The Girlfriends S3/E5: Is He Dead Yet?

Summary

The Girlfriends: Jailhouse Lawyer - Season 3, Episode 5: "Is He Dead Yet?"

Introduction

In Season 3 of The Girlfriends: Jailhouse Lawyer, host Anna Sinfield delves deeper into the harrowing case of Kelly Harnett, a woman convicted of murder under circumstances that blur the lines between victim and villain. Episode 5, titled "Is He Dead Yet?", released on August 11, 2025, focuses on Kelly's tumultuous trial, examining the night of the murder, the prosecution and defense strategies, and the pivotal courtroom moments that ultimately led to Kelly's conviction.

---

Overview of the Trial

The episode opens with a detailed recounting of Kelly Harnett's trial for the murder of Reuben Angel Vargas. Kelly, who has been incarcerated for over a decade, maintains her innocence, asserting that she was a victim of domestic violence. The trial is marked by intense legal battles, emotional testimonies, and strategic maneuvers from both the prosecution and defense teams.

Key Moments and Testimonies

1. Tommy Donovan's Confession (00:03:48 - 00:05:29)

   • Courtroom Exchange: Tommy Donovan, Kelly’s co-defendant, initially admits to participating in the murder of Angel Vargas. He states, “By your plea of guilty, you admit that on or about July 7, 2010, here in Queens, you acting in concert with another person caused the death of Reuben Angel Vargas by beating and choking him.” (00:03:48)
   • Kelly's Involvement: Kelly confesses to acting in concert with Tommy, saying, “My girlfriend, Kelly Harnett.” (00:03:57)
   • Tommy's Retraction (00:04:25 - 00:05:29): In a dramatic turn, Tommy sends a letter to Kelly’s lawyer, David Epstein, retracting his earlier confession. He states, “I murdered Angel Vargas by strangulation. I committed this murder in full presence of Kelly, though at no time was there any collusion between her and I.” (00:04:25)

2. Courtroom Standoff (00:06:15 - 00:08:43)

   • Judge Lasak's Reputation: Known among inmates as "Mr. Murder" for his relentless sentencing, Judge Lasak oversees Kelly's pretrial hearings. Kelly, frustrated with her attorney’s reluctance to use Tommy's confession, demands to present the letter as evidence.
   • Hearsay Issue: Kelly implores the court, “I am in possession of an exculpatory letter from Mr. Donovan stating that Mr. Donovan acted alone...” (00:07:28). The judge dismisses her request, citing hearsay, leaving the original testimony against her intact. She exclaims in disbelief, “Like, what the hell is everybody listening to?” (00:08:08).

3. Prosecution's Case and Armando Perez's Testimony (00:21:18 - 00:37:26)

   • Introduction of Armando Perez: Armando serves as the prosecution's key eyewitness, claiming to have witnessed Kelly and Tommy murder Angel Vargas. Anna recounts his detailed testimony, where Armando describes seeing Kelly hand over a shoelace used in the choking assault. He notes, “I saw Kelly kick Angel from the stomach to the chest while he was face down.” (00:21:18)
   • Defense Challenges: Kelly’s lawyer, David Epstein, systematically dismantles Armando’s credibility. He highlights inconsistencies in Armando’s statements, such as his fluctuating estimates of his distance from the crime scene and his struggles with English comprehension. For instance, Armando claims to be both 8 feet and 20 feet away from the altercation, leading Epstein to question the reliability of his observations. (00:29:36)
   • Critical Moments: During cross-examination, Armando fails to identify Kelly in court, stating, “She’s not here.” (00:32:18). This moment raises significant doubts about his testimony, suggesting possible flaws in the prosecution's case.

4. Reuben Angel Vargas: The Victim’s Perspective (00:37:26 - 00:41:19)

   • Personal Impact Statements: Anna introduces the audience to Reuben Angel Vargas through his sister Olga’s heartfelt victim impact statement. Olga describes Reuben as “a good son, an excellent brother, and a warm uncle,” emphasizing the profound loss his family feels. (00:37:26)
   • Angel’s Background: It is revealed that Angel struggled with alcoholism and had an AA chip, adding layers to his personal struggles and the context of the night he was killed. Kelly alleges that Angel had sexually assaulted her that same night, complicating the narrative of victimhood versus villainy.

5. Jury Deliberation and Verdict (00:42:04 - 00:44:26)

   • Tense Waiting Period: As the jury deliberates, Anna conveys the palpable tension experienced by Kelly, who anxiously awaits the jury’s decision. Kelly reflects, “I was found guilty... I'll never forget that sight of seeing Ronnie in tears.” (00:43:23)
   • Unanimous Verdict: The jury returns with a guilty verdict, solidifying Kelly’s conviction. Kelly’s defiant response to the prosecutor, Sean Clark, underscores her determination to fight the injustice she perceives. (00:42:04 - 00:43:49)

Legal and Emotional Implications

The episode meticulously explores the legal intricacies of Kelly’s case, highlighting potential miscarriages of justice. Kelly's transformation from a victim of domestic abuse to a convicted murderer raises critical questions about the legal system's ability to discern true culpability. The defense's failure to effectively counter the prosecution’s narrative, coupled with questionable witness testimony, paints a troubling picture of bias and systemic failure.

