Best of The Herd – Comprehensive Summary

Date Released: April 15, 2025
Podcast: The Herd with Colin Cowherd
Hosts: Colin Cowherd, Jordan Schultz
Collaborators: Nick Wright, Greg Rosenthal, Jeremy Hobson

Introduction

In the "Best of The Herd" episode, Colin Cowherd and Jordan Schultz navigate through a spectrum of compelling sports topics, offering in-depth analyses, passionate debates, and insightful commentary. This episode stands out by delving into the intricacies of the NFL draft, the evolving role of international athletes in major sports leagues, the current dynamics within the NBA's Golden State Warriors, and memorable moments in golf that have captivated audiences worldwide.

1. NFL Draft and Quarterback Strategy

Timestamp: 02:07 - 06:13

Jordan Schultz opens the episode with a critical examination of the upcoming NFL draft, emphasizing the paramount importance of quarterback selections. He categorizes NFL teams into distinct tiers based on their management and quarterback effectiveness.

• Tier One Teams: Schultz identifies eight elite NFL franchises, including Baltimore, Kansas City, Green Bay, Rams, Philadelphia, Detroit, and Buffalo. He states, “[04:30]... the NFL's becoming a little bit like the NBA. Very few at the top, small, middle, large, bottom,” highlighting the concentrated talent and strategic management within these teams.

• Quarterback Importance: Schultz underscores that in the modern NFL, the quarterback is essential, often determining a team’s success or failure. “In the NFL, quarterback is so essential now that if you don't have one, you're a have not,” he explains at [06:13].

• Draft Prospects Analysis: Focusing on the draft prospects, Schultz singles out Cam Ward as a transformative player for Tennessee, capable of elevating the team to Tier Two status. At [05:45], he mentions, “The goal shouldn't be to find the next Patrick Mahomes,” suggesting that teams should prioritize quarterbacks who can secure playoff berths over necessarily producing superstars.

• Comparative Performance: Schultz compares Jackson Dart unfavorably to Zach Wilson, citing their college performances and questioning their NFL readiness. “Jackson Dart to me is Zach Wilson,” he asserts, indicating both might struggle at the professional level.

Notable Quote:

“The NFL's becoming a little bit like the NBA. Very few at the top, small, middle, large, bottom.” – Jordan Schultz [04:30]

2. International Players as Faces of Major Sports Leagues

Timestamp: 05:45 - 35:31

The discussion transitions to the rising prominence of international athletes in major sports leagues, challenging the notion that non-domestic players cannot serve as league icons.

• Breaking Barriers: Schultz advocates for the acceptance and celebration of international players, citing examples like Luka Doncic in the NBA and Rory McIlroy in golf. He counters skepticism by highlighting their ability to connect with fans and embody the competitive spirit of American sports.

• Rory McIlroy’s Triumph: A significant portion is dedicated to Rory McIlroy’s emotional victory at the Masters. Schultz narrates the intensity and vulnerability displayed by McIlroy, comparing it to iconic sports moments. “[47:32]... Rory McIlroy go to his knees and just a waterfall of emotion, just crying in front of everybody,” he describes, emphasizing the raw human element that makes sports so captivating.

• Nick Wright’s Perspective: Nick Wright echoes Schultz’s sentiments, agreeing that international players can indeed become faces of their respective leagues if they possess the requisite charisma and leadership. At [35:31], Wright states, “I think international players definitely can be.”

Notable Quote:

“I don't buy into this. Rory can't be the face of golf or Shay or Messi or Conor McGregor.” – Jordan Schultz [34:10]

3. NBA Dynamics and the Golden State Warriors

Timestamp: 21:13 - 37:34

A deep dive into the current state of the Golden State Warriors offers listeners an insider’s look at the challenges and prospects facing the team.

• Aging Core: Schultz and Nick Wright discuss the Warriors’ aging roster, particularly focusing on veterans like Draymond Green and Steph Curry. Schultz critiques Curry’s defensive capabilities, stating, “[29:28]... he is a true defensive liability.”

