Loading summary
T-Mobile Advertiser
You can count on T Mobile to help keep you connected from big cities to small towns on America's largest 5G network. Switch the T Mobile keep your phone and they'll pay it off up to 800 bucks per line via prepaid card. Learn more@t mobile.com heap and switch up to four lines via virtual prepaid card. Allow 15 days qualifying unlock device credit service port in 90 plus days with device and eligible carrier and timely redemption. Acquired card has no cash access and expires in six months Jon Stewart is.
Jon Stewart
Back in the host chair at the Daily show, which means he's also back in our ears on the Daily Show Ears Edition podcast. Join late night legend Jon Stewart and the best news team for today's biggest headlines, exclusive extended interviews and more. Now this is a second term we can all get behind. Listen to the Daily Show Ears edition on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
T-Mobile Advertiser
The Volume.
Colin Cowherd
What is going on everybody? How are we doing? I'm excited because we're going to do a little mailbag today. Just watched the Rose Bowl. Obviously Ohio State dominated and I went out with Colin. We recorded actually a halftime of that game. That's what you do when they're down 34 to nothing. So we had a little look back at some of the college games. I was going to do something today with Jackson but they moved back the other game. Hopefully they still play it. We'll find out the next 24 hours. Notre Dame, Georgia, so we'll do that tomorrow. React to that game. So today I thought let's just do a mail because I wanted to get something up. So let's do a mailbag. Your boy was really hurting yesterday during the day I've had back to back. My IV lady has come over twice and honestly it might have saved my life because I was not literally, but I was in pretty bad shape and gotten back to back IVs. I've never done that before and it's worked and it's worked wonders. And now I feel like I'm on the mend. Just still head's a little stuffy but my body, I couldn't keep my eyes open. I was sleeping like 20 hours a day. It's like a dog or a cat. But now I'm alive and need to talk a little football and 2025. So happy new Year and yeah, let's talk some ball. But before we do, you know I got to tell you about my friends, my partners in the official ticketing app of this podcast Game Time. Here's the thing. It's 2025. So do you want to do something? Get out of the house, go do something fun. There were so many ASU fans today at that game and I was like, that's awesome. Hopefully they use Game Time because if you want to go to a game, college or pro, a concert, a comedy show, you guys know the drill. Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Game time. Download the GameTime app, create an account, use the code John, that's me for $20 off your first purchase terms apply again, create an account, redeem the code Johan. For $20 off. Download the game Time app today. Last minute tickets, lowest price is guaranteed. Okay, let's dive into the mailbag. We'll start with Kellen. John, what are your thoughts on the potential Chargers vs Chiefs divisional round game? Assuming the Chargers get the 5 seed and beat the Texans? As a Chargers fan, I am hungry for another shot at KC and we have a better chance of winning in Kansas City then we would be going on the road to Buffalo or Baltimore because the style of teams, we always play them close but have lost seven times in a row. We got to get them eventually. I do think Kansas City would much rather play like the Texans at home or the Steelers at home. Then not just the Chargers, but Denver as well. Because those two teams, if you look at their potential opponents, right, they can't play Buffalo and they can't play Baltimore, but they could play basically Kansas or Houston Texans on down, they could play any of those teams. And if somehow Pittsburgh were to upset Baltimore and Denver, let's say upsets, I guess they probably wouldn't upset Buffalo. But the Chargers, yeah, I mean, I think it's just going to be tough. I think more than likely, especially the way the Chiefs have played these last couple of weeks, it looked like they flipped a switch. But sometimes when you flip a switch, you get the momentum rolling, then you just stop playing. Because this week they're going with Carson Wentz, which obviously I don't, I don't blame them at all for going through, you know, the backup quarterback. But then you're not going to play another week, so which they're a veteran team. It's. It's the right move. But whoever they would be to play, especially if it is the Chargers, which I guess now I talk it out, it's much more likely than the Broncos, but I do think that the Chargers would have moment. You know, they've just been playing, right? They won last week, they'll win again this week. And then they'll. If they beat the Texans, they've just been playing a lot of football now, like there'll be a seven point underdog. I don't think the Chiefs are thinking too long and hard about it. It's the playoffs. They got to play hard teams. I mean, last year they went on the road and they beat Buffalo in the second round. But I do think they would just be more susceptible to the two divisional teams than they would be the Steelers or the Texans. I would, I would be much more nervous if I was a Chiefs fan playing the Broncos or playing the