Loading summary
SoFi Advertiser
Foreign
Mike Pesca
It's Friday, May 29, 2026 from Peach Fish Productions. It's the gist. I'm Mike Pesca. Today is a Funny youy Should Mention day and I have a fascinating character for you to meet. Funny too. Janet McNamara has been tested many, many, many times for having autism. She usually falls one or two questions short and we'll get into it all. She is, I think she says explicitly, yes, this is right, spectrumy. When you meet her she wears a vest and when she was a child she wore a life preserver. For many years straight she is always wearing a vest. She has this great insight about how stupid people think she's stupid, but the smart know she's smart and I came away with that opinion. I have to say talking to Janet, whose comedy is great and unexpected but unexpectedly for me, not always why she thinks it's funny though. She's smart enough to know if the audience tells her something is funny then it is funny. But it's just interesting to me to talk to a person who is a self diagnosed and really should be diagnosed person who is neurodivergent, a category that she finds useful just to ask all the questions you ever wanted to ask how it helps your comedy, but because when you ask someone about their comedy you really ask them how they see the world. So to ask a neurodivergent person many, many questions about how they see the world, how they process the world, how they communicate that to others, not under the guise of with the assignment Tell me about your comedy was very interesting. A gift if you will. Very, very special. I enjoyed and got a lot out of this conversation with Janet McNamara, who I hope you will find for your own sake to be quite intelligent and of course funny.
SoFi Advertiser
Does it feel like your student loans are a permanent part of your life? It doesn't have to be that way. With SoFi you can consolidate your student loans and refinance with the shorter term for potentially becoming debt free Sooner. Join over 580,000 members who have already refinanced their student loans with SOFI to take control of their financial future. Getting started is easier than you think. View Your rate@sofi.com Next Today SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank NA member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply in MLS 696891 we all need advice, but it's
Mike Pesca
not always clear who to ask. Even in 2026. Enter how to the longstanding advice show and Ambie Award nominated personal growth podcast that's back with new episodes and A new host. And that host. Here's the reveal. It's me, Mike Pesca. Each week I tackle a listener question ranging from travel to finance to relationships and beyond, with help from world class experts who actually know what they're talking about. Think of it as eavesdropping on someone else's therapy session without the copay or awkward silence. No question is too big or too specific. Some topics, how to protect the elderly from scammers, how to take psychedelics therapeutically, and of course, how to emigrate to the Netherlands as a throuple. You've got questions, we'll find the answers. So follow how to with Mike Pesca on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.
Janet McNamara
I'm an accountant. That's my day job. I'm an accountant. Yeah. That's why I'm just like a. Right now they call it the autism spectrum because Asperger's. Who was a Nazi? Yeah, he was a Nazi. Yeah. Yeah. Do you know that?
SoFi Advertiser
No.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Read a book.
Mike Pesca
Janet McNamara is not smart enough though. She is. She is. That's just the name of her special, which is I don't know if It's Blowing Up. I think it's doing really well. I will tell you, from an artistic standpoint point, it is excellent. This is of course funny you should mention where we talk to comedians about the ideas behind the jokes and Janet's brimming with ideas. Thanks for coming in.
Janet McNamara
Thank you. Thanks for having me.
Mike Pesca
So I know you are an accountant.
Janet McNamara
Yes.
Mike Pesca
Are you a Philo or FIFO fan?
Janet McNamara
I actually, I don't do inventory.
Mike Pesca
Damn.
Janet McNamara
No, I'm a corporate accountant.
Mike Pesca
So you say that when you say you're an accountant. No one wants to talk about it, but I have some accounting questions.
Janet McNamara
You do?
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Okay.
Mike Pesca
Well, I just like the different. I just like, you know the difference between credit and debit. And I just, you know, depending on.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Credit and debit's confusing because the deposit is a debit.
Mike Pesca
Yes. I guess a lot of people know that because in their own bank account it says credit or debit. But it's interesting on a corporate level.
Janet McNamara
On your bank, a credit is a deposit.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
But in accounting, a deposit is a debit.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
So it's, it's just like, it's this mind.
Mike Pesca
And your mind was made for that.
Janet McNamara
No, it took. It took. It took effort.
Mike Pesca
Uh huh. Were you a math person going in?
Janet McNamara
No.
Mike Pesca
No. Wait, so then why'd you go in? Because you were very much not a verbal person.
Janet McNamara
No, I'm Not. I'm not an anything person. I was, like, probably in the bottom. I was really low on the sat. Accounting isn't math. Accounting is. I'm really good at Excel.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
So I'm really good at computer programs, so I can learn a computer program like that.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
And then I just. You know, I started. I was. I was. I started from beginning. From the very bottom, and then I worked up.
Mike Pesca
Yeah, just like that Drake song.
Janet McNamara
Exactly. I kind of started from the beginning. I don't have a. I, like, majored in, like. I majored in, like, human services, which is a major nobody's ever heard of. It's kind of like psychology. And then I went to grad school. I got a business degree, but then I was really bad. Like, I was bad at the accounting classes, so I ended up getting just a generalized business degree.
Mike Pesca
General. From where?
Janet McNamara
Suffolk.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
So my mba and then I kind of just fell into, like, an accounts payable position.
Mike Pesca
You did your MBA before you were even working or while you were working?
Janet McNamara
I was, like, doing bookkeeping for this, like, rent, so my mom's a bookkeeper.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
So my mom. I got burned out of. I was, like, working with kids, and I got burned out after, like, a year or two of doing, like, people shit.
Mike Pesca
It's the people.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. And then. And then my mom got me, like, a bookkeeping position in, like, a small plumbing company. And then I was, like. I was making, like, twice as much money as I was doing the people shit. And then from there, I, like, became, like, a professional temp, and I started temping, doing, like, accounts payable. And then I did some GL work. And then American Idol. I auditioned for American Idol.
Mike Pesca
I know about this because this, now, this, which.
Janet McNamara
That put, like, a whole dent in my whole career.
Mike Pesca
Oh, it did.
Janet McNamara
Oh, yeah.
Mike Pesca
Right now you're going through your second huge brush with fame. And I don't know if you'll ever get to the first one just in terms of, you know, sheer tonnage of initial impression.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. So it, like, it messed up my career in that. Like, I was like.
Mike Pesca
I was working for this, not your comedy career.
Janet McNamara
This was before comedy.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
So I did American Idol before I did comedy. I just did American Idol just because it. I thought it would be fun. Like, it was just, like.
Mike Pesca
It was fun.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. And then it was like, I was working for this company that. It was, like, your temp, but they marketed us like we're CPAs, even though I wasn't a CPA. So it was like, you were hired by the company. And then you had clients.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And basically I told them about American Idol. Like, I took the day off. I auditioned. I told them about American Idol. I told them it was gonna air.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
I don't think they realized that I was gonna be batshit.
Mike Pesca
Well, this is the thing you could have told them, like, oh, I didn't know that she sang, and you kind of don't.
Janet McNamara
I told them. I was like, I need you to be prepared. And. And then I ended up. I was on the commercials.
Mike Pesca
Right. And then my wife, the very first auditionee, the first person to try on the show of season nine, which was the season after Paula left. It's like, everyone's watching.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. People.
Mike Pesca
Here's Janet bouncing off the wall.
Janet McNamara
People don't realize how viral that was because that was when one video was viral. Like, it wasn't like, now where thousands of videos are viral at the same time. Like, yeah, that was the one video that people kept.
Mike Pesca
There was maybe a YouTube, and if they surfaced it. Everyone watched it.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
This was the biggest show in America at a time when it, you know, the biggest show in America meant some.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. So anyway, after the show where they were like, you can't. Like, they freaked out. It, like, went all the way up, and they basically were like, we can't present you to clients.
Mike Pesca
Oh.
Janet McNamara
Like, I was getting. Like, I was on the train. Like, people recognizing me on the train. Like, I walked into the. Like, people were like, it. Like. Because it was the Boston episode, too. And then I, like, lost that job. But then they brought me back on because some of the clients were like, like, jen's in the middle of a project. Like, we kind of need her to finish.
