Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Best of The Herd Release Date: July 31, 2025

The Herd with Colin Cowherd brings listeners a curated compilation of insightful discussions, debates, and stories from one of the most engaging sports talk shows. The Best of The Herd episode encapsulates a variety of topics ranging from major sports trades to personal anecdotes about old-school punishments. Here's a detailed breakdown of the episode's key segments:

1. MLB Trade Deadline Insights

Timestamp: 04:39 – 07:30

The episode kicks off with a deep dive into the Major League Baseball (MLB) trade deadline, highlighting significant moves and their implications for the teams involved.

• Key Trade Highlighted:

  • Mason Miller to the Padres: Rich Davis notes, "They are trading their 100 mile an hour flamethrower closer Mason Miller to the Padres, which affects the Dodgers guys because it's an arms race now with LA and San Diego trying to keep track of each other." (04:45) This trade underscores the intensifying competition between teams aiming to bolster their bullpens ahead of the postseason.

• Bullpen Importance:

  • Discussion on Postseason Strategies: Tuohy emphasizes, "As you get closer to the postseason, having that strong bullpen can mean all the difference." (05:56) The conversation reflects on how teams like the Dodgers leveraged their bullpen during their World Series run, emphasizing the strategic value of strong relievers.

2. NFL Hall of Fame Game & Quarterback Analysis

Timestamp: 07:30 – 12:42

Transitioning to the National Football League (NFL), the hosts discuss the Hall of Fame game and focus on quarterback performances, particularly Justin Herbert.

• Hall of Fame Inductees:

  • Notable Names: The episode mentions Antonio Gates, Jared Allen, Sterling Sharpe, and Eric Allen as this year's inductees, highlighting their contributions to the sport. (07:07)

• Justin Herbert's Performance:

  • Critical Analysis: Colin Cowherd remarks, "Justin Herbert's biggest weakness is all of those that he's counting on... I wake up every day to try to get to his level." (07:31) This critique points to the dependence on Herbert's supporting cast and raises questions about his consistent performance.
  • Comparison with Trey Lance: The discussion shifts to Trey Lance, questioning why he's not labeled among the NFL's most scrutinized quarterbacks despite similar pitfalls. Rich Davis muses, "No one talks about Trey Lance as the bust of all bust." (09:00)

• Host Perspectives:

  • Colin's Observation: "Maybe certain people garner more sympathy or empathy and other people are just more fun to pick on." (09:44) This statement reflects on media biases in evaluating player performances.

3. Introduction to "Over Promised" Podcast

Timestamp: 13:35 – 14:45

Covino and Rich introduce their new podcast, Over Promised, designed to delve deeper into topics that the main show couldn't cover due to time constraints.

• Podcast Features:
  • Content Focus: "We're going to be talking sports, of course, but we're also going to talk life and relationships." (14:08)
  • Engagement: Emphasizing an uncensored and in-depth discussion, the hosts encourage listeners to join and engage with additional content beyond the primary show.

4. Old School Punishments: A Nostalgic Reflection

Timestamp: 19:22 – 43:59

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to reminiscing about traditional forms of discipline and punishment during childhood, contrasting them with contemporary methods.

• Host Stories:

  • Colin's Anecdote: Colin shares a story about altering a school display to cause his team to run laps, reflecting on the blend of pride and embarrassment that accompanies such actions. (46:15)
  • Rich's Memories: Rich recalls punishments like standing against the wall or having to clean meticulously when misbehaving, highlighting the stark differences from today's punitive measures. (35:15)

• Discussion Points:

  • Effectiveness and Impact: The hosts debate the effectiveness of old-school punishments versus modern disciplinary approaches, pondering their implications on personal development.
  • Generational Perspectives: "It's a different generation," Colin notes, discussing how past methods are often viewed nostalgically despite their harshness. (34:40)

• Listener Engagement:

  • Call-Ins and Stories: The show features listener-submitted stories detailing unique and sometimes extreme punishments experienced during their upbringing, fostering a communal reflection on disciplinary evolution.

5. The Face of a Team: Beyond the Quarterback

Timestamp: 22:12 – 32:21

Transitioning from personal stories to professional sports analysis, the episode explores the concept of "the face of the team" and its significance.

• Rock Star Parallel:

  • Paul Stanley at Cold Stone Creamery: Colin narrates an encounter with Paul Stanley of Kiss, drawing parallels between a rock star's persona and a sports team's figurehead. (22:12) He muses, "It's not always the quarterback that you should have got a picture of the franchise." This analogy emphasizes that leadership and representation in teams aren't limited to one role.

• Implications for Teams:

  • Team Identity: The discussion underscores how the chosen "face" reflects a team's culture, values, and public image, affecting fan engagement and team dynamics.

6. Conclusion and Upcoming Topics

Timestamp: 32:21 – End

As the episode wraps up, the hosts tease upcoming discussions and encourage continued listener participation.

• Future Segments:

  • Trade Deadline Recap: Continuing the conversation on ongoing trade activities and their impacts on the leagues.
  • Face of the Team Debate: Further exploration into how the chosen public figures represent their respective franchises.

• Listener Interaction:

  • Call for Stories: Encouraging listeners to share their own experiences and opinions on discussed topics, ensuring an interactive and inclusive dialogue.

Notable Quotes:

• "Justin Herbert's biggest weakness is all of those that he's counting on." – Colin Cowherd (07:31)
• "It's like when ask you in a job interview, what's your biggest weakness? You're like, I tried too hard." – Rich Davis (07:47)
• "We're having the same debates that American households are having all over the country." – Colin Cowherd (17:44)
• "Rest is certainly a form of self-care, but if you are watching your full neighbors starve... your rest is selfish." – Tiffany Cross (17:48)

Conclusion:

The Herd with Colin Cowherd delivers a multifaceted episode that seamlessly blends sports analysis with personal storytelling. From dissecting major MLB trades and scrutinizing NFL quarterbacks to reminiscing about the disciplinary tactics of yesteryears, the episode offers a comprehensive look into the myriad issues that resonate with sports enthusiasts and everyday listeners alike. The inclusion of interactive segments and the introduction of the Over Promised podcast further enriches the listening experience, making Best of The Herd a must-listen for those seeking depth and engagement in sports commentary.