Notable Quotes

• Kelly Harnett: “I am in possession of an exculpatory letter from Mr. Donovan stating that Mr. Donovan acted alone...” (07:28)
• Tommy Donovan: “I murdered Angel Vargas by strangulation. I committed this murder in full presence of Kelly...” (04:25)
• Olga Vargas: “He was a good son. He was an excellent brother. He was a warm uncle and a very great friend.” (37:26)
• Judge Lasak: “Your Honor, hearsay is not admissible...” (08:12)
• Ryan Reynolds (narrator): “It's the kind of thing that gets a case thrown out, charges dismissed. Except we already know that's not how it goes down for Kelly.” (05:29)

Conclusion and Future Outlook

As the episode concludes, Kelly Harnett’s conviction marks a pivotal moment in her fight for justice. Despite overwhelming odds and a seemingly biased legal process, Kelly remains resolute, vowing to continue her battle against the system that condemned her. The episode sets the stage for future installments, where Kelly is expected to wage a "17-month war of attrition" against the forces aligned against her, including the formidable prosecutor Sean Clark and the inflexible Judge Lasak.

The Girlfriends: Jailhouse Lawyer continues to shed light on the complexities of the justice system, the resilience of its protagonists, and the blurred lines between victimhood and villainy. This episode not only portrays the struggles of one woman fighting for her innocence but also underscores the broader issues of domestic violence and legal advocacy within the prison system.

Final Thoughts

Anna Sinfield masterfully combines courtroom drama, personal testimonies, and legal analysis to provide a comprehensive look into Kelly Harnett's case. By focusing on the human elements behind the legal battle, the podcast offers listeners a nuanced perspective on justice, redemption, and the fight to reclaim one’s narrative in the face of overwhelming adversity.

---

Resources and Support

Listeners affected by the themes discussed in this episode are encouraged to reach out to NO MORE, a domestic violence charity partnered with the podcast, offering resources and support for abuse victims.

---

Produced by Novel for iHeart Podcasts.

Transcript

[Host]

This is an iHeart podcast.

[Sports Announcer]

Ice Cube's Big Three is the surprise hit of the summer. This Saturday, 4pm Eastern on CBS with playoff elimination on the line. The most physical, fiercest and competitive basketball in the world. Miami's Michael Beasley and Lance Stevenson must win to make the playoffs and breakout star Dwight Howard of the LA Riot will battle Gary Payton's Boston squad in a do or die match for both teams. Six teams are allowed for four spots and all must win. There's no crying in the big three, and the no holds barred action starts Saturday at 4pm Eastern, 1pm Pacific.

[Gatorade Advertiser]

Presented by iHeart Gatorade Zero the number one proven electrolyte blend made with zero sugar, designed to hydrate better than water so you can lose more sweat and push more limits. Gatorade 0 is it in you?

[Ryan Reynolds]

Hey, it's Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now I was looking for fun ways to tell you that Mint's offer of unlimited Premium Wireless for $15 a month is back. So I thought it would be fun.

[Gatorade Advertiser]

If we made $15 bills, but it.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Turn that's very illegal. So there goes my big idea for the commercial. Give it a [e-mail] Switch upfront payment.

[Danielle Fishel]

Of 45 for 3 month plan equivalent to 15 per month required new customer offer for first 3 months only.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Speed slow after 35 gigabytes of networks.

[Danielle Fishel]

Busy taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com this is Danielle Fishel from Pod Meets World. Parents, quick question. When is the last time you won snack time? The other day I handed my son a perfectly portioned Pinterest level snack and he traded it for a Mott's Applesauce pouch. I'm not mad, just impressed. And that's why Mott's no Sugar added Applesauce pouches are perfect to keep on hand. They're made with real apples packed in a super easy pouch. Perfect for tossing in a lunchbox, keeping in the car, or grabbing as you're running out the door. Plus, they're a good source of vitamin C and kids love them. Win win. Make sure your kid wins snack time with Motts. Real apples make real good applesauce.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Learn [e-mail] hey girlfriends, it's me, Anna, here to let you know what's coming up. This episode covers Kelly's trial, so as you'd expect, we'll be speaking about the night of the murder in great detail. But we also dive deeper into the case for the prosecution and the defence, and at the end you can make up your own mind about whether the right verdict was reached. If you feel impacted by some of the themes in this show, you can reach out to know more. They're a domestic violence charity with a lot of great resources to help you or your loved ones. You can search knowmore.org and we've also put a link to their website in the episode description. Oh, and by the way, there's going to be some swear words. When Tommy Donovan is first arrested back In July of 2010, he immediately tries to shift the majority of the blame for Angel Vargas death onto Kelly, saying that he choked angel to the point of unconsciousness, but implying that it was Kelly who really killed him. He then takes a deal where in return for giving evidence against Kelly, his charge is reduced to manslaughter. Here's an exchange from Tommy's sentencing that I found in the court records. I'll be playing the role of the court official while my producer, Jake, will voice Tommy. By your plea of guilty, you admit that on or about July 7, 2010, here in Queens, you acting in concert with another person caused the death of Reuben Angel Vargas by beating and choking him.

[Kelly Harnett]

Yes.

[Ryan Reynolds]

The person you were acting in concert with, who was that person?

