Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – "Best of The Herd" (January 13, 2025)
Introduction
In the "Best of The Herd" episode, released on January 13, 2025, Colin Cowherd, alongside co-hosts Matt Hasselbeck and J. Mac, delves into the intricacies of the NFL playoffs. The episode offers a comprehensive analysis of team performances, coaching decisions, quarterback dynamics, and pivotal playoff moments, providing listeners with in-depth insights and expert opinions.
NFL Playoffs Overview
The episode kicks off with Matt Hasselbeck setting the stage for a detailed playoff breakdown. He outlines the final AFC teams—Kansas City, Buffalo, Baltimore, and Houston—highlighting the competitive landscape as the playoffs approach.
Philadelphia Eagles' Performance
A significant portion of the discussion centers on the Philadelphia Eagles' recent performance. Matt critiques their gameplay, emphasizing their offensive struggles despite having talented players.
- Matt Hasselbeck (04:45): "Philadelphia has two excellent receivers, Dallas Goddard and Saquon Barkley, yet they're 2 for 11 on third downs and threw for only 121 yards."
Colin echoes these sentiments, pointing out the missed opportunities and inconsistent quarterback performance.
- Colin Cowherd (05:07): "Philadelphia is so talented, but they have to prove they can win the Super Bowl. They leave so much on the table."
The hosts discuss the impact of injuries and missed offensive linemen, questioning the Eagles' ability to capitalize on their talent in high-stakes games.
Buffalo Bills Analysis
Transitioning to the Buffalo Bills, Matt praises their offensive strategy and quarterback play, particularly highlighting Josh Allen's contributions.
- Matt Hasselbeck (05:43): "Buffalo's got Josh Allen, James Cook who smells the end zone, two excellent tight ends, and three solid wide receivers. They were amazing on third downs."
He contrasts Buffalo's disciplined execution with Philadelphia's shortcomings, asserting that Buffalo's structured approach positions them as formidable playoff contenders.
Coaching Changes: Mike McCarthy and Dallas Cowboys
A pivotal moment in the episode revolves around the unexpected news of Mike McCarthy being released as the Dallas Cowboys' head coach and the ensuing speculation about his future.
- Matt Hasselbeck (14:52): "Mike McCarthy is out as the Dallas Cowboys head coach. The sides could not agree on the length of the contract."
The hosts debate potential suitors for McCarthy, with a consensus leaning towards the Chicago Bears as the optimal fit.
- Matt Hasselbeck (19:09): "I think Mike McCarthy is the perfect hire for the Bears. He's a proven coach who develops quarterbacks effectively."
The discussion highlights McCarthy's extensive experience and successful track record with quarterbacks like Joe Montana, Brett Favre, and Aaron Rodgers, underscoring why he remains a sought-after coach despite the setback with Dallas.
Quarterback Mobility in the NFL
A recurring theme is the importance of quarterback mobility in modern NFL play. Both hosts agree that mobile quarterbacks like Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and emerging talents such as Jaden Daniels have transformed offensive strategies.
- Matt Hasselbeck (45:49): "Almost every quarterback winning in this league moves. Mahomes moves, Hurts moves, Jaden moves."
Colin concurs, emphasizing that mobility allows quarterbacks to create plays beyond the pocket, making defenses work harder.
- Colin Cowherd (46:23): "Quarterback movement keeps defensive coordinators up at night. It's essential for modern play."
Where Colin Was Right and Wrong
In a segment dedicated to evaluating past predictions, Matt assesses areas where Colin's insights were spot-on or missed the mark.
-
Where Colin Was Right:
-
Ohio State's Performance: Matt acknowledges Colin's accurate projections regarding Ohio State's presence in the national championship, underscoring the team's resilience and performance post their Michigan loss.
- Matt Hasselbeck (27:44): "I picked them to be in the national championship before the year. They are playing tremendous football."
