Podcast Summary: "The Herd with Colin Cowherd" — Episode 3 & Out

Release Date: January 9, 2025
Host: Colin Cowherd
Produced by: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Episode Title: "3 & Out - Future of the Raiders, 49ers Make Coaching Changes, Kauff on Campus"

I. Introduction: Acknowledging Recent Tragedies

The episode begins with John Middlekauff expressing heartfelt condolences regarding recent catastrophic fires in Southern California. He emphasizes the bravery of first responders and the profound impact these events have on communities.

John Middlekauff [05:15]: "These first responders... they run into danger while us just civilians run away from it. It really tears at your heart because these people will do anything to save people's lives that they don't know."

II. NFL Discussions

A. Future of the Las Vegas Raiders

Middlekauff delves into the future of the Raiders, discussing the possibility of owner Mark Davis eventually handing over control to Tom Brady. He draws parallels to legendary coach Bill Belichick, suggesting that Brady’s influence could shape the organization's direction in the coming years.

John Middlekauff [07:20]: "Mark Davis... maybe Tom Brady... would be willing to pivot, maybe take over the Raiders."

Middlekauff also touches on the Raiders' current lack of a quarterback and the challenges they face in building a robust team under Brady's potential consultancy.

B. 49ers Make Coaching Changes

The discussion shifts to the San Francisco 49ers, focusing on head coach Kyle Shanahan's decision to fire his defensive coordinator. Middlekauff critiques the 49ers' defensive strategy and the implications of these changes for their future performance and draft strategies.

John Middlekauff [09:45]: "You can't just run that defense anymore. You have to have other pitches."

He underscores the importance of a versatile defense and speculates on possible new hires, including Robert Sala and Lou Amaruno, questioning the 49ers' willingness to innovate rather than stick with familiar strategies.

John Middlekauff [10:09]: "They got to think a little bit outside the box. Hiring Robert Sala is like what Belichick always did... but they need to think differently."

Middlekauff also discusses the 49ers' draft strategy, emphasizing the necessity of securing impactful players to sustain the team's success, especially with Brock Purdy set to receive a long-term contract.

C. Mike McDaniel and NFL Fines Discussion

A significant portion of the episode critiques Mike McDaniel's stance on the NFL's fine system. Middlekauff argues that fines are not merely financial deterrents but symbols of respect and professionalism.

John Middlekauff [31:20]: "It's not about the money. It's about the level of respect and the view that... you view what you're saying as important to help me out."

He contends that McDaniel's comments reflect poorly on his leadership and question whether players genuinely respect him and his system.

III. Simulated Golf with Tiger Woods

Middlekauff evaluates Tiger Woods’ latest venture into simulated golf, acknowledging the technological advancements but expressing skepticism about its long-term appeal. He appreciates the innovation but remains doubtful about its sustainability beyond initial interest.

John Middlekauff [25:30]: "I would probably bet against its staying power. But Tiger is a big deal, and he's playing..."

IV. College Football Playoffs: "Kauff on Campus"

A. National Championship: Notre Dame vs. Penn State

A substantial segment is dedicated to the highly anticipated national championship game between Notre Dame and Penn State. Middlekauff analyzes both teams' strengths and weaknesses, focusing on key players like Notre Dame’s Drew Allers and Penn State’s Abdul Carter.

John Middlekauff [33:38]: "Drew Allers is a first-round pick, and Abdul Carter... he's not going to show you that same production as two of those guys."

He discusses the impact of injuries, strategic play-calling, and quarterback performance, highlighting the potential outcomes and what each team needs to secure victory.

John Middlekauff [44:21]: "This game is going to be an absolute war zone. Whoever comes out, you just pray to God you don't lose a couple bodies."

B. Other Playoff Games: Ohio State vs. Texas

Middlekauff provides an in-depth analysis of the Ohio State vs. Texas playoff matchup, scrutinizing both teams' offensive and defensive capabilities. He questions Texas's ability to overcome Ohio State's elite defense and offensive strategies.

John Middlekauff [51:30]: "I don't see. It's just a bad matchup because the thing their deficiency has been coverage..."

He predicts a challenging environment for Texas, emphasizing the high stakes and Ohio State's dominant season performance.

C. Impact of the Transfer Portal

The conversation transitions to the effects of the transfer portal on college football, examining how it reshapes team dynamics and coaching opportunities. Middlekauff expresses concerns over the equitable application of transfer rules and the financial disparities between major conferences.

John Middlekauff [76:48]: "The transfer portal has become a little like NFL free agency. Once the franchise tag happened, it's like actual NFL free agency."

D. Financial Aspects of SEC and Big Ten

Middlekauff explores the financial tensions between the SEC and Big Ten conferences, highlighting how budget disparities influence recruitment and program competitiveness. He mentions specific instances of financial inducements leading to coaching changes and debates over NCAA enforcement.

John Middlekauff [71:04]: "The Big Ten schools... this is all about money now. Like Mario Cristobal is not a very good coach, I think relative to how much recruiting and talent and he can dominate..."

V. Conclusion: Key Insights and Takeaways

As the episode wraps up, Middlekauff and Jon Stewart reflect on the discussed topics, reinforcing the importance of strategic decisions in both professional and collegiate sports. Middlekauff reiterates his support for Penn State and outlines his predictions for the upcoming games, emphasizing the evolving landscape of college football.

John Middlekauff [83:04]: "It's a fantastic... it's been a special run. It's been fun to see for sure."

Notable Quotes

• John Middlekauff [07:20]: "Mark Davis... maybe Tom Brady... would be willing to pivot, maybe take over the Raiders."
• John Middlekauff [10:09]: "They got to think a little bit outside the box. Hiring Robert Sala is like what Belichick always did... but they need to think differently."
• John Middlekauff [31:20]: "It's not about the money. It's about the level of respect and the view that... you view what you're saying as important to help me out."
• John Middlekauff [44:21]: "This game is going to be an absolute war zone. Whoever comes out, you just pray to God you don't lose a couple bodies."
• John Middlekauff [51:30]: "I don't see. It's just a bad matchup because the thing their deficiency has been coverage..."
• John Middlekauff [76:48]: "The transfer portal has become a little like NFL free agency. Once the franchise tag happened, it's like actual NFL free agency."

Final Thoughts

This episode of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd" provides a comprehensive exploration of current NFL and college football dynamics, offering listeners nuanced insights into team strategies, coaching decisions, and the broader financial and regulatory landscape shaping the sports industry. Through detailed analysis and candid discussions, Middlekauff and Stewart deliver an engaging narrative that caters to both avid sports enthusiasts and casual fans seeking to stay informed.