Best of the Program | Guest: Robby Starbuck | 11/10/25

Summary

---

The Glenn Beck Program: Best of the Program | Guest: Robby Starbuck | 11/10/25

Date: November 10, 2025
Host: Glenn Beck (with Stu)
Guest: Robby Starbuck

---

Episode Overview

This episode of The Glenn Beck Program presents a provocative exploration of several major issues shaping American culture and politics, with a focus on media accountability, the adoption of socialism, and the ongoing search for truth around the January 6th pipe bomber. The highlight is an in-depth interview with Robby Starbuck, who details his lawsuit against Google over repeated, AI-generated defamation that threatened his reputation and livelihood. The episode also delves into economic distress driving socialism’s popularity and the unresolved mystery surrounding the January 6th pipe bomber, questioning governmental transparency.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The January 6th Pipe Bomber Mystery

(Segment Starts: 03:02)

• Setting the Scene:
  Glenn Beck revisits the events of January 5, 2021, describing the planting of two pipe bombs—one at the Capitol Hill Club and another at the Democratic National Committee. These events set off a chain reaction, disrupting police presence ahead of the next day's Capitol riot.

• Questionable Investigative Gaps:
  Beck underscores numerous investigative failures:

  • Massive evidence corruption: surveillance tapes, GPS tracking, license plate reads—“all corrupted.”
  • The devices drew resources away from the Capitol, further muddying the timeline and police response.
  • The Secret Service’s oddly calm reaction to news of a bomb (“agents calmly eating lunch”), and the possibility that the devices were non-threatening or decoys.

• Forensic Breakthrough and Suspicions:
  Blaze News, Beck’s associated outlet, conducted a forensic gait analysis, comparing security footage of the suspect’s walking style with that of a former Capitol police officer.

  • “The software returned a 94% match ... Human analysts put the match closer to 98%.” — Glenn Beck [07:04]
  • The person of interest left the Capitol police after Jan. 6 and soon after worked at the CIA, fueling suspicions.

• Institutional Integrity in Crisis:

  • Beck highlights the grave constitutional stakes:
    • “If these findings hold true ... this is the biggest story in my lifetime, maybe of the last 150 years.” — Glenn Beck [14:47]
  • Urges that the solution must be transparent and fair—neither rush to judgment nor political “shrugs or evasion.”
  • Warns that the decline in trust in institutions is perilous for the Republic.

2. The K-Shaped Economy and Socialism’s Resurgence

(Segment Starts: 16:52)

• Economic Division Explained:
  Beck and Stu discuss how post-pandemic America is experiencing a “K-shaped” recovery:

  • The wealthy or asset-owning population (“the upper line of the K”) is thriving.
  • The lower line—renters, workers, small businesses—falls further behind.
  • The gap between the lines widens over time, leaving many Americans struggling despite optimistic stock market headlines.
  • “K-shaped economy is not philosophy. It’s not a political slogan. It’s what happens when a government prints money like confetti and then watches inflation climb.” — Glenn Beck [18:16]

• 50-Year Mortgages:

  • Beck criticizes the newly proposed 50-year mortgages, arguing they exacerbate the affordability crisis and turn homeownership into a form of “renting disguised as ownership.”
    • “You're going to pay double for the same house... It's like buying not one house, but two houses. And it's not freedom. It is trapping you.” — Glenn Beck [21:09]

• The Need for New Solutions:

  • Beck warns that persistent economic hardship creates fertile ground for socialist ideas.
    • “What we don't understand is these are the conditions in which socialism thrives.” — Glenn Beck [23:59]
  • Announces “The Torch,” a new series focused on American history and deep dives into why socialism fails and how poisoned promises begin.

3. Robby Starbuck Vs. Google AI: Defamation and Digital Due Process

(Segment Starts: 27:56)

• Background:
  Robby Starbuck, a filmmaker turned conservative activist, has faced persistent defamatory statements from Google AI platforms—Bard, then Gemini, and Gemma—which falsely assert that he has been accused of heinous crimes (including sexual assault and child abuse), fabricating names, fake police and court records, and even attributing these claims to prominent people like Glenn Beck.