• Strategic Mistakes: Wright acknowledges past missteps, including his earlier misjudgment regarding Draymond Green’s conduct. At [28:42], he concedes, “I owe your dear friend Draymond Green an apology.”

• Future Prospects: The hosts debate the Warriors' future, contemplating the impact of recent coaching changes and the integration of younger talent. They ponder whether the team can sustain its success or if further strategic adjustments are necessary.

Notable Quote:

“He is a true defensive liability.” – Jordan Schultz [29:28]

4. Rory McIlroy’s Historic Masters Victory

Timestamp: 37:34 - 47:44

Jordan Schultz paints a vivid picture of Rory McIlroy’s triumphant moment at the Masters, capturing the emotional and historical significance of his win.

• Emotional Resonance: Schultz shares a personal narrative of watching McIlroy’s victory, describing it as one of the most gripping and emotionally charged moments in sports history. He likens McIlroy’s resilience to that of legends like Michael Jordan.

• Comparative Analysis: By juxtaposing McIlroy with Tiger Woods, Schultz highlights the unique journey and emotional investment that make McIlroy’s win particularly compelling. “Rory's always kind of felt like Europe's Tiger. The difference is Tiger's better,” he reflects.

• Impact on Golf: The episode underscores how McIlroy’s victory embodies the essence of sportsmanship and the relentless pursuit of excellence, inspiring both fans and aspiring athletes.

Notable Quote:

“For Rory to go to his knees and just a waterfall of emotion, just crying in front of everybody. And, you know, athletes often say... his reaction tells you he wouldn't have slept for weeks after that.” – Jordan Schultz [47:32]

5. Concluding Discussions and Final Thoughts

Timestamp: 47:44 - 52:35

As the episode winds down, the hosts synthesize their discussions, reiterating key themes and offering final reflections.

• Leadership and Talent: Schultz emphasizes the importance of relentless determination and effective leadership in achieving sports success. He draws parallels between legendary figures, reinforcing the idea that perseverance is paramount.

• Evolution of Sports Icons: The conversation circles back to the evolving nature of sports icons, advocating for a more inclusive and global representation in major leagues.

• Future Outlook: The hosts express optimism about the future of various sports franchises, contingent upon strategic decisions and the cultivation of emerging talent.

Notable Quote:

“The number one quality of success in the world. Are you relentless? How do you react to failure?” – Jordan Schultz [43:57]

Conclusion

The "Best of The Herd" episode masterfully intertwines analysis, personal anecdotes, and spirited debates, offering listeners a multifaceted perspective on contemporary sports. From strategic evaluations of NFL quarterback prospects and the dynamic shifts within the NBA to heartfelt recounts of historic victories in golf, the episode serves as a comprehensive guide for sports enthusiasts eager to stay informed and engaged with the latest developments across various leagues.

Overall Notable Quotes:

1. On NFL Tier Systems:
   “The NFL's becoming a little bit like the NBA. Very few at the top, small, middle, large, bottom.” – Jordan Schultz [04:30]

2. On Draft Strategy:
   “The goal shouldn't be to find the next Patrick Mahomes.” – Jordan Schultz [05:45]

3. On International Players as Icons:
   “I don't buy into this. Rory can't be the face of golf or Shay or Messi or Conor McGregor.” – Jordan Schultz [34:10]

4. On Draymond Green:
   “I owe your dear friend Draymond Green an apology.” – Nick Wright [28:42]

5. On Steph Curry’s Legacy:
   “He is a true defensive liability.” – Jordan Schultz [29:28]

6. On Rory McIlroy’s Victory:
   “For Rory to go to his knees and just a waterfall of emotion, just crying in front of everybody...” – Jordan Schultz [47:32]

This summarizes the key discussions and insights presented in the "Best of The Herd" episode, structured into clear sections with timestamped notable quotes for easy reference.