[Kelly Harnett]

My girlfriend.

[Ryan Reynolds]

What's her name?

[Kelly Harnett]

Kelly Harnett.

[Ryan Reynolds]

And the evidence shows both of you were involved in the choking that led to Mr. Vargas dying.

[Kelly Harnett]

Yes, sir.

[Ryan Reynolds]

And that's the story Tommy sticks to until 2013.

[Host]

Dear Mr. Epstein, as you're already acquainted with me, I will get to the point.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly's reading from a letter sent by Tommy Donovan to her lawyer, David Epstein.

[Host]

On the night of July 7, 2010, I murdered Angel Vargas by strangulation. I committed this murder in full presence of Kelly, though at no time was there any collusion between her and I. Though my initial written confession differs from this account, at the time, I was exhausted in opiate withdrawal and angry with Kelly. I don't know why. Perhaps I was jealous of her going free without me and concocted a version of events. I do not regret much in life, but I do regret dragging Kelly into this. I am here to tell you, and if necessary, the court, that I myself intentionally caused the death of decedent Vargas.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Holy shit. This has got to be as close to a get out of jail free card as you can get, right? The kind of thing that gets a case thrown out, charges dismissed. Except we already know that's not how it goes down for Kelly. It's June 2013. Kelly's in a pretrial hearing. This is where the defense and prosecution can discuss Any issues or questions surrounding the upcoming trial. What charges the prosecution will move forward with, what evidence will or won't be allowed in front of the jury, that kind of thing. Presiding over everything is the honorable Judge Lasak. But that's not what Kelly and some of her fellow inmates know him as.

[Host]

They call Judge Lasak Mr.

[Anna Sinfield]

Murder.

[Host]

They call him Mr. Murder for two reasons. He tries only murder cases, and he puts everyone away. So, in essence, he murders them.

[Ryan Reynolds]

All the while Kelly's been in court, listening to the lawyer and the prosecutor go back and forth, she's been chomping at the bit for her chance to chip in and ask.

[Host]

Your Honor, can I have permission to address the court, please?

[Ryan Reynolds]

Now, defendants don't normally address the court unless asked a question. But Kelly is not like other defendants.

[Host]

Judge Lasak says, talk to your lawyer. I said, you, Honor, it's actually about my lawyer.

[Ryan Reynolds]

To say Kelly's keen for the jury to hear Tommy's new confession is a colossal understatement. But her lawyer, David Epstein. Well, as far as Kelly's concerned, that's another story.

[Host]

He just.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly says he doesn't want to bring up the letter at all. So now here she is, taking matters into her own hands. The judge nods at her to say her piece.

[Host]

Your Honor, I am in possession of an exculpatory letter from Mr. Donovan stating that Mr. Donovan acted alone, and I, in fact, took no part in this whatsoever.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly wants to call Tommy as a witness so he can tell his new story from the doc without calling Mr.

[Host]

Donovan to my trial. This is violating my right to a fair trial.

[Ryan Reynolds]

The judge looks down at Kelly, poker face revealing nothing. He ponders for a few moments while Kelly crosses her fingers, hoping she's done enough to convince him. After an excruciating pause, the judge leans.

[Host]

Forward, and he's like, Ms. Harnett, I don't know who you're talking to in the jailhouse, but hearsay is not admissible. And I was like, what the hell is he talking about? Hearsay.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Hearsay, in a legal sense, means telling the court what someone else told you, either in person or in this case, by letter. It's not allowed. You can only talk about what you know, did, or experienced firsthand.

[Host]

That letter, or whatever it is you have, is hearsay. Let me start again. Your Honor, at no point in time did I request the letter to be submitted into evidence. I am stating that I am in possession of an exculpatory letter from. Which is leading to my request to have him called to testify on my behalf at my trial. However, Mr. Epstein is refusing to call him. Then Mr. Epstein, my attorney sides with the judge and says she seems to think hearsay is admissible. After what I just said. Like, what the hell is everybody listening to?

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly can't understand why her own lawyer wouldn't be fighting tooth and nail to bring Tommy in unless he's working against her deliberately.

[Host]

I don't know what to think. But when you have something as earth shattering as, hi, I'm the killer, your client is innocent, and you don't use it, you have to assess it and attest to the fact that he might have thrown this case. I don't know. How far does the rabbit hole go?

[Ryan Reynolds]

I have to say, I've not seen any evidence presented in court or otherwise that Kelly's lawyer was trying to lose the case on purpose. And unfortunately, I'll never get the chance to ask him because he died in 2017. But I can see it from Kelly's perspective. She's handing her lawyer what she thinks is a smoking gun, and he doesn't seem to want to know. With even her own lawyer seemingly against her, it doesn't take very long for Judge Lasag to shut down Kelly's request about the letter. So for now, Tommy's original statements stand. The ones that say Kelly was a willing participant in the murder.

[Host]

It was awful. And the trial, I feel that I lost it before it began.

[Ryan Reynolds]

I'm Anna Sinfield, and from the teams at Novel and I Heart podcast, this is the Girlfriends jailhouse Lawyer.