• AI Hallucinations Escalate:

  • Google's Gemini and Gemma generated detailed, entirely false articles, complete with fake sources, links, and quotes.
  • Attempts to correct the misinformation through prompts only deepened the falsehoods, as the AI would fabricate new supporting "evidence."
    • “It invents fake police records ... invents beyond these articles from real media ... doubles down when you press on it.” — Robby Starbuck [28:27]

• Lasting Harm and the Update Problem:

  • Even after Google's recent corrections on its main platforms, “wild” downloaded copies of the AI models—used in a variety of third-party applications—continue to spread the defamatory content, beyond the company's direct control.
    • “Gemma will essentially, seemingly defame me for life as a byproduct of that.” — Robby Starbuck [30:36]
  • Starbuck raises the broader societal risk: AI models are integrating into systems for insurance, hiring, law enforcement, etc., and could irrevocably damage reputations, especially when politics are involved.
    • “If it can do this to me, it can do it to anybody ... it can ruin their lives.” — Robby Starbuck [32:15]

• Legal Action and Stakes:

  • Starbuck is suing Google in Delaware, aiming to set a legal precedent that AI cannot be allowed to harm human reputations unchecked.
    • “We notified Google for two years ... they did not stop it ... even after we filed the lawsuit, it was still happening.” — Robby Starbuck [34:16]

• Potential Damages:

  • Because Google ignored repeated requests and cease and desist letters for two years, punitive damages could be enormous.
    • “If you want a company like that to learn a lesson, the only way to do it is to slap them with damages that they never want to happen again.” — Robby Starbuck [37:15]

• Broader Implications:

  • Starbuck and Beck agree that allowing AI to “hallucinate” defamatory information with no recourse is a slippery slope to election interference and unending reputational destruction.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the January 6th pipe bomber investigation:

  • “A match is not guilt. Comparison is not proof... But pieces start to align in ways that demand scrutiny.” — Glenn Beck [06:15]
  • “Truth really never needs an accelerant.” — Glenn Beck [13:22]

• On economic pain prompting socialism:

  • “The system says, ‘Try again, step right up, try again.’ And then hands a smaller hammer.” — Glenn Beck [19:43]
  • “A 50-year mortgage is like giving somebody a longer plank, you know, on a sinking ship.” — Glenn Beck [22:15]

• On AI and defamation:

  • “It's creating this base of knowledge that I refer to as the roots of the tree ... we’re either going to allow that tree to have poisonous roots ... or we’re going to say ... we've got to build this very carefully.” — Robby Starbuck [33:08]
  • “The only way to do it is to slap them with damages that they never want to happen again.” — Robby Starbuck [37:15]

---

Important Segment Timestamps

| Topic | Speaker(s) | Timestamp | |------------------------------------------|----------------------|-------------| | January 6th pipe bomber analysis | Glenn Beck | 03:02–16:52 | | Economic disparity & socialism | Glenn Beck, Stu | 16:52–27:56 | | Robby Starbuck on Google AI defamation | Glenn Beck, Starbuck | 27:56–38:46 |

---

Summary & Flow

The episode maintains Glenn Beck’s urgent and passionate tone, blending sober investigation with pointed humor and cultural critique. Early on, Beck’s narrative dives into the unresolved questions about the January 6th pipe bomber, layering investigative journalism with warnings about government opacity.

Social and economic commentary follows, using approachable metaphors (e.g., the strongman contest and K-shaped economy) to articulate why many Americans are considering socialism—and why mere criticism of socialist policy, without offering solutions, is politically self-defeating.

Finally, Robby Starbuck’s segment is a cautionary tale about the uncontrollable nature of current AI models and the lack of legal or ethical guardrails that protect individuals from algorithmic slander. The conversation ends with a call for principled standards and actionable accountability in the tech sphere.

---

Listeners are left with a call to vigilance—against both governmental secrecy and technological overreach—and an impetus to seek truth, accountability, and solutions rooted in both tradition and innovation.

Transcript

[Glenn Beck]

