Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd
Episode: 3 Rounds w/Din Thomas - Daniel Cormier GOES IN ON Ilia Topuria #1 P4P ranking over Islam Makhachev
Release Date: July 6, 2025
Host: Daniel Cormier
Guest: Dean Thomas
Sponsor: Total Wireless (Skipped in Summary)
1. Introduction and Guest Welcome [02:42 - 03:14]
Daniel Cormier opens the episode with enthusiastic greetings, introducing Dean Thomas as the guest for the discussion. Cormier highlights his own training camp activities and teasing the topic of the day: the recent rise of Ilia Topuria in the pound-for-pound (P4P) rankings.
Quote:
"Ilia Topuria last weekend beat Charles Oliveira to become the lightweight champion, making him a double champ. Now, Ilia Toporia on yesterday was announced as the new number one pound for pound fighter in the world."
— Daniel Cormier [04:03]
2. Ilia Topuria's #1 P4P Ranking Debate [03:14 - 07:03]
Cormier and Thomas delve into Ilia Topuria's recent achievements, discussing his victory over Charles Oliveira and his ascent to the top of the P4P rankings. Dean Thomas expresses strong agreement with Topuria's ranking, emphasizing his impressive strength of schedule and technical prowess.
Key Points:
- Topuria's Performance: Dominant victories, including a first-round knockout of Oliveira.
- Ranking Justification: Thomas cites Topuria's consistent performance and quality of opponents as reasons for his #1 P4P status.
- Future Implications: Discussion revolves around whether Topuria's ranking will hold or if Islam Makhachev can reclaim the top spot.
Notable Quote:
"Ilot Toria as the number one pound for pound fighter in the world. No doubt about it."
— Dean Thomas [04:28]
3. Potential Matchup: Ilia Topuria vs. Islam Makhachev [05:45 - 07:43]
The conversation shifts to the potential showdown between Ilia Topuria and Islam Makhachev. Dean Thomas confidently predicts Topuria's victory over Makhachev, critiquing Makhachev's past performances and questioning his ability to adapt to Topuria's fighting style.
Key Points:
- Thomas's Prediction: Topuria will defeat Makhachev, solidifying his P4P standing.
- Makhachev's Challenges: Struggles with taking opponents down, particularly against top-tier fighters like Alexander Volkanovski.
- Ranking Dynamics: If Makhachev wins against other contenders, the dynamics of the P4P rankings could shift again.
Notable Quote:
"I think he beats Islam."
— Dean Thomas [05:45]
4. Jamal Hill's Struggles and Performance Analysis [07:03 - 12:29]
The discussion transitions to Jamal Hill, a former champion currently experiencing a three-fight losing streak. Thomas critiques Hill's preparation and training discipline, suggesting that physical and technical shortcomings are hindering his performance.
Key Points:
- Hill's Excuses: Claims of injuries and not being at his optimal level.
- Thomas's Critique: Accuses Hill of lack of responsibility and insufficient training, leading to predictable fight outcomes.
- Path Forward: Believes Hill can recover within the light heavyweight division if he improves his game and maintains discipline.
Notable Quote:
"He's become predictable. He's got to add more stuff to his game."
— Dean Thomas [11:52]
5. Media Responsibility in Reporting Fighters' Stories [18:12 - 20:39]
Cormier and Thomas engage in a critical discussion about the media's role in accurately reporting fighters' personal stories and the ethical responsibilities that come with having a large platform.
Key Points:
- Accuracy and Verification: Emphasize the need to fact-check stories before broadcasting.
- Impact of Misinformation: Highlight how spreading unverified rumors can damage fighters' reputations.
- Personal Responsibility: Both agree that journalists and media personalities must prioritize truthfulness over sensationalism.
Notable Quotes:
"You have a responsibility to tell the truth and to do your homework."
— Dean Thomas [19:46]
"You have to always preface everything you say with rumor has it, or allegedly."
— Dean Thomas [20:39]
6. Refereeing and Fight Stoppages Responsibility [22:04 - 23:03]
The topic shifts to the role of referees in ensuring fighter safety, referencing specific instances where referee decisions were questioned.
Key Points:
- Case Study - Jack Hermanson: Discusses a recent knockout and the subsequent actions (or lack thereof) by the referee.
- Referee's Role: Emphasizes the importance of referees making split-second decisions to protect fighters.
- Shared Responsibility: Acknowledges that both referees and fighters have roles in maintaining fight integrity and safety.
Notable Quote:
"The ref should have tackled him."
— Dean Thomas [22:39]
7. Final Thoughts on Ilia Topuria's Impact and Character [23:03 - 27:38]
In concluding the episode, Cormier reflects on Ilia Topuria's influence both inside and outside the Octagon. He contrasts Topuria's demeanor with that of other fighters like Conor McGregor, emphasizing Topuria's respectful and humble nature.
Key Points:
- Topuria's Character: Portrayed as a grounded and confident fighter who commands respect.
- Public Perception: Addresses the polarized reactions to Topuria, advocating for recognition of his genuine persona.
- Future Prospects: Optimistic about Topuria's continued success and positive influence in the sport.
Notable Quote:
"He is watching an individual who believes that only success lies ahead of them every time they step into the octagon."
— Daniel Cormier [27:38]
8. Closing Remarks (Skipped Advertisements and Outros)
The episode wraps up without covering any advertisements or non-content segments, ensuring that the focus remains on the in-depth discussions and insights shared between Daniel Cormier and Dean Thomas.
Conclusion:
This episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd offers a comprehensive analysis of Ilia Topuria's standing in the P4P rankings, the potential impact of a fight against Islam Makhachev, and a critical look at Jamal Hill's recent performances. Additionally, it underscores the ethical responsibilities of the media in reporting accurate information and the crucial role referees play in fighter safety. Dean Thomas provides candid and insightful commentary throughout, making this episode a valuable listen for MMA enthusiasts seeking detailed discussions on current sports topics.