Podcast Summary: "Police Have Brown Suspect ID And Warrant"

Podcast: The Five (FOX News Podcasts)
Date: December 19, 2025
Panelists: Dana Perino (Host), Greg Gutfeld, Brian Kilmeade, Jessica Tarlov, Jesse Watters, Ainsley Earhardt, Paul Morrow (guest)

Overview

This episode of "The Five" delivers a dynamic roundtable on two major topics: breaking details in the Brown University and MIT shootings, and reactions to President Trump’s recent speech on the economy. The panelists also touch on the shifting landscape of marijuana laws, playful political jabs, and speculation around future presidential candidates. Their trademark banter, skepticism, and humor infuse even the most serious stories with engaging debate and personal flair.

Segment 1: Breaking News – Brown University and MIT Shootings

[01:21-10:51]

Key Discussion Points

• Providence Police Identify Suspect:
  – Providence police have named a suspect in the Brown University campus shooting, with an active warrant out for arrest.
  – Authorities are probing a potential connection to the murder of MIT professor Nuno Loro in Brookline, Massachusetts, one hour from Brown.

• Emerging Narrative & Speculation:
  – Surveillance footage shows the suspect “casing” the Brown neighborhood; a second person is seen on video but not necessarily linked. – Speculative links to a car tracked from Providence to Boston, possibly the same make/model.

• Personal Impact of Professor’s Death:
  – MIT professor, a nuclear fusion expert from Portugal with young children, was shot in his upscale Boston condo.

• Law Enforcement Insights from Paul Morrow:
  – The link between crimes might hinge on a license plate reader match. – Police may have put an alert on a suspicious car; the same vehicle shows up near both crime scenes.

Notable Quotes & Moments

• Jesse Watters [04:06]:
  “If they had had cameras there and had done their job, if this is connected to MIT, the professor at MIT would be alive. So that's sad.”

• Jessica Tarlov [06:23]:
  “It’s crushing to learn the details ... he lived on the first floor and had three little kids at home.”

• Jessica Tarlov [07:24]: “There is a lot going on in your phone that has not been verified ... be careful about that.”

• Paul Morrow [07:49]:
  “If I had a guess, they had an alert on the car, the car tripwired someplace near the second crime [MIT]. ... that’s the commonality.”

• Jesse Watters [09:09]:
  “The hit, if it was a hit, was incredibly sloppy, which makes me think it wasn’t a hit ... it seems really personal.”

• Paul Morrow [09:38]:
  “They’re not entirely clear ... how the shooter entered [the building]. ... If he went to the first classroom that presented itself, it says to me ... he’s sending some kind of a message at either Brown writ large or America.”

Segment 2: President Trump’s Rapid-Fire Economic Speech

[12:19-24:45]

Key Discussion Points

• Speech Style and Reception:
  – Trump gave a brisk, high-energy 18-minute speech emphasizing wage gains, energy prices, border control, and other economic “wins.” – Panel critiques focus as much on style (“mile a minute,” “shouting”) as content.

• Fact-Checking Claims:
  – Jessica Tarlov debunks and questions several statistics, including inflation, employment, and drug price reductions. – Discussion over “warrior dividend” for military — is it new money or a rebrand of existing benefits?

• Public and Political Reaction:
  – Some say the speech was effective for direct, televised communication.
  – Others argue metrics presented were exaggerated or unsubstantiated.

Notable Quotes & Moments

• Donald Trump [12:36]:
  “When I took office, inflation was the worst in 48 years ... we have brought more positive change to Washington than any administration in American history.”

• Greg Gutfeld [13:46]:
  “One exaggeration after another exaggeration ... trying to convince Americans the sky is green, that trees can walk.”

• Dana Perino [14:19]:
  “He wants to be on offense on this issue ... he has time for some of these things to set in ... if you can keep this trajectory going, it takes inflation a long time to come down.”

• Jesse Watters [16:57]:
  “It might have been his most effective speech because ... direct injection of his accomplishments that the media doesn’t cover.”

• Jessica Tarlov [20:06]:
  “He said unemployment is down. It's up to 4.6% where it hasn't been since 2021 ... bringing down drug prices by 600%. You can't bring down prices by 600%.”

• Greg Gutfeld [21:31]:
  Speaking on the speech: “This was a bait and switch. The media ... expected something big ... instead, what did he do? Just showed up ... had to talk fast, couldn’t waste any time.”

Fact-Checking Flare-Up

– Jessica Tarlov and Dana Perino spar over military “warrior dividend,” with Jessica citing reporting the money is just a reallocation, not a new benefit.
– Perino [24:18]: “The Defense Department can say ... when they do the budget we’ll take the tariff money and put that back in the account.”

