, friends from school, his employer. Right. He shows up all the time, you know, on time for work, treats people with respect. You know, the usual stuff that you would expect, especially when someone is looking at potentially spending 35 years behind bars. I was curious as well about whether there was a plea offer of manslaughter involved in this, where I think you said the maximum would be 20 years. And then maybe he's getting out in 10 to 12 years with good behavior. And then he still has his life ahead of him. Right. He's going to be in his early 30s. The jury selection question will definitely be the linchpin of where this goes. If we find out and people are saying it was an all white jury, it wasn't an all white jury. There were Asian people and Latino people on the jury. But if they find that there was someone who is either an educator or in a profession akin to an educator that didn't get pushed off the jury to then make sure that there were no black people on the jury. Obviously, that could take us down a different path. I'm also curious about the videos we've heard about the one that allegedly showed, because we haven't seen any of this, that, you know, Carmelo Anthony was really the instigator, that he wasn't surrounded. There's also an eyewitness who has been talking about a video circulating on the Internet that he saw that Carmel Anthony was surrounded.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Yeah.

[Jessica Tarlov]

And so I think that one of

[Dana Perino]

the angles here, though, Jesse, is about Jasmine Crockett trying to stir up something for what? I guess for her own attention.

[Jesse Waters]

Why would Carmelo Anthony be scared? I mean, if you're a young black man in America, you're scared of other black people. Nine out of ten blacks who are killed are killed by other blacks. You're not afraid of white people. Same with white people. White people kill white people at the same rate. Blacks kill black people. There's very little crossover. In fact, if there is, it's usually blacks killing whites, but not at that high of a rate. There's a track meet. It's a whole meet for Metcalf. There's eight teams. It's raining. Every team brings a tent. Carmelo's team couldn't get up the tent. Okay, so everyone's scrambling around. Now, when you're in high school, you usually don't mingle with the other teams. You never mingle. You stay on the other side. There's no mixing. That's just how it is. Very competitive. So he goes over there, and for six minutes, they ask him to leave politely. And then Carmelo threatens him, and he goes like, try me. See what's gonna happen. And Metcalf was like, what are you looking in your bag for? This is a low crime area. Like, no one carries a knife. Who carries a knife, 5 inch blade to a track meet? And what's he doing? And if you're really thinking you're under threat, brandish it. You don't stab the guy in the chest so violently. When the cops came, they found bone. That's how deep it went. And the video shows that he wasn't surrounded at all. In fact, black witnesses testified that Carmela was kind of the instigator. So I don't know what happened. I don't know what was going through his mind, but he should not have been doing that.

[Dana Perino]

And what's going through Jazzy Crockett's mind, Greg.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Yeah, I mean, I would rather just comment on what I can see and what I know. The only thing we seem not to know is why he was in the tent. So I'll just leave it there. She says she doesn't know what it's like. We don't know. We don't know what it's like to be a black woman. And that's true. But she doesn't know what it's like to be a white man. A white man like me. I can't afford to be as stupid as she is. Like, I have to try harder because I'm going to be called all sorts of names. But she can say whatever she wants. I think she said, like, what if it were a white teen who stabbed a black kid? Oh, it would be different. She's right. There would be riots, there would be looting, there would be murals, there would be marches, there would be corporate virtue signaling quiet moments in the court quad, politicians weeping, celebrity videos. I am Carmelo Anthony. We would kneel. Nancy Pelosi would wear a scarf. If this were in reverse, they would George Floyd the crap out of it. Fact is, we have an incredibly low bar for black leftist commentary. If any white person said that stuff about the murder of a black kid, it would be the apocalypse. But on the left, every heartless bozo gets a hall pass. The weird thing about it is we're in a situation where you can, like, talk about justifiable homicide when you're dealing with whiteness. And it's because we have created a filter of historical oppression that, like, you could be innocent, but you represent something. So I look at you as a. As a totem, I guess, for all the guilt and because our society is evil and racist and bigoted, the stakes are life and death. So when I am confronted with a white person, I can stab you. That is what she is saying. She's not. She's not saying, like, oh, he's innocent. She's not saying, he's innocent and he's guilty. She's saying it's. Okay.