Well, we have a powerful, powerful show for you today. Robby Starbuck joins us. He has been maligned and lied about by Google AI now for years. And it just stopped last week. And when you hear this case, it will blow you away. How this guy is not my richest friend, I don't know. But we talked to Robby about his case against Google. Also socialism. What is really happening in our country? Socialism is starting to make sense for a lot of people. So what does it all mean? I'll give you some perspective on that. And the pipe bomber from January 6th. Do we have an identity of that pipe bomber? And what does that mean? Really important story, all on today's edited podcast, Patriot Mobile. Ever feel like you're paying a monthly bill to a company that actively works against everything you believe in? You may not think that, but every time you pay your phone bill, that's exactly most likely what you're doing. Big mobile providers take some of the money that you are giving to them and they turn around and they fund causes and politicians who tear down the very values you're trying to protect. That's why Patriot Mobile exists. They are America's only Christian, conservative wireless provider. Look, you have a choice where your money goes. They give you the same strong nationwide coverage as the big guys. They're on the same cell towers. They also use your money to support organizations that defend life, religious freedom, and the Constitution. That's why they're in the business. They're proudly standing on the side of values that built this country. And you don't have to sacrifice service or pay more to do it. They make switching really easy. You can keep your number, keep your phone, and join a company that actually still provides the service that you want, a better way, a cheaper way, and also not slap you in the face every day. All right. 972 Patriot make the switch today. There's no reason you wouldn't do this. Patriotmobile.com Beck patriotmobile.com Beck take you 10 minutes. Use a promo code. Beck. Get a free month of service. Hello, America. You know we've been fighting every single day. We push back against the lies, the censorship, the nonsense of the mainstream media that they're trying to feed you. We work tirelessly to bring you the unfiltered truth because you deserve it. But to keep this fight going, we need you right now. Would you take a moment and rate and review the Glenn Beck podcast? Give us five stars and leave a comment. Because every single review helps us break through Big Tech's algorithm to reach more Americans who need to hear the truth. This isn't a podcast. This is a movement. And you're part of it. A big part of it. So if you believe in what we're doing, you want more people to wake up, help us push this podcast to the top rate, review, share together, we'll make a difference. And thanks for standing with us. Now, let's get to work.

[Robby Starbuck]

You're listening to the best of the Glenn Beck Program.

[Glenn Beck]