Chargers, especially now with Harbaugh and Sean Payton, than I would playing Mike Tomlin or the Texans team. Like I would expect to beat the shit out of those two. But the other two, I could just see where it could get weird. Why is it so rare for GMs to be rehired after losing their first job? Especially if I'm a bad organization, I'd much rather go with a guy like Rick Spielman, Thomas Dimitrov or John Dorsey that has shown they can put together a good roster rather than taking a chance on an unproven gm. Curious to hear your thoughts. I don't know. I mean, I was told a long time ago by, by a buddy of mine who was a fire gm, he said, john, we don't get second chances, not like coaches. And I don't know how why to define that. But there's something with a retread coach, right? Like Mike Vrabel's technically a retread, but no one looks at him like a failure or someone that you wouldn't want to hire. If Pete Carroll and Bill Belichick were 65 instead of 72, they would have easily, easily been rehired. So I think part of it is sometimes you look for the next best thing. Sometimes you. Maybe that guy is more tied to your money. And when a guy gets fired, he makes financial decisions for the owner. So there's more of a stink that carries with them. I'm just speaking out. I don't know. I'm just trying to. I have no clue. Because every gm, the good ones and the bad ones make bad. You know, miss on picks. Right. Or sign bad free agents. I don't know. I can't. Not sure why that happens, but it clearly happens. By his performance in the Peach bowl, did Scatter Boo boost his draft stock to the first round? He reminds me of a 511, Peyton Hillis. I don't think Scatter Boo will be a first round pick. I think he will be a second day selection. One thing I think that's going to hurt him and I can see this coming is, and this is stupid because this is what happens when we get to draft season. He's going to go to the combine and I would imagine he's not going to run that fast. Let's just say he runs a 4 7. I hope he doesn't. But let's just say he runs a 47 0. That won't be ideal for his draft stock. You'd be like middle cuff. What are you talking about? I'm like, listen, I don't make the rules. These are just the rules, right? Anyone who's ever shopped for houses knows there are certain things in a house when it comes to square footage. The amount of bathrooms, the amount of bedrooms, size of the kitchen, the size of the backyard, how many car garage that factor into the market value of the home. No different than a car has ever been in a wreck. How many miles on it, what year is it, what model is it? Like these things factor in, well, runs great, you're going to love living there. It doesn't matter because this is a market value exercise of where you get drafted. So if he runs slow, that will knock him down a little bit. But anyone with a brain, if you watch him, that guy's a football player and a really good football player. And running back is one of those positions more than most where instincts and feel for the position are stuff that separates guys. And if you have elite physical attributes, like, you know, Adrian Peterson is one of the most physically gifted running backs of all time, it didn't really matter that he couldn't catch her. Ironically for a size and strength, wouldn't pass block. But he was such a good runner, it didn't matter. Most other guys, you get nitpicked. And to me Scatter Boo is just, I mean he's just a, he's just a ball player and to me he's got Jim Harbaugh written all over him. I feel like Jim Harbaugh is going to love that guy. If Jon Gruden was coaching, I feel like Jon Gruden would have loved that guy. I'll tell you who's going to like that guy. Andy Reid is going to like that guy. Why did early in the season Carson Steele get some reps? Because Andy Reid loved that guy from watching him play at the Mac two years ago. If you think Andy Reid is not going to like Scatter Boo, like I used to be crazy. Now they're not going to take him in the first round, but would they take him at the end of the second round? You know, pick 62? I just, it's. There are a lot of guys in this draft. They're going to be NFL starters and running back, which I think can hurt Scatter Boo a little bit. My guess is he goes somewhere between 50 and 70. Just based on not knowing anything, I'm assuming high character, you know, all that stuff checks off. Never heard anything bad but his 40 speed, which is stupid because as a running back, like how many 40 yard runs are you going to have? You know, Saquons and Derrick Henry are pretty rare. Guys that are long, you know, breakout guys that have 60, 70, 80 yard runs. If you're getting me 20, 30 yard runs, that's all I need. But I do wonder if that's going to hurt him a little bit. But today was fucking awesome. How much fun was watching Scatter Boo just carry his team in that game? I think same about Genty. I feel like I learned more watching Genty in Scatterboo play against Penn State in Texas than I did in a lot of their games when they went nuts against lesser opponents because they were facing NFL fronts and they just willed their way to yards and they just, it was like, this is awesome. This is football right here. Question for the podcast. Do you think Ohio State lost to Michigan on purpose? Like, was it a strategic loss to not have to play in the conference championship game? Watching