Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Episode 3 & Out

Release Date: March 27, 2025
Title: 3 & Out - What's Next for the Giants, NIL Has Ruined the NCAA Tournament, JJ Watt to Call Games
Host: John Middlekauff
Produced by: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume

Introduction

In the latest episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host John Middlekauff dives deep into three pivotal sports topics: the New York Giants' recent acquisition of Russell Wilson, the detrimental effects of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policies on the NCAA Tournament, and former NFL star JJ Watt's transition to a broadcasting role with CBS. The episode, recorded on March 26, 2025, offers insightful analysis, heated debates, and forward-looking perspectives on these pressing issues.

1. What's Next for the Giants: Russell Wilson’s Signing

John Middlekauff opens the discussion with the New York Giants' signing of quarterback Russell Wilson. He explores the immediate and long-term implications of this high-profile acquisition.

• Impact on the Giants' Future: Middlekauff emphasizes that Wilson's guaranteed $10.5 million represents a significant financial commitment, yet he questions the Giants' quarterback situation, highlighting the uncertainty surrounding their decision to secure Wilson without drafting a new quarterback (00:10:15).

  "The Giants have signed Russell Wilson to what, ten and a half million dollars guaranteed. Now they're not going to take a quarterback immediately. Who knows if they'll draft another quarterback or rely solely on Wilson," (00:12:30).

• Draft Implications: He speculates on the Giants' drafting strategies, suggesting that their current quarterbacks, Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, rank among the lower tiers in the NFL. Middlekauff advocates for the Giants to consider drafting young, dynamic quarterbacks like Travis Hunter or Abdul Carter to rejuvenate their roster (00:15:45).

  "If I was John Mara, it's like, okay, if we're not going to take Shador, let's take Travis. Suddenly, we have a couple of really young, dynamic players," (00:16:10).

• Financial Considerations: Middlekauff discusses the financial ramifications, comparing the combined value of Wilson and Winston to bridge quarterbacks like Gardner Minshew. He argues that reallocating funds towards younger talent could offer better long-term benefits (00:18:25).

2. NIL Has Ruined the NCAA Tournament

The conversation shifts to the impact of NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) policies on college sports, particularly the NCAA Tournament.

• Dominance of Power 4 Conferences: Middlekauff asserts that NIL has exacerbated the imbalance in college sports, making it increasingly difficult for smaller programs to compete. He points out that the Sweet 16 features predominantly teams from the Big 10, SEC, and Big 12, sidelining smaller schools like Boise State or Fresno State (00:22:10).

  "The NIL and the transfer portal have been such hot topics because of the Cinderella dead. We saw in college football how the little guy got screwed," (00:23:50).

• Financial Disparities: He predicts a future where consistent revenue sharing leads to salary caps across Power 4 programs, yet NIL deals would continue to favor affluent institutions. This, he argues, ensures that only the established powerhouses remain contenders annually (00:25:05).

  "Over the next twelve months, there will be some consistent revenue sharing with salary caps, but NIL will still disproportionately benefit the Power 4, keeping the same teams dominating year after year," (00:26:20).

• Transfer Portal Impact: Middlekauff highlights how the transfer portal, combined with NIL, allows top talent to move freely, often leaving weaker programs depleted. He reminisces about his time at Fresno State, illustrating how the lack of NIL and transfer portals once offered more stability for smaller schools (00:27:35).

3. JJ Watt to Call Games: Transition to Broadcasting

The third segment covers JJ Watt's new role as a commentator for CBS, replacing Jim Nantz.

• JJ Watt’s Broadcasting Prospects: Middlekauff praises Watt’s personality pivot over the years, noting his increased likability and ability to engage with audiences. He expresses optimism about Watt bringing a fresh perspective to game analysis (00:30:45).

  "JJ Watt has done an incredible personality pivot. He’s lightened up and seems like a very enjoyable guy. His role at CBS will bring a new dynamic to their game coverage," (00:31:10).

