Podcast Episode Summary: "Sherlock Holmes: The Empty House" (EP0984)
Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio
Release Date: June 27, 2013
Host: Adam Graham

Episode Overview

In the final installment of the Sherlock Holmes series on The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio, host Adam Graham presents a compelling dramatization of "The Empty House," one of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's canonical Sherlock Holmes stories. This episode marks the triumphant return of Holmes after his presumed death, engaging listeners with a masterful blend of suspense, character development, and intricate plot twists.

Plot Summary

The episode opens with Dr. John Watson recounting the aftermath of Sherlock Holmes's apparent demise at the Reichenbach Falls, where he was believed to have fallen while battling his nemesis, Professor Moriarty. [05:22] Watson narrates his struggle with Holmes's loss and his attempts to honor his friend's legacy by delving into criminal investigations.

In the spring of 1894, Watson encounters Colonel Sebastian Moran, who grapples with the mysterious murder of Ronald Adair. Adair, a respected young man with a penchant for card games, was found dead in his Park Lane home, mutilated by an "expanding bullet." [08:00] Moran is baffled by the lack of evidence, particularly the absence of a weapon, and the seemingly impossible circumstances of the crime scene—Adair was shot through an open window from a distance that made the use of a revolver implausible.

As Watson and Moran investigate, they discuss the intricacies of the case, contemplating whether the murderer could have infiltrated the locked room and executed the perfect crime. [09:03] Moran expresses doubt over the feasibility of the method, emphasizing the skill required to cause such extensive damage without leaving traceable evidence.

Upon returning to his study, Watson is astonished to find Colonel Moran, who reveals himself to be none other than Sherlock Holmes. [12:57] Holmes explains that he faked his death to dismantle Moriarty's criminal network from within. Utilizing his mastery of disguise and combat, including knowledge of the Baritsu wrestling system, Holmes evaded Moriarty and his associates, ultimately escaping the chasm unscathed.

Holmes elaborates on his strategic disappearance, stating, "I was never in it," highlighting his survival and subsequent journey to dismantle Moriarty's operations globally. [14:19] He details his travels to Tibet, Persia, and France, culminating in his return to London to confront the remaining threats posed by Moriarty's lieutenants.

Reunited with Watson, Holmes leads him through the hidden alleys of London, showcasing his unparalleled knowledge of the city's secret pathways. Their journey culminates in Camden House, Holmes's "empty house," where they set a trap for Colonel Moran—the last of Moriarty's henchmen. [21:32] Holmes has orchestrated an elaborate ruse using a wax bust to project a shadow, deceiving Moran into believing that Holmes is still dead.

As Moran attempts to execute his plan using a specially designed air gun commissioned by Moriarty, Holmes reveals the truth. A confrontation ensues, resulting in Moran's capture without any loss of life. Holmes triumphantly declares, "That was the greatest compliment you could possibly pay me," acknowledging Watson's unwavering loyalty and the restoration of their partnership. [25:03]

Key Interactions and Insights

• Watson's Resilience: Throughout the episode, Watson exemplifies steadfast dedication to his friend, illustrating the profound bond between the two characters. His initial reluctance to believe in Holmes's survival underscores the depth of his grief and subsequent relief.

• Holmes's Strategic Genius: Holmes's meticulous planning and ability to outthink his adversaries once again highlight his status as a premier detective. His use of disguise, physical prowess, and psychological manipulation in recriminating Moran showcases his multifaceted approach to problem-solving.

• Colonel Moran's Cunning: As Moriarty's lieutenant, Moran embodies the quintessential antagonist—skilled, ruthless, and relentless. His interactions with Holmes reveal the enduring conflict between good and evil, and the personal vendettas that drive their encounters.

Notable Quotes

• Dr. John Watson:

  • "I have to conclude, alas, with the account of his death as he fell into the great chasm of the falls of Reichenbach in Switzerland..." [05:22]

• Colonel Sebastian Moran:

  • "Murder, Dr. Watson. It's stark murder." [06:19]
  • "I don't know. Just a notion I sometimes have." [06:57]
  • "You're the devil, Holmes. You truly are the only one who's..." [16:28]

• Sherlock Holmes (Narrator):

  • "We have our work to do first. You think you'll be all right?" [15:24]
  • "The game's afoot, Watson. Old times, old times. Come. The adventure, as you'll no doubt call it, of the empty house." [18:15]
  • "That was the greatest compliment you could possibly pay me." [15:29]
  • "The late Professor Moriarty's first lieutenant. You fiend, Sherlock Holmes." [25:57]

Conclusion

"The Empty House" serves as a fitting finale to the Sherlock Holmes series on The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio. It not only fulfills the anticipation of Holmes's return but also reaffirms the enduring appeal of Conan Doyle's creation. Through masterful storytelling, rich character portrayals by Sir John Gielgud and Sir Ralph Richardson, and a tightly woven plot, the episode encapsulates the essence of classic detective fiction. Host Adam Graham aptly concludes the series, reflecting on the timeless nature of Holmes's adventures and the impact they continue to hold for audiences worldwide.

Listeners are encouraged to explore other detective tales featured on the podcast, ensuring that the legacy of great detectives like Sherlock Holmes remains vibrant and engaging.

This summary is intended to provide an in-depth overview of the episode "Sherlock Holmes: The Empty House" for those who have not listened to it, capturing the critical elements and memorable moments of the dramatization.