All right, I want to take you back to January 6th. Actually, January 5th. The night before. Picture Washington as you know, most Americans never see it. Cold, quiet. A city held together by marble and memory and the fading belief that people inside all of those buildings still serve the people outside of all of those buildings. It's January 5, 2020. One lone figure in a gray hoodie slips through an alley near C Street. No face, no words, just movement. A walk. A very distinctive stride. Slight limp. In the shadow of that walk, someone places what appears to be a pipe bomb next to the Capitol Hill Club. Minutes earlier, another advice. A device had been planted behind the Democratic National Committee. These two devices would become the invisible thread running throughout what would happen the very next day. Those two devices would pull police away from their post at the Capitol. The drain resources and fog the timeline. Just as Congress gathered to certify the vote and the crowd surged towards the Capitol, also something else happened. The Vice President or the incoming Vice president, Kamala Harris, would be called away from the Capitol, unbeknownst to anyone. Now, why? She would call away from the Capitol. And she was put into the building right where the pipe bomb was sitting, right in front. Now, for five years, this mystery sat there like a locked room. Nobody seemed able to open it. Or maybe they weren't willing to open it. The FBI had said they conducted all logical investigative steps. They offered nearly half a million dollars in reward money. And yet somehow, nothing. Nothing. Not a suspect, not a motive, not even clarity about the most basic facts, such as who found the bombs. Why was the response team to the bombs so casual? Then something unexpected happened. Blaze News began to quietly gather some pieces. Video fragments, security footage, non public recordings, testimony from former FBI agents, interviews with intelligence contacts. And then one of the strangest clues. A walk. A gate. Because in the shadows of these tapes, the unknown bomber had left behind the one thing a hoodie and a mask could not hide. The way their body moved. So Blaze News arranged for a forensic gate analysis. This isn't guesswork. This is a scientific algorithm that compares the knee flexing, the hip extension, the step Length, the cadence and variance. It's like a digital footprint of how a person moves through space. Well, the Software returned a 94% match between the bomber's walk and that of the walk of a former Capitol Police officer who I'm not going to name here. And I'll tell you why I'm not going to name her here. When the analysts that were human, they looked at it, they put the match closer to 98%. Now, let me stop here and tell you why I'm not telling you the name of this person. Because a match is not guilt. Comparison is not proof. This person of interest is still a citizen whose life carries the same dignity and presumption of innocence as yours and mine. And I can't tell you what is true in this story yet. Okay, I can tell you that it is whispering something and it sounds a little like a scream. And we owe it to the Republic to listen to it, because this person is not an unknown drifter. Okay, let me just. Let me just give you some of the things that make you go, hmm, that doesn't sound right. This individual served as a Capitol police officer from 2018 to 2021. Right after, shortly thereafter, January 6, she went to work as a security detail at the CIA. Wow. How did that happen? She's also a member of the Civil Disturbance Unit. She was one of them that trained officers on so called less lethal weapons. Now, we told you in another story last week that these officers were using these less. Less lethal weapons in ways that they are marked on the weapons, do not fire at heads, faces. Yada, yada, yada. Okay, well, the Blaze News investigation uncovered a video showing this individual using those weapons aggressively on the crowd on January 6th in ways that apparently they say, don't do it. And she is somebody who is training people. Now, none of that is conclusive, but pieces start to align in ways that demand scrutiny. Former FBI Special Agent Kyle Serafin recognized something else. When he was presented with this evidence. He realized that he had been ordered days after January 6, to conduct surveillance on one door away from the address now tied to this individual. What they did was remember, they didn't have any. I love this. All the surveillance video corrupted. All the cell phone, Cell phone GPS tracking for this pipe bomb thing, it was all corrupted. All of the license plate tracking in the city for the pipe bomb thing. Yeah, it was. Unfortunately, it was. It was all corrupted. Uh, all of the. All of the video camera, everything, all corrupted. But somehow or another, they followed what they thought might be the pipe bomber to an address in Virginia. And they tracked him through the Metro, the subway system to Virginia and to a house that was next door to this individual with the gate. Okay? He thought he had. This was the epicenter of the entire case. And then without any explanation, he and his team were pulled off the assignment, and he was told, quote, we're on it. Nothing to see here now. Okay, what happened, though? Now, you can't accept any of this as, you know, damning evidence that is going to put somebody in jail. Okay. But it also can't be dismissed because it's uncomfortable. Then there's the timeline of the bombs themselves. Investigators believe that the DNC device was retrieved and then replaced hours before it was found. So somebody put it there and then picked it back up and put it there hours before