[Jesse Waters]

Justified.

[Greg Gutfeld]

It's justified. And this is when you're.

[Jesse Waters]

I mean, you.

[Greg Gutfeld]

You are seeing behavior. And maybe it's my algorithm, but you see a lot of fights where there are people who do not know how to manage their emotions when it comes to conflict, and they go right to the punch or right to the stab.

[Paul Moro]

And that's why they said white supremacy. That was the phrase you heard right away. And what she was doing and others were doing, which is so shameful in this context is that they enlarged the context back to 1861. And somehow or other Austin Metcalfe is supposed to be an avatar of white supremacy. He's a 17 year old kid at a track meet. He's representative of white supremacy. And remember something else? Salient point. When Carmelo was taken into custody, the police and others heard him say the following. He put his hands on me and that was the warning that he gave. Touch me and see what happens. He didn't say he threatened my life. He had a baseball bat. They said they were going to kill me. He put his hands on me. That's an awfully low bar to stab somebody in the heart.

[Dana Perino]

Coming up next, Ms. Rachel taking story time to detention time. The children's YouTube star is visiting an ICE facility.

[Bloomberg Announcer]

Some follow the noise. Bloomberg follows the money. Because behind every headline is a bottom line. Whether it's the funds fueling AI or crypto's trillion dollar swings. There's a money side to every story. And when you see the money side, you understand what others miss. Get the money side of the story. Subscribe [e-mail].

[Jesse Waters]

Miss Rachel acting more like Ms. Rachel, 13, as the popular children's YouTube creator crashed Delaney hall in Newark, New Jersey, accusing the Trump administration of terrorizing children and singing some nursery rhymes for all the murderers, rapists and pedos inside.

[Paul Moro]

I sing from here and you sing

[Jessica Tarlov]

from there Together we'll sing down the

[Jesse Waters]

walls everywhere Together we'll sing until everyone's free. A DHS spokesperson calling BS on trend Rachel telling Fox Digital ICE does not separate families. Parents are asked if they want to be removed with their children or ICE will place the children with a safe person the parent designates. But why doesn't Ms. Rachel sing a lullaby about the hundreds of thousands of migrant kids lost under the Biden administration? DHS Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen is getting to the bottom of that.

[Mark Wayne Mullen]

We found 146,000 kids so far. 146,000 kids. We still have nearly 300,000 missing. We're investigating reports to where some of these kids claim that they were raped six to seven hundred times. I don't care who you are. I don't care if you have kids. If you don't have kids, I don't care if you're liberal, you're independent, you're a Democrat, you're Republican. If you can't stand for law enforcement to go find these kids, who are you?

[Jesse Waters]

Jessica? Will you be showing your children, Ms. Rachel, after this despicable display?

[Jessica Tarlov]

My older daughter was a huge Ms. Rachel enthusiast. She's outgrown it. Ms. Rachel helps a lot of kids, no matter their parents, partisan affiliation, learn to talk. And her story is great and her videos are beloved. Her politics more divisive to some people, but there are kids in these facilities and I'm for kids having access to nursery rhymes and good entertainment. I think it is a losing argument to just say everything is fine with the conditions in places like Dilley in Texas or in Delaney hall, poo pooing, you know, maggots in the food. To take us back to a classic. ICE has detained over 500. Okay, gross. ICE has detained over 500 babies and toddlers under Trump. An average of 25 a day are in custody. So you know Ms. Rachel. Her job is to bring joy to children and to help them.

[Greg Gutfeld]

She hates Jews, but you're okay with that? I guess so. I guess so. No, because here's the deal. You are falling. Either you're falling for this ploy or you don't care. She's a Trojan horse that exploits the benign, innocent nature of a kids show host because that way every time you scrutinize her political mission, you look like the bad guy. She just wants to help little kids.

[Jessica Tarlov]

She just wants to.