[Host]

Yes, I love me.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Got you. Episode 5 Is he dead yet? It's September 4, 2013, the first day of Kelly Harnett's trial for the murder of Reuben Angel Vargas. Like a lot of trials, this one will turn out to be pretty long and more than a little messy. Before things even really get going, one of the original 12 jurors has to be let go, which then leads to a mistrial and the selection of a brand new jury. So the whole thing has to start all over again. Eventually, things do get moving, and everyone's ready to play their part. Taking on the role of prosecutor is Assistant District Attorney Sean Clark. And the first thing you should know about Sean is he's kind of a dreamboat.

[Host]

When Superman is Clark Kent, he has dark hair, handsome with glasses. Right? That's exactly what Shawn looks like.

[Ryan Reynolds]

But unfortunately for Kelly, Sean isn't here to rescue her. He's here to send her down. And he is very, very good at his job. Kelly is facing two charges. The most serious is murder in the second degree, which essentially means murder that wasn't premeditated. The other charge is criminal possession of a weapon. In this case, that means the shoelace. Kelly actually had more charges before the trial began. Another murder charge and three more for robbery, but they were all dismissed. Despite this, Sean Clark leans into the robbery angle in his story of the crime. It's the primary motive.

[Kelly Harnett]

Cool.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Okay. Should we do this?

[Kelly Harnett]

Yeah. Yeah, let's do it.

[Ryan Reynolds]

I looked in my producer Jake again. This time to be the voice of Superman, AKA Shawn Clark. This next section is taken directly from official court transcripts.

[Kelly Harnett]

What does make sense? The likely reason why they got into an altercation with Mr. Vargas was to rob him. That's the likely explanation here. Did I pull that out of the air? No, I pulled that out of the evidence.

[Ryan Reynolds]

In at least one of Tommy Donovan's statements, the oral one typed up by police, it says that Kelly robbed Angel's wallet after the murder. Tommy says he then took the cash out before throwing the wallet on the ground. From police documents, we know that Angel Vargas wallet was found roughly near his body.

[Kelly Harnett]

In that wallet, identification, credit cards, two Citibank cards, but no money. What's on Tommy Donovan when the police stop him in his sock is $60, three $20 bills. That's the likely motive for what happened.

[Ryan Reynolds]

One of the wildest parts of Tommy's multiple statements is that he says Kelly didn't just hand over the shoelace. She actually physically put it around Angel's neck and pulled it before handing it over to Tommy. Tommy then claims that after the attack, he walked away and looked back to see Kelly on top of angel, choking him again with the string. But Sean Clark and the prosecution, they're only going as far as to argue that Kelly kicked Angel and then handed over the shoelace. Which is interesting, because if you're trying to convict someone for murder, surely you'd want to tell a story that makes them seem as culpable as possible. Kelly, of course, argues that Tommy took the shoelace from her foot. And when Tommy himself pulled it around Angel's neck, it snapped.

[Host]

It snapped so fast. And I remember thinking about that. When I saw it snap, I got scared. I said, he's going to come back over to me.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Now, there is physical evidence to support this. A broken white shoelace was found near the crime scene. Kelly then says that Tommy finished strangling angel with his belt. A theory that she says is also partially supported by physical evidence.

[Host]

When you read the doctor's testimony, it clearly states that there was an indentation in the form of a rectangle that was unidentified right there.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly's pointing to her neck.

[Host]

I said I could identify it. It's a belt buckle. So if you take away the allegation of handing a shoelace and put in the fact that he used his belt, the entire charge does not meet any element of the crime for me.

[Ryan Reynolds]

In addition to Kelly's lawyer, David Epstein, not fighting to call Tommy as a witness, Kelly says he also doesn't want her taking the stand in her own defense. This honestly isn't all that unusual. A lot of attorneys don't want to risk putting their client on the stand. If they get up there and get flustered or say the wrong thing, that's blood in the water for the prosecution. But Kelly's worried they're missing an opportunity to make the jury really see what she went through as a victim of Tommy's abuse, something only she can truly explain.

[Host]

If you don't paint a picture as to that, I was scared. They need to hear more of it, like maybe they needed to hear from me, and my attorney told me, don't testify.

[Ryan Reynolds]

So if Epstein doesn't want the courts to hear from Kelly or Tommy, what is his case about? Here's one angle he took. Research shows that you can feel the effects of Booze at about 0.02% blood alcohol level. On the night of the murder, Angel's bloods came out at 0.36. His liver was also found to be enlarged and fatty, which is something commonly associated with chronic alcoholism. In the trial, it's argued that Angel's drunken state could have led to the bruising found on his body by falling off his bike, for example. But still, it seems like there's no mention of Kelly's experience as a victim of domestic violence or really any context from her complicated life. The prosecution has painted this really vivid picture of Kelly as a villain, but the defence doesn't really present an alternative story. In fact, if you ask Kelly, she says Epstein's approach basically amounts to Kelly's not guilty. And that's it.

[Host]

I think it was more of a selfish reason than anything, because I think that he knew he was unprepared and I think that he wanted to just play it safe.

[Ryan Reynolds]

But playing it safe is not going to cut it here, because the prosecution is about to unleash the biggest tool in their arsenal. There's a witness who says he saw the whole thing and the story he's got to tell looks really, really bad for Kelly.

