Podcast Summary: "Sherlock Holmes: The Final Problem" (EP0978)

Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio
Host: Adam Graham
Release Date: June 20, 2013

Introduction

In this episode of The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio, host Adam Graham delves into the classic Sherlock Holmes narrative, "The Final Problem." This dramatized rendition features distinguished voices, including Sir John Gielgud as Sherlock Holmes, Sir Ralph Richardson as Dr. Watson, and the iconic Orson Welles portraying Professor Moriarty. The episode captures the tense and climactic confrontation between the legendary detective and his arch-nemesis, culminating in the fateful encounter at the Reichenbach Falls.

The Dramatization of "The Final Problem"

Rekindling the Partnership

The episode opens with Dr. Watson reminiscing about his long-standing friendship with Sherlock Holmes. At [04:53], Richardson sets the scene, expressing his dedication to chronicling their adventures:

Ralph Richardson [04:53]: "It is with a heavy heart that I come before you with the last adventure of my friend Sherlock Holmes that I shall be able to relate."

Despite years of drift due to personal commitments, Watson is unexpectedly reunited with Holmes at [06:25]:

Sherlock Holmes [06:25]: "Good evening, Watson."

Holmes's Obsession with Moriarty

Holmes reveals his growing concern over Professor Moriarty, describing him as the mastermind behind a vast criminal network in London. At [08:05], Holmes emphasizes Moriarty's subtle yet pervasive influence:

Sherlock Holmes [08:05]: "He corrupts all London with his evil influence."

Watson remains skeptical, but Holmes is unwavering in his determination to bring Moriarty down, stating at [08:34]:

Sherlock Holmes [08:34]: "Three days more and I shall have him, Watson. Three days more. If I live to see them."

The Confrontation

The tension peaks during the intense dialogue between Holmes and Moriarty. At [05:27], Orson Welles's Moriarty declares:

Professor Moriarty [05:27]: "Mr. Sherlock Holmes. Your efforts on the side of law and order have seriously inconvenienced me."

Their conversation, laden with veiled threats and intellectual sparring, showcases the deep animosity and mutual respect between the two geniuses. A notable exchange at [12:35] illustrates Holmes's strategic prowess:

Sherlock Holmes [12:35]: "Above your own mark, Professor. The exact spot, I think."

The Flight to the Continent

Anticipating danger, Holmes devises a meticulous plan for him and Watson to flee to the continent. At [17:33], Holmes provides detailed instructions to Watson:

Sherlock Holmes [17:33]: "Tomorrow morning at 8:45 you will take a hansom cab."

Despite following the plan meticulously, Watson remains anxious as they board the train, fearing Moriarty's imminent threat. The narrative builds suspense as Moriarty appears on the train at [20:00], leading to a dramatic showdown.

The Climactic Encounter at Reichenbach Falls

The final act unfolds at the picturesque yet perilous Reichenbach Falls. As described by Watson at [23:13], Holmes and Moriarty engage in a fierce struggle that results in both men plunging into the abyss:

Ralph Richardson [23:13]: "They had gone down to the abyss. Only the letter. The last greeting from my friend and comrade."

Holmes's heartfelt letter [29:01] addressed to Watson reveals his final thoughts and preparations for the inevitable conclusion:

Sherlock Holmes [29:01]: "Believe me to be, my very dear good fellow. Yours most sincerely, Sherlock Holmes."

Host's Analysis and Critique

After the dramatization concludes, host Adam Graham reflects on the episode's execution and its place within the Sherlock Holmes canon. At [32:31], Graham shares his initial reservations about the episode:

Adam Graham [32:31]: "Actually it's one of the first ones when I was considering whether we would do this particular Sherlock Holmes series and I almost decided not to do it."

He critiques the production for its staged feel, attributing this to the limited number of characters and the interactions resembling a three-person play rather than a dynamic radio drama. Graham also points out the overly polite exchanges between Holmes and Moriarty, which he feels detract from the inherent tension of their rivalry:

Adam Graham [32:37]: "Holmes and Moriarty were just ridiculously polite to one another."

Despite these critiques, Graham acknowledges the value of the original story and the efforts of the radio adaptation. He compares it to his preferred Granada Television adaptation and expresses appreciation for the classic narrative's enduring appeal. As the series nears its conclusion, Graham encourages listeners to tune in for the final episode, promising more Sherlock Holmes content in future specials.

Conclusion

"Sherlock Holmes: The Final Problem" offers a faithful yet dramatized portrayal of one of literature's most iconic confrontations. Through stellar performances by Gielgud, Richardson, and Welles, the episode brings to life the intense battle of wits between Holmes and Moriarty. While the production may have its shortcomings, as noted by Adam Graham, it remains a significant installment in the ongoing celebration of Sherlock Holmes in old-time radio formats.

Listeners are left contemplating the sacrifices Holmes makes in his quest for justice and the profound impact of his partnership with Dr. Watson. As Adam Graham aptly summarizes, despite certain flaws, the episode serves as a heartfelt homage to the timeless detective and his enduring legacy.

For more episodes and discussions, visit RadioDetectives.net, follow on Twitter at @radiodetectives, and join the community on Facebook at facebook.com/radiodetectives.