Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd Episode: Hoops Tonight - NBA Mailbag: Issues w/ NBA Media, KD's Next Team, Celtics All-Time Greats? Release Date: March 5, 2025

Introduction to "Hoops Tonight"

In this episode of Hoops Tonight hosted by Jason Tatum on The Volume, the show delves deep into pressing NBA topics, addressing fan questions and providing insightful analysis on the current state of the league. Skipping over the initial advertisements and promotional segments, the main content begins at [01:39] and covers a range of subjects from NBA media dynamics to team strategies and player evaluations.

The Complex Relationship Between NBA Media and Players

Timestamp [01:39]

Jason opens the discussion by exploring the intricate and often strained relationship between NBA players and the media. He reflects on recent comments made by LeBron James regarding the media's criticisms and the broader implications for the league.

• Sympathy for Players: Jason empathizes with players who feel burdened by constant scrutiny from media figures who may not have firsthand playing experience. He states, "I totally sympathize with the players who are doing all of the work and are actually playing basketball at the highest level."

• Criticism vs. Praise: Emphasizing the necessity of balanced media coverage, Jason argues that while constant praise would become propaganda, constructive criticism based on evidence is essential for the growth and understanding of the game. He remarks, "Sports are nasty, competitive, physical, violent. It's about a pursuit of winning. It is inherently nasty."

• Personal Accountability: Reflecting on his own experiences, Jason shares a moment of regret where he criticized Russell Westbrook, only to apologize the next day. "Russell Westbrook doesn't suck. He's one of the very best basketball players to ever grace the earth. And I'm a fan."

• Call for Evidence-Based Criticism: Jason urges media professionals to base their critiques on solid evidence rather than personal biases or unfounded opinions. "If you're going to be critical of a player, make sure that it's based in evidence, in something that I can defend."

Mailbag Segment: Addressing Fan Questions

Timestamp [05:00]

The heart of the episode features the Mailbag segment where Jason addresses various questions submitted by listeners. Key topics include team strategies, player performances, and hypothetical scenarios involving player trades.

1. Stanley Johnson and the Lakers' Injury Woes

A listener inquires whether Stanley Johnson could alleviate the Lakers' struggles amid Rui's injury.

• Jason's Analysis: He suggests that signing Stanley on a two-way contract could provide the Lakers with additional depth, especially given the complexity of managing Trey Jemison alongside other roster challenges.

  "I think Stanley is a perfect fit. I think he's a great small ball type of forward." [Timestamp: 10:15]

2. Evaluating the Celtics' Performance at the Highest Level

Questions arise about the Celtics' ability to compete against top-tier teams and whether they lack the "killer instinct" necessary for championship contention.

• Balanced Perspective: Jason acknowledges the Celtics' strengths, such as versatile defense and a well-rounded starting five, while also expressing concerns about their historical performance in high-stakes playoffs.

  "I do not view this Celtics team as an all-time great type of team... But as I zoom out and I look at all the teams, yes, their record is not as good as Cleveland or OKCs." [Timestamp: 15:45]

• Potential for Greatness: He notes that multiple dominant playoff runs are necessary to cement a team's legacy as all-time greats.

3. Strategic Focus for the Lakers

A listener asks whether the Lakers should prioritize securing a higher seed or experiment with lineups to optimize for the playoffs.

• Health Over Everything: Jason emphasizes the importance of player health, advocating for winning as many games as possible without overtaxing key players.

  "I would be 100% focused on health within the context of trying to win games." [Timestamp: 19:30]

4. Coaching Decisions with Tatum's Playtime

Concerns are raised about Celtics coach Mike Budenholzer's rotation decisions, particularly his handling of Jayson Tatum in critical game moments.

• Standard Rotation Practices: Jason explains that such playtime strategies are common across the league, aimed at managing player fatigue and optimizing performance throughout the game.

  "It's pretty typical for teams to want to get off to a really strong start and set the tone." [Timestamp: 21:27]

5. Evaluating Kevin Durant's Next Team

Fans speculate on where Kevin Durant might land following his departure from the Suns.

• Houston and Oklahoma City: Jason posits that both Houston and OKC are prime candidates, with each offering unique benefits that could maximize Durant's impact.

  "Houston because they can anchor him with just a rock solid defense and a ton of physicality. A good coach." [Timestamp: 25:10]

Highlighting Players with "Unsolvable" Skills

Timestamp [25:50]

Responding to a listener's question about NBA players with game-changing abilities, Jason compiles a list of 18 players who possess unique skills that present significant challenges for defenses.

• Notable Mentions:

  • Giannis Antetokounmpo: "overwhelming size and athleticism."
  • Stephen Curry: "the threat of his shooting."
  • LeBron James: "one of the best defenders in the league."

  "I'm setting a pretty low bar. Like there's obviously four or five of those dudes that are at another level above everyone else." [Timestamp: 28:00]

Upcoming Content and Show Schedule

Timestamp [30:00]

Jason wraps up the episode by outlining the show's upcoming schedule, including game breakdowns and live segments. He encourages listeners to leave ratings and reviews to support the show.

Conclusion

Hoops Tonight delivers a comprehensive and engaging discussion on current NBA issues, blending player insights with strategic analysis. Jason Tatum effectively addresses fan concerns, offers professional viewpoints on media-player dynamics, and anticipates future team movements, making this episode a must-listen for avid basketball fans.

For those interested in more detailed breakdowns and live discussions, be sure to subscribe to the Hoops Tonight YouTube channel, follow on Twitter @jason_lt, and listen to the accompanying podcast for continuous updates and insights.