[Sports Announcer]

The reviews and ratings are in and Ice Cube's Big Three is the surprise hit of the summer. This Saturday, 4pm EAS Houston on CBS with playoff elimination on the line, the Stars will be flocking to Los Angeles to witness the most physical, fiercest and competitive basketball in the world. Miami's Michael Beasley and Lance Stevenson must win over Houston to make the playoffs, reeling from last week's savage beating at the hands of Chicago's possessed Montrez Harrell. Last time these teams met, Miami beat Houston, but they are a dangerous team having their manhood at stake. Then breakout star Dwight Howard of the LA Riot will battle Gary Payton's Boston squad in a do or die match for both teams. Will LA avenge their previous shocking loss to perennial basketball Boston rivals? To survive, six teams are allowed for four spots and all must win. Don't miss the Big Three, the three on three basketball league everyone is talking about. There's no crying in the Big Three and the no hold spot action starts Saturday at 4pm Eastern, 1pm Pacific, followed by two games on Vice starting at 6:30 Eastern.

[Anna Sinfield]

Presented by iHeartrade Tired of spills and stains on your sofa? WashablesOfAs.com has your back featuring the Annabe Collection, the only designer sofa that's machine washable inside and out. Where designer quality meets budget friendly prices. That's right, sofas start at just $699. Enjoy a no risk experience with pet friendly stain resistant and changeable slipcovers made with performance fabrics. Experience cloud like comfort with high resilience foam that's hypoallergenic and never needs fluffing. The sturdy steel frame ensures longevity and the modular pieces can be rearranged anytime. Check out washablesofas.com and get up to 60% off your Anna Bay sofa backed by a 30 day satisfaction guarantee. If you're not absolutely in love, send it back for a full refund. No return shipping or restocking fees. Every penny back. Upgrade [e-mail] Offers are subject to change and certain restrictions may apply.

[Gatorade Advertiser]

Gatorade Zero the number one proven electrolyte blend made with zero sugar, designed to hydrate better than water so you can lose more sweat and push more limits. Gatorade 0 is it in you.

[LifeLock Advertiser]

You're great at protecting your own personal information. You probably even use things like two factor authentication, strong passwords and a vpn. But as much as you try to be in control of how your information is protected, there are lots of places that also have it and they might not be as careful as you are. That's why LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second for identity threats. If your identity is stolen, a LifeLock US based restoration specialist will help solve identity theft issues on your behalf, guaranteed or your money back. Plus, all LifeLock plans are backed by the million dollar protection package, meaning LifeLock will reimburse you up to the limits of your plan. If you lose money due to identity theft. You might not be able to control how others handle your personal information, but you can help protect it with LifeLock. Save up to 40% your first year. Call 1-800-LIFELOCK and use promo code IHEART or go to lifelock.com iheart for 40% off terms. Apply.

[Ryan Reynolds]

One late night in July 2010, Amando Perez is out jogging. It's about 2am on a balmy summer's night. The sky up above is black. The lights of Manhattan are flickering off in the distance. Armando is out late because he's training for his football team, or soccer if you must. He's weaving through Astoria park on his second lap when he says he hears something that brings him to a stop. Someone's screaming. Armando ducks and hides behind a tree. He says he peers out into the darkness, looking for where the scream came from. His eyes land on a shadowy figure. He's got a man in a chokehold on the ground. The figure shouts at a woman standing nearby to kick the man he's holding down, which she does. It's Tommy, Kelly and Angel. Armando says. He hears Tommy ask Kelly to find a shoelace. He watches as Kelly walks off, kicking up bags and a bicycle before returning with something and handing it to Tommy. At this point, it dawns on him he's watching a murder. Armando sprints off to get help. Over the next hour, he runs into several people. Firstly, he tells some cops in a nearby patrol car, but he says they just drive off. Next, he tries flagging down some teenagers, but they just laugh at him. In between these unsuccessful attempts to raise the alarm, Armando keeps heading back to near where Tommy and Kelly are. He doesn't want to lose track of them. He says he hears Kelly ask, is he dead yet? Tommy replies that angel is dead. He's touched a body to be certain. Then Armando sees him and Kelly hiding things in the wood chips on the ground. Armando keeps leaving, trying to find help. Eventually, he comes across a group of four teenagers and one of them calls the police. Once the police arrive, Amanda walks them over to near where Angel's body is. The police point out Tommy and Kelly and ask Amanda if he's sure it was them. Amanda replies, of course I'm sure. I've been watching them for over an hour. Then Kelly and Tommy are taken away. Armando is the key witness, essentially the core of the prosecution's case against Kelly. With Tommy's statements, any defence lawyer worth their salt can argue he has a clear motivation to try and shift the blame onto Kelly. But Armando, well, he has no obvious reason to lie. Prosecutor Sean Clark described him as a completely independent eyewitness who doesn't know Kelly Harnett, has never met Kelly. Harnett has no reason to come in here and say negative things about Kelly Harnett. Armando is a neutral party who can testify that he saw Kelly hand over the shoelace. He doesn't actually ever mention anything about seeing Kelly strangle Angel, which is probably why the prosecution have decided to ignore that part of Tommy's statement. But crucially, Armando also says that he saw Kelly kick Angel. In his earlier police statements, he doesn't specify where on the body angel was kicked. But by the time Kelly's trial rolls around, Armando says it was, quote, from the stomach to the chest. He also says that angel was lying face down, which is something Kelly takes issue with.