[Greg Gutfeld]

She's anti west, she's anti Jew, she's anti anti Israel. That's fine, right? But don't you dare attack our politics. Isn't it interesting too that all these politics happen to follow the same path? You know, the same people that are out there screaming for Hamas are also hating on ice and they tend to mush it together like there's chocolate in their peanut butter. They can't. It's not separate. Does that just raise your suspicions a little bit? I would love for her to do a sing along with a handful of male detainees unsupervised and watch the suicide empathy take hold as she defends, as the typical misguided leftist does, this innocent trapped man who is a refugee, who might be a felon, but I don't know, he was just trying to cross the Rio Grande. These naive virtue signal. Signalers will help a felon that will lead to their own death. She can operate in her stupidity as long as the felons are behind a wall. But she should have them come live, take two of the guys, have them move in with you, Ms. Rachel. People have done that. And have you read what happens? It's pretty interesting. I wouldn't advise it.

[Jesse Waters]

I think it's pretty clear Greg will not be showing Ms. Rachel to his child anytime soon.

[Paul Moro]

No, way

[Dana Perino]

I knew she existed. But I've never watched any of her videos.

[Jesse Waters]

She's pretty good.

[Jasmine Crockett]

But

[Dana Perino]

remember when the Israelis had to gather groups together and show them those videos of the heinous acts and the massacre of October 7th? And finally, after a year, the UN Women's Organization finally said, oh, yeah, that was bad. And what I thought Mark Wayne Mullen today was so effective at was I didn't see partisanship at all on his behalf. This is a guy who wants to solve problems, committed to solving problems. That's the kind of people you want in government. Ms. Rachel has a different job, right? Her job is to educate kids and teach them some language. If she wants to get involved in politics, well, then this is what you're going to get. You are going to get scrutinized. What Mark Wayne Mullen is saying is that how could you not want to help us here to try to help to find these children, regardless of when they were lost in the system, they are now saying, we will find them. They've got people out there that are called super sponsors, and they would say, okay, I'll take 30 children. And what do you think was happening? And there was never any checks. So as he said, they did a very good job of finding 146,000 kids so far, but there's 300,000 more to go. And what he is saying is, Ms. Rachel, would you like to watch this video or hear some of this evidence and maybe work with us? Yes, that would be a reasonable way to proceed.

[Greg Gutfeld]

These People laugh about October 7th. They laugh about it, but why is

[Paul Moro]

it so hard for the progressive left to leave the kids out of it? And of course, we know what the answer is, is because this is the equivalent of the drag queens at the library. As the Jesuits used to say, give me the child till seven, I have him for life. This is indoctrination period. End of story. Hey, Ms. Rachel, how about this song? How about the Ballad of Lake and Riley? All right. How about A Little Diddy for Jocelyn Nungare? No, we're not going to hear those songs. She knows, and they know exactly what they're doing. This is the same stuff going on in Teen Vogue and all kinds of other influence peddling that goes on. They should be done.

[Greg Gutfeld]

They killed my subscription.

[Paul Moro]

But the other thing is this. And we just have to remember this. This is the same narrative every time I've been through it. You can take it back to the war on terror. Gitmo is inhumane. Al Qaeda, somehow or other were the good guys because they weren't getting everything they wanted in Gitmo. Same thing during, during the summer 11 2020. They were trying to NYPD in New York City had nothing to do with George Floyd. Nonetheless, they're trying to burn down Macy. They're bouncing bricks off my cops faces. I'm out there with all of this stuff and I'm finding out that the city is like almost immediately going to pay all of these people who sue just to make them go away. The same thing's happening in Minnesota and the same thing's going to happen in Delaney, folks. It's a vicious cycle. It goes on and on. They get paid off by the Blue Cities. That money supports more protest movements because we know a lot of them are paid. It keeps going on. It's extortionate on the Blue Cities, but also the rest of us because a lot of it is tax money. They know what they're doing. That's why it never goes away. It only grows because it's lucrative.

[Jesse Waters]

And did you see the menu at Delaney, Jessica? It's like a charming bed and bread. I should eat so well. It was delicious.