Mike Pesca
Oh, you were actually good at your job.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, they, like, they, like, let me go, and then they brought me back.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
But they brought me back as, like, part time, hourly, like, this, like, bullshit situation.
Mike Pesca
But do you think the temp agency was correct in assessing that it would be a bad reflection on them or were they overly
Janet McNamara
well? So then it took me a long time to get a job because I would walk into a job interview, and they were like, I know, like, you're from American Idol. Because, like, on the American Idol, like an idiot, I told them, like, it says, Janet McMahon, accountant, Somerville. So, like, anybody who's in accounting is like, oh, this is an accountant. So, like.
Mike Pesca
But wasn't the first question they were going to ask you. I hear you're an accountant and you're dyslexic.
Janet McNamara
That was supposed to be the first question. Oh, how do you. I didn't even know you knew that. I knew that that was the first.
Mike Pesca
That that's why Victoria Beckham gave me her notes, is how I know that.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Yeah, Victoria. So, like, the two storylines they were going to do on me was either, like, this is like, she has this, like. Which I did. I had this, like, day job where I wore a suit every day, and I was like, very, boom, to the point. And then I'm this, like, crazy person, which was just kind of a character I did.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
But that was this one storyline. And the story, one line was like, oh, it's so goofy because she's an accountant, but, like, she's dyslexic. And the reason why I get away with being dyslexic is I'm really good at Excel, so I can automate it. I automate everything.
Mike Pesca
But dyslexic can be in an orphan. Are great with numbers.
Janet McNamara
Agreed. Yeah. Like, I can add numbers. Like, I'm this. Like, I'm either really good at things or terrible.
Mike Pesca
Well, there's. There's a lot of research that people with dyslexia and other disorders. I don't want to use the wrong word like that often. So overcompensate. I'm thinking Daredevil, who's blind but is a superhero. No, but, like, there are so many great actors who are dyslexic because they're so good at memorizing lines, they can't read it and memorize it.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, I'm also. I don't. I don't even know if I'm dyslexic, to be honest. That was like another whole. That was like another whole thing where they were like, you're not dyslexic. Like, they ended up going, I thought I was dyslexic my whole life. And then I took, like, a neuro psych, and they're like, you're not dyslexic. And also, we went through all of your records, and it doesn't say anywhere that you're dyslexic. And I was like, my mom's been telling me I was dyslexic. I went to a. I went to a dyslexic school. I went to a school for dyslexic.
Mike Pesca
But they didn't tell you that at the time?
Janet McNamara
No, no.
Mike Pesca
Like, I thought it was a nice, small school.
Janet McNamara
They just kept telling me I was. No, no. I went to this, like, summer school. It was called, like, Landmark Academy. And it's all kids with dyslexia.
SoFi Advertiser
Oh.
Janet McNamara
And you can't even get into the school if you don't have dyslexia. But none of my records say I'm dyslexic.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And then this guy who did the neuropsych was like, yeah, you're not dyslexic. You just have add, so, like, you're not interested in reading, so therefore you can't read.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. I think the entire evaluation apparatus industrial complex has failed you pretty much.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, I've. Yeah. Yeah. But anyways, I couldn't get a job after the American Idol thing, so I was a professional temp for a long time.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Which, like, worked really well for me in the long term, because I did. I worked for all these companies, so I learned, like, 30 different softwares and companies, and I learned how to, like, I learned how to learn really fast.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
Because as a temp, they'll fire you on the second day like that. And it's not even personal.
Mike Pesca
So attempts.
Janet McNamara
Right, Exactly. The point of attempt.
Mike Pesca
Although they got mad at you or someone at your later job got upset with you because you weren't personable enough.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. That's the story of my life.
Mike Pesca
I'm not finding that, by the way.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Thank you. I'm very personable. As long as you don't, like. As long as it's, like, somewhat interesting.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
I'm like. I'm personable. It depends. It's like, if I'm trying to, like, do. If I'm focused on something, I don't want to talk to you.
Mike Pesca
You think people would want workers like that?
Janet McNamara
I grew like. I literally. I was just thinking about this yesterday. There's this lady that I used to work with who would, like, just ramble about being on cruises, like.
Mike Pesca
Oh, I'll stop you. That is a fascinating topic of, like,
Janet McNamara
all the etiquette of, like, how she's, like, she went on a cruise every year. It was just like, the etiquette of, like, cruising and.
Mike Pesca
Not that. Not the fun kind.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. It was like the etiquette of, like, putting, like, taking a pool. It was just like, the etiquette of, like, how she says. And, like, she would just go on about, like, cruising. And there was one point, like, I would, like, just ask her a question, and she would snap at me, like, I was being, like, rude. And I'm like. And my boss even said to me at one point, like, you should ask her about the cruising thing. And I was like, I think I'm allowed to interrupt, like, a Personal conversation. To ask a work question. I don't think that's rude.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. And also you should ask her about the cruising thing. Except you're going to get an earful of that. And how is that good for you or the business?
Janet McNamara
Yeah, yeah, that, too. I also know everything about. I know everything there is to know about cruising because I sit next to her.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Like, there's. I have no. I have no authentic questions to ask her about cruising.
Mike Pesca
Well, I think maybe you are personable, except in this kind of corporate, demanding. How was your weekend? Social niceties? Yeah, I don't really see the point of social nice and cities.
Janet McNamara
I don't.
Mike Pesca
And you might be right.
Janet McNamara
I don't see the point of asking somebody a question I already know the answer to.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
I'm not going to ask you how you are. You're doing great. The traffic sucked. Like, I don't give a fuck.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
So I want to go back to American Idol. What was your conception there of what you were going to do and try to do? So people should know. How would you rate yourself as a singer? As an actual singer?
Janet McNamara
Oh, I'm pretty bad.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
So, yeah, I'm like. It was one of those things that was like, I'm by far. So my entire family, like, we have. My family can't sing. Like, we're just not musical people. And it was one of those things that, like, my friends would always be like, you should audition for American Idol. Because American Idol was like, the show.
Mike Pesca
Oh, yeah.
Janet McNamara
And the bad people were like, the thing.
Mike Pesca
The bad people, they used to make fun of people.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. So people said it for years, and
Mike Pesca
then you were so bad that they said, you know what you should audition for. Yeah. You've, like, reached the point of. Or gone past the point of, I'm not enjoying your singing or you really need to admit this. Like, you're in that special realm of this. That American Idol might reach out and pluck you from that.
Janet McNamara
Oh, they didn't reach out. I auditioned.
Mike Pesca
No, I know. But they might appreciate how bad you are.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, exactly. Like, I was. I was pretty bad, and I wasn't embarrassed about it.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
Like, I thought. I thought it was funny that I was so bad.
Mike Pesca
You get embarrassed about things.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, I get, like, My embarrassment level is so. I have a. My embarrassment level is like, I get embarrassed about the dumbest things. Like, I won't. My hair. Like, I won't make a. I get. If you mentioned that I got a haircut. It's humiliating.
Mike Pesca
Humiliating.
Janet McNamara
It's humiliating.
Mike Pesca
What's it. What goes through your mind? It's an analogous gift to what, like pointing out you got some sort of surgery or.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, I don't even. Yeah, it's not Like, I don't even know what's. So there's something humiliating to me about somebody knowing that I got a haircut. Like, I literally. Like, I. I won't let them cut more than, like. Like, if I'm trying to, like, cut my hair shorter, I'll go three times and have them cut, like, half an inch every time. And that. That was another issue. Like, my boss had mentioned that, like, I was the only person that didn't mention a haircut. And I was like, I would be humiliate. Like, I would be mortified if I cut my hair short. And people like, oh, I can't think of anything. It's mortifying to me.
Mike Pesca
Are you bad at taking compliments in general? I'm terrible, yes. What about. For your comment?
Janet McNamara
It's practiced.
Mike Pesca
Are there some things that you could take a compliment about?
