Podcast Summary: The Gist
Episode: "John J. Lennon — 'I'm Owning My Sh*t on the Page'"
Date: November 12, 2025
Host: Mike Pesca (Peach Fish Productions)
Guest: John J. Lennon, incarcerated journalist and author of The Tragedy of True Crime: Four Guilty Men and the Stories that Define Us
Episode Overview
This episode of The Gist features journalist John J. Lennon, calling in from his cell at Sing Sing Correctional Facility, where he has been incarcerated for over two decades following a murder conviction. Lennon has become a prolific and published writer, and the discussion centers on his new book, The Tragedy of True Crime, the ethics and narratives of the true crime genre, his personal journey toward accountability, and insights about writing, rehabilitation, and storytelling from inside prison.
Key Themes and Discussion Points
1. Rethinking “True Crime” and the Notion of Innocence
-
Lennon critiques the true crime genre's obsession with innocence.
- Many true crime stories focus on “innocent men,” which Lennon sees as a convenient narrative that oversimplifies the justice system and erases the complexities of guilt (07:49).
- Quote:
"Activists and criminal justice reform folks...they love the innocent man, right? Because it fits the story formula so well." – John J. Lennon (07:49)
- He argues the stories of guilty men, like himself, are far more complicated and can provide deeper insights into crime, punishment, and redemption.
-
True crime as exploitation.
- Lennon discusses how producers and creators often promise one narrative but pursue sensationalism and victim exploitation (09:36).
- Quote:
“There’s a lot of exploitation...a lot of schmoozing...and then there’s arrogance too—‘well, we’re gonna tell it anyway.’” – John J. Lennon (09:36)
2. Experiencing Exploitation: The Chris Cuomo “Inside Evil” Segment
-
Being labeled “evil” by the media.
- Lennon describes being lured onto a CNN show under the pretense of a redemption story only to discover it was still titled “Inside Evil,” a show focused on pathology rather than transformation (12:11).
- He recalls feeling set-up and powerless, akin to his experience within the justice system.
-
On being portrayed unsympathetically.
- The show’s production juxtaposed interviews with Lennon and the victim’s family to question his sincerity and redemption, prompting Lennon to double down on becoming a journalist who could tell more nuanced stories (19:57, 21:36).
- Quote:
“That’s when I really said, I have to write to this. Like...I can do this better than you guys. Fuller stories.” – John J. Lennon (21:36)
3. Class and Authenticity: Who Gets to Tell Crime Stories?
-
Outsider vs. Insider Journalism.
- Lennon questions the legitimacy of outsiders (like Chris Cuomo) telling stories of the incarcerated when they lack lived experience (23:26).
- Quote:
“Chris Cuomo grew up in the governor's mansion. He probably shouldn't be doing these, like, shows, like, just as a matter of...agency as a narrative journalist." – John J. Lennon (23:26)
-
Lennon makes a point to position himself beneath, not above, the other men whose stories he tells.
- He uses his own guilt and experience to draw out more empathetic and complicated portraits of others (24:46).
4. Crime, Punishment, and Social Hierarchies Inside Prison
- How crimes are perceived behind bars.
- Lennon explains the hierarchy of crimes in prison, where reputations are shaped by the nature of one’s offenses (17:06–17:21). Organized crime figures often get the most respect, while those who harm women or children are scorned.
- He describes how his own crime was seen—a “lifestyle crime” resulting from immersion in drug dealing culture.
- Quote:
“When you go to prison, there is like a sort of pecking order and a social stratification.” – John J. Lennon (17:06)
5. The Role and Reception of Journalism in Prison
-
Lennon’s reputation among prisoners.
- He’s respected as “the dude that writes,” and his articles circulate widely, though he deals with criticism from fellow inmates who sometimes feel exposed (33:57).
- Quote:
“If you publish a piece in Men's Health...guys will be like critiquing you, like, you know, for like revealing too much.” – John J. Lennon (33:57)
-
Navigating risk and relationships.
- Reporting on prison dynamics can lead to tense situations, but Lennon also notes how his established reputation and the reach of his work offer a unique protection and role (35:33).