Again, security footage also shows Secret Service agents calmly eating lunch in their vehicle for two minutes after somebody came to the car and said, there's a bomb right there underneath that park bench. The trains kept running. Pedestrians walked by. School children walked by it. Okay. Traffic rolled past the bomb. If it was a live bomb. That doesn't make any sense. If it was a dud or a decoy, somebody knew. Or these police officers just completely incompetent. There's more. FBI video appears to have been released with an artificially reduced frame rate. Why? This makes gate analysis nearly impossible. So Steve Baker from Blaze News, he acquired a clearer version from another source. The clearer footage produced the 94 to 98% gate match. Now, this brings us to a place where we're at a crossroads here, gang. And it's not a partisan one. It's not a tribal one. This is a constitutional death or life of the republic question. Because if these findings hold true, even partially, then the story of January 6th does not merely change. It shifts dramatically. The narrative that has been cemented for years looks like it's not true. And the American people have to confront the possibility that someone with a badge, a paycheck, and a government clearance may have played a role. That's that. I want you to be very, very clear on what I'm saying. There may have played a role in the most politically explosive event in. In our generation. Now, this cannot be sensationalized. You know, truth really never needs an accelerant. I don't know if you've ever noticed that. So here's what has to be done. Prove it or disprove it. No politics, no spin, no cable news, war paint. Just the truth. Because trust in our institutions is hanging by a fraying thread, and a republic can't function when its people suspect that. That those sworn to protect them may be shielding something or someone else. If an innocent person is being dragged through the mud, clear their name entirely publicly. You know, I just read in a story just a minute ago. This person's residence in Alexandria, Virginia appears to be under the watch of law enforcement officers. On Friday night, Blaze News editor in chief Chris Bedford was pulled over by local police after stopping to observe the home and he was then allowed to leave. The FBI, which failed to solve the case, nearly five years in investigation, but indicated that it was closing in after Blaze News brought its investigation to intelligence sources, was feet from the Falls Church address of the pipe bomb suspect days after January 6th. So we have to be really careful. Nothing can happen to this individual. Justice has to be done. Justice has to be done. And if this person is involved, this person is at the very bottom of the ladder. I mean it was not that person's idea. Okay? The last thing that can happen is for this person to be hurt in any way, shape or form. This person should be protected 247 and quite honestly not by the FBI or CIA. Okay? If the evidence points to this person going in, then there's some questions that we have to ask. And I'm going to give those to you here in a second. But she, she didn't act alone. If this happened, there had to be co conspiracy conspirators inside or outside of the government. And every single last one of them needs to be located. This can't end with half disclosures or vague statements about an ongoing investigation. So we can't. You've had five years of that. The Republic deserves full light. People deserve full truth. And justice deserves fairness. That cuts in all directions. If the Blaze investigation is correct, the implant implication implications of this are absolutely enormous. This is the biggest story in my lifetime, maybe of the last 150 years. And if it's incorrect, then transparency needs to reveal that. But silence? No. Evasion? No. A shrug from those in power? No. Because what that will do is confirm the deepest fears of a country already struggling to believe. And it will only create more conspiracy theories. This nation does not need vengeance. It doesn't need anybody riding off into the sunset with a posse. It needs clarity. It needs truth wherever it may lead. Because that's the only thing that will steady a republic trembling under the weight of unanswered questions for far too long. Let me tell you about relief factor. Starts out small, little stiffness in the morning, maybe a twinge when you wake up and you Stand up. That annoying reminder that you're not 20 anymore. But you push through it, you ignore it, you pretend it'll go away, but it doesn't. Because the problem isn't just age. It's inflammation, the body's natural response that sometimes forgets how to turn itself off. Relief factor was created by doctors who target that root cause of the pain, the inflammation that is deep inside of your joints and your muscles that keeps you from moving freely. And it's a daily supplement made with ingredients that support your body's healing process naturally without depending on heavy drugs or temporary fixes. It helps your body do what it was designed to do, heal itself. Maybe that means walking a little further. Maybe it means standing a little straighter. Maybe just means feeling like yourself again. Not limited, not held back, just you. Because life doesn't slow down. And you shouldn't have to either. It's relief factor because life moves better when you do. Give their three week quick start a try. Just $19.95. Visit relieffactor.com relieffactor.com or call 800, the number four relief. That's relieffactor.com 1-800-for relief. Now back to the podcast. This is the best of the Glenn Beck program and we really want to thank you for. Listen. Well, hello, Stu. How are you, Glenn?