Janet McNamara
I'm better at compliments.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
I used to literally walk away if somebody complimented me. I'd say, thank you and then walk away. And then it became an issue because people would be like, janet's rude. And it's just kind of one of those, like, I. Yeah, it's that thost. And, like, don't try to be better than you are kind of situation.
Mike Pesca
That is true.
Janet McNamara
So I find I practice, like, literally, like, my therapist would. Like, I, like, literally practice back and forth, except in. I'm not good at giving or taking on.
Mike Pesca
What is she open with? What's a good. If I were to be like.
Janet McNamara
She'll say, like, I like your glasses.
Mike Pesca
Okay. Something very benign.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Then you'll have to.
Janet McNamara
And then I have to say, like, thank you. I bought these at Target.
Mike Pesca
Now you're in the middle of a conversation. It's almost as bad as cruises.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. I don't. I bomb every. Like, I bomb. But I just. Like, the big improvement I made is that I'm. I. Most of the time, don't walk away anymore.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
I. Most of the time, we'll just say thank you until it's over. And then. Yeah. Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Now when you do this, do you understand, or is it more like, all right, this is a concession to, quote, unquote, normal interaction, and it's not too painful for me to give into it.
Janet McNamara
I think the compliment thing, it's like, I appreciate compliments. Like, they feel good. I like. Like, I like when people compliment me. It's the. I don't know what to say after part.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
It's the. It's the. Like, I don't want to agree with them because then, like, who do you think you are?
Mike Pesca
Yeah, a lot of people are in that position. I mean, they're very. People are very bad at taking compliment. They deflect.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Just saying thank you usually works.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, that's. That's the only thank you. Thank you. I just say thank you.
Mike Pesca
Thank you right back at you.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
But then if they don't have glasses.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
I assume the contacts are working well.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, it's hard because it's like, a lot of the times it's like, I have nothing to compliment you about.
Mike Pesca
Don't say that. And I would. I, too, would compliment you if anything came to mind.
Janet McNamara
That. That. That. That's the part about, like, the deflection. Like, the, like, thank you. And then you're supposed to compliment them. And I literally can never, like, I. I don't want to talk about somebody's. I don't want to, like, mention somebody's appearance. Like, so I, like, I don't know you. I didn't watch your act. Like, I didn't. Like, I don't. I don't know what to say. Like, yeah, it's like, I don't know what to.
Mike Pesca
What about this. This act? You've been working on it for 15 years. It's the culmination of 15 years worth of comedy. And if someone says, it's great, it's amazing, or just like, oh, yeah, I laughed a lot. Is that different from something about your glasses?
Janet McNamara
Definitely. But I'll just. I do, like, the thank you thing. I've gotten. I have, like, It's. I've improved. Like, anybody who says I'm bad now has no idea where I was a year ago.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
I have improved, but I just do the, like.
Mike Pesca
So I do want to go back. Not because it's the most fascinating or defining thing about you. There were just one or two American Idol questions lingering in the air, which is. So this was a time when they would put on kind of ridiculous people and everyone would have a laugh over it. Do you think they were exploiting those people, you being one of them?
SoFi Advertiser
Do what you want, but you're never gonna break me.
Janet McNamara
Sticks and stones.
Mike Pesca
You're never gonna shake me up. Real life.
Janet McNamara
And this character is going to give you a resounding no after one of them. I. So it's. I was like. I don't know if it was a manic Episode at the time. So it was like I went in. It was a combination. It was three months. So it was like the first audition was like eight hours in the cold. And you. I basically, like, I. I, like, had waited so long that I was like, the only way I'm going to be upset with myself is if I don't go all out. Like, if I don't just belt this song. Like, if I kind of like shy away from it. So I. I just, like, I was just like, the only way I'm going to be disappointed is if I didn't. It's like when you're playing sports and you're like, why didn't I die for that? Like, if you dove and you missed it, you're not upset, right? But if you didn't dive, then you. So it was one of those. And anyways, I belted the song and. And then it's like, everybody wants to talk to you about it. Like, it was like the story that all my friends wanted to talk about. And then it was like I was. I was.
Mike Pesca
Before it got. It was on tv before it was
Janet McNamara
on tv, and I just kept talking about it.
Mike Pesca
That was your social currency for.
Janet McNamara
It was my social currency for like a month or two. And then the audition happened, and the audition was like, I'd, like, been. I didn't know how to like, workshop a joke. Like, this is before comedy, but I kind of. By talking to people. Like, I planned the Paula thing, like calling Victoria Beckham Paula. That was something that I, like, planned on doing. Like, I planned on, like, a lot of the things that happened on air. I had like, pre thought of. Yes, I pre thought of doing them and then doing those show. Like, I didn't. Reality, it's like, it's like doing improv, except the scene is about you and it's a really good scene partner. Like, they were like, kind of feeding me the lines, right? And that day of the. The actual audition that aired, it was eight hours. So I had sat in podcasts like this except for like two hours, like three or four times. Like, I had. They had talked to me as if I was the most interesting person in the. On the planet. And I. They, like, help you get into. Like, they don't want to know that you're playing a character, so they help you be into character. Like, like, they would be like, are you excited? Like, I'm excited, but, like, are you excited? And like, you know that they're trying to get you. And I just kind of. I knew that they were Manipulating me. And I played into it. So it was part me on me.
Mike Pesca
But did you have a comedy career then? Was this.
Janet McNamara
No, this was.
Mike Pesca
This was just a goof for your friend.
Janet McNamara
This was literally, like, to tell a story. I thought that, like, I didn't understand how viral worked. I thought I was, like, I thought it was gonna be. I didn't. Like, I thought that these people on tv, because the people I see on tv, at least I see him for three seconds, and I never think about them again. And my whole thing was, like, I was gonna have a party. I was gonna have a viewing, watching party. People are gonna watch me. Like, my, like, people. And then. But I didn't realize that, like, strangers would watch. I didn't realize that people would Google me. I didn't realize people would find out where I worked. Like, I didn't know. Well, that's sick that people are insane.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. Did it really affect your life poorly?
Janet McNamara
It didn't. Like, I'm not. I don't regret that I did it. If it's the highlight of my life, I'm happy. Like, it's probably the funniest thing I'll ever do, and I'm okay with that being the best day. That day the show aired was incredible.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
It was just like, I had a party. Like, my mom was proud of me. It was just this thing, but then was like, my mom. This is, like, my mom being insane. My mom sent out a Christmas letter that year saying, like, janet's gonna be on American Idol. Like, make sure, like, you watch. And I was like, mom, you have to tell I'm gonna be bad. Like, you have a mother does not say that their daughter is bad. I was like, mom, you. So, like, my mom wrote this, like, Christmas card to everybody saying, like, basically saying, like, I'm really proud of Janet. Like, she is gonna be on American Idol this season. And then I guess, like, she. She lives in, like, a small town, and. Well, she had just moved to a small town, and, like, people wouldn't look at her. Like, people weren't making eye contact. Like, people were, like, literally avoiding her. Because they.
Mike Pesca
Because my mom was telling that you were good.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Because, yeah, they didn't. Like, my mom didn't tell anybody that I was gonna. That it was an act and I was gonna be bad. So then everybody. So, like, stuff like that happened, and it was like, there was this depression level in that. For 48 hours, strangers were stopping me. Like, it was this anxiety provoking. It was so anxiety provoking. That was like, I Constantly thought people were looking at me when maybe they weren't. Maybe they were. I didn't know. And then after, like, 72 hours, nobody gave a. About me. Yeah, like, people were sick of me talking about it. Like, after the show aired, it was like you were a fallen idol. And I couldn't stop talking. Yeah. Like, because for months, like. Like, I couldn't stop talking about myself. So that. That was a. That was a lot of, like, depression part. Was that, like, it was this, like, super viral thing. And then so quickly.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
Nobody gave a damn.
Mike Pesca
So two observations. One, you're very good at snapping to. You said, you know, you had manic episodes, but that's. Those were real. Now, did you know you were prone to them back then?