[Host]

The person was face down. That's an impossibility.

[Ryan Reynolds]

He.

[Host]

You cannot kick someone from the stomach to the chest if they are face down.

[Ryan Reynolds]

I interpret this a little bit differently. To Kelly, Armando could just be describing general areas of the body. I think I'd say the same thing even if someone was being kicked from the side on, but I'm no lawyer. Instead, it's up to Kelly's defense attorney, David Epstein, to cross examine the hell out of this witness, to keep poking holes in Armando's story until it's left in tatters on the courtroom floor. So come on, David, dig deep. It's time to strike.

[Host]

As soon as David Epstein stood up, he dropped all the paperwork everywhere. I said, oh, Jesus Christ. If this is foreshadowing, I'm screwed.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Armando's testimony makes for a compelling story, but especially according to Kelly, there are some holes in it if you look hard enough. And planted in those holes are some striking red flags. The first has to do with language barriers. Kelly claims that Armando can't really speak English, and police documents do show that his statement was transcribed for him by a cop. I've looked at this written statement and there are phrases in it like where the scene was, which honestly does sound like something a cop would say. I think we have to interrogate how much Armando understood his own statement or how his words could have been interpreted into helpful shorthand by the police. And obviously, if Armando can't fully understand English, it does call into question whether he could fully understand the things he claims he heard Tommy and Kelly say. Another issue is that Armando really struggles with judging distances. He claims at one point in the trial that he was maybe 8ft away from Tommy, Kelly and Angel. Then at another point, he says he was about 20ft away. To me, both of these options seem like they would bring him way too physically close to Tommy and Kelly without being noticed, so I can't see how either could possibly be true. Then, in the courtroom, he's asked to judge a distance of about 3ft, but he's not able to. And when Armando is asked to mark everyone's locations on the night of the murder on a map, Kelly spots more issues.

[Host]

He tells the witness to put an X where the body was, an F where the female was, and an M where the male was. Then he said, put an AP Armando Perez for his initials. Now this. I just want to let everyone know those initials are taken on a bridge that you cannot even get up on. There's no way in God's green earth that he was standing there.

[Ryan Reynolds]

But there appears to be some confusion, and at some point, Armando seems to claim that the X actually marks where he was standing. And this confusion about who was where, it doesn't end here. Later in the trial, the prosecution alludes to the fact that Kelly and Tommy moved angel's body around 80ft away from the actual scene of the murder. Prosecutor Sean Clark tries to make sense of it by saying that because the murder happened near a lit path, Angel's body could have been discovered.

[Kelly Harnett]

He then says, if you drag him into the middle of the park, you drag him in the middle where there's no lights, he's not going to be found until morning.

[Ryan Reynolds]

But here's the thing. Armando never explicitly said he saw Angel's body being dragged. None of his police statements reference the body being moved at all. The police themselves also deny moving the body when questioned on this, too. This whole thing with the body being moved seems to be a tactic the prosecution lands on in order to explain away Armando's confusion over who and what was where. The prosecution claims that all the dirt and grass on Angel's face and clothes show his body was dragged. But I don't buy that. Those could easily have come from angel trying to fight off Tommy while they were wrestling on the ground. The theory that the body was moved also goes against physical evidence. A shoelace was found right by Angel's body. If he'd been moved 80ft after he was killed, wouldn't the shoelace that the prosecution claimed was used to kill him be much further away? But next up is the biggest and reddest flag of them all. At one point in the trial, the prosecution decides to secure an easy win using a tried and tested tactic. While Armando is on the stand, they ask him to point out the girl he saw kicking Angel Vargas, the girl he claims willingly handed over her shoelace moments before angel was strangled to death. Armando scans the courtroom and then he.

[Host]

Says, she's not here.

[Ryan Reynolds]

What the fuck?

[Sports Announcer]

The reviews and ratings are in and Ice Cube's Big Three is the surprise hit of the summer. This Saturday, 4pm Eastern on CBS, with playoff elimination on the line, the stars will be flocking to Los Angeles to witness the most physical, fiercest and competitive basketball in the world. Miami's Michael Beasley and Lance Stevenson must win over Houston to make the playoffs, reeling from last week's savage beating at the hands of Chicago's possessed Montrez Harold. Last time these teams met, Miami beat Houston, but they are a dangerous team having their manhood at stake. Then breakout star Dwight Howard of the LA Riot will battle Gary Payton's Boston squad in a do or die match for both teams. Will LA avenge their previous shocking loss to perennial basketball Boston rivals? To survive, six teams are allowed for four spots and all must win. Don't miss the big three, the 3 on 3 basketball league. Everyone is talking, there's no crying in the big three and the no hold spot action starts Saturday at 4pm Eastern, 1pm Pacific followed by two games on Vice starting at 6:30 Eastern. Presented by iHeart.

