Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 1: Rich's Mom Wears Work Boots (May 8, 2025)
The Herd with Colin Cowherd, hosted by iHeartPodcasts and The Volume, offers listeners a thought-provoking and opinionated exploration of the top sports stories of the day. In the episode titled "Hour 1 - Rich's Mom Wears Work Boots," co-hosts Steve Cavino and Rich Davis engage in lively discussions covering the origins of baseball terminology, ethical dilemmas surrounding "finders keepers," and recent sports updates.
I. Origins of the Term "Bullpen"
The episode begins with Rich Davis sharing an interesting tidbit about baseball terminology. He explains the historical origins of the term "bullpen":
"A term was developed today in 1877 and I know you love these stupid ass fun facts from back in the day. It was the Cincinnati Inquirer who termed this phrase that we still use today in the world of baseball." – Rich Davis [01:28]
Steve Cavino humorously questions the authenticity of the fun fact, leading Rich to elaborate on how "bullpen" originally referred to an area where latecomer fans congregated, resembling cattle, before evolving into its current meaning related to relief pitchers.
II. "Finders Keepers, Losers Weepers" Debate
A significant portion of the episode revolves around the age-old saying "finders keepers, losers weepers." The hosts explore various real-life scