Mike Pesca (30:35)
So it is wrong procedurally and appalling ethically that Blanche and the department has taken this stance. And also, and this is most of what I want to talk about, it is not in the interests of even the Trump administration, I believe, although the Trump administration probably believes that what is in their interest is jutting their jaw out, being defiant and talking to only the ever shrinking portion of the population that wants maximum border or interior enforcement. So many of the analyzes of this center on and it's proper how awful it is that Ross won't be prosecuted. They jump to prosecuted. You hear many mayors fry Mamdani, even more or less moderates like Seth Moulton come out and say that this was a murder. I don't do that just because I was raised in a journalistic tradition where you don't call something a murder until it's been adjudicated as such. But we all know what we saw. And a woman was shot who shouldn't have been shot, who didn't deserve to be shot. And certainly shots number two and three were not, and she might have been dead already, were not justified by any fear that Ross could have been feeling. So most of the analysis, and I won't fault it, jumps to this man should be in jail. But I want to go one step back from that. I want to talk about the procedure. Every single jurisdiction that I know about, and I'm even talking about very conservative, very pro police jurisdictions like Albuquerque or many towns in Texas. They would at least have the fig leaf, the patina of actual investigations. And one of the reasons that you do that is it might not be a fig leaf. I suppose there is a chance that one of these municipalities that never indicts cops would come up with an indictment. And you know, maybe it's more than a possibility, especially if there is a lot of public pressure. Elected officials are sensitive to members of their polity protesting vociferously outside their office in a way that Donald Trump isn't. You know, Donald Trump is one of the few that really likes to be opposed by a lot of people because he thinks, and I don't think he's wrong, that this deepens the passions of his minority of supporters that has gotten him elected in this far. Okay, almost every other place in America at least says they're going to look into it and maybe look into it. And the reason for that is many. You tell the public that you're taking their concerns seriously. You also tell your side. If your side is people who just want the police never to be held to account. You tell them, hey, the people who are acting in your interest, the people who we all hold up as proud defenders of safety and the American way of life, who can almost never do any wrong, hey, they were subject to scrutiny. It kind of helps everyone, just in terms of norms and psychology, but also in terms of actually possibly holding the next person to account or maybe even that person to account if some horrible details emerge or some unavoidable evidence is unearthed that could make you look very, very bad and drive you out of office or drive anyone else who's not Donald Trump out of office. Everything argues for either a real investigation or a fig leaf investigation. Signal to the public that, hey, we're taking this seriously. And then the usual playbook is, and I could be cynical about this or I could just be honest because I've seen and you've seen many investigations go that way, hey, we did our best. This guy isn't going to be indicted. Or then there's the step of you do bring it to a grand jury, but if they don't return the indictment, you're okay. And then sometimes you even bring it to court. Usually prosecutors and local officials won't want to roll the dice on that. But even when bringing a case, a police case to court, the police usually win. The couple of cases in Minnesota being the notable exceptions. Not just Derek Chauvin, but the case of Brooklyn Center Minnesota police officer Kim Potter, who was convicted of killing Dante Wright. This was the case of she went to grab what she thought was a Taser, but she but it was a gun. It's kind of unusual. I wouldn't expect most of those cases to get a guilty verdict, except maybe that time in Minnesota. But if you listen to all of the logic of this, you'd have to say that more of it should apply to Trump Ross, the current state of ice than shouldn't. What I'm arguing is he's making a mistake, even out of self interest. Now I know how Donald Trump thinks and I know how Kristi Noem thinks. And now apparently we know how Todd Blanch thinks, even though he was once a respected member of the New York Bar. Who lawyers I know, who are very, very ethical people held in very high esteem and how they think is. All we need to do is be defiant. All we need to do is play to our people who think law enforcement never does any wrong. All we need to do is to continue to signal to ICE officers to keep doing this. You know, the other day I got a message. I forgot if it was on substack or I don't think it was an email to the Gist account. And it was someone who alleged that I was covering up for fascists and advancing the cause of totalitarianism. And then he asserted, you know, all that Stephen Miller and those in the administration of his ilk want to do is to convince more ICE officers to kill people illegally, to treat it as legal and to foment the maximum amount of carnage and discontent that they can normally in any other times, I'd say, well, that's quite a fanciful story, but you don't have really evidence to back it up. That was not my initial instinct. I have been paying attention to what's going on in Minnesota and America and I have been shocked. Not just because the deaths and the insensitivity are shocking, but also because to generate shock in people like me and maybe people like you now seems to very much be the tactic and strategy of the administration. And that's it for today's show. Cory War is the producer of the Gist. Kathleen Sykes helps me with the Gist list. Great Pesca profundities piece out today. Jeff Craig is in charge of moving images. You know, he also does some audio editing. I don't like to brag too much about Jeff. Multi talented fellow Leah Yan is the production coordinator of Peach Fish Productions and Michelle Pesca is the COO in quite a coup for Peach Fish Productions in Peru. G Peru do Peru. And thanks for listening.