Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd Episode: 3 & Out - Eagles are on a Roll, Raiders Extend Max Crosby, WR Market
Release Date: March 6, 2025
Host: Mark Wahlberg
Produced by: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume

Introduction: Podcast from Nashville

Mark Wahlberg kicks off the episode by sharing a personal anecdote about recording the podcast from a high-rise in Nashville while preparing for his upcoming wedding. Despite initial challenges with the environment, he emphasizes his commitment to delivering insightful sports commentary.
“I'm up in a high rise in Nashville getting married in a couple days... there’s a will, there’s a way.” ([02:37])

Philadelphia Eagles: Strategic Roster Moves Propel Success

Wahlberg delves into the Philadelphia Eagles' impressive performance, attributing their success to savvy financial and personnel decisions, particularly on the defensive side.

Key Points:

• Defensive Investments:
  The Eagles secured two All-Pro players—Zach Bond (Linebacker) and Saquon (Running Back)—for a combined $70 million guaranteed. This strategic investment allows the team to maintain a strong defense without overspending.
  “They got two All-Pros... for $70 million guaranteed.” ([03:15])

• Contrasting Market Values:
  Wahlberg contrasts the Eagles' approach with the San Francisco 49ers, who are reportedly concerned about Brandon Aiyuk's $75 million contract despite similar performance metrics.
  “The 49ers are freaking out about Brandon Aiyuk's contract... they put him on the block because they want to get rid of the money.” ([04:00])

• Philosophical Shift:
  Eagles' GM Howie Roseman traditionally undervalued linebacker positions, favoring mid-round drafts. However, Bond's exceptional performance compelled a reevaluation of this philosophy.
  “He pushed back against that at the combine... they reexamined their philosophy.” ([04:45])

• Impact on NFC:
  The Eagles' defensive strength, bolstered by Bond and Saquon, significantly influences the NFC landscape, enhancing their competitiveness against other top teams.
  “The Eagles, the only question mark is this new guy calling plays... the roster is still going to be loaded.” ([06:20])

Las Vegas Raiders: Extending Max Crosby Amidst a Competitive Division

Wahlberg highlights the Raiders' decision to extend Max Crosby's contract as a testament to their commitment to building a winning team within a highly competitive division.

Key Points:

• Max Crosby's Value:
  Crosby is portrayed as an exemplary player—dedicated, reliable, and a potential Pro Bowler for years to come. The Raiders secured his future with a three-year extension, ensuring stability on their defense.
  “Max Crosby is every GM's dream... he's everything you want.” ([07:05])

• Competitive Division Pressure:
  The Raiders face immense pressure from division rivals like the Chiefs, Broncos, and Chargers. Extending Crosby signals their intent to compete aggressively rather than rebuilding.
  “Extending Max Crosby shows... we're trying to win now.” ([08:00])

• Raiders' Market Appeal:
  Beyond on-field strategy, the Raiders leverage factors like no state income tax and a desirable living environment to attract and retain talent, making them an appealing destination for players seeking both professional and personal benefits.
  “The Raiders have a lot going for them, it’s a desirable place to live... no state income tax.” ([09:30])

• Long-Term Prospects:
  Wahlberg expresses uncertainty about the Raiders' long-term competitiveness, citing the strength of their division but remains optimistic about their immediate strategies.
  “It's going to be a long haul for the Raiders... but I understand why you would give a guy three years, $100 million.” ([11:15])

Wide Receiver Market: DK Metcalf's Trade Frenzy

The episode shifts focus to the evolving wide receiver market, with a spotlight on DK Metcalf's trade demands and the broader implications for NFL teams.