them play Tennessee and now against Oregon seems like some sandbag playing calling might have been possible. Obviously, you're better off in a weird way not playing the conference championship game. If you lose, if you lose that conference championship game, it's just you got to play the extra game and then you still make the playoffs like Penn State. So you're just playing extra games on your body. And you look at Penn State, I mean, their best player, Carter, and it's now banged up, hopefully he's healthy. But I do not think they tried to lose that game because the way Ryan Day talked about it, the way their players attack now, the way you're saying, you know, the players might not have to be involved in a sandbag, but the way they attacked everyone after the game, I think it's pretty fair to assume that they just had a bad game. Watching Michigan's defense against Alabama now these bowl games, I don't put that much stock into, partly because some of these games, I mean, you have 10, 15, 20 guys opting out some of them to the transfer portal some of them to the NFL draft. I mean A and M had a USC beat Texas A and M. Google how many guys from Texas A and M did not play in that game. So I think it's hard to put a value on a draft, on a bowl game, who won, who lost, who plays well, who doesn't. But I do think Ohio State clearly tried to win that game and they just played their worst game of the season. And one thing's pretty clear watching Ohio State these last couple of weeks is I just had a buddy that scouts in the NFL say he thinks Jeremiah Smith's the best college wide receiver he's ever seen. I mean that guy, when God made that guy, it's like this. That's what an NFL player looks like. Tell you that much. Mailbag there's been a lot of talk about the flaws of the college football this year, mainly focused on the fact that 12 teams that are in are not the true actual 12 best teams in the country and that it's not possible to get an accurate gauge of who the best 12 teams are because the schedule difficulty varies so much in college football. One fix I've thought of is this. They reduce both the number of conference games each team plays and put a set list of teams eligible for the college football playoffs. This list would include all power four teams, Notre Dame and maybe a few non P4 teams, but I'd be fine with leaving the non P4 teams out altogether. That's a problem. Let me stop you right there. The reason they had to include them is so like the Mountain west wouldn't sue. So you have to include them. That's the reason they're in now Boise show like they're they're clearly a top 15 team in the country but they have to include like to give them an invite to the dance or they would get sued. Each of these teams will only play four conference games and the other eight games would be played against other Power four teams outside of the conference. The primary goal for scheduling would be to even out the scheduling difficulty so the gap between the easiest and harder schedules is as small as possible, making a 102 Big 12 record worth the same as a 1012 record. Thoughts? One more thing. Each team could be given the right to pick two opponents each year so they can maintain certain rivalries. So Ohio State could be guaranteed to play Michigan and Penn each year and Bama could be guaranteed to play Auburn or Georgia or same for everyone else. Etc. I think the pushback would be the SEC says what we do Together is financially worth more than the other conferences. So when you get to play us, like our television deal on the sec, games are worth the most right now in the country. So meaning our properties, like when Ole Miss plays Georgia or Alabama plays lsu, those games are the most valuable throughout the course of the season and the Big Ten is second. So when we split up those matchups, we neutralize or not even. We diminish our earning power. So when we let Penn State play Utah, and this is not a shot at Utah, I love Utah's program, or we let Alabama play North Carolina, we are giving you free money. And that's where I think this is difficult is all these conferences are like independent entities. So it's just fucked up. I hear what you're doing and your heart's in the right place, but the SEC would never agree to that. The Big Ten would never agree to that. The big 12 might, but those two conferences would not. I think I heard McShay or someone say within the last couple weeks that what is going to happen is the College Football Playoff buys are going to turn out to be the Big Ten. Winner gets a buy, the SEC winner gets a buy, and then you just pick the other two teams to get a buy. Who you think are the best two teams. It's like, because the SEC and the Big Ten have all the power and they're going to start yielding their power. So the sec, what I think should happen is every conference should play nine conference games, even 10 conference games. And then your other two conference games are against other two big. You know. So if you're an SEC team, you play nine conference games and then your other three opponents are from the Big 12 or the ACC. And the Big Ten does the same thing. The Big Ten plays nine conference games and their other three opponents are from the ACC or the Big Ten or the Big 12. And it kind of rotates that way. That's how I think I would do it. But I wouldn't take away from Big Ten or SEC games.
