Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd Episode: Hour 1 - A Top Doink of All Time
Release Date: May 22, 2025
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Description: The Herd with Colin Cowherd is a thought-provoking, opinionated, and topic-driven journey through the top sports stories of the day.

Introduction

In the premiere episode titled "A Top Doink of All Time," Colin Cowherd, alongside regular hosts Rich Davis and Danny G, delves into one of the most controversial and talked-about moments in recent Knicks history. The episode blends insightful sports analysis with lively banter, providing listeners with a comprehensive look at the game-deciding play that left fans and analysts alike baffled.

Main Discussion

The Knicks vs. Pacers Showdown

The focal point of the episode is the dramatic encounter between the New York Knicks and the Indiana Pacers. The hosts dissect the pivotal moment in the fourth quarter where the game took an unexpected turn due to a controversial shot referred to as the "doink."

• Nick's Early Confidence and Unexpected Turnaround

  Rich Davis recounts his initial reaction during the game:

  "At the moment when they were up about 18, I went outside to start trimming my rose bushes and, you know, do the dad thing." ([06:47])

  Danny G humorously adds:

  "Hope you had a Pacer sort of night, not a New York Knicks sort of night." ([04:11])

• The Controversial Doink Shot

  The discussion intensifies as they analyze the infamous shot by Tyrese Halliburton:

  "With six minutes left in the fourth quarter, the Knicks were up 111, 94... He pushed it to overtime and they ended up winning." ([11:46])

  Rich Davis emphasizes the significance of the play:

  "Doink. What about this one? One of your favorite doinks off the head of Jose Canseco." ([13:37])

  Danny G adds historical context by comparing it to other notable "doinks" in sports:

  "Danny G. Will open it up to everybody. Prisoner of the Moment or not." ([11:28])

Analyzing 'Doink' Moments in Sports History

The hosts draw parallels between the Knicks' doink and other memorable sports moments, highlighting the unpredictability and excitement that such plays bring to the game.

• Kawhi Leonard's Triple Doink

  "That triple doink... Doink Doink." ([10:19])

  "That was the most ridiculous shot ever." ([13:15])

• Teen Wolf's Legendary Foul Shot

  Danny G nostalgically references the movie Teen Wolf to illustrate the dramatic nature of such plays:

  "It was the wildest ending. Like, it looked like he was driving to the basket... and then he did the little backup, and you're like, oh, what is he trying to be a hero?" ([09:16])

  "Teen Wolf himself makes that legendary foul shot." ([10:27])

Emotional Reactions and Player Performance

The episode doesn't shy away from the emotional toll such games take on players and fans alike. The hosts discuss the stoic demeanor of Knicks' coach Brunson post-game and the overall impact on the team's morale.

• Brunson's Bewildered Reaction

  "Did you see Brunson at the end of the game at the press conference sitting there like... emotionless?" ([12:35])

  "It was the weird. And I get it." ([12:40])

• Player Statistics and Team Performance

  Rich Davis provides a statistical breakdown of the players' performances:

  "By the way, looking at stats, Halliburton ended up with 31 points..." ([10:06])

  Danny G highlights the significance of free throws and clutch performances:

  "You can't sleep on what Nismith did, hitting all those threes, free throws." ([19:45])

Comparative Analysis: Doinks Across Sports

The hosts take a detour to compare the Knicks' doink with other sports' infamous shots and plays, creating an engaging cross-sport dialogue.

• NFL's Triple Doink

  "Danny, we just broke the record for the word doink in one hour, man. Record holders." ([48:04])

  "It just had the roll, essentially." ([17:16])

• Historical Moments in Other Leagues

  Rich Davis reminisces about memorable plays in football and baseball:

  "Remember when that big comeback against the Detroit Lions in the NFC Championship game..." ([13:17])

  "One out of like 10,000 times... That was insane." ([15:21])

The Bigger Picture: Playoff Implications and Future Games

As the episode progresses, the conversation shifts towards the broader implications of the Knicks' loss and what it means for the playoffs.

• Playoff Dynamics and Team Morale

  Rich Davis muses on the team's chances moving forward:

  "The Pacers are up by five and a half to six in some places. There's a sentiment that redemption is coming." ([24:51])

  Danny G discusses the resilience of the Knicks:

  "The Knicks aren’t done. No, they're going to come back in game two." ([38:05])

• Fan Reactions and Social Media Buzz

  The hosts touch upon the social media buzz, including reactions from Cowboys fans regarding the Knicks' performance and Stephen A. Smith's commentary:

  "Are Dallas Cowboys fans thrilled? Are they calling this the redemption?" ([22:03])

Notable Quotes

• Rich Davis on the Doink:

  "Was that a three? Oh no. Is that a premature celebration?" ([08:52])

• Danny G on Emotional Impact:

  "It ripped the hearts out of all Knicks fans." ([12:35])

• Rich Davis on Historical Comparisons:

  "The Kawhi's doink was triple doink, competing with that one." ([10:19])

Conclusion

In "A Top Doink of All Time," Colin Cowherd and his co-hosts provide an in-depth analysis of a single moment that encapsulates the unpredictability and emotional intensity of sports. Through vibrant discussions, historical comparisons, and heartfelt reactions, the episode paints a vivid picture of how one play can reverberate through teams, fans, and the broader sports landscape. This episode not only highlights the specific incident but also underscores the enduring passion and engagement that fans bring to their favorite teams.

Key Takeaways

• Unpredictability of Sports: A single play, like the Knicks' doink shot, can dramatically alter the course of a game and influence team morale.

• Emotional Investment: Players' reactions and fan sentiments underscore the deep emotional connections forged through sports.

• Historical Parallels: Comparing the doink to other memorable sports moments enriches the understanding of its significance.

• Future Implications: The Knicks' resilience and the upcoming games are critical for their playoff aspirations.

Listeners are left with a comprehensive understanding of the event, its ramifications, and the shared experiences that make sports a captivating spectacle.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• "At the moment when they were up about 18, I went outside to start trimming my rose bushes and, you know, do the dad thing." — Rich Davis [06:47]

• "Hope you had a Pacer sort of night, not a New York Knicks sort of night." — Danny G [04:11]

• "Was that a three? Oh no. Is that a premature celebration?" — Rich Davis [08:52]

• "It ripped the hearts out of all Knicks fans." — Danny G [12:35]

• "The triple doink... Doink Doink." — Danny G [10:19]

• "Danny G. Will open it up to everybody. Prisoner of the Moment or not." — Danny G [11:28]

• "That's the triple doink to end the game where teen Wolf himself makes that legendary foul shot." — Danny G [10:27]

• "You can't sleep on what Nismith did, hitting all those threes, free throws." — Danny G [19:45]