Key Points:

• Trade Speculations:
  Metcalf's rumored desire to be traded from the Seattle Seahawks to a contender like the Los Angeles Chargers sparks widespread discussion. Wahlberg analyzes the feasibility and potential impact of such a move.
  “DK Metcalf has asked for a trade... it's going to be fascinating.” ([12:00])

• Team Strategies and Fit:
  Wahlberg assesses how teams like the Chiefs or Rams might approach acquiring Metcalf, considering salary cap implications and team philosophies. He speculates on the challenges Seattle would face in retaining Metcalf amid these demands.
  “If you're Seattle, you're not trading DK Metcalf... but a team like the Chargers might see value.” ([13:45])

• Metcalf's Market Value vs. Impact:
  Despite not having explosive statistical outputs consistently, Metcalf's presence dramatically alters offensive dynamics, making him more valuable than traditional metrics suggest.
  “His impact is more than just the stats... he's like a modern-day Terrell Owens.” ([15:20])

• Potential Outcomes:
  Wahlberg discusses possible scenarios, including Metcalf staying with Seattle or moving to another team, and the ripple effects such a trade would have on the receiver markets and team performances league-wide.
  “His value is much higher than just his statistics... it changes defensive strategies.” ([17:00])

Chicago Bears: Offensive Line Investments and Future Draft Picks

Wahlberg shifts attention to the Chicago Bears, emphasizing their commitment to strengthening the offensive line through significant contracts and strategic drafts.

Key Points:

• Offensive Line Focus:
  The Bears prioritize the offensive line, signing key players like Joe Thuney and trading for Jonah Jackson to bolster their interior line-up. This move reflects a broader understanding of the offensive line's critical role in team success.
  “The Bears go all in on the offensive line... they've improved their interior offensive linemen.” ([18:30])

• Financial Commitments:
  Investing heavily in the offensive line with substantial salaries indicates the Bears' dedication to this foundational aspect of their team, setting them apart from other franchises that might overlook these positions.
  “They are heavily invested into these two guys... making them a cornerstone of the offensive line.” ([20:00])

• Draft Strategy:
  Looking ahead to the draft, Wahlberg predicts that the Bears will prioritize defensive linemen, anticipating where the offensive line investments will allow for flexibility in other areas.
  “They’re going to draft a defensive lineman really, really high... Becton is going to be fascinating.” ([21:15])

Cleveland Browns and New NFL Dynamics

Wahlberg provides a critical analysis of the Cleveland Browns, addressing misconceptions about the team and evaluating their strategic position within the league.

Key Points:

• Team Reputation vs. Reality:
  Contrary to popular belief, Wahlberg argues that the Browns are a competitive and financially strong team, dispelling the notion that they are undesirable places for players.
  “It's not like they're kicking him to the curb... Cleveland's been a really good team.” ([22:40])

• Financial Powerhouse:
  Highlighting the Browns' substantial financial investments, including record-breaking contracts for players, Wahlberg contends that the team's monetary strength makes them an attractive destination despite any negative perceptions.
  “The owner gave the most money to a quarterback in NFL history... no one's ever got $230 million.” ([23:10])

• Front Office and Coaching:
  The Browns' management and coaching staff are portrayed as savvy and committed to building a winning team, further enhancing their standing in the league.
  “Their GM's pretty good... it's a dirty game, but they play it smart.” ([24:55])

Conclusion: Navigating the Complex NFL Landscape

Mark Wahlberg wraps up the episode by reflecting on the ever-evolving dynamics of the NFL, emphasizing the importance of strategic investments, player-management relationships, and the intricate balance teams must maintain to remain competitive.

“It's a cold-blooded business... but for the players and teams investing wisely, the rewards are significant.” ([26:00])

Notable Quotes:

• “They reexamined their philosophy.” – Mark Wahlberg ([04:45])
• “Max Crosby is every GM's dream.” – Mark Wahlberg ([07:05])
• “His impact is more than just the stats.” – Mark Wahlberg ([15:20])
• “It's a dirty game, but they play it smart.” – Mark Wahlberg ([24:55])

Final Thoughts

This episode provides a comprehensive analysis of key NFL teams and players, offering listeners in-depth insights into strategic decisions shaping the league's future. Wahlberg's expertise illuminates the complex interplay of finances, player performance, and team dynamics, making it a must-listen for sports enthusiasts seeking a deeper understanding of the game.