[Anna Sinfield]

Time for a sofa upgrade. Visit washablesofas.com and discover Annabe where designer style meets budget friendly prices with sofas starting at $699. Annabe brings you the ultimate in furniture innovation with a modular design that allows you to rearrange your space effortlessly. Perfect for both small and large spaces, Anime is the only machine washable sofa inside and out. Say goodbye to stains and messes with liquid and stain resistant fabrics that make cleaning easy. Liquid simply slides right off. Designed for custom comfort, our high resilience foam lets you choose between a sink in feel or a supportive memory foam blend. Plus our pet friendly stain resistant fabrics ensure your soft sofa stays beautiful for years. Don't compromise quality for price. Visit washablesofas.com to upgrade your living space today with no risk returns and a 30 day money back guarantee. Get up to 60% off plus free shipping and free returns. Shop now at washablesofas.com Offers are subject to change and certain restrictions may apply.

[Gatorade Advertiser]

Gatorade zero the number one proven electrolyte blend made with zero sugar, designed to hydrate better than water water so you can lose more sweat and push more limits. Gatorade 0 is it in you?

[LifeLock Advertiser]

You're great at protecting your own personal information. You probably even use things like two factor authentication, strong passwords and a vpn. But as much as you try to be in control of how your information is protected, there are lots of places that also have it and they might not be as careful as you are. That's why LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second for identity threats. If your identity is stolen, a LifeLock US based restoration specialist will help solve identity theft issues on your behalf, guaranteed or your money back. Plus, all LifeLock plans are backed by the million dollar protection package, meaning LifeLock will reimburse you up to the limits of your plan if you lose money due to identity theft. You might not be able to control how others handle your personal information, but you can help protect it with LifeLock, save up to 40% your first year. Call 1-800-LIFELOCK and use promo code IHEART or go to lifelock.com iheart for 40% off. Terms apply.

[Ryan Reynolds]

After Armando's frankly unbelievable answer to the seemingly easy question of Is the woman you're testifying against here? The court goes into recess. When everyone comes back into the courtroom, the prosecution try to ask Armando again, but it still doesn't go great. He says, I'm not sure because it's been three years. Some star witness. For the record, I find the fact that this happened incredible, like a finale scene out of the Good Wife or something. Armando doesn't even attempt an educator guess. Kelly is literally standing a few feet away from him at this point. Of course, we do know that Kelly was in the park that night. That's not up for debate, even by her. Maybe Amanda was just too far away to recognize her in court, especially all these years later. But if he was so far away to the point that he's unable to identify Kelly when she's right there in front of him, doesn't Kelly have a point about this guy? How much stock can we put into his testimony about what he could apparently see and hear from really far away in the middle of the night? Given he's the prosecution's star and only witness of the events of the murder, this has got to put A dent in their case. Kelly's lawyer, David Epstein, certainly seems to think so.

[Host]

He did state to me, well, being that the sole eyewitness didn't even point you out, I think that they're the ones that are on the weak side right now.

[Ryan Reynolds]

So I've told you about how things went down in the courtroom, some of what the prosecution argued, and how the defense tried to fight back. But there's another side we should hear from Angel's family. I know that so far in this show, I haven't told you very much about who Reuben Angel Vargas was. I'm also well aware that in many true crime series, too many, the person who actually lost their life becomes something like a background character in their own story. Their voice gets drowned out by everyone else's, including, of course, podcast hosts like me. Part of the reason I haven't told you much is practical. Unfortunately, we just don't know that much about Angel. I tried and I failed to track down his family. So I've pieced together snippets from articles and court documents, trying to patchwork together an impression of who this man was. We know that angel was likely an alcoholic, both from the evidence provided by the medical expert and also from Kelly, who says angel had an AA chip on him. We also know that Kelly claimed Angel sexually assaulted her on the night of the murder, which is objectively a horrific thing to do. But as Kelly has said herself, angel didn't deserve to die that night. I think it's only fair to take a moment to get to know him, to remember that he was someone's son, someone's uncle, and someone's brother. So I'd like to read you a section from his sister's victim impact statement. My name is Olga Vargas and the sister of Reuben Vargas. In a few words, I'm going to tell you what he was like in person. He was a good son. He was an excellent brother. He was a warm uncle and a very great friend. He worked with everybody. He helped everybody. We were a great big family. The last day that we were together was on July 4th. We laughed, we played. Nothing changed until July 7th, where we were given the sad news that had been unknown to us until that moment. This changed life for all of us, for all those who knew him, especially our family. I feel destroyed. How can they feel, my parents, that it's to lose a son. It's not easy to accept, to know the terrible way in which his life was taken. My brother's life. My brother is another victim who dies unjustly and it's for him and all my family that I ask for justice. For Olga and Angel's family, justice means Tommy and Kelly going behind bars. In another statement, Olga talks about their blows and their actions which caused her brother to suffer the death he did. But for Kelly, justice means something very different. Justice would mean recognising her as another victim of Tommy's violence. For Kelly, justice would mean an acknowledgement that she was scared for her life, too. Justice would mean leaving the courtroom and going back to her mother and her brother Ronnie. The trial draws to a close. Now Kelly's fate is in the hands of 12 strangers. The jury is ushered out to start their deliberation. For Kelly, each minute that passes with no news feels like an hour. And each hour feels like a year.

[Host]

I got scared. I already didn't feel good about any of the trial.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Scenes from her own personal courtroom drama start running through Kelly's head.

[Host]

Ms. Harnett, hearsay is not admissible.