-
Relationship with prison authorities.
- Lennon describes a mostly indifferent attitude among prison staff, but notes that as he’s gained prominence, there’s institutional tolerance—even for potentially controversial pieces (37:38).
6. Technology, Reform, and Prison Communication
- Recent technological reforms.
- Lennon discusses the switch to tablet-based, free phone calls in New York prisons, a significant improvement for inmates and their families (38:59–41:23).
- But he tempers praise with a critique about the exploitative aspects of digital services for incarcerated people.
7. Changing the True Crime Narrative and the Politics of Parole
-
Impact on true crime creators and consumers.
- Lennon hopes his book will inspire both audiences and fellow writers to think more judiciously about the stories they consume and tell (41:31).
- Quote:
“When we produce work, you have to ask yourself...to what end am I telling this story?” – John J. Lennon (43:27)
-
On narrative and parole.
- Pesca and Lennon discuss how narrative skill and the ability to “tell your story” can disproportionately affect parole decisions, sometimes to the detriment of less articulate but equally deserving inmates (43:49).
- Quote:
“I just think that it would be better if...the lengths of sentences are too long...as a society, we'd be better off if we kind of capped all sentences at, I don't know, pick a number—15, 20 years.” – Mike Pesca (45:08)
- Lennon reflects that the parole system often demands a depth of introspection and narrative skill that many are ill-equipped for, and that real rehabilitation is rarely supported by the system (45:08–48:44).
Notable Quotes & Moments
-
On the difference between innocence and guilt in crime stories:
"I write about guilty men because I'm guilty myself…I can relate to the most when they're guilty." – John J. Lennon (07:49)
-
On Inside Evil and Chris Cuomo:
"My friend told me...The superintendent told me it was Inside Evil. I was like, no, no, they said it's a different series about redemption. She's like, bro..." – John J. Lennon (12:11)
-
On insider/outsider narratives:
“I try to put myself beneath my characters who also kill. And that's a literary tactic, and that's something obviously [Cuomo] can't do." – John J. Lennon (24:46)
-
On owning his past and finding purpose in writing:
"I'm owning my sh*t on the page. Like, I have a life when I get out. So that's what I'm trying to do." – John J. Lennon (33:37)
-
On technology's double-edged sword in prison:
"I have a love-hate relationship with the technology. Right. Because it's kind of exploitative. But at the same time it's like, they ain't going to give it to you for free." – John J. Lennon (41:23)
Important Timestamps
- 07:14 – Lennon joins, explaining the loaded meaning of “guilty” and “us” in his book title
- 09:36 – Lennon’s critique of true crime’s exploitation
- 12:11–14:06 – The experience of being featured on Cuomo’s “Inside Evil”
- 17:06–17:21 – The pecking order of crimes within prison
- 21:36 – The moment Lennon commits to writing fuller, more authentic stories
- 23:26 – Questioning Chris Cuomo’s authority and perspective in crime storytelling
- 24:46 – Lennon positions himself as “beneath” his subjects
- 33:37 – “Owning my sh*t on the page” and writing as a path to meaning
- 38:59—41:23 – Discussion on advances (and limits) in prison technology and communication
- 43:27 – Lennon on the responsibility of narrative creators
- 45:08–48:44 – The role of narrative in forgiveness, parole, and sentencing
Conclusion
Lennon's perspective—writing from within the prison system about his own and others' guilt—offers a powerful challenge to both the conventions of true crime storytelling and to societal ideas about crime, punishment, and redemption. He critiques exploitation in the genre, calls for more nuanced narratives, and advocates for empathy toward those who admit guilt and strive for accountability.
Guest information:
- John J. Lennon's latest book: The Tragedy of True Crime: Four Guilty Men and the Stories that Define Us
- Selected journalism in The Atlantic, Esquire, New York Times, Sports Illustrated, and more
Host:
- Mike Pesca, The Gist (Peach Fish Productions)
This summary skips all advertisements and non-content sections, focusing exclusively on the substance of the conversation between Mike Pesca and John J. Lennon.