Segment 3: AOC vs. JD Vance – 2028 Hype

[25:48-31:51]

Key Discussion Points

• AOC “Stomping” Poll:
  – Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez touts an early poll showing her beating VP JD Vance in a hypothetical 2028 contest, joking: “Let the record show, I would stomp him.” [26:07]

• Panel Reactions:
  – General consensus: these polls are fun but too early to mean much. – Dana Perino: “She’s funny, she’s got charisma ... If that is the matchup, we’re going to have a heck of an election season.” [26:31] – Discussion widens: Who else might run in 2028? Names include Rubio, Youngkin, Kemp, DeSantis, Hegseth, Newsom, Bashir, Shapiro, Mayor Pete.

• Debate on “Moderate” Democrats & Transgender Policies:
  – Greg Gutfeld criticizes House Democrats for voting against a ban on transgender surgeries for minors: “There is no moderate in that ... that is just repulsive.” [28:37]

• Vibe Check:
  – Light, playful banter about political spectrum, seriousness of issues, and cable news culture.

Segment 4: Reclassification of Marijuana – Trump’s Executive Order

[32:54-37:42]

Key Discussion Points

• Policy Change:
  – Trump signs order reclassifying marijuana to Schedule III (with Tylenol w/codeine), easing federal rules but not legalizing it. – Framed as medical, not recreational — Trump: “Unless a drug is recommended by a doctor ... don’t do it.” [33:11]

• Public Sentiment:
  – Growing popular support for legalization (Gallup: 64% favor, Pew: 88% for medical/recreational use).

• Panel Concerns:
  – Debate over potential youth use, risk for accidents, high-potency THC, and need for a new classification system. – Jessica Tarlov: “...the tide has really turned on this and it’s going to be incumbent, especially on parents to be really diligent...” [36:00] – Jesse Watters jokes: “Whenever I take a gummy, I’m wiped out for days.” [37:27]

Segment 5: Trump Trolls with Presidential Plaques

[38:06-41:13]

Key Discussion Points

• Political Theater:
  – President Trump installs plaques criticizing Biden (“Sleepy Joe ... worst president in American history”) and Obama (“one of the most divisive ... in history”) in the White House.

• Panel Responses:
  – Jessica Tarlov calls it “repulsive behavior,” Brian Kilmeade says “I’m not for the trolling.” [38:40–38:58] – Jesse Watters is unfazed: “It’s just a word, Jessica. It’s his own house. He lives there...so he can decorate it however he wants.” [39:44] – Greg Gutfeld: “This is free money on the table ... it’s entertaining to us. This is why we don’t deserve him.” [40:09] – Panel agrees it’s a classic Trump move: eye-rolling for some, entertaining for others.

Segment 6: One More Thing – Lighthearted Stories

[41:29–42:49]

• Reunited Pet Story: A missing dog makes it home after four years, traveling from Detroit to California.
• Show Banter:
  – Greg Gutfeld shares “sexy polar bear news.” – Jesse Watters on a woman marrying ChatGPT; playful skepticism about cultural stereotypes. – Humorous exchange on who's the smartest on the team (Grok the AI says Greg is smart), chatty wrap-up.

Summary of Tone & Style

The episode featured the lively, sometimes combative blend of news, skepticism, fact-checking, and jokes that "The Five" is known for. While breaking coverage of the Brown and MIT shootings provided seriousness and urgency, the panel was quick to turn heated or complicated issues (Trump’s speech, AOC polling, marijuana) into sharply opinionated and sometimes irreverent exchanges.

Memorable One-Liners:

• “One exaggeration after another exaggeration ... trying to convince Americans the sky is green, that trees can walk.” – Greg Gutfeld [13:46]
• “Let the record show, I would stomp him.” – Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (read by Jessica Tarlov) [26:07]
• “Whenever I take a gummy, I'm wiped out for days.” – Jesse Watters [37:27]
• “This is free money on the table ... it’s entertaining to us. This is why we don’t deserve him.” – Greg Gutfeld [40:09]

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [01:21]– Breakdown of Brown/MIT shootings and suspect developments
• [04:06]– Jesse Watters: Cameras & MIT Link
• [07:49]– Paul Morrow: License Plate Reader Analysis
• [12:36]– Trump’s Speech Highlights
• [13:46]– Panel Skewers Speech Delivery
• [16:57]– Jesse Watters: Impact of the Speech
• [20:06]– Jessica Tarlov Fact-Checking
• [26:07]– AOC “I would stomp him” Poll
• [28:37]– Gutfeld on House Dems’ Trans Policy Vote
• [33:11]– Trump: Marijuana Statement
• [38:40]– Panel Reacts to Trump’s Plaques
• [41:29]– “One More Thing” Light Segment

Conclusion

This episode delivers hallmark "The Five" banter, timely reporting, and strong opinions on top national stories and political dynamics. From the intensity of breaking crime news to playful presidential trolling, each segment highlights the ideological divides, humor, and unpredictability the show thrives on. For listeners who missed the episode, this summary captures both the themes and the distinct personalities that make the panel compelling—no matter where you land on the issues.