Janet McNamara
So like, my dad, my grandma, like, bipolar is in my family.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
And then they had, like, kind of mentioned, like, my pcp, had kind of talked about it. And then after American Idol, I, like, I was, like, having panic attacks and stuff just from, like, it's. It's like, it's like. I don't know if it's even real or fake paranoia that people are looking at you.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
It's like you constantly think people are looking at you. Maybe they are, maybe they're not. It was like I was, like, paranoid and anxious and, like, I just lost my job. And, like, I had. I was. I had started anxiety medication when I was, like, 22. And this is when I was, like, 26. And then my PCP was like, I can't see you anymore. Like, you have to go to a psychiatrist.
Mike Pesca
Okay. So that was an inciting incident that got you to graduate from.
Janet McNamara
From the PCP to a psychiatrist.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
And that. Yeah, it was the. When the American Idol. Because I think she knew, like, I think she watched American Idol and then was like, this American Idol person is in my fucking office.
Mike Pesca
It must have been weird for her to diagnose you on tv. Like, wait a minute.
Janet McNamara
She basically was like, I was presenting as. Yeah, she basically said, like, this is above, like, my expertise. And then she was like, I'll fill what you have, but I'm not going to give you anything. In addition, and they took away, like, my Klonopin at the time, too, which was, like, huge. Or they had taken away my Klonopin like, a couple years before that, which I didn't really need. But then at this point, I was, like, freaking out.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
And then. And then I ended up, like, I had. I had really shitty healthcare because I was like, I was working for a temp Agency. So I had Athena. Not Athena. I think it was like, it was some cigna hell. Whatever it was, was like, I ended up in this psychiatry office. It was like this old man was in his house, and he kept. Like, he was like, smelled and like. I forget how the autism thing came out. I think somebody on the Internet said I was autistic or. Oh, somebody on the Internet said I was autistic or something. And I present dumb, even though I'm not dumb. And he. It was like, he was, like, upset. And I was on Zoloft at the time, and he. He was like. He kept. He was obsessed with, like, me. Like, I don't really have sex. And he was obsessed. He was like, what do you mean you don't have a sex drive? Like, you don't masturbate? And I was like, no. And like, we kept. Like, he. It kept going back to, like, masturbating. And he was like. Like, he, like, really wanted me to get off so loft. And I was like, I kind of like not caring. Like, I kind of like this side effect. And then I asked him, like, at third or fourth session, I was like, people keep. Like, is this, like, a thing? And he just. He was just like, no, is what a thing is? Like, am I. Like, is. Am I Asperger's?
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
Back when the Internet says I'm Asperger's. And then he was. And that's when he was like, no, people with Asperger's generally have a bad. He said, like, people with Asperger's generally have above average. Average IQs. But he said it, like, in that Irish way of like, do you think you're smart enough to have that?
Mike Pesca
Another challenge? Yeah, you wish. Asperger's.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Like, he said it in that, like, Irish way, Irish Catholic way of being like, oh, so you think you're smart? Like, like, that's the way he said it. And I was like, oh, okay. And then how'd you take.
Mike Pesca
Did you rebut that? Did you like, wait, I am smarter or is like, well, you must be, right? You're a guy.
Janet McNamara
I took it on the chin. Yeah, I took it on the chin. It was. Yeah. Here's a fun thing about me. I've been tested for autism three times. I keep getting retested every five years. Yeah, I keep getting retested because people keep asking me. And then the comedy had started, like, somewhere around. I think I was doing comedy at this point.
Mike Pesca
Like, if not, that's a great joke. I mean, that's your Own.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, that was, yeah, that was like I would. Yeah, that was like I wrote that joke like almost. That was like one of my first jokes.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Was obviously it wasn't tight. Like it was probably like a three minute story at the time. But yeah, that was like one of my first jokes was you have to have an above average iq. So it's one of those things. I've been telling that story. I've been saying it that exact way for so long, I don't remember what actually happened.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
Because I've told that joke so many times that I don't remember the actual.
Mike Pesca
But that's how memory works.
Janet McNamara
That's how memory works.
Mike Pesca
Ruts. There's a new rut.
Janet McNamara
But it was like. Yeah, it was this like crazy psychiatrist who said that to me. And then. Yeah, that's that. That was the first. It wasn't really a real assessment. It was just more of a psychiatrist that was like, no, you don't have it.
Mike Pesca
And then since then, how many times have you gone back? Because people are like, no, you must have some.
Janet McNamara
So I got like the first time I got like an actual like the first neuros. So I've, I've taken maybe 20 neuro psychs in my life. Like as a kid, maybe like 15. I, I, I'm in the process of doing another assessment.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
But I just sent a 250 page like set of records to a ran to a random psychiatrist. Like to somebody, somebody from the Internet was like, I could get you the diagnosis. So I sent him one.
Mike Pesca
Why do you want the diagnosis?
Janet McNamara
Well, I wanted at the time because at work I wanted accommodations.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
So like I kept getting in trouble at work and I wanted to be like, like, literally like I can't deal with these. Like I'm gonna have a meltdown in a meet. Like because I was having meltdowns. Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Like it goes from annoying to act.
Janet McNamara
I was doing that thing in meetings where I was going like this.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And it was like uh, where like people like nine people would be talking at the same time and I was melting down. It was coming off as rude or like, like at one point in me I got in trouble. I said at one point in a meeting, like, I don't understand how this is hard.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. Which is, that's good.
Janet McNamara
It wasn't. It really, it honestly it literally was like, oh, it's just it, it was like a 20 minutes. It was, the meeting was about scanning.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Like we were talking about scanning.
Mike Pesca
Like taking like, you know how you
Janet McNamara
scan something into a Xerox machine.
Mike Pesca
I thought maybe you were using a phrase, an accounting phrase that I wasn't familia. Scanning.
Janet McNamara
I literally said in the meeting, I don't understand why I'm better at scanning than anybody else than everybody else.
Mike Pesca
It's about centering a picture and pressing a button.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Like, that was what the meeting was about. That I said, I don't understand how this is hard, but. Yeah, but it was just everybody's cross talking and debating and it was a little bit more complicated than it was. Like, it was a little bit more complicated than scanning. But it was literally the meeting was about scanning.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
And. And I'd known the answer for like 25 minutes. And they just kept going. And basically I wanted accommodation so that, like, I stopped getting pulled into HR or like, I stopped having to, like, deal with that stuff. And I just realized that, like. So, like, the first time I got the accommodation was like 10 years ago. The first neuroscient I got was like, 10 years ago. And I had like a wicked bad meltdown at work where I ended up in the hospital. And I was like, I think I'm autistic. And the doctor at the hospital was like, no, you're not autistic because only kids have autism.
Mike Pesca
You've had some great doctors.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Like, the two things we know about autism are smart kids have it.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. She was like, adults don't have autism. It's just kids that have autism. And like, you don't have autistic. You don't have autism. And I was like, pretty insistent that I get the autism test because, like, my friend, like, I was an accountant at the time and, oh, I mean, I was doing comedy at the time and like, my friends were telling me out, whatever. People were like, you're not bipolar, you're autistic. And I was like, I don't know what the I am. And then so I ended up getting this like, neuropsych exam. And I was like, I was like manic at the time. So, like, I wasn't cohe. I wasn't emotionally very good. Like, I was all over the place.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And basically he said I'm like, super add. Like, I failed that. Like, which I knew I've gotten. I've been diagnosed for ADD like 12
Mike Pesca
times, but that keeps coming back. Yes, you have it.
Janet McNamara
ADD is the only thing, like, I like every year, all until like my junior year in high school. I took some sort of like, testing and they basically just said, she has like a third grade reading level. She Is like I was a third grade reading level for a long time and then I jumped to like an 8th grade reading level.
Mike Pesca
Wow. That's sad because there's a lot of good books for fifth and sixth graders and you never got to read them.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. It was like, I don't. I think that the reading level thing is bullshit because I read fine.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. And they say like the New York Times, the Boston Globes written.
Janet McNamara
It's like a seventh grade reading grade. Yeah. It's like. Yeah. I don't know what. Like I can't read a dinosaur book.