DraftKings Advertiser
It's the most wonderful time of year.
Colin Cowherd
For getting in on all the hoops.
DraftKings Advertiser
Football and hockey action at the Draft King Sportsbook. It's the season of giving and we're being gifted. College football and basketball, pro football and basketball and pro hockey, too. Almost 24 7. So many games every day. So many opportunities to place your first bet. Try betting on something simple like picking.
Colin Cowherd
A team to win.
DraftKings Advertiser
Go to DraftKingsportsbook app and place your bet. And here's a gift for all new customers. Bet 5 bucks to get 150 in bonus bets if your bet wins, download the DraftKingsportsbook app and use the Code John. That's Code Johan for new customers to get 150 in bonus bets if your first bet wins when you bet just five bucks. Happy holidays from DraftKings. The crown is yours.
Gambling Helpline
GAMBLING PROBLEM Call 1-800-GAMBLER in New York, call 877-8-HOPENY or text hopeny 467-369 in Connecticut. Help is available for problem gambling. Call 888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org Please play responsibly on behalf of Boot Hill Casino and Resort in Kansas, 21 and over. Age and eligibility varies by jurisdiction. Boyd in Ontario one bonus bet per customer base on amount of initial touchdown bet and expires 168 hours after issuance. One single use boost per customer that only appl. See sportsbook.draftkings.com promos for additional terms and responsible gaming resources.
T-Mobile Advertiser
You can count on T Mobile to help keep you connected from big cities to small towns on America's largest 5G network. Switch the T Mobile keep your phone and they'll pay it off up to 800 bucks per line via prepaid card. Learn more@t mobile.com heap and switch up to four lines via virtual prepaid card. Allow 15 days qualifying unlock device credit service port in 90 plus days with device and eligible carrier and timely redemption required. Cart has no cash access and expires in six months.
Katie Couric
Hey everyone, it's Katie Couric. Well, the election is in the home stretch and I'm exhausted, but turns out the end is near, right in time for a new season of my podcast. Next Question. This podcast is for people like me who need a little perspective and insight. I'm bringing in some foks friends of Katie to help me out, like Ezra Klein, Van Jones, Jen Psaki, Asted Herndon. But we're also going to have some fun, even though these days fun and politics seems like an oxymoron. But we'll do that thanks to some of my friends like Samantha bee, Roy Wood Jr. And Charlemagne tha God. We're going to take some viewer questions as well. I mean, isn't that what democracy is all about? Power to the podcast for the people.
Colin Cowherd
Power.
Katie Couric
So whether you're obsessed with the news or just trying to figure out what's going on, this season of Next Question is for you. Check out our new season of Next Question with me, Katie Couric, on the iHeartRadio app. Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Colin Cowherd
Quoting for the Mailbag why isn't Dan Quinn gaining any momentum for Coach of the Year? He took the second worst team in the NFL to an 11 win team and not a ton of talent. Something this team has not accomplished in over 20 years. I think the Coach of the Year is a little like the mvp, that the momentum and the narrative starts early and then it's hard to slow it down. Like Kevin O'Connell, people were all in on that early and then they never really pivoted. It's like what he's done is awesome. And obviously if he beats the Lions, I got no issue with him winning the award. But they were, they were making a playoff push last year before Kirk Cousins tore his Achilles. They won like 12 or 13 games two years ago. So like his team's been good with a lot of these same players. Not trying to diminish anything he's doing. I would say the same Dan Quinn and Jim Harbaugh. Dan Quinn's team drafted second, Jim Harbaugh's team drafted fifth. They were dog shit. If it was comeback player of the year, but it was for Coach of the Year, it'd be between those two guys now. I think that Kevin O'Connell thinks pretty easy. They were not good last year. But yeah, I don't know, I just. There's just no overcoming that momentum. I think what Dan Campbell. If Dan Campbell wins this game, I think he has to win it because of how many injuries they've had. Got a question for the mailbag?
DraftKings Advertiser
Over the past year we saw a.