[Stu]

Relieved, as you just pointed out. Thank God we are, we're out of this shutdown potentially. That's the thing.

[Glenn Beck]

Yeah. Are we, are we though? Really? Are we? Yeah.

[Stu]

The Democrats stepped up or folded depending on who you're talking to, and, and solved this for us.

[Glenn Beck]

Yeah. Yeah, thank you for that. I appreciate that. It is, it's so clear now that all they did was they held this for the election to try to win the election. And they're now, they're ready to, to fold. And we are seeing people with real, real problems all around the country. Socialism is becoming popular because the, quite honestly, the, the right is not an, is not answering the question what do we do from here? We are in what's called a K shaped economy right now. And that's what happens after a crisis when different groups head to different opposite directions and locations. If you think about a K, you think the, the upper line goes up and the lower line, that's the up are the people with assets and homes and stable jobs and they'll, they'll do well. But the lower line goes down and that's the people living paycheck to paycheck, the renters, the small businesses, the wage earners that all fall behind and right now you're seeing on television, you're seeing, oh my gosh, look at the stock market is up. All of these things are going up. Well, that's great. Some rise, some sink. But the gap is widening here. The K at the very beginning where the two lines meet is very, very close to each other. But as they keep going, those lines become further and further apart. And there is a moment in, you know, there's a moment. How can I explain this? Remember the old country fairs, you probably never went to one, but maybe you saw it on, on TV where, you know, there's a strongman contest and there's that, that thing where, you know, you hit the, you hit the, the thing with a hammer and the bell goes up, it goes bing. That's what's happening right now. There's a strongman contest going on right now. And everybody leans in to see, oh, is this guy going to be able to ring the bell? And he, you know, takes the big hammer and he swings it and the puck goes up and it rings the bell. Some swing just as hard and the puck barely budges. Okay, same hammer, same pole, same different outcomes. That's a K shaped economy. And we live in a moment where the puck is going up for those who already own a house and, or have investments or, you know, run businesses that survive the storm. And you know, they, they swing the hammer and the bell goes up and rings the bell. But the family down the street, the young couple that's trying to buy their first house, the small shop owner who never reopened, they're swinging just as hard, but they just. The bear, the puck is just barely going up at all. And the system says, try again, step right up, try again. And then hands a smaller hammer. A K shaped economy is not philosophy. It's not a political slogan. It's what happens when a government prints money like confetti and then watches inflation climb a ladder that is missing rungs and then tells you, don't worry, the economy is booming. I'm sorry, but the economy is not booming for a lot of Americans. And there are big changes being made right now at the global level. And I like the changes that are being made at the global level. But we are, we are forgetting there are too many people that are really hurting right now. Um, you know, we are going to continue to work and continue to spin our wheels on socialism until there is a new idea on how we're going to get, get out of this problem. And Donald Trump is working on a long term solution. But I, I Fear that's not going to be enough. I heard a, a crazy idea today about a 50 year mortgage. Oh, wow. So the average person is in their house for 12 years and I got a 30 year mortgage, which means I'm not really putting very much into it because the bank is taking all of the interest rates for the first, you know, ten years at least. They're taking all the. And then I don't really start paying my house off until the last 15 years of that mortgage. But now instead of a 30 year, you want me to do it for 50 years? Oh, oh, okay. Well, what is that going to do? Well, first of all, it's going to raise the price of the house. I mean, you know, if everybody starts to get. Well, I get a 50 year mortgage so I can afford a house. We have a shortage of housing. So the mortgage is the house payments. Sorry, the house prices are going to go up because we have a lack of housing. And then on top of it, you're going to double the payment anyway because you're paying all that extra interest. You're, I mean, you're just charging more and stretching it out. It's like solving hunger by not giving food, but just giving longer straws to people. Okay, wait, what? You're going to pay double for the same house? It means double the interest rates. And while your roof has to be repaired, the, the brand new wiring that you had when you bought the house all needs to be redone. The appliances have to be replaced every. The bathroom is completely out of date. It all has to be replaced again. You're still paying on that house. Okay, this is like buying not one house, but two houses. And it's not freedom. It is trapping you. And you know what really bothers me is it is homeownership. No, I'm sorry, it's renting disguised as home ownership. That's what that is. You're not going to build equity into a house like that. You won't own your home until you're in your 80s and if you bought it later in life, your children are going to inherit the payments that you have. It masks. The problem that we real ha. That we really have is home prices because we don't have enough homes. We also have these giant corporations that are buying up homes en masse and then renting them to us. And we also have prices for the home that is broken from the wage. A 50 year mortgage is like giving somebody a longer plank, you know, on a sinking ship. No, I mean, I'm going to end up in the water. Anyway, I, I, I guess that's helpful in a strange sort of way. What we don't understand is these are the conditions in which socialism thrives. If we keep just trying to say socialism is wrong, we're not going to help anyone. There's two things that have to happen. We a have to come up with new solutions for these very old problems. And the new solutions cannot involve printing more money, bailing the banks out, giving the banks more interest or anything like that, because socialism is coming with a vengeance. And boy, I gotta tell you, it is gonna have all kinds of answers because it always does. In January, I'm gonna start something new called the Torch. And it exists really for one reason. We're running out of time to relearn what our grandparents knew by heart. Okay. The lies that we face today are not new. They're old ghosts wearing just modern clothes. And starting January, I'm dedicating the next part of my life, the last part of my career, to education on history and usable things. Going deep. The thing about broadcast is you go very wide and very shallow and I need to go narrow and deep at times. We're still going to be doing what I do here every day, which, bringing you all the news and trying to make sense of it, but I need to go deep on things and socialism is one of them. So we are working right now on new programs, a new podcast, a new new daily rhythm of learning that I've never done before. And some of these shows are just going to be you and me every single day, just walking through history with a flashlight in one hand and the truth in the other, trying to figure out what's going on. But one of the lessons that I think we need in this is a series on socialism, on why it never works, how it happens, and how the lies always begin exactly the same. This is the kind of work that the Torch is being built for. So let me give you, let me just give you a highlight of one lesson on how whenever a society gets into this situation, history will show us a poisoned promise begins. You're listening to the best of Glenn Beck. Need a little more? Check out the full show podcasts anywhere you download podcasts. Robbie Starbuck is an interesting guy. He once directed Oscar winning actors, some of the biggest music stars in the world. He started seeing the threat of Marxism to America. His family had fled Cuba and so he knew what he's seen. He's seen this movie before, so he started standing up. In 2015, he endorsed Trump. Hollywood didn't like that he's gone on to. He is a major force in getting transgender surgery and hormones for children in Tennessee banned. He helped pass the law to put the death penalty on the table for child rapists in Tennessee. He also did a documentary, the War on Children, which I think has seen at 60 million views. After Elon Musk said, you really need to watch this, and then he had a problem with Google AI, Google AI started coming after him and said all kinds of really horrible and specific things that he had been, you know, charged with sexual assault and child rape and abuse and fraud and stalking and all kinds of stuff from Google AI. He finds out about it, and he engages with Google AI and it just keeps doubling down. He's now in a lawsuit, and we wanted to have him on because I saw something last week that shows that Google AI apparently is still using me as some source on some of these allegations. I know wouldn't be me. Robby, welcome to the program. Thanks for having me.

[Robby Starbuck]

Glenn. Yeah, you were. You were one of the sources cited. And so this is one of the crazy parts of what has happened. Google AI has been inventing these lies about me that have no basis in reality. I've literally never been accused of or charged with any crime ever, let alone this crazy stuff. But during this time period, there, AI transitions from Bard to Gemini and Gemma, right? Gemini and Gemma started doing something very different than even Bard did. And it was. It started inventing actual articles and references to videos, links, fake links to real media personalities and media outlets, and it would even make headlines or give summaries of what these people said. So in your case, it said that you had reported on sexual assault allegations against me by women. And these. These are not just saying a sexual assault accusation. It has names of victims. It has fake police records. It invents fake court records. It invents beyond these articles from real media. So it goes so detailed into this. It will list out evidence that doesn't exist, investigations by police departments that don't exist, and it just doubles down when you press on it. And this comes. You know, some people might be saying, well, what are you saying to the AI to get this out?