-
Mike Vrabel to the Patriots: Colin's prediction about Mike Vrabel's move to the New England Patriots is validated as Matt expresses confidence in Vrabel's ability to build a competitive team.
- Matt Hasselbeck (26:13): "Mike Vrabel to the Patriots. I said Vrabel's the best candidate. Patriots the best job."
-
-
Where Colin Was Wrong:
-
Jordan Love's Potential: Colin overestimated Jordan Love's immediate impact with the Green Bay Packers. Matt reflects that Love's performance fell short of expectations, citing his multiple interceptions and low passer rating.
- Matt Hasselbeck (25:36): "I was a little too high on him. He ended up with 14 picks and the 19th highest passer rating in the NFL."
-
Justin Herbert's Playoffs: Colin anticipated a stellar playoff run for Justin Herbert, which didn't materialize as Herbert struggled in critical moments.
- Matt Hasselbeck (27:08): "Justin Herbert had his worst playoff game. He needs a really great playoff performance to cement his legacy."
-
Coaches in Transition
The conversation touches on the broader landscape of coaching changes and the traits that make successful head coaches. Mike McCarthy's adaptability and ability to manage teams through adversity are highlighted as key strengths.
- Matt Hasselbeck (36:08): "Mike McCarthy is a great coach. He develops quarterbacks and handles the podium well during press conferences."
Emerging Quarterbacks: Jaden Daniels
Jaden Daniels emerges as a focal point of discussion, with Matt drawing parallels between Daniels and seasoned quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes. Daniels is lauded for his calm demeanor and clutch performances under pressure.
- Matt Hasselbeck (41:05): "Jaden Daniels is unfazed and unbelievable in pressure moments. He's like a young Mahomes in the making."
The hosts debate whether Daniels' success is rooted in innate talent or cognitive abilities, ultimately praising his potential to influence games significantly.
Defensive Strategies and Game Planning
The importance of defensive strategies against mobile quarterbacks is another topic of interest. Matt analyzes how teams like Baltimore adapt their defense to counteract offenses that rely on quarterback mobility.
- Matt Hasselbeck (43:41): "Todd Monken in Baltimore has done a great job with naked bootlegs and jet sweeps. You can't play your normal NFL style defense against this offense."
Final Thoughts: Mike McCarthy's Future
As the episode wraps up, the discussion circles back to Mike McCarthy's future in the NFL. While there are rumors of interest from teams like the Chicago Bears and potential mentions of Belichick, the consensus remains that McCarthy's next move will significantly impact the coaching landscape.
- Matt Hasselbeck (47:28): "Mike McCarthy is the perfect coach for the Bears. His experience and ability to develop quarterbacks make him an ideal fit."
Conclusion
"Best of The Herd" offers listeners a thorough exploration of the NFL playoffs, emphasizing team dynamics, coaching strategies, and the evolving role of quarterbacks. With insightful analysis and expert commentary, Colin Cowherd and his co-hosts provide valuable perspectives for both avid fans and casual followers of the sport.
Notable Quotes
-
Matt Hasselbeck (04:45): "Philadelphia has two excellent receivers, Dallas Goddard and Saquon Barkley, yet they're 2 for 11 on third downs and threw for only 121 yards."
-
Matt Hasselbeck (19:09): "I think Mike McCarthy is the perfect hire for the Bears. He's a proven coach who develops quarterbacks effectively."
-
Matt Hasselbeck (41:05): "Jaden Daniels is unfazed and unbelievable in pressure moments. He's like a young Mahomes in the making."
-
Matt Hasselbeck (27:44): "I picked them to be in the national championship before the year. They are playing tremendous football."
-
Matt Hasselbeck (25:36): "I was a little too high on him. He ended up with 14 picks and the 19th highest passer rating in the NFL."
This episode serves as a valuable resource for understanding the current state of the NFL playoffs, the strategic decisions shaping team performances, and the individuals driving the sport forward.