Transcript
Jesse Watters (0:00)
Foreign Jesse Waters along with Katie Pavlich, Harold Ford Jr. Emily Campagno, and Greg Gutfeld. Five o' clock in New York City. And this is the five. Two huge news stories we're following at this hour. Fresh new reaction from President Trump on whether the United States is going to bomb Iran. But first to this, Karen Reed was found not guilty of murdering her Boston police officer boyfriend. So let's go right now to Brian Yanes with the latest. Brian.
Brian Yanes (0:40)
Jesse, good evening. Well, Karen Reed hugged her attorneys and she dabbed her face with a tissue after the jury found her not guilty of second degree murder, manslaughter and leaving or fleeing the scene of an accident resulting in death. She was found guilty of an OUI operating under the influence of liquor. She will serve one year. Now, the verdict culminating in at least 22 hours of deliberations for the jury. In this retrial outside of court, Reid briefly spoke.
Emily Campagno (1:09)
I could not be standing here without these amazing supporters who have supported me and my team financially and more importantly, emotionally for almost four years.
Jesse Watters (1:22)
And the second thing I want to.
Emily Campagno (1:24)
Say is no one has fought harder for justice for John o' Keefe than I have.
Brian Yanes (1:33)
Outside of court, hundreds of Reid supporters cheered when they heard the verdict, chanting, karen Reed is freed. Loud enough you can hear it in the courtroom. Reid was accused of hitting her Boston police officer boyfriend, John o' Keefe, with her car and leaving him in the snow to die in January of 2022. Her defense said the collision never happened and she was framed by police. Now, for the family of, of John o' Keefe, they filed a wrongful death civil lawsuit last year. And in a statement, witnesses who testified on behalf of the prosecution called this a, quote, devastating miscarriage of justice. Jesse, Brian, thank you.
Jesse Watters (2:09)
Let's get some quick reaction from Emily on the Karen Reed verdict.
Greg Gutfeld (2:13)
All right, guys, this was a textbook illustration of how to nail it the second time around. So essentially, defense came in swinging because it was a second trial, right? Like, here's what they did. They targeted reasonable doubt through all of that missing text messages, all of the digital evidence that was missing. They came in and said, look, we are turning the spoliation of evidence into something not right here. And that's the thing. The jurors didn't need to believe that there was this big orchestrated effort or event. They just needed to believe that something wasn't right with all of those law enforcement officers that were concealing texts, missing texts, destroying text, per the defense. Right. And they used reverse narrative to their benefit. So they painted the defendant saying, she's the patsy, she's the one that's getting framed, her right victim over and over again. John o' Keefe be damned, essentially. And then they repeated undermining the chain of custody and the scene integrity. Why was his body moved? Look, this is asking so many questions that they didn't have answers to. And they didn't present them as just sloppy mistakes. They presented them as a sort of intentional concealment of evidence. And then finally, they weaponized the arrogance that they framed for. For all of those protesters that you saw that raised a million dollars on her behalf that hung on every word of the documentary that traveled by states to watch this, right? They said, look at this. These guys think they're pulling one over on all of you. And that's why they nailed it.