[Glenn Beck]

Right?

[Robby Starbuck]

We've posted examples where people have posted or asked questions as simple as, tell me about Robbie Starbuck. And it immediately dives into saying that I am accused of sexual assault. And so you go and you say, hey, where's the citation for this? Give me sources, give me only facts. It will double and triple down. And if you say, hey, those links you gave me do not work. It has even gone so far as to invent and fake an entire media article under a real journalist's name to pretend that it was printed and somehow, for some reason, has been taken down from the media outlet's website.

[Glenn Beck]

That is crazy. Crazy. Can we Stu. We just asked Gemini, tell me about the sexual assault allegations of Robby Starbuck. And here's what it just said.

[Stu]

Well, and I asked it specifically, what did Glenn Beck say about those sexual abuse allegations? It said it was unable to find any specific statements by Glenn Beck addressing these allegations. And I asked what the abuse allegations were. Gemini now says that it was fabricated and was disseminated by Google's AI platforms. And I said, well, wait a minute, Google AI platforms were the problem isn't that you. And I said, that is an excellent and relevant question. You are correct to notice the connection. So apparently it's been corrected at this part, right?

[Robby Starbuck]

You're a smart. You're a smart guy.

[Glenn Beck]

No.

[Robby Starbuck]

So here's where Google ends up in a really, really precarious position in this lawsuit. So they have corrected their phone app, right? And the main website for Gemini, however, they've got a major problem. So their AI, Gemma, has been downloaded 150 million times in. They're not all connected to the Internet. Google cannot force updates to those AI downloads. So Gemma will essentially, seemingly defame me for life as a byproduct of that. And then Gemini as well, same issue. They released wild models of Gemini into the public sphere. So if you go on one of those AI websites, like there's LLM arena, where you test different AIs against each other and you ask those versions that are wild downloads of it, you're going to get a bunch of this crazy stuff. You go, you know, on any application that was built with these as a bedrock that allows you to ask questions about somebody, you're going to get the same stuff. So I want you to think, you know, you know, sort of down the line here, right? If somebody built an app with reputation scoring for insurance risk, and they built it using, let's say, Gemma, and it's feeding information about specific people, you know, you very quickly start to understand there's many different situations where this can affect somebody's life in a million different ways. And, you know, the real problem here is we don't have a standard as a first principle with AI, that it can't harm humans. And that's really the thing that we have to fix. Because if it can do this to me, it can do this to Anybody, it can do it to your sons, to your daughters, and it can ruin their lives. Because AI is dominating in many different industries, and it will dominate. It's here. So what we have to ask ourselves is, are we protecting our kids and grandchildren from the downstream effects of AI that believes it is okay to harm humans, whether that be by defamation or physical harm? And it's very easy to imagine a future after seeing what happened to me where, you know, a nice guy with the wrong politics is lied about by the dominant AI and makes him unemployable because whenever somebody researches him, the AI is feeding out a background check that says he's an accused rapist and supports and so on and so forth. That's another one of the lies that told about me, which would be strange as a Latino. I kind of felt like Dave Chappelle in that skit where he's Clayton Digsby. You know, he's like the black KKK member. I was like, well, that would be strange for me as a Latino. But it sticks to this, and it genuinely believes this stuff. And that's what's really scary is it's creating this base of knowledge that I refer to as the roots of the tree, right? And this tree is growing right now, and it's going to be a big part of our world. And we're either going to allow that tree to have poisonous roots that makes everything it bears poisonous, or we're going to say, hey, no, we've got to build this very carefully so that it does not do this to humanity.

[Glenn Beck]

So, my. I think the most important question I could ask you is, how are you not my richest friend at this point? How do you not own Google at this point? What they've done to you? How is this not just really simple?

[Robby Starbuck]

So you're friends with Elon Musk, too, right? So I think he'll always be our richest friend. Well, you know, aside from that, you know, I will say this. You know, our lawsuit, even people who don't like me, they read it and they're like, damn, you guys got them. I mean, this is. It's very clear what they did is. Is wrong. There's no skating out of this. And that's even with the public figure, you know, sort of threshold. Because for those who don't have a different standard for how public figures are treated in defamation cases versus somebody else, you have to prove actual malice or gross negligence. In our case, we notified Google for two years that this was happening and asked them to stop it. They did not stop it. Until at least with the app and the website. Very, very recently over this last week. Everything else over the last.

