Podcast Title: The Herd with Colin Cowherd
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Episode: 3 & Out - Justin Tucker suspended, NBA Draft vs. NFL Draft, NFL players are more relatable
Release Date: June 27, 2025
Introduction
In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host John Middlecoff dives deep into some of the most pressing sports stories of the day. From the sudden suspension of NFL's elite kicker Justin Tucker to nuanced discussions comparing the NFL and NBA drafts, John provides his unfiltered opinions and insightful analyses that cater to both hardcore fans and casual listeners alike.
Justin Tucker's Suspension and Its Implications [02:36]
John launches the episode with breaking news about Justin Tucker, one of the NFL's most reliable kickers, being suspended for ten games. This suspension, John argues, likely marks the unofficial end of Tucker's illustrious career.
John Middlecoff [02:45]: "When Justin Tucker was suspended for 10 games, I think it unofficially ended his career."
John draws parallels to the DeSean Watson situation, emphasizing the harsh realities celebrities face in their personal lives impacting their professional careers.
John Middlecoff [05:10]: "Justin Tucker put himself in this situation, clearly, and just like Deshaun Watson, the league wants no part of it."
He underscores the NFL's zero-tolerance policy towards off-field scandals, especially for positions like kickers, who are often the first to be cut under such circumstances.
Comparing NFL and NBA Draft Processes [10:15]
Shifting gears, John delves into the intricacies of the NFL Draft versus the NBA Draft. He highlights the emotional and symbolic significance of the NFL Draft room compared to its NBA counterpart.
John Middlecoff [12:30]: "The NFL draft room is kind of a special holy place in the building—the culmination of years of strategy and hope."
He contrasts this with the NBA, where drafts are less critical due to different team-building strategies and the relative depth of talent in the NFL.
John Middlecoff [14:45]: "In the NBA, good teams sometimes go years without even having picks. It doesn't necessarily matter as much."
John also touches upon the public's perception and media coverage differences between the two drafts, arguing that the NFL Draft garners more respect and anticipation.
Relatability of NFL Players vs. NBA Players [18:50]
One of the standout discussions revolves around the relatability of NFL players compared to their NBA counterparts. John posits that NFL players maintain a closer connection to fans through their off-field behaviors and lifestyles.
John Middlecoff [19:20]: "The NFL has an advantage in relatability. You see tight ends sponsored by Bud Light, players ordering beers, something the NBA has largely lost."
He reminisces about the cultural icons of the NBA, like Michael Jordan and LeBron James, who engaged in everyday activities, making them more approachable to fans.
John Middlecoff [21:05]: "Michael Jordan drank beers. Michael Jordan gambled. Dwyane Wade and LeBron James sip wine. These players are more human to the average fan."
In contrast, he criticizes the NBA's newer star generation for their lack of relatable behaviors, suggesting that this disconnect affects the league's cultural footprint.
John Middlecoff [22:30]: "The basketball guys not drinking at all is, to me, pretty weird. It’s something football still retains that resonates more with Americans."
Mailbag: Undervaluing the Minnesota Vikings [28:10]
John opens the mailbag segment with a listener’s question about why the Minnesota Vikings are being consistently undervalued. The listener points out significant improvements in their offensive and defensive lines, coaching staff, and player roster.
Listener [28:15]: "Why is everyone underselling the Vikings? They’ve improved their lines, have a strong coaching staff, and a solid roster."
John agrees with the listener’s assessment, attributing it to uncertainties surrounding the new quarterback and the organization’s ability to fully capitalize on their upgrades.
John Middlecoff [28:45]: "The quarterback change does matter, but don't discount the entire coaching staff. They’re among the best in the league."
He emphasizes the importance of stability in the quarterback position and how it plays a pivotal role in a team’s success.
Aaron Rodgers: A Case Study in NFL Longevity [35:50]
Another significant discussion centers around Aaron Rodgers and his potential trajectory in the NFL. John contrasts Rodgers with retired quarterbacks like Tom Brady and Drew Brees, focusing on physical health and team dynamics.