Mike Pesca
Like the topic just like the people talking about the cruise. It has to be interesting to you.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, exactly.
Mike Pesca
The books aren't interesting to you.
Janet McNamara
Exactly. Like the whole philosophy, the idea of spelling something out is impossible to me. Like I can't do it.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
Like I literally, I can't spell out a word. Like it makes no sense to me.
Mike Pesca
But as you explained in your special, it's not dyslexia. It's just you don't care to meet, I guess the rest of the public where they are, including places like this is an agreed upon spelling of epitome.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. I have some sort of. I don't know what I have. I have. I definitely have some sort of like language processing.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
Issue. I definitely. I don't know what it's called. I don't know what it is. It could be. I don't know what it is.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. But you also say you have a bad memory. Right. And so that's why like this special is. Could be a collection of one liners but it's in this structure.
Janet McNamara
So that it has to be in
Mike Pesca
that structure so you can remember it. But some of spelling is intuiting the rules, some of spelling just memorizing. If you've seen that epitome or Penelope is another one. Right. You're going to know how to spell it. But then the big thing that I was listening or that I was occurring to me as I listened is you don't care to meet people at their expectation level. I think. And so isn't a lot of what we call intelligence just. I'm going to say this thing so you understand it. Kind of slow myself down.
Janet McNamara
It's like the older I get when I was a K really used to bother me when people thought I was dumb.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. And now you put it on the title of your album.
Janet McNamara
I know. And now I literally. I'm like anybody who thinks I'm dumb just. I almost don't think they're Smart? Yeah, because it's like they think I'm dumb. Like they're not. Like they can't understand what I'm saying is why they think I'm dumb is that they're not understood. Like, because I can't, like I can't explain, I can't explain it. Like, you're a five year old.
Mike Pesca
Yes. Did you, in your work life, in your accounting life, did you ever have coworkers or even bosses who actually really did get you and thought you were really smart?
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
So like the, for the job I had, I was attempt for a long time and then I worked for this Internet company and I stayed at that Internet company. I was making such little money. I was making. It was unbelievable how little money I was making. But I, they hired me even though I had the American. Like I could not get a job with health insurance and then the house. Like I needed better health insurance because I had this fucking psychiatrist and it was the only psychiatrist, the ultimate guy in the house.
Mike Pesca
That guy.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, the guy that I had in the house. So like I, I just wanted a job that had Blue Cross.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
That's all I wanted in life. So I took this. Like it was unbelievably low paying and it was like $20 an hour with a master's degree and. But like the, My boss at the time, he was brilliant.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And like he would say, like he said to me a couple times, like, it's crazy because you're either really, really good at things or you're unbelievably bad. And they ended up getting, they ended up getting me an assistant. So. Which was great because the assistant was able. All this shit that I couldn't do.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
Like, I couldn't do the day to day. Like I could do these like, like big, like month, end, quarter end. Like, like I could do all the like higher end stuff, but the lower end, like filling out the timesheet or. Yeah. Or like it was like daily transaction. Like there was like daily things that you had to do or like the accounts pay. Like I just couldn't, I couldn't. It was just like I. There's something wrong with my brain that I literally just can't type like numbers and I just couldn't bring myself to do the same repetitive task.
Mike Pesca
Your assistant getting paid more than 20 an hour?
Janet McNamara
No, he was getting, he was getting paid less. He was a smart guy. But. But so like. And it was like they couldn't. Yeah. And then so I, I stayed at that job like way too long. But I also, like, learned I went from, like, way low, where, like, they ended up hiring, like, two people to replace me. Like, I ended. I. I was doing pretty much everything that you would do because I couldn't, Like, I was so bad at the lower end stuff.
Mike Pesca
But what about that boss who saw your potential and found a way to work around it by getting someone to do the gr. What was the difference between him and his mindset or either how he looked at the workplace, how he looked at other people, and Marilyn and the rest of these other people who.
Janet McNamara
So he was brilliant.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
So that boss, he's one of the smartest people I've ever met.
Mike Pesca
Okay. So smart people think you're smart.
Janet McNamara
Smart people think I'm smart.
Mike Pesca
Okay.
Janet McNamara
Smart people think I'm smart. Dumb people think I'm dumb.
Mike Pesca
That's interesting. What does that tell you about that?
Janet McNamara
Yeah, exactly. Smart people do think I'm smart.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
So he was brilliant. And he was able to, like, see, like, because I can, like, he was. I learned Excel, like, from him. Like, he was so good at Excel.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
But, like, I was actually, like, able to learn.
Mike Pesca
And.
Janet McNamara
And like, I used to watch, like, YouTube videos and like, we watch the same YouTube videos and you get them.
Mike Pesca
You understand it from the.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Videos. Are you good? Besides computers, are you good at systems? Yeah. Yes. Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And so, you know, I'm really, I'm good. I was about to say I'm really good at puzzles.
Mike Pesca
Someone sets up the rules for something, you intuit it quickly, but there's probably a novelty to it.
Janet McNamara
So there's like, Like I'm good at, like, engine building board games. Like any engine building board game, I'm probably going to win.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Like, there's. There's the specific things that I'm, like, painfully good at.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. I don't really understand what autism is or isn't.
Janet McNamara
I don't either.
Mike Pesca
But from what these stereotypes types are, you definitely seem to have it like, you're brilliant at these brilliant tasks and then can't do the normal stuff.
Janet McNamara
Exactly. But. Yeah, so.
Mike Pesca
But it also seems that not being able to do the normal stuff stems from maybe this is true lack of patience and connection to humans. Like, if you were dealing with a computer or a program making you do the normal stuff where you didn't have to explain it to a human, you might be better at it.
Janet McNamara
The idea of explaining something to a human, like, drives me. Like, if I had to explain copying and pasting in Excel.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
I cannot explain how copying and pasting works to Say, like. It's like. I cannot explain it.
Mike Pesca
Does it make sense to you?
Janet McNamara
Like, I don't understand how it doesn't make sense to anyone.
Mike Pesca
So if it makes so much sense to you, does this indicate that maybe Excel was designed by someone who was autistic?
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Bill Gates, right? Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Yeah, I've heard about him.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Oh, man. More about comedy. More about. More about.
Janet McNamara
I can talk about Excel for, like, two hours.
Mike Pesca
More about Excel, maybe. We'll get into sheets in a minute when we're back.
Janet McNamara
Autistic. I said, I'm not autistic. I don't have sensory issues. And my therapist said, you wore a life jacket every day for two years. Did you tell them that?
Mike Pesca
Foreign. We're back with Funny youy Should Mention. I don't know if you could tell. I'm finding this conversation interesting. We haven't even talked about too many of Janet's jokes. Let's do that. You come out on stage, and you immediately put the whores on blast. What's that about?
Janet McNamara
The horns on blast?
Mike Pesca
The whores.
Janet McNamara
Oh, the whores. That was like.
Mike Pesca
The way you say it in the Boston accent is extra funny.
Janet McNamara
I was like, corporate whore. It was like a play on that. So, like. Yeah, it was just like, I'm gonna. Like, that's what. Because it was like. When I first started comedy, the job I have that I just left, it was more of a casual work environment. So I used to, like, come into, like, comedy clubs wearing, like. Like a suit.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
And you kind of have to address why you're dressed like that.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
So that. That's kind of how that came about. And I honestly never understood. Understood why it was funny. I just kind of said it one day and it worked. And then somebody explained to me, like, an audience member was like, oh, I think that joke's funny because prostitutes, like, tell cops that they're accountants when they ask.
Mike Pesca
That's not why it's funny. That person's wrong.
Janet McNamara
Okay, well, that's why I thought it was like, I
Mike Pesca
will have played this on the show, and I guarantee you, 1% of the audience, like, oh, yeah, that's why. No, yeah, it's funny if it is. It's funny because of how you say it. It's funny because of the overstatement. You seem so impassioned about, like I said, putting the whores on blast. And there's nothing whorish about your appearance. Yeah, it's like that office joke where Angela says, you know, let's do anything, except in yellow, because that's a whorish color.