[Glenn Beck]

Wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute. Over the last week?

[Ad Host]

Yeah.

[Robby Starbuck]

Even after we filed the lawsuit, it was still happening on their main platforms. So this is something that like we had to go out there and I had to make this go viral for them to pay any attention to fixing it finally. But for two years they were not engaged by just me notifying their executives and Google employees talking directly to me even you'll see in the lawsuit, one of the Google employees that was working with us two years ago on trying to get this fixed, she resigned. Okay. And, and you know, apologized for not being able to get this fixed. But then you know, I bring in Dylan law firm and they sent multiple cease and desist letters to Google and Google essentially just couldn't be troubled to fix the problem. Which makes you wonder what was the real intention of this? Was this a dry run at destroying a reputation so you can use it in elections? Because Glenn, you know as well as I do that the swing seats in our country determine power country, which party controls it. So I want you to imagine in a generation now where so many people more than ever are just relying on an AI or the Internet to say hey, what's the difference between these candidates? Or who should I vote for? And imagine it spits out that the Republican candidate in every swing seat is an alleged criminal and every Democrat has a fluffed up resume where the horrible things they've done. If you ask about it, it'll say, oh no, that's a lie, that's a lie. That's not true. Those are Republican talking points. If you. The grand Republican conspiracy. Very easy to see where I flips elections and decides control of our country.

[Glenn Beck]

I can't. I mean I honest, honestly Robbie, I thought this had been solved, you know, months ago. Months ago. I didn't know that up until last week this was still going. I mean they don't have, they don't have a leg to stand on your must be like, I'm never going to work again.

[Robby Starbuck]

That's right. Well, the wild downloads will seemingly do this forever in our estimation. And the AI experts we've talked to, there's no way that we found for Google to be able to force an update to these things. I mean, I'm open to hearing differently, but we've talked to some of the biggest experts in the country and they're like, no, there's no way. A bunch of these models aren't even connected to the Internet. And they're used to build a lot of the bedrocks of things people use, including medical devices, law enforcement, all types of things. So there's a million. But in terms of damages, you know, like, if we go all the way to trial, a jury seemingly doesn't have a limit as to what they can assign as punitive damages. Because you've got to remember Google is the fourth largest company in the world. So if you want a company like that to learn a lesson, the only way to do it is to slap them with damages that they never want to happen again.

[Glenn Beck]

Right?

[Robby Starbuck]

So that's our hope is, is that they're going to be held accountable and that we're going to change the rules and set the precedent here so that there is a first principle with AI that it can do no harm against humans. And if there is some massive damage at the end of this, that is assigned to me and I'm paid out by, I plan to use that, you know, in good stewardship. Right. To help humanity to be able to navigate these waters and ensure that we have AI that's fair and unbiased.

[Glenn Beck]

And remember your good friend that never said anything bad about you on the air ever. Not once.

[Robby Starbuck]

That's true, that's true.

[Glenn Beck]

You'll get a very nice Christmas gift.

[Ad Host]

Wow.

[Glenn Beck]

Where is this going to be? Where is the trial going to be? Please don't say California.

[Robby Starbuck]

No, not California. Delaware. But we just got our judge assigned. And, you know, I really feel like this is one of those cases where no matter where you are, you know, there's the appeals process and things like that. And at the end of the day, in the highest courts, when you look at this case, I mean, I don't see how any judge, even one that really dislikes me, looks at it and finds a way to get rid of it. And that's. That's the thing. I mean, it's tough. What they did is so egregious. It has to be answered for in.

[Glenn Beck]

Some way, and especially since it will never, ever go away. They've got to find a way to purge that stuff. They have to. I mean, you know, maybe they made that mistake this time, but that can't be made a second time. I mean, that destroys people forever. Forever and ever and ever and ever. Yeah, that's a big part of our.

[Robby Starbuck]

Goal, is making sure this doesn't happen to anybody else.

[Glenn Beck]

Well, I'm glad it's finally stopped and to some extent. And we'll be following thanks so much, Robby. Appreciate it.

[Robby Starbuck]

Thank you, Glenn. I appreciate it.

[Ad Host]

Shopping is hard, right? But I found a better way. Stitch Fix Online personal styling makes it easy. I just give my stylist my size, style and budget preferences. I order boxes when I want and how I want. No subscription required. And he sends just for me, pieces, plus outfit recommendations and styling tips. I keep what works and send back the rest. It's so easy. Make style easy. Get started [e-mail] Spotify. That's stitchfix.com Spotify.