[Jessica Tarlov]

It's embarrassing.

[Jesse Waters]

Try it sometime.

[Greg Gutfeld]

If the left ran it, they would put maggots on the menu and say, good for you.

[Jesse Waters]

That's probably right. Coming up next, President Trump's throwing America a birthday banger, while some Democrats want to leave before the candles get lit.

[Paul Moro]

So America is about to celebrate. Two hundred and fifty Democrats apparently want to spend it in Canada. A new poll found that 55% of Democrats would rather join the ranks of TDS all stars like Rosie and Ellen, and rather live in a different country than the United states, while only 10% of Republicans said the same. All right, Jesse, I got to come to you. You've been walking around in the Fox building here in a beret. We've all seen it. What's this?

[Jesse Waters]

If there was only one country, it would be France, maybe Canada, but no, obviously the United States of America. Imagine if you had another passport. Imagine you had an Argentinian passport and you go abroad and you get kidnapped, you get lost. Do you think the Argentinian government is going to find you? They're not even going to try America. If we lose an American anywhere, Bangladesh, South Korea, the President of the United States will get on the phone with the other president and will say, hey, find them or else the Marines are coming and that's the kind of country you want to live in. Plus everywhere else barely has any air conditioning. The ice cubes are small, the service is slow. Good luck buying an SUV anywhere else.

[Paul Moro]

So your metric, your metric is like, were you kidnapped? Essentially, you want to make sure you're in a country that's going to actually look for you.

[Jesse Waters]

Yes.

[Paul Moro]

Don't count on that too much, Jesse.

[Jesse Waters]

Well, it depends on who's President Trump

[Jessica Tarlov]

is definitely looking for, Jesse.

[Jesse Waters]

Yeah, desperately.

[Paul Moro]

Jess, what about you? You going to Mexico City? Where are you going to go?

[Dana Perino]

Go?

[Jessica Tarlov]

No, I couldn't go to the Mexico City.

[Paul Moro]

Talking about it.

[Jessica Tarlov]

Oh, I love Mexico City. It's very cool place not to live. I've lived abroad. I had a great time living in London. I am a New Yorker. I plan on staying here, much to Greg's chagrin. Listen, you know, you always want to see the data if things were reversed. And I don't think it even works to go back 10 years ago. I think the last 10 years have been incredibly difficult on the partisan level for the country. So let's repoll everyone when it is, you know, President jon Ossoff in 2030 and see what's up then.

[Paul Moro]

President Plattner. Yeah, I mean, it's actually a fair point. Dana, where are you going? I think I know.

[Dana Perino]

So I'm going to be here. And guess what? The Europeans want to be here. This is my favorite content of the entire week has been the Europeans, like Freddie on X, who is from Germany. They're here on a road trip going to their games today and they have fallen in love with America. And it's just so fun. You can see it on your screen there. Follow and enjoy them realizing how awesome America is. It's like when de Tocqueville came and went back to Europe. He's like, wow, these people are amazing. They really get along and everything. It's not just about the food. It was about the wealth as well. There's like, look at these houses. Look at this largesse. Look at what they have that we don't.

[Paul Moro]

Yeah. And you know, that's always a fun experience for Americans. Watching a nick game last night we were in a restaurant. The kid outside was watching through the window. So we went, this is near the end of the game. We brought him in. Turns out he was Serbian and he was new to this country and yet he was a basketball nut. It was very much the same kind of thing. He was just like, sort of infatuated. Greg, take us out with you.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Tell the rest of the story. When he mugged. You know, it's funny. You hear about the people who leave because they can, because they keep their home in the United States. When you're rich. You can move to England or France for six months and come back. Everybody else who's doing this poll, well, okay, you must sell your home. You must quit your job and find work in a foreign country. And the country you go to is not as friendly as America. Good luck moving permanently to Japan or finding work in England. It's hard. I'm willing to bet that the person who says, I'm going to live abroad, abroad instead of America is the first person when they arrive in France to look for a McDonald's or a home Depot. A seasoned traveler, if you're a seasoned traveler, always has a lot of gratitude for having America as their home to return to. Because you've seen the world, you know what works and you really know what what doesn't. But if you're super rich, you can live anywhere. Perhaps, you know, except Haiti or Somalia. But it's a very easy thing for somebody like Ellen DeGeneres or Rosie to because it's not a big deal to fly in your private jet.

