The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio
Episode: Cloak and Dagger – “Windfall”
Host: Adam Graham
Original Air Date: October 22, 1950
Podcast Release: December 13, 2025

Main Theme / Episode Purpose

This episode features the final adventure from the classic radio drama Cloak and Dagger: “Windfall.” Drawing from real-life OSS (Office of Strategic Services, WWII-era intelligence) files, the episode immerses listeners in an espionage tale of neutrality, patriotism, and moral reckoning. Host Adam Graham introduces and then reflects on a drama about an American gambler, Mike Slade, caught between self-interest and higher ideals in wartime Switzerland.

Key Discussion Points and Story Breakdown

1. Setting the Scene (Starts ~[02:46])

• Location: Noirmont Lodge, on the Swiss border near Nazi-occupied France during WWII.
• Main Characters:
  • Mike Slade, American gambler and self-proclaimed neutral
  • Jen, his Swiss girlfriend, a ski instructor
  • Frederick Haywood, apparent American diplomat/spy
  • McAllister, OSS agent
  • Keitel and Wierstadt, Gestapo agents

2. Arrival of a Mysterious American ([02:46]–[08:00])

• Haywood checks into the lodge, arouses Slade’s curiosity.

• Jen deduces Haywood must have crossed the border on foot, implying clandestine activities.

  “There aren’t any Americans touring France these days.”
  — Jen, [08:26]

• Slade pitches card games in hopes of making money—highlighting his personal motivation ("I'm what they call a neutral, I guess." – Slade, [06:40]).

3. The Murder and the Microfilm ([10:39]–[14:00])

• Slade and Jen discover Haywood’s murdered body after hearing a disturbance.

• Haywood’s dying words: “Shoe… heel… left shoe… McAllister” ([12:07]).

• Slade finds a cylinder of microfilm hidden in the heel.

  “That’s no bullet, baby. It’s a cylinder of microfilm.”
  — Slade, [13:16]

• Jen hides the film for safety at Slade’s request.

4. Intrigue and Conflicting Loyalties ([14:00]–[22:00])

• Nazis Keitel and Wierstadt, as well as OSS agent McAllister, express interest in the microfilm.

• McAllister offers Slade a deal for the microfilm, urging him to consider its vital importance to the Allied war effort.

  “Those are pictures...showing the location of every Nazi V2 rocket launching site on the French coast. They could mean the saving of thousands of lives.”
  — McAllister, [19:09]

• Slade remains fixated on monetary gain, raising his price as different parties apply pressure (first 25,000 francs, then 50,000 dollars).

• Jen is appalled at Mike’s greed and loses faith in his love:

  “I love you, Mike. But I couldn't go on loving you if you did a thing like this. I‘d come to hate you.”
  — Jen, [23:33]

5. Climax: Violence and Decision ([23:47]–[28:00])

• Nazis assault and torture Slade and Jen, trying to force the film’s location.

• McAllister intervenes heroically during a gunfight, rescuing both.

• Despite being given another chance to sell the film, Slade challenges McAllister to cut cards for it—a gambler’s last attempt at neutrality.

  “I’ll cut cards with you for the microfilm. Double or nothing.”
  — Slade, [27:00]

• Slade deliberately loses, handing over the film for nothing; Jen realizes he chose patriotism:

  “You had him beaten…He would have paid the 50,000…Why did you do it?”
  — Jen, [28:49]
  “I don't know, baby. I guess some guys just can’t help being suckers.”
  — Slade, [29:00]
  “I guess some guys just can’t help being patriots.”
  — Jen, [29:06]

6. Resolution and Aftermath ([29:20]–[31:15])

• Slade and Jen remain in Switzerland, penniless but redeemed.

• After the war, McAllister tells Slade how the film helped save thousands, emphasizing the impact of small acts of reluctant heroism.

  “You were the toughest ally the OSS ever had, brother. But you did the job.”
  — McAllister, [30:55]

Host Reflection and Analysis (Adam Graham, [31:15]–[35:51])

Comparison to Casablanca

• Adam Graham likens Slade’s arc to Rick in Casablanca—an American expat in a neutral land forced to choose sides by brutality and the courage of others.

• He emphasizes the difference between real OSS agents and fictional super-spies.

  “These were not professional spies…but citizens who took on a dangerous task, all responding 'yes' to the offer that we heard at the start of each episode. And at least some of the people profiled paid with their lives.”
  — Adam Graham, [33:56]

The Series as Tribute

• Adam lauds Cloak and Dagger for its blend of suspense and respect for the risks and sacrifices of regular people.
• He shares listener appreciation and calls the show a “magnificent tribute” with lasting resonance.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Haywood’s code:
  “Shoe… heel… left shoe… McAllister.” ([12:07])
  (Launches central quest for meaning and sets up the microfilm intrigue.)

• Jen’s moral ultimatum:
  “I love you, Mike. But I couldn’t go on loving you if you did a thing like this. I’d come to hate you.” ([23:33])

• Slade’s choice:
  “I don’t know, baby. I guess some guys just can’t help being suckers.” ([29:00])

• Jen’s reply:
  “I guess some guys just can’t help being patriots.” ([29:06])

• McAllister on Slade’s contribution:
  “You were the toughest ally the OSS ever had, brother. But you did the job.” ([30:55])

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [02:46] – Story introduction and character setup
• [07:49] – Jen suspects Haywood’s real identity and mission
• [12:07] – Dying clue about the microfilm’s location
• [14:00] – First Nazi confrontation and stakes rise
• [19:09] – McAllister reveals importance of the microfilm
• [23:33] – Jen’s ultimatum to Mike about his moral choice
• [27:00] – High-stakes gamble for the microfilm
• [29:00] – Slade’s self-sacrificial turning point
• [31:15] – Host analysis and tribute to real OSS agents

Tone and Style

• The dialogue is hardboiled and economical, in the classic noir style.
• Themes of cynicism, redemption, and reluctant heroism echo throughout.
• Adam Graham’s host commentary is thoughtful, respectful, and appreciative.

Summary for Non-Listeners

“Windfall” is a taut wartime drama about a self-interested American in Switzerland juggling the chance to escape poverty with a critical OSS mission. Through violence, patriotism, and the inspiration of others, he’s forced to choose: profit or aiding the Allies. The story’s emotional climax comes not from spectacular action, but from one man’s quiet moral conversion and the price of a conscience. Adam Graham closes the episode and Cloak and Dagger series with a heartfelt salute to the unsung heroes who inspired these tales.

For more episodes and information: greatdetectives.net