Janet McNamara
I think, like, the reason why I thought it was funny was because I thought it was a play on, like, I'm dressed like a corporate whore. Like a corporate whore is like a term.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Maybe I made up. Is that a term?
Mike Pesca
Sort of.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, it's like, you're a corporate whore. Like, you're like, change your desk, you're
Mike Pesca
whoring out for the corporation.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. So that. That's what I thought was funny about it when I started saying it. And then it was getting such a good response that I just kept saying it and I. It was like one of those things. I was like, I don't really.
Mike Pesca
Don't question it.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. I don't know why this is getting.
Mike Pesca
Do you have any other jokes like that?
Janet McNamara
Yeah, I have another joke that I just, like, randomly said one day and it was. It's on the special.
Mike Pesca
What about her childhood? You weren't trying to hit on the fact that they have terrible childhoods?
Janet McNamara
No.
Mike Pesca
Porn actresses. You were saying, what about the character in that porn who says, maybe there's another way to pay for that pizza?
Janet McNamara
Yeah, yeah. I meant it as, like. I don't really know how I meant it. It was just something I said one day and it got a laugh. So I just kept repeating it.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
And then I forget the comic's name. I was opening for her. Carolyn Plummer, her name is. She's a Boston comic. She's great. Very funny. She said to me, she said, you know, I really like that porn joke. You do? Like the childhood thing. And I was like, yeah, I don't like, explain it to me. I was like, it gets a laugh, but I don't get it.
Mike Pesca
Explain my jokes to me.
Janet McNamara
And then I was probably like. I probably tightened it up now. Like, I don't remember. It was very. It was a much lucid joke. Like, I was a open. I was probably like three or four years in at this point. It was probably like a much longer joke. And then she explained to me why it was funny. And I was like, oh, that makes sense.
Mike Pesca
I don't know. I think it's funny for reasons.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. She explained to me. That was like, you know what? Whatever was. It helps with the. It helps with the joke to know why people are laughing.
Mike Pesca
It does, yeah. Which words to emphasize. But. But the jokes, do they. Did they start out as a collection of one liners and then you organized them?
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
And so in that bit, it was about. I think. I think you don't like sex. You're not interested in Sex.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Was that even part of a bigger. Was that nested in a bigger idea?
Janet McNamara
So like I. That porn joke of like, I don't watch porn.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Was probably like the first joke.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And then it went into like, it went into like the like being on Doloft and I used to have. I had a Tinder profile. I used to like make fake. I used to like put these and then my mom made me take them all down. I'm so pissed. But I used to like post. I used to just make like batshit Tinder profiles.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And then wait for them to go on barstool sports. Like that was like a thing because, like I would make like bat shit Tinder profiles. And this is like another thing I did. I was, I was a comedian at the time, but I wasn't like, I didn't. I like. It's hard to explain to people that I had no career interest. Like, this was just all some stuff that I did.
Mike Pesca
Right. Like just like the American Idol or this.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. It was like I didn't really put anything.
Mike Pesca
Happened to be a comedian.
Janet McNamara
I didn't really put anything online because I didn't want to lose. Like, I knew what happened with American Idol. So I didn't really put anything online because. So like if you Google, like up until a year ago, if you Googled me, my LinkedIn showed up and I like, if something like I was pretty like, I have. There's a couple like old YouTube videos and stuff for me that came up. But like, I like worked like I scrubbed the entire Internet of that. Like the reason why that American Idol video, it's hard to find. You have to literally Google My Janet MacMier American Idol.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. It only exists in a grainy form.
Janet McNamara
It's like grainy and it has like 30,000 views.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
But it's because after the show aired, I went through and I copyright struck. Like, I had no, I didn't have any career. Like, I didn't like, I didn't think that any of this was.
Mike Pesca
Fox should thank you. I mean, you save them a lot of money.
Janet McNamara
But I went through and I copyright struck. So for a while you couldn't like, you couldn't find it on the Internet.
Mike Pesca
Right. You think that hurt your career?
Janet McNamara
No, because I think that if I. Well, if I started comedy and I tried to play that character.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
That character is just not.
Mike Pesca
Oh, no. What I meant. Do you think having no Internet presence up until like two years ago, your career.
Janet McNamara
I think it. Well, at the time it did.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Like, nobody knew where I was. But it also, like, it made it so that when industry did see me, they were like, who the F?
Mike Pesca
There's a lot of buzz.
Janet McNamara
Like, where did this come from? Yeah, like, nobody saw me suck. Yeah, in Boston they saw me suck. But like, I, it's not like I, it's, it's not like industry, like, saw me and they were like, oh, she's getting better. She's getting better. She's getting better. Oh, she's like, they just saw me. Like, nobody saw me till I was like 14, 15 years in.
SoFi Advertiser
Yes.
Janet McNamara
So I think that helps that I just kind of came out of nowhere as far as anybody outside of Boston. Like, within Boston, I've grown a reputation.
Mike Pesca
So one of the things I wanted to ask about is how the one liners now present themselves in this very special. But your process. Will you still write one liners and then just trust I'll find the place for them.
Janet McNamara
That's my writing.
Mike Pesca
That's it.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. I.
Mike Pesca
You don't even know what else it relates to.
Janet McNamara
So I learned to write by watching Gary Goleman.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
So Gary Goldman wrote In this Economy. He wrote, he used to go to this club called the Comedy Studio in Cambridge. And then from the Comedy Studio, he went to this other bar called the Barn. And he did that every Wednesday. And I would watch him, like between the Comedy Studio and the Barn, tweak up the jokes. And I would watch him, like, write a one liner and then write a one liner. And then I went to his taping and I. And then I, you know, I've probably seen Gary Goldman at this point in my life, two, 300 times. Wow. No, that's a lie. Probably like 670 or 80 times. But anyways, I watched him like write like a, you know, a joke about finding a $20 bill in a thing. And then he wrote an entire. And he wrote his in this economy special is about him finding a $20 bill in a coat. And then it goes into this whole. And it's all, it's basically all these, like, side quests. And that's how he writes.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
And that's the autism joke. After in this Economy came out, that's when I was able to put the autism. The autism joke was like, you know, I wrote a joke about saying hi to people. I wrote a joke about relaxing. I, I wrote like the joke about Asperger's. Like, I wrote all these like one liner jokes, but I didn't have anywhere to put them. So I. And then when I saw it in this economy. I was like, oh, this can all be wrapped up in this story.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
And the same thing happened, like, with the bipolar. Like the three jokes. I only have three jokes in my special. I have autism. Bipolar. And then sex is stupid. And then the bipolar thing, weirdly, three
Mike Pesca
jokes, but, like 112 laughs.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, weirdly, but I only have three jokes. But, yeah, I'm a three joke pony. But the bipolar thing was. The same thing was like, I had written all these one liners and then my therapist, I googled her and like, she missed an appointment. I googled her. I realized that she, like, is one of those, like, people that protest. Like, she's like. I realized that, like, she secretly, like. Like, you know, there's like, there was a video of her.
Mike Pesca
Whatever, she's an environment.
Janet McNamara
But it was like, figured I figured out how to, like, wrap that all in a bow.
Mike Pesca
Yes. Do you think that works for the audience as well as being necessary for you? I don't think it doesn't work for the audience.
Janet McNamara
I don't think it works for the audience.
Mike Pesca
Well, you.
Janet McNamara
I do care if it works for the audience. Yeah, but it's. It's. I. I don't know.
Mike Pesca
It's like, you couldn't do it any other way.
Janet McNamara
I don't think. I don't think. Yeah. I don't know. Yeah. I wouldn't know how to. I. I guess, like, before I learned how to just wrap things in a bow.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
I still, to this day, I have dozens of jokes that I only do at open mics.
Mike Pesca
That was my question.
Janet McNamara
Because I have nowhere to put, like, I.
Mike Pesca
But they might be great jokes.