John Middlecoff [36:10]: "Unlike Brady or Brees, Rodgers hasn’t physically deteriorated as much, but team performance is a concern."
He speculates on Rodgers' ability to stay healthy and remain effective, highlighting the importance of reliable teammates and a robust offensive line.
John Middlecoff [38:25]: "If Aaron Rodgers can stay healthy for 17 games, he could still be top-tier. But team dynamics play a crucial role."
John also touches upon how external factors, such as playing in colder climates, could impact Rodgers' performance as he ages.
John Middlecoff [40:00]: "Playing outdoors in the AFC North's harsh winters could take a toll on Rodgers’ body, unlike his experiences in warmer climates."
Draft Analysis and Player Hype: Arch Manning [45:15]
John discusses the hype surrounding Arch Manning, a highly touted college quarterback entering the NFL Draft. He expresses skepticism about his potential despite his family's legacy and physical attributes.
John Middlecoff [45:45]: "Arch Manning hasn't even played yet, but the hype is through the roof because he's a Manning. We need to see how he performs on the field."
He draws comparisons to other quarterbacks like Caleb Williams and Trevor Lawrence, emphasizing the importance of actual performance over lineage.
John Middlecoff [46:30]: "Unlike Trevor Lawrence and Caleb Williams, who proved themselves early, Arch Manning needs to demonstrate his skills once he starts playing."
John predicts that despite high expectations, Arch Manning's actual impact will depend on his performance in critical games like the College Football Playoff.
John Middlecoff [48:00]: "If Arch performs well in his debut against Ohio State, the hype could be justified. Otherwise, it may just be another overblown expectation."
Team Dynamics and Future Predictions [60:50]
Towards the end of the episode, John shares his thoughts on various NFL teams' futures, focusing on coaching strategies, player health, and organizational stability. He touches upon the Pittsburgh Steelers' situation, the potential of the Dallas Cowboys, and the overall impact of coaching on team success.
John Middlecoff [61:20]: "Teams like the Steelers need to manage their quarterbacks effectively to stay competitive. Health and coaching will determine their success this season."
He also discusses the resilience of the Kansas City Chiefs and the implications of long-term ownership stability on continued success.
John Middlecoff [63:40]: "The Chiefs have been living high for seven years, but even that won't last forever. Ownership and coaching will need to adapt to maintain their edge."
Closing Thoughts and Final Insights [85:30]
In wrapping up, John reflects on the importance of adaptability and resilience in sports management. He reiterates the significance of healthy players and sound organizational decisions in determining a team's success.
John Middlecoff [85:30]: "Ultimately, it's about resilience. Teams that adapt and prioritize health and strategic decisions will thrive, while others may falter despite star players."
Conclusion
John Middlecoff offers a comprehensive analysis of the current state of the NFL, addressing critical issues like player discipline, draft strategies, and the cultural impact of sports. His candid insights, backed by detailed observations and listener interactions, provide a nuanced understanding of the sports landscape in 2025. Whether it’s the potential downfall of a seasoned kicker or the rise of the next quarterback star, John ensures that listeners are well-informed and engaged with the latest developments in the world of sports.
Notable Quotes:
-
Justin Tucker Suspension:
John Middlecoff [02:45]: "When Justin Tucker was suspended for 10 games, I think it unofficially ended his career."
-
Relatability of NFL Players:
John Middlecoff [21:05]: "Michael Jordan drank beers. Michael Jordan gambled. Dwyane Wade and LeBron James sip wine. These players are more human to the average fan."
-
Arch Manning's Potential:
John Middlecoff [45:45]: "Arch Manning hasn't even played yet, but the hype is through the roof because he's a Manning. We need to see how he performs on the field."
-
Aaron Rodgers' Longevity:
John Middlecoff [36:10]: "Unlike Brady or Brees, Rodgers hasn’t physically deteriorated as much, but team performance is a concern."
This comprehensive summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from the episode, providing a clear and engaging overview for those who haven't listened to the podcast.