Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Episode 3 & Out
Episode Information:
- Title: 3 & Out - MNF Reaction, Is Mahomes okay, Michael Vick is coming back
- Host: Jon Middlekauff (as part of The Herd with Colin Cowherd)
- Release Date: December 17, 2024
- Description: A deep dive into the latest NFL happenings, including Monday Night Football reactions, updates on Patrick Mahomes’ injury, and surprising news about Michael Vick’s potential return to coaching.
1. Monday Night Football Reaction
Jon Middlekauff begins the episode by reflecting on the recent Monday Night Football games, highlighting the outcomes and performances of key teams.
-
Vikings vs. Bears:
- Performance: Vikings secured a decisive victory over the Bears, showcasing their dominance.
- Insight: Middlekauff emphasizes the Vikings' consistent performance, attributing their success to strong ownership and effective franchise management.
- Quote:
- "The Vikings are a well-run franchise. They start at the top, with ownership and hiring the right people, drafting and developing good players." [06:45]
-
Atlanta Falcons:
- Performance: The Falcons' game was initially perceived as a potential disaster but turned riveting in the final minutes.
- Insight: Middlekauff criticizes the Falcons’ management and quarterback performance, labeling the team as one of the NFL’s bigger disappointments.
- Quote:
- "The Falcons are an embarrassment. They've been bad, and their quarterback looks completely overmanned." [12:30]
2. Patrick Mahomes’ Injury Status
A significant portion of the episode focuses on the recent injury update concerning Kansas City Chiefs' star quarterback Patrick Mahomes.
-
Injury Details:
- Mahomes sustained a high ankle sprain, rendering him week-to-week.
- The injury raises concerns about his availability for crucial upcoming games, including the Christmas matchup.
-
Impact on the Chiefs:
- Performance: Without Mahomes, the Chiefs face a challenging schedule with consecutive tough opponents.
- Strategy: Middlekauff discusses the potential strategies the Chiefs might employ in Mahomes’ absence, including reliance on backup quarterbacks like Carson Wentz.
- Quote:
- "Patrick Mahomes has a high ankle sprain and is week to week. If he's out, Carson Wentz will be playing, but he's nowhere near the athlete he once was." [28:10]
-
Business Angle:
- The episode touches on the business implications of Mahomes’ injury, particularly the NFL's partnership with Netflix and the sustained viewership despite star player setbacks.
- Quote:
- "Even if Mahomes is injured, the NFL's partnership with Netflix ensures that viewership remains strong. It's a testament to the league's resilience." [35:50]
3. Michael Vick's Potential Return to Coaching
In an unexpected turn, Middlekauff discusses rumors about former NFL quarterback Michael Vick considering a return to the sport in a coaching capacity.
-
Potential Role:
- Vick is reportedly in serious discussions to become the head coach at Sacramento State, marking a surprising move given his limited coaching experience.
-
Prospects and Challenges:
- Middlekauff speculates on how Vick’s playing experience and leadership qualities could translate into coaching, while also expressing skepticism about his lack of connections on the West Coast.
- Quote:
- "Michael Vick's potential coaching role at Sacramento State is beyond shocking. He has no connections there, but his leadership skills could make a difference." [45:20]
-
Comparison with Other Former Players:
- The discussion includes comparisons to other former players like Peyton Manning and Tom Brady, evaluating their involvement in coaching and team management.
- Quote:
- "It would be cool to see former stars like Michael Vick give back to the game, much like Peyton Manning has been involved in various business ventures." [50:15]
4. General NFL Analysis
Middlekauff offers a comprehensive analysis of various NFL teams, focusing on leadership, management, and on-field performance.
-
Franchise Leadership:
- Highlights the stark contrast between well-managed franchises like the Vikings and poorly managed ones like the Bears, Raiders, and Falcons.
- Quote:
- "When ownership is strong and the franchise is well-run, teams like the Vikings consistently perform well. The Bears, on the other hand, are a joke due to poor management." [22:40]
-
Quarterback Evaluations:
- Critiques various quarterbacks across the league, including Caleb Williams, Desmond Ritter, and Kirk Cousins, pointing out their strengths and weaknesses.
- Quote:
- "Kirk Cousins and Caleb Williams are struggling under immense pressure, reflecting poorly on their teams' offensive lines." [30:55]
-
Coaching Effectiveness:
- Discusses the impact of coaching on team performance, praising leaders like Mike Tomlin while criticizing others for their inability to adapt and lead effectively.
- Quote:
- "Mike Tomlin exemplifies exceptional leadership, helping his players thrive even in tough seasons, unlike some other coaches who falter under pressure." [65:10]
5. Other NFL Updates and Insights
The episode also delves into additional NFL topics, including player transfers in college football, the transfer portal's impact, and the evaluation of running backs.
-
Transfer Portal:
- Middlekauff analyzes recent movements within the transfer portal, emphasizing its growing influence on college football and player careers.
- Quote:
- "The transfer portal has revolutionized college football, allowing players to move freely and teams to reshape their rosters mid-season." [75:30]
-
Running Back Evaluations:
- Provides insights on evaluating running backs based on their physical skills and how offensive schemes impact their performance.
- Quote:
- "Evaluating running backs goes beyond stats. You need to consider their speed, strength, vision, and how they fit into the team's offensive scheme." [80:45]
6. Conclusion
In wrapping up the episode, Middlekauff reflects on the current state of the NFL, emphasizing the importance of leadership, effective management, and player performance in determining team success.
- Final Thoughts:
- Stresses that the NFL remains unpredictable, with injuries and managerial decisions playing pivotal roles in shaping the season's outcomes.
- Quote:
- "The NFL is a constantly evolving landscape. Leadership and adaptability are key to navigating the challenges that arise throughout the season." [99:20]
Notable Quotes:
-
On Vikings' Leadership:
- "The Vikings are a well-run franchise. They start at the top, with ownership and hiring the right people, drafting and developing good players." [06:45]
-
On Falcons' Performance:
- "The Falcons are an embarrassment. They've been bad, and their quarterback looks completely overmanned." [12:30]
-
On Mahomes’ Injury:
- "Patrick Mahomes has a high ankle sprain and is week to week. If he's out, Carson Wentz will be playing, but he's nowhere near the athlete he once was." [28:10]
-
On Michael Vick’s Coaching Potential:
- "Michael Vick's potential coaching role at Sacramento State is beyond shocking. He has no connections there, but his leadership skills could make a difference." [45:20]
-
On Transfer Portal Impact:
- "The transfer portal has revolutionized college football, allowing players to move freely and teams to reshape their rosters mid-season." [75:30]
-
On Running Back Evaluations:
- "Evaluating running backs goes beyond stats. You need to consider their speed, strength, vision, and how they fit into the team's offensive scheme." [80:45]
-
Final Reflection:
- "The NFL is a constantly evolving landscape. Leadership and adaptability are key to navigating the challenges that arise throughout the season." [99:20]
Conclusion: In this episode of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd," host Jon Middlekauff provides an in-depth analysis of recent NFL events, focusing on team performances, player injuries, and potential coaching changes. Through detailed discussions and critical insights, Middlekauff offers listeners a comprehensive understanding of the current state of the NFL, emphasizing the significance of effective leadership and management in achieving team success.