Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd
Episode Title: 3 & Out - 49ers make more cuts, Daniel Jones goes to Indy, Tiger needs another surgery
Release Date: March 12, 2025
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume

Introduction

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host John Middlekauff delves deep into the latest developments in the NFL and the world of golf. The discussion centers around the San Francisco 49ers' recent roster cuts, the trade of quarterback Daniel Jones to the Indianapolis Colts, and the concerning injury updates for golf legend Tiger Woods. Middlekauff provides insightful analysis, backed by data and personal opinions, making it a must-listen for sports enthusiasts.

San Francisco 49ers' Roster Cuts

Timestamp: [02:52]

John Middlekauff begins by addressing the significant roster changes within the 49ers organization. The team has recently made several cuts, including high-profile players like Leonard Floyd, a consistent starter and a key defensive player. Middlekauff expresses confusion and frustration over the decision to release Floyd, especially given his performance and relatively modest salary.

Notable Quote:
“Leonard Floyd, seven and a half million dollars. Kind of the going rate for a guy that is going to give you nine or ten sacks and never misses any time like that's what they cost. I just do not understand it. It makes no sense.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]

He further criticizes the 49ers' management under the York family, highlighting their shift from high expenditure to aggressive cost-cutting despite the team's strong financial standing. Middlekauff argues that the 49ers are undervaluing their talent by offloading key players to save a few million dollars, which could jeopardize their competitiveness in the season.

Additional Insights:

• The 49ers spent $334 million in cash last year, exceeding the salary cap by $80 million.
• Comparison with other NFL teams like the Eagles and franchises owned by Jeffrey Lurie and Robert Kraft, who have more autonomy and spend accordingly to maintain team performance.
• The head coach Jim Harbaugh’s reputation and the potential negative impact on team morale due to inconsistent management decisions.

Daniel Jones Trade to Indianapolis Colts

Timestamp: [02:06]

Middlekauff shifts focus to the trade of quarterback Daniel Jones from the New York Giants to the Indianapolis Colts. He expresses skepticism regarding the Colts' decision, questioning Daniel Jones' performance and potential impact compared to other available quarterbacks.

Notable Quote:
“It’s bad. It was stupid, you know, so I’m all for a very, very difficult negotiation with Brock Purdy, but when you start cutting Leonard Floyd for basically no reason, that one’s a head scratcher.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]

He reflects on Jones' career trajectory, comparing him unfavorably to other quarterbacks and emphasizing his lack of consistent performance. Middlekauff also critiques the Colts' quarterback room, highlighting concerns about Anthony Richardson's survival being tied to Jones and the overall instability it might introduce to the team's future prospects.

Additional Insights:

• Daniel Jones' history with injuries and inconsistent performance metrics.
• The Colts' dilemma in building a stable quarterback lineup with both Jones and Richardson.
• Middlekauff draws parallels to other quarterbacks like Alex Smith and Matt Stafford to illustrate his points on quarterback performance and team dynamics.

Tiger Woods' Injury and Career Impact

Timestamp: [39:43]

Switching gears to golf, Middlekauff discusses the latest injury update on Tiger Woods, who reportedly tore his Achilles, adding to his already extensive list of injuries. He speculates on the potential end of Woods' professional playing career, given his history of injuries and recent setbacks.

Notable Quote:
“I think it’s fair to say that this is like the cherry on top. Like it’s completely over.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]

Middlekauff reflects on Tiger Woods' grueling career, filled with numerous surgeries and physical strains from his intense playing style. He underscores the improbability of Woods making a comeback, likening his situation to athletes from other sports who have struggled to return to form after similar injuries.

Additional Insights:

• Comparison of Woods' physical condition to retired NFL and NBA players who suffer from long-term injuries.
• Speculation on the future of golf without Tiger Woods, emphasizing his role as a marquee player who drove viewership and engagement in the sport.
• Middlekauff discusses the broader implications for the PGA Tour and other golfing events, suggesting that the absence of a figure like Woods could lead to diminished interest and financial challenges.

Free Agency and NFL Transactions

Timestamp: [02:52]

Middlekauff provides an in-depth analysis of the current NFL free agency period, criticizing the existing tampering rules and suggesting a more streamlined approach. He argues that the current system complicates transactions, leading to inefficiencies and frustration among fans and teams alike.

Notable Quote:
“I just think this tampering period is just a complete joke. It really is.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]

He advocates for initiating free agency immediately after the combine, eliminating the unnecessary delays that prevent swift team adjustments. Middlekauff believes that allowing teams to negotiate and sign players without the current restrictions would enhance the excitement and competitiveness of the free agency period.

Additional Insights:

• Theoretical implications of removing the tampering period on player mobility and team strategies.
• Middlekauff shares personal opinions on specific player transactions and contract negotiations, highlighting perceived missteps by team management.
• Discussion on the financial dynamics of NFL teams, particularly focusing on how high cash spending does not always correlate with on-field success.

Additional Topics: Golf Betting and Player Performances

Timestamp: [39:43]

Expanding beyond NFL discussions, Middlekauff delves into the world of golf betting, sharing his strategies and experiences. He highlights the complexities of predicting golf outcomes compared to other sports, emphasizing the importance of understanding course specifics and player form.

Notable Quote:
“One thing I've learned, it is very, very difficult to build to bet winners. It’s why I like betting.” — John Middlekauff [39:43]

He shares insights on top golfers to watch, such as Justin Thomas, Keegan Bradley, and Jason Day, providing listeners with informed betting tips based on player performance and course characteristics. Middlekauff also touches upon the psychological aspects of golf, discussing how player mindset and external factors can influence performance outcomes.

Additional Insights:

• Middlekauff's personal betting strategies, including parlays and outright bets.
• Analysis of current golf tournaments, highlighting standout performances and potential dark horses.
• Reflection on the shift in golf's competitive landscape post-Tiger Woods, and the rise of new talents filling the void.

Conclusion

Throughout the episode, John Middlekauff offers a blend of passionate commentary and critical analysis on both NFL and golf-related topics. His candid opinions on team management decisions, player performances, and the broader implications for sports industries provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the current sports landscape. The episode culminates with Middlekauff's personal anecdotes and reflections on the challenges faced by athletes, both on and off the field.

Notable Quotes Recap

• “Leonard Floyd, seven and a half million dollars. Kind of the going rate for a guy that is going to give you nine or ten sacks and never misses any time like that's what they cost. I just do not understand it. It makes no sense.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]
• “I just think this tampering period is just a complete joke. It really is.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]
• “One thing I've learned, it is very, very difficult to build to bet winners. It’s why I like betting.” — John Middlekauff [39:43]
• “I think it’s fair to say that this is like the cherry on top. Like it’s completely over.” — John Middlekauff [02:52]

Final Thoughts

This episode serves as a critical examination of significant sports events and decisions, offering listeners a thoughtful perspective on the current state of the NFL and golf. John Middlekauff's thorough analysis and engaging delivery make this episode both informative and compelling for those looking to stay informed on major sports narratives.