[Paul Moro]

Yeah, you know, it's a transatlantic virtue signal. And the truth of the matter is that most of us are only as virtuous as our options. All right, the fastest is up next.

[Jessica Tarlov]

Welcome. Enjoy my sex music. Is it ever appropriate to send a midnight text? Oh, leads right into it. Well, it depends. It's okay if it's your spouse or your best friend, but your boss, that can be invasive or anxiety inducing. Jesse, do you think there are time guards on text messages?

[Jesse Waters]

Yeah. You can only send a late night text to a woman because. And a woman that works with you because you want to really get ahead of things for the next day. At 6 o', clock, she wanted to wake up and see the text that you send after midnight. You just try to motivate her. You know, these women, they have these grooming things they do with their hair. You know, you got to snap them out of.

[Dana Perino]

Well, first of all, I don't have any notifications on my phone. So the text thing doesn't bother me because I'm not going to hear, like there's not some train whistle that's going to blow when texts come in. But also there are tools on the text. If you want to write a text, you can hit the send later button, schedule it to send at 8am and then you won't be a jerk.

[Jessica Tarlov]

Won't be a jerk.

[Greg Gutfeld]

That's not why they're texting. If you get a midnight text, the first thing you're going to hear is your spouse going, who Is that. And then you're screwed. I'm more interested in this weird human behavior that we have. And I know we all do it because I do it. Not responding to a text when you could, but just waiting, as though you have a sense of power in it. And that the longer you wait, the more anxiety you create in the person who texted you.

[Dana Perino]

That's what's happening in the dating world right now with the young people.

[Paul Moro]

You do that, huh?

[Greg Gutfeld]

Everybody but he does it.

[Paul Moro]

Paul, you're the guy who was pulling the wings off of small insects. And that was last week. Look, this thing. I absolutely cannot stand this thing. It runs my life. It's like the mistress I never agreed to. I look at it before I go to bed. I wake up with it as soon as I wake, frankly. You know what this is? It's an Eastern European escort that won't leave me alone. It's insatiable, but nonetheless, I can't get rid of it.

[Jesse Waters]

Another Serbian.

[Paul Moro]

Serbian.

[Jesse Waters]

Other Serb.

[Jessica Tarlov]

One more thing's up next. Next.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Time now for one more thing.

[Paul Moro]

I'll go first.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Tonight we got a great show. Guy Benson. Madison. Allworth. Cat, Tim. Tyrus. That's tonight. Let's do this. Greg. Sexy Bear news. Roll it from the Oakland Zoo. Yeah, a bunch of bears dancing. Nothing more romantic. Especially when they're standing on their hind legs shifted side to side, which allows them to leave their scent. And you know, when you have a scent like that, Dana, what do you need? Lysol. That's right, Lysol. Which, coincidentally, is sponsoring this segment. Nothing better than the smell of Lysol. In fact, I hear it's quite a pheromone among the.

[Dana Perino]

It's an aphrodisiac, right?

[Greg Gutfeld]

Yes, it is an aphrodisiac.

[Dana Perino]

I always thought that.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Although. Don't bring race into this, Jesse.

[Jesse Waters]

I'll bring Race into it. Happy DEI Thursday. Sponsored by Wonder Bread. That's not sponsoring.

[Ad Announcer]

I'm sorry.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Sponsored by Lysol.

[Jessica Tarlov]

He said Wonder Bread.

[Greg Gutfeld]

Danny, you got.

[Dana Perino]

Oh, okay, ten seconds. Then everyone should read Purple State,

[Ad Announcer]

listen to the 5ad free on Amazon Music with your prime membership, or subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.