Janet McNamara
Exactly. I have, like, I have this. At this point, there's like a little bit of like. Like, it's. It's, you know, I have to be. It's this, like, confidence or this, like, faith of, like, if I just write these things and I work on these jokes, like, eventually it's just gonna come together and it's gonna work out and something will happen. If I just keep working towards. If. If you. If you're constantly working at an ending goal and it's just like, I'm gonna write an hour. You're not gonna write an hour. You have to be like, I'm gonna write one 30 second joke. And if you write a 30 second joke and then you start freaking out because you have nowhere to put in your act, like, like, for me, that just once I start thinking about how I'm gonna make money or how it's gonna work long term, or where it's gonna fit my. I can't just, like, be like, I'm gonna sit down and write a joke about autism.
Mike Pesca
Yes, I get it. But your bar for including it in the special is really, really high. And some great jokes might be kept out. Yeah, maybe. Like, have you talked to Gary about this? Does he give you any advice about. No. Have you talked to Gary about any of this? Because Gary tweets.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, he did. I, I, like, I, I, I, I, I read them.
Mike Pesca
Yeah, those were good. I gave them to my son who's an aspiring stand up. Yeah, like, read this. This guy's the best.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, he's, he's, he's brilliant.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. But Gary also does this thing where he has, Unlike you, he'll kind of embody different characters. Yeah, right. And so the Trader Joe's routine, he could maybe put some jokes in there. I don't know if he'll want to. Yeah, that's like a Christmas tree that you could hang ornaments off of. I'm just thinking if you could do something like that.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, yeah. To be honest, like, I don't watch as much stand up as I watch should on a structural level. A lot of it. Yeah. I just, I, I don't have the attention span to watch too much comedy. I would be better structurally if I watched more.
Mike Pesca
But you listen to a lot of Bieber and Hanson, right?
Janet McNamara
Hanson, the band?
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Not anymore. Really. I've been really into Justin Bieber lately.
Mike Pesca
But you were, like, big into.
Janet McNamara
I was. I've been to, like, more than 30 Hanson concerts. Yeah. Yeah. I was really, really into them in college in my 20s.
Mike Pesca
So my question is, do the, to the Hanson. What are you guys called? Hansonites. Team Hanson heads.
Janet McNamara
What? I. Fanson's.
Mike Pesca
Fanson's. There you go. What are the, what are the fansons? Think about mbop.
Janet McNamara
It's one of the best I could go off. It's like, it's a deeper song than people realize it is.
Mike Pesca
Well, I'll stop you and say it's the perfect pop song, but I was just wondering if the, you know, True Believers, like the Deadheads, will be like Casey Jones, whatever.
Janet McNamara
No, no, no, no. It's, it's, no, it's, it's a, it's a brilliant song. I'm not like Justin Bieber, wise. I, I put, I listened to so much Justin Bieber. It's more of, like, a special interest I have right now.
Mike Pesca
What do you mean by that?
Janet McNamara
And I ruined music. So I was into Courtney Barnett for a while last Year before that, I was in this. This person named Joy. Alana Kun. And then I was into Brandi Carlisle before that. And I'll get, like, I'll listen to the same album six times a day for like six months, and then I'll. I'll ruin the album and I can't listen to it again.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
You.
Mike Pesca
That way with Hanson.
Janet McNamara
Hanson kind of. They kind of went off the deep end over Covid. As far as the political right.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. Well, there, you know, from Oklahoma, like, home school.
Janet McNamara
They'll homeschool kids from Oklahoma. I don't know what. Why I didn't see that coming.
Mike Pesca
But at this point, they're 30 something, so they're not.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, they're 40 something.
Mike Pesca
40 something. Jeez.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
All right. I want to ask you. I want to make sure. I have so many questions, but you've been very generous with your time. I want to make sure I get to them. Oh, yeah. Okay. So as the. One of the things about autism, I don't know if it's true or not, is the inability or. The people who are autistic don't love to look others in the eye. Do you have that? You don't seem to have that.
Janet McNamara
I don't think I do.
Mike Pesca
I don't think you do either.
Janet McNamara
I, like, I have a joke about it, but I don't. I definitely. I look up, but I do that when I'm thinking it's. Cause I have really bad memory recall.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. Yeah. When you look up and to the left is when you're trying to invent something. When you look up and to the right, it's when you're trying to recall something. This I learned from poker tales.
Janet McNamara
Oh, God.
Mike Pesca
Yeah. But what about crowd work? When you interact with the crowd, is that for someone like you, is that pleasurable or not?
Janet McNamara
I've been doing it. I do it more than I realize. As far as crowd interaction, I don't hate it. I like. Like, I'm in control. Like, my therapist asked me, like a year or two ago. She was like, I don't get it. Like, you hate. You don't. You're not good at meeting new people. Like, I have, like, a social anxiety disorder. Like, that's my latest autism test. They were like, you're not autistic. You have social anxiety. And with comedy, you're in control.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
So it's like, I'm gonna win.
Mike Pesca
Yes. With. I don't know if it was in the special or an interview I saw. I think it was in the special. Your therapist Said, what do you mean you're not autistic? You wore a life jacket for two years and you didn't tell them that because they didn't ask, but I noticed you wear a vest all the time.
Janet McNamara
I know. Wait, that's where that came from.
Mike Pesca
But is that.
Janet McNamara
I was in a green room. Judy Gold. Shout out. I was in a green room with Judy and my. My best friend Emily, and Judy did, like, the Judy Gold thing of, like,
Mike Pesca
being demure and not speaking up.
Janet McNamara
Or she, you know, she would. She, like, she had seen my act, and she was like, they were talking about autism, and she was like, what? The vest? And. And then Emily, my best friend, was like, you know, it's like an autism thing. Like, people do it like weighted jackets. And then I don't know where it came from, but I just mentioned that I wore a life jacket when I was a kid, and Judy did the. Like, what's wrong with you? Like, how do you not have a joke? And then, like, about the wearing the life jacket for two years, which I did do as a kid. Like, it's my album cover, is me wearing a life jacket. But it was just one of those things that I forgot I even did. And then my best friend Emily just kept hounding me to write that life jacket joke.
Mike Pesca
Let me ask you a question, Janet. Did you drown?
Janet McNamara
No, I didn't. See? See?
Mike Pesca
Who's the joke on?
Janet McNamara
Exactly. Exactly. I did not drown.
Mike Pesca
What do you think of the idea, label conception of neurodivergence?
Janet McNamara
I think it's confusing. I don't. To be honest, I'm not super educated. I'm talking to somebody now about it where it's more of like. Like, you have all these, like, mixed things in your head, and it's hard to, like, bring them all together. And you're just like, the neurodivergent brain is, like, looking for patterns.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
And when there's no patterns, you get all flustered.
Mike Pesca
I think it could mean a lot of things.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. I think it's.
Mike Pesca
You have some. Like, when I say, how did she think of that? Or how does she think like that. Well, if you want to say neurodivergence, I can't disagree.
Janet McNamara
Yeah. Yeah. It's. I. I'm probably out. I don't. I have to. Like, this is crazy to me. Like, I can't tell you how much effort I've put into wanting to. Want to learn about it.
Mike Pesca
You can't watch YouTube videos. What if they put it on an Excel spreadsheet?
Janet McNamara
They're like, help. They're so boring. Like, I just don't find them that interesting. Yeah, I need somebody. Like, I think it's like, I think everybody has a different experience with it. And I haven't seen anyone on any of these YouTube things that I'm like, oh, I do. Like, this is how my brain. Like, it's a lot of it. Every once in a while, I'll see, like, an Instagram where I'm like, oh. I also. Like, I didn't know the walking away thing was an autistic thing. Yeah, I didn't know that it was an autistic thing until very recently.
Mike Pesca
Interesting.
Janet McNamara
But so some. Some of these. Some of these things I'm, like, learning by YouTube and Instagram. But so, so many of the things people talk about, I don't really connect with or relate to. And. But, yeah, I don't. But so many people. I get so many DMS and comments of people who are like, oh, like, what you just said is exactly.