Colin Cowherd
Running back market change dramatically beginning 2024 with no one wanting to pay running backs big money to running backs being recognized again as essential for team success despite it being a passing heavy league. Do you believe this season running backs are being highly valued again is directly connected to having a franchise quarterback? During the past few seasons we saw teams find their franchise quarterback and now they good portion has theirs. It seems as if now the running back in those teams are gaining or having career years. Also if you do agree, do you think teams should focus more on paying big contracts to a dynamic receiver in quarterback duo or a consistent running back in quarterback duo? I think I would rather have one of the star running backs like I'd rather have, you know, Gibbs on a rookie contract. But let's use saquon who makes 13 $12 million a year and a solid wide receiver than a 30 million dollar wide receiver and a 50 million dollar quarterback and just random running backs. Now Jefferson's A bad example because he's the best. But let's just use non like Justin Jefferson or Jamar Chase. I think you could make a legit argument. Would you rather have Jameer Gibbs, you know, Saquon Barkley, Derek Henry? It depends how good your offensive line is and what style quarterback you have. But I don't know. The more I think about it, I was like, I'd rather have Justin Jefferson. I'd rather have Jamar Chase. You know, if you're an Eagles fan right now, would you rather have Saquon or just a middle tier running back or A.J. brown or a middle tier wide receiver? If you could only keep one of the two guys, the good part, the argument for you guys, like we got them both. But I'm just saying big picture. If next year you could only keep AJ Brown or Saquon Barkley. I think it's a hard discussion. I think it would. It varies player to player. The reality is you don't really have to make that decision because the cost of running backs is so low. Like it's linebackers, tight ends and running backs are all under on average $15 million a year. So you're basically paying. And you could argue like if you're Saquon, I'm not a $25 million player this year. You do get kind of screwed. If Debo stays with the Niners next season, why not fully transition him to running back? Ego Seems like he could be McCaffrey Light. Well, I think they've kind of transitioned them a little this year. They've put him at kickoff returner, which is not nothing like and maybe he liked he did it in college and he's good at it. But like how many players, you know, they wouldn't put Jamar Chase back there? Even though Jamar Chase probably be freaking awesome at it. They wouldn't put, you know, think of some wide receivers you could put back there that would be good. Now D ball is unique, but I think they're already transitioning him a little bit. You draft Ricky Pearsall, I you comes back, I think his role will just go back to more of that hybrid mold because he's not a true just wide receiver. That's not where he's at his best. He's at his best getting touches behind the line of scrimmage, whether that's passes or rushes. And obviously kickoff return he's really good at. So this is the Alabama you said deserve to be in the playoffs because they have more talent. Alabama was a 22 1/2 point favorite over Vanderbilt, a 14 point favorite over Oklahoma and a 16 1/2 point favorite over Michigan. Yeah, bro, they lost. I don't know what to tell you. Every time Caitlin DeBoer loses, OSU fans gotta let you know. As a dedicated Seahawks fan, I'm eager to see how our team rise to the next level. The quarterback position is crucial and curious about your thoughts on the best pass forward. Do you believe Geno Smith is the long term answer for us? He had notable success including leading the league in completion percentage in 22 and earning Pro bowl selections in 22 and 23. Alternatively, should we consider drafting a new quarterback to develop in the future? Some analysts suggest the Seahawks might be sleepers to draft a quarterback even with Geno set to return in 24. Or is exploring a trade for someone like Kyler Murray a viable option? If Arizona would be willing to trade you Kyler Murray inside the division, I think that's a pretty big red flag. I would not say that's an option, but maybe Ryan Grubb would like to work with them. I would just keep Geno before I traded for Kyler Murray. I think the best option would be, you know, I would sign Sam Darnold. I would take Sam Darnold over Geno. Younger, similar skill set. I think just better player or has a chance. I mean Geno's this year has been a little all over the place, but he's a solid player. I do think Geno the type guy is a pretty good bridge quarterback if you drafted a young guy. It's why I thought Michael Penix made a lot of sense for you guys. Obviously, you know, he got drafted way higher than when you guys picked. But I don't, I don't really know who there is to draft. I just don't think that guy's really there. So I just think Geno is not your long term future. But he's just kind of your guy for now. He's just your best case scenario of just having a guy to fill that void. And it sucks kind of being in quarterback purgatory, but that's kind of where you are. You're in quarterback purgatory. Luckily your team's still solid and you're competing to win, you know, nine, 10 games. It could be worse. It really could. You could be one of those shitty 3, 4 win teams, but you're winning 9, 10 games and you're just in position and you know your general manager is aggressive and if there's a chance to pounce, he will.
