The Herd with Colin Cowherd: Daniel Cormier Reacts to Poirier vs. Holloway 3 Announcement at UFC 318

Release Date: April 30, 2025

Episode Overview

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host Daniel Cormier delves deep into the highly anticipated announcement of the third bout between Dustin Poirier and Max Holloway at UFC 318 in New Orleans. Cormier provides a comprehensive analysis of the fighters' histories, the significance of the matchup, and its implications for the lightweight division. Throughout the discussion, Cormier offers insightful commentary, blending his extensive knowledge of MMA with personal reflections on the evolving landscape of the sport.

Fight Announcement: Poirier vs. Holloway 3

At the onset of the episode ([02:01]), Cormier announces the official confirmation of the trilogy fight between Dustin Poirier and Max Holloway for the BMF (Baddest Mother F***er) title. Scheduled to take place in July in New Orleans, this fight promises to be a marquee event, given the fighters' storied rivalry and the vibrant location choice.

Notable Quote:

"Dustin Poirier is fighting against Max Holloway for the BMF title in July in New Orleans... it's exciting enough for me in its own regard that they're fighting in New Orleans." ([02:15])

Analysis of Previous Encounters

Cormier revisits the history between Poirier and Holloway, highlighting their first two meetings in the Octagon:

1. First Fight (2012): Cormier reflects on Holloway's relative inexperience at the time, stating, "Max Holloway was far too young, didn't really know what he was doing in the UFC. Dustin got through him pretty convincingly." This fight showcased Poirier's ability to capitalize on his opponent's vulnerabilities.

2. Second Fight (2019): Held in Atlanta, Georgia, for the interim title, Holloway faced challenges making weight, appearing "pudgy" compared to his former self. Despite this, the fight was competitive, with Poirier ultimately securing the victory.

Notable Quote:

"In that second fight, even though Dustin won through those middle rounds, Dustin felt a new Max Holloway... I think that is when Dustin Poirier truly became Dustin Poirier." ([05:30])

Significance for the Fighters and the Division

Cormier emphasizes the importance of this third bout, not just as a personal rivalry but as a pivotal moment for the lightweight division:

• Dustin Poirier: Having almost retired after his bout with Islam Makhachev, Poirier's continued presence exemplifies resilience. Cormier notes, "Dustin Poirier wasn't [interim champion]. He was brought in to get beat up by Josh Grisbie. He beat the crap out of Josh Crispie and became the Dustin Poirier today."

• Max Holloway: Transitioning from his earlier years, Holloway has matured into a formidable champion. Cormier praises Holloway's growth, stating, "Max Holloway did have hype, but we saw Max Holloway grow up in the UFC."

The fight is portrayed as more than just a title match; it's a culmination of two elite fighters at the pinnacle of their careers, battling not only for the belt but for legacy.

Notable Quote:

"When it comes to Dustin Poirier and Max Holloway, those guys are going to rock that Smoothie King Arena, and I can't wait." ([08:45])

The Dynamics of Fighting at Home

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around the advantages and disadvantages of fighting in one's hometown:

• Advantages:

  • Familiar environment and supportive fanbase.
  • Increased ticket sales and local engagement.

• Disadvantages:

  • Heightened pressure to perform.
  • Potential for heightened emotions, as seen in instances like Anthony Smith's post-fight altercation and the anticipated intensity in New Orleans.

Cormier references past fighters who struggled when fighting at home, suggesting that while it can be a boon, it also introduces variables that can affect a fighter's performance.

Notable Quote:

"Why not get in there, retire clear, go home with no stitches for my daughter. But knucklehead fashion, I'm going to stand in the middle with Max and we're going to bleed and we're going to put on a show for the last one." ([04:25])

The BMF Title and Its Legacy

The introduction of the BMF Championship is another focal point. Initially viewed skeptically by Cormier, he acknowledges its value in adding narrative depth to the fight:

• Legacy Concerns: Unlike traditional titles, the BMF belt lacks a lineage, leading to questions about its long-term significance.

• Enhancing Storytelling: Cormier concedes that the BMF title elevates the fight's stakes, making it more engaging for fans.

Notable Quote:

"It adds something to the story that is a story that really don't need much because the fights are what matters." ([11:10])

Changing of the Guard in the Lightweight Division

Cormier paints a broader picture of the lightweight division's evolution, highlighting the transition from its golden era to a new era led by emerging talents:

• Golden Era: Featuring legends like Charles Oliveira, Dustin Poirier, Khabib Nurmagomedov, Justin Gaethje, and Tony Ferguson.

• Shift to New Contenders: With figures like Islam Makhachev now holding titles and rising stars like Arman Tsarukyan making waves, the division is experiencing a generational shift.

Cormier expresses a sense of nostalgia for the division's past while recognizing the inevitability of change and the importance of current fighters stepping up to fill the void.

Notable Quote:

"We were lucky to live through what has Been such a great time at 155... There's a changing of the guard happening in our division right now." ([12:05])

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Wrapping up the episode, Cormier reiterates his excitement for the upcoming Poirier vs. Holloway 3 fight, emphasizing its potential to be a defining moment for both fighters and the lightweight division as a whole. He invites listeners to share their opinions on fighting at home and the concept of retirement bouts, fostering engagement and discussion within the MMA community.

Notable Quote:

"But if there's anyone that can overcome all of those things, it's DP. But he's got a killer in front of him. Max Holloway. I cannot wait." ([12:30])

Cormier signs off with anticipation for the fight's electrifying atmosphere in the humid heat of New Orleans, promising an unforgettable showdown for fans worldwide.

Key Takeaways

• Poirier vs. Holloway 3 is set to be a monumental fight for the BMF title at UFC 318 in New Orleans.
• Both fighters have evolved significantly since their previous encounters, bringing a wealth of experience and heightened skills to the Octagon.
• Fighting at home presents unique challenges that can impact a fighter's performance.
• The lightweight division is undergoing a generational shift, signaling the end of an era dominated by legends and the rise of new contenders.
• The BMF title, while unconventional, adds an intriguing narrative layer to this high-stakes matchup.

This in-depth analysis by Daniel Cormier provides fans with a nuanced understanding of the upcoming fight's significance, the fighters' journeys, and the broader context within the UFC's lightweight division. Whether you're a longtime follower or a newcomer to MMA, this episode offers valuable insights into one of the sport's most compelling rivalries.