Mike Pesca
See, isn't that better? Like your original DMs.
Janet McNamara
There are people.
Mike Pesca
People assailing you for the American Idol experience, calling you autistic now. They're helping you.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, exactly. Like, there's so many DMS and comments of people that are like, I think the exact same way as you.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Like, I also get in trouble for this. Like, they also told me I'm not autistic because of this reason. This reason. This reason. So I. I think it's like. I think it's. There's a ton of new research and stuff and conflicting research, and I think it's. It's all. It's all. It's all, like, it's something that I'll learn about, but I keep being told I'm not. So I'm like, why would I learn about something that I'm not?
Mike Pesca
I mean, all the people who've tried to diagnose you, it seems like a lot of them are wrong.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Well, this is a thing.
Mike Pesca
Listen to them.
Janet McNamara
This is the thing I recently figured out was that, like. And I. I know I did this. Whereas, like, the day, like, I would, like, start panicking, like, right before the assessments and be. And be, like, they're gonna find, like, I don't want, like, another label. I don't want something else wrong with me. So I didn't, like, lie, but I didn't. I sabotaged them to a degree by, like, I wanted the assessments. I wanted the diagnosis, which is why I got the assessments. And then I, like, emotionally, I just couldn't Handle, like, finding more stuff. Like, yeah, like, my whole life. Like, I've just. Oh, you have a third grade reading. Like, like, you have.
Mike Pesca
It's like layers and layers of burdens on you.
Janet McNamara
It was like, every time I took a test as a kid, it would be like, you know, I'd be like, in 10th grade, and they'd be like, congratulations, you now have a 3.5 grade level. Like, reading level. I'm like, that's like, you went up half a grade. Like, so it was just like, I had. I. It was just. Yeah, I almost. I almost sabotaged them to a degree.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
But they also, like, the interview is like, they ask you, like, they ask you questions, and then when the interview's over, you're like, oh, I have so much to add. But then they don't. You don't really have a chance to like, be like, oh, these things I didn't tell you.
Mike Pesca
Yeah, why not in anything else phase. Right.
Janet McNamara
Yeah.
Mike Pesca
Any other comments? Do you think you'd have been better off in an earlier era of work? The negatives would be, you know, women in the workplace weren't that. Weren't that embraced, but the positives. I tend to think that maybe in the 50s and 60s, there was just. It was, do your work. We're not here to be a family or to have fun. We're not here to chit chat. Do your work. And we like it when you do your work.
Janet McNamara
Oh, no way.
Mike Pesca
No, no.
Janet McNamara
I would have been. No, in the 50s and 60s, you had to be like, hi. Like, yeah, I think it was more that, but it was also, like, without the tech. Like, technology changed my life.
Mike Pesca
Yeah.
Janet McNamara
Like, without Excel. Like, I can't do. I couldn't do. Like, I don't have an accounting degree because I couldn't do the T accounts. Like, I can't do accounting on. Like, I can't explain how accounting. I just know how it works. I could just. I can do it. Like, I can't.
Mike Pesca
You are a ledger. You are a human.
Janet McNamara
Yeah, I can't. So, like, I can't do it the way they did it back in the day. The. Because they teach you in school. The way they did it in the 50s and 60s. I can't do. I couldn't do it. Like, it didn't. I could do the job I couldn't do.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
So I kind of just meant the vibe of the work, the vibe of the workplace. Maybe I would have been better. But I like, like listening to podcasts on my headphones. Like, I don't I don't think I would have. I don't think. I think ideally if I could like go, I wouldn't want to be born 2010, deal with COVID But with the exception of COVID like 2010 would have been like my ideal time to be born. Or like maybe 2000 where it was like, because like I grew up, they didn't have spell check. They focused on handwriting. Like all stuff that doesn't matter anymore.
Mike Pesca
Yes.
Janet McNamara
Like they, they said they were like, you're stupid because you have bad handwriting.
Mike Pesca
Right.
Janet McNamara
And that doesn't.
Mike Pesca
Do you think AI is going to take away accounting most?
Janet McNamara
Oh yeah. That's a lot of why I pivoted towards stand up comedy. I would have been an accountant.
Mike Pesca
AI's bad at comedy because, like, I
Janet McNamara
don't have a CPA. I don't have a CPA. I don't even have an accounting degree.
Mike Pesca
Like the name of the new special, get it on YouTube is not smart enough. I mean, that's the name, but I think you can tell. What if you think she's not smart enough? And maybe something about, you're a good dummy. Janet, thank you so much.
Janet McNamara
Thank you.
Mike Pesca
All right, That's it for today's show. The Gist is produced by Cory Wara. Jeff Craig does How To Ben Astaire is our booking coordinator. Kathleen Sykes does the Gist list. And Michelle Pesca is extraordinary in her role as coo. Thanks for listening.
Janet McNamara
Foreign.
SoFi Advertiser
Does it feel like your student loans are a permanent part of your life? It doesn't have to be that way. With SoFi, you can consolidate your student loans and refinance with a shorter term, potentially becoming debt free Sooner. Join over 580,000 members who have already refinanced their student loans with SOFI to take control of their financial future. Getting started is easier than you think. View your rate@sofi.com Next Today, SoFi Student loans are originated by Sofi Bank Rank NA Member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891.
THE GIST – EPISODE SUMMARY
Janet McNamara: Smart People Think I'm Smart, Stupid People Think I'm Dumb
Release Date: May 29, 2026
Host: Mike Pesca
Guest: Janet McNamara
In this episode of The Gist, host Mike Pesca sits down with stand-up comic and accountant Janet McNamara—a self-described “spectrumy” individual with a fascinating career trajectory, unexpected brushes with fame, and a neurodivergent outlook that both challenges and delights her audience. The conversation unpacks Janet’s unique relationship to diagnosis and self-understanding, her experiences in the high-pressure world of accounting, her infamous American Idol moment, and her approach to comedy and life as someone who both resists and revels in labels.
Janet’s Professional Background
Brush with Fame – American Idol
Ambiguity of Labels
Adapting to Neurotypical Environments
Desire for Diagnosis
Viral Notoriety’s Double-Edged Sword
Mental Health Journey
Who Gets Janet?
On Communication and Frustration
Material Origin Stories
Structure and Style
Internet Presence & Comedy Success
Ambivalence and Acceptance
Sabotaging Diagnoses
Generational Fit and Technology
On AI and the Future of Work
“Smart people think I’m smart. Dumb people think I’m dumb.”
— Janet McNamara (39:09)
“I don’t see the point of asking somebody a question I already know the answer to.”
— Janet McNamara (14:31)
“I just say thank you. Thank you. I just say thank you.”
— Janet McNamara, on handling compliments (18:43)
“There was this depression level…strangers were stopping me…for 48 hours, strangers were stopping me…After 72 hours, nobody gave a damn about me.”
— Janet McNamara (24:29–25:21)
“I’ve been tested for autism three times. I keep getting retested every five years. I keep getting retested because people keep asking me.”
— Janet McNamara (29:08)
“The older I get…when people think I’m dumb, I almost don’t think they’re smart…because they can’t understand what I’m saying.”
— Janet McNamara (36:01)
“I could do all the high-end stuff but…the lower end, like filling out the timesheet? I just couldn’t bring myself to do the same repetitive task.”
— Janet McNamara (37:43)
“I can talk about Excel for, like, two hours.”
— Janet McNamara (41:14)
The episode’s tone is frank, self-aware, and laced with dry humor. Janet is straightforward, analytical about her own limitations and strengths, and wry about the absurdities of diagnosis, social norms, and fame. Pesca matches her candor with gentle curiosity, exploring Janet’s worldview both as a comic and neurodivergent individual.
This intimate, refreshingly honest episode offers an inside look at what it’s like to navigate work and society a little bit “off script”—by necessity and by design. It’s especially valuable for listeners seeking nuanced conversation around comedy, neurodiversity, and the blurry line between funny and strange. Janet McNamara makes the case that sometimes the best punchline is simply being oneself—warts, quirks, diagnoses, and all.