T-Mobile Advertiser
The volume.
DraftKings Advertiser
Bring the food at your Big Game party.
Colin Cowherd
To a whole new level with the.
DraftKings Advertiser
Original Louisiana brand hot sauce with bold, authentic flavor that embodies the rich culinary tradition of Louisiana. The original Louisiana brand hot sauce is perfect for those who demand the great flavor with just the right amount of heat. Crafted with a time tested recipe, it's the perfect companion for grilling, dipping and cheering on your favorite team. With a burst of that Louisiana heat for burgers to wings, every dish becomes a touchdown, a flavor turning your tailgate into the ultimate culinary celebration. Available at a store near you.
Allstate Advertiser
Some people just know they could save hundreds on car insurance by checking Allstate First. Like you know to check you have the tickets in your wallet first before you drive two hours to the big game. Seriously, you had one job. Now the closest you'll get to the 50 yard line is parking lot D. Yeah, checking first is smart, so check Allstate first for a quote that could save you hundreds. You're in good hands with Allstate Savings. Vary terms apply. Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates Northbrook, Illinois Travis Matthew is gear.
DraftKings Advertiser
Designed for the life you're living. Whether you need something nice, button ups, polos, Whether you need some loungewear, the hoodies cannot recommend them enough. The quarter zips Fantastic. Whether you're chasing adventures or just chasing the perfect coffee. No matter what you're doing, a business meeting, you name it. If you're a podcaster, they got you covered. Make every moment count in gear that is as confident as you are. I swear by Travis Matthew Stuff. Do yourself a favor and hit up travismathu.com all new customers get 20% off their first order. Again, that's travismathieu.com you'll thank me later.
Jon Stewart
Jon Stewart is back in the host chair at the Daily show, which means he's also back in our ears on the Daily Show Ears Edition podcast. Join late night legend John Stewart and the best news team for today's biggest headlines, exclusive extended interviews and more. Now this is a second term we can all get behind. Listen to the Daily Show Ears edition on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcast or wherever you get your podcast.
Summary of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd" – Episode: 3 & Out - Mailbag
Release Date: January 2, 2025
Host: Colin Cowherd
Produced by: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
In the episode titled "3 & Out - Mailbag," Colin Cowherd delivers a dynamic and engaging session focused primarily on listener interactions and current sports debates. Skipping over the usual advertisements and non-content segments, Colin dives deep into various topics ranging from NFL playoff predictions to the intricacies of college football scheduling. This summary captures all the essential discussions, insights, and conclusions presented during the episode.
At the outset, Colin shares a personal health update with his audience, adding a relatable and human touch to the episode.
Quote:
"Your boy was really hurting yesterday during the day I've had back to back. My IV lady has come over twice and honestly it might have saved my life because I was not literally, but I was in pretty bad shape..."
Timestamp: [02:15]
Summary:
Colin recounts experiencing significant health issues, necessitating two IV treatments. While he emphasizes gradual improvement—mentioning reduced fatigue and a slight recovery—he candidly discusses the challenges he faced, setting a transparent tone for the episode.
Colin addresses a listener named Kellen's thoughts on a potential Chargers vs. Chiefs divisional round game.
Quote:
"As a Chargers fan, I am hungry for another shot at KC and we have a better chance of winning in Kansas City than going on the road to Buffalo or Baltimore..."
Timestamp: [04:20]
Summary:
Kellen, a Chargers supporter, expresses optimism about his team's prospects against the Chiefs, highlighting historical matchups and home-field advantages. He believes the Chargers have a strategic edge playing in Kansas City over facing teams like Buffalo or Baltimore on the road. Colin engages with this analysis, discussing momentum shifts and the Chiefs' recent performances, particularly noting their decision to start Carson Wentz and the potential impacts on their playoff run.
A listener questions why general managers (GMs) rarely receive second chances after their initial tenure.
Quote:
"We don't get second chances, not like coaches... But sometimes you look for the next best thing..."
Timestamp: [10:45]
Summary:
Colin reflects on insights from a former GM, explaining the industry’s reluctance to rehire GMs compared to coaches. He suggests that financial decisions and organizational reputation play significant roles in this trend. The discussion touches upon the challenges GMs face, such as missed draft opportunities or poor free-agent signings, and why these missteps can lead to hesitancy in rehiring.