[Kelly Harnett]

They got into an altercation with Mr. Vargas to rob him.

[Host]

My attorney told me, don't testify.

[Kelly Harnett]

You drag him into the middle of the park. He's not going to be found until morning.

[Host]

Amanda Perez, he says, she's not here.

[Kelly Harnett]

Did I pull that out of the air? No, I pulled that out of the evidence.

[Ryan Reynolds]

And then the update everyone has been waiting for comes. The jury has a verdict.

[Host]

The heartbeat that you feel, I've never felt anything even close to that in my life.

[Ryan Reynolds]

As the 12 members of the jury file back into the Queen's courtroom, a hushed silence falls. Kelly holds her breath as Judge Lasak asks for their verdict.

[Host]

They came back with a unanimous decision and the verdict was guilty. I couldn't believe it because I was like, oh, my God, what trial were they watching? Because it was not mine.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly turns around and finds her brother Ronnie's eyes. He's begged her over and over to plead guilty before trial, to take a deal in exchange for a shorter sentence.

[Host]

He was in tears. Oh, my God. I'll never forget. I'll never forget that sight of seeing Ronnie in tears.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Kelly turns her gaze to the prosecutor, Sean Clark.

[Host]

It was a stare down. I was like you, you son of a. You are never, ever going to forget this moment. I am taking you down.

[Ryan Reynolds]

It would have been so easy for Kelly to give up and accept defeat in this moment. But next time on the Girlfriend's Jailhouse Lawyer. Kelly goes to war with Sean Clark, Judge Lazak, and everyone else she sees standing in her way.

[Host]

I was found guilty. I said, what do you want me to do. She goes, oh, guilty schmilty. You won't take your butt to that little library and figure something out. This was the beginning of of a 17 month war of attrition.

[Ryan Reynolds]

You're a very unique person, Kelly.

[Host]

Thank you. I take that as a compliment.

[Ryan Reynolds]

It's a compliment. It is a compliment for sure. The Girlfriend's Jailhouse Lawyer is produced by novel for iHeart podcast. For more from Novel, visit Novel Audio. The show is hosted by me, Anna Sinfield and is written and produced by me and Lee Meyer with additional production from Jake Otajevic and Michael Jino. Our assistant producer is Madeline Parr. The editors are Georgia Moody & Me Anna Sinfield production management from Cherie Houston, Jo Savage and Charlotte Wolf. Our fact checker is Danya Steven, Sue Lehmann Sound design, mixing and scoring by Daniel Kempson and Nicholas Alexander. Music supervision by me, Alice Enfield, Lee Meyer and Nicholas Alexander. Original music composed by Nicholas Alexander, Daniel Kempson and Louisa Gerstein. Story development by Nell Gray Andrews and Willard Foxton. Creative director of Novel. Max o' Brien and Craig Strachan are our executive producers for for Novel and Katrina Norvell and Nikki Etor are the executive producers for iHeart podcasts and the marketing lead is Alison Cantor. Thanks also to Carrie Lieberman and the whole team at WME.

[Sports Announcer]

Ice Cube's Big Three is the surprise hit of the summer. This Saturday, 4pm Eastern on CBS with playoff elimination on the line. The most physical, fiercest and competitive basketball in the world. Miami's Michael Beasley and Lance Stevenson must win to make the playoffs and breakout star Dwight Howard of the LA Riot will battle Gary Payton's Boston squad in a do a die match for both teams. Six teams are allowed for four spots and all must there's no crying in the big three and the no holds barred action starts Saturday at 4pm Eastern, 1pm Pacific. Presented by iHeart.

[Gatorade Advertiser]

Gatorade Zero, the number one proven electrolyte blend made with zero sugar, designed to hydrate better than water so you can lose more sweat and push more limits. Gatorade 0 is it in you.

[LifeLock Advertiser]

You're great at protecting your own personal information. You probably even use things like two factor authentication, strong passwords and a vpn. But as much as you try to be in control of how your information is protected, there are lots of places that also have it and they might not be as careful as you are. That's why LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second for identity threats. If your identity is stolen, a LifeLock US based restoration specialist will help solve identity theft issues on your behalf, guaranteed or your money back. Plus all LifeLock plans are backed by the million dollar protection package, meaning LifeLock will reimburse you up to the limits of your plan if you lose money due to identity theft. You might not be able to control how others handle your personal information, but you can help protect it with LifeLock. Save up to 40% your first year. Call 1-800-LIFELOCK and use promo code iheart or go to lifelock.com iheart for 40% off terms. Apply the Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max.

[Sports Announcer]

Bundle plan starting at just 16.99amonth. Catch Limitless Live Better now season one.

[LifeLock Advertiser]

With Chris Hemsworth on Disney Plus.

[Sports Announcer]

We got a lot of work to do. Alien Earth on Hulu this Ship Collected Monsters and Final Destination Bloodlines on HBO Max.

[Host]

Death is coming for our family.

[Sports Announcer]

The Disney Plus Hulu HBO Max bundle.

[Ryan Reynolds]

Plan starting at 16.99amonth.

[LifeLock Advertiser]

All these and more streaming soon. Visit Disney Plus Hulu HBOMaxBundle.com for details.

[Host]

This is an iHeart podcast.