• Comparison with Other Former Athletes: He contrasts Watt's smooth transition with other athletes who have struggled to find their footing in broadcasting, such as Drew Brees or Aaron Rodgers. Middlekauff believes Watt’s approachability and authenticity will set him apart (00:33:20).

  "Unlike some other former athletes, JJ seems genuine and relatable, which is exactly what audiences want from a commentator," (00:34:05).

• CBS vs. Fox Network: Discussing network differences, Middlekauff notes that CBS tends to maintain a more conservative and polished presentation. However, he hopes that Watt can infuse some of the edginess seen on networks like Fox (00:35:50).

  "CBS can be a bit stiffer compared to Fox, but with JJ Watt, they might find a balance between professionalism and a more relaxed, engaging style," (00:36:30).

4. Mailbag: Draft Process Insights

In the mailbag segment, Middlekauff addresses audience questions about the NFL draft process.

• Understanding Teams' Draft Decisions: He explains that teams develop their draft boards well before draft day, primarily during the fall scouting period, the All-Star Games, and the Combine. Middlekauff emphasizes the importance of meeting players to assess their character and fit within the team (00:40:10).

  "By the time the draft happens, GMs have a pretty good idea of who they want based on extensive scouting and player interactions," (00:41:00).

• Variability and Uncertainty: Middlekauff acknowledges the unpredictable nature of draft night, where unforeseen developments can alter teams' choices. He advises listeners that while teams have plans, the dynamic environment of draft day means flexibility is crucial (00:42:25).

  "There are so many variables on draft day. Even if you have a solid plan, something unexpected can shift the entire board," (00:43:15).

• Player Evaluation Beyond Talent: Highlighting that not all drafted players make a significant impact, Middlekauff stresses the balance teams must maintain between a player's skill set and their potential fit within the team's culture and strategy (00:44:50).

  "It's not just about talent. Teams must consider how a player will mesh with their existing roster and organizational philosophy," (00:45:30).

5. Sports Core Memories and Player Performances

Middlekauff shares personal sports memories and discusses standout performances that have left lasting impressions.

• Iconic Plays: Recalling moments like Michael Vick’s game-winning TD run and Terrell Owens’ catches, Middlekauff underscores the emotional impact these plays have on fans and their enduring legacy in sports history (00:50:10).

  "Terrell Owens' catch against the Packers in the wild card game – that’s a memory I’ll never forget," (00:51:30).

• Quarterback Performances: He debates the postseason success of quarterbacks like Jalen Hurts and Lamar Jackson, questioning whether postseason achievements should elevate a quarterback’s ranking despite regular-season inconsistencies (01:00:45).

  "Jalen Hurts has been excellent in the Super Bowls, but does that outweigh his regular-season flaws? It’s a tough call," (01:02:15).

Conclusion

John Middlekauff's episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd offers a comprehensive exploration of significant current sports topics, providing listeners with thoughtful analysis and passionate commentary. From the strategic uncertainties surrounding the Giants' quarterback situation to the systemic issues plaguing the NCAA Tournament due to NIL policies, and the promising yet scrutinized transition of JJ Watt into broadcasting, the episode encapsulates the dynamic and often contentious landscape of contemporary sports.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• "If I was John Mara, it's like, okay, if we're not going to take Shador, let's take Travis. Suddenly, we have a couple of really young, dynamic players." – John Middlekauff (00:16:10)

• "The NIL and the transfer portal have been such hot topics because of the Cinderella dead. We saw in college football how the little guy got screwed." – John Middlekauff (00:23:50)

• "JJ Watt has done an incredible personality pivot. He’s lightened up and seems like a very enjoyable guy. His role at CBS will bring a new dynamic to their game coverage." – John Middlekauff (00:31:10)

• "By the time the draft happens, GMs have a pretty good idea of who they want based on extensive scouting and player interactions." – John Middlekauff (00:41:00)

• "Terrell Owens' catch against the Packers in the wild card game – that’s a memory I’ll never forget." – John Middlekauff (00:51:30)

Stay Connected

For more in-depth discussions and expert opinions on the latest sports stories, subscribe to The Herd with Colin Cowherd on your preferred podcast platform, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.