A listener inquires about Scatter Boo’s draft prospects following his impressive performance in the Peach Bowl.
Quote:
"Anyone with a brain, if you watch him, that guy's a football player and a really good football player."
Timestamp: [16:00]
Summary:
Colin assesses Scatter Boo’s chances in the NFL Draft, predicting he will likely be a second-day pick rather than a first-round talent. He reasons that while Scatter Boo demonstrates exceptional football instincts and physicality, concerns about his 40-yard dash time at the combine could negatively impact his draft stock. Despite this, Colin praises Scatter Boo’s football intelligence and potential, suggesting that teams valuing instinctual play may still find him an attractive pick.
A listener proposes a restructuring of the college football playoff system to ensure a more accurate representation of the top teams.
Quote:
"The SEC would never agree to that. The Big Ten would never agree to that..."
Timestamp: [13:30]
Summary:
The listener suggests reducing the number of conference games and standardizing non-conference matchups to level the playing field and ensure the top teams are accurately represented in the playoffs. Colin analyzes the feasibility of this proposal, highlighting the financial dominance and contractual obligations of major conferences like the SEC and Big Ten. He concludes that while the idea has merit, the powerful conferences are unlikely to agree due to their lucrative television deals and competitive advantages.
Colin discusses why Dan Quinn isn’t garnering sufficient momentum for the Coach of the Year award despite significant team improvements.
Quote:
"If he beats the Lions, I have no issue with him winning the award."
Timestamp: [21:00]
Summary:
Colin contemplates the nature of award momentum, pointing out that early narratives often dominate over substantial achievements made later in the season. He acknowledges Dan Quinn’s success in transforming a struggling team into an 11-win contender but notes that other coaches like Kevin O’Connell have maintained consistent visibility and support, making it harder for Quinn to secure the accolade despite his accomplishments.
A listener explores the changing market dynamics for running backs and their relationship with franchise quarterbacks.
Quote:
"I think it varies player to player... The reality is you don't really have to make that decision because the cost of running backs is so low."
Timestamp: [23:30]
Summary:
Colin delves into the resurgence of running backs in the NFL, linking their value to the presence of franchise quarterbacks. He debates whether teams should prioritize dynamic receivers or consistent running backs when building their rosters. Colin suggests that while star running backs on rookie contracts provide significant value, the low average cost of running backs allows teams flexibility in roster construction without heavy financial commitments.
A listener from the Seahawks seeks advice on whether to continue backing Geno Smith or to explore other quarterback options.
Quote:
"I think the best option would be, you know, I would sign Sam Darnold. I would take Sam Darnold over Geno."
Timestamp: [26:15]
Summary:
Colin advises the Seahawks to view Geno Smith as a bridge quarterback while considering long-term solutions such as drafting a new quarterback or exploring trade options. He emphasizes the importance of balancing immediate competitiveness with future planning, suggesting that while Geno has been solid, investing in a younger talent like Sam Darnold could provide better long-term benefits.
Throughout the episode, Colin Cowherd effectively engages with his audience through thoughtful analysis and candid discussions. By addressing a wide range of topics—from NFL playoff scenarios and general manager practices to college football scheduling and player evaluations—Colin provides listeners with comprehensive insights into the current sports landscape. His ability to blend personal anecdotes with professional analysis makes the episode both informative and relatable.
Personal Health:
"Your boy was really hurting yesterday during the day I've had back to back IVs..."
[02:15]
Chargers vs. Chiefs Discussion:
"As a Chargers fan, I am hungry for another shot at KC and we have a better chance of winning in Kansas City..."
[04:20]
GMs’ Rehiring Practices:
"We don't get second chances, not like coaches..."
[10:45]
Scatter Boo’s Draft Prospects:
"Anyone with a brain, if you watch him, that guy's a football player and a really good football player."
[16:00]
Coach of the Year Debate:
"If he beats the Lions, I have no issue with him winning the award."
[21:00]
Running Backs’ Value:
"I think it varies player to player... The reality is you don't really have to make that decision because the cost of running backs is so low."
[23:30]
Seahawks’ Quarterback Advice:
"I think the best option would be, you know, I would sign Sam Darnold. I would take Sam Darnold over Geno."
[26:15]
This structured summary encapsulates the essence of Colin Cowherd’s "3 & Out - Mailbag" episode, providing a comprehensive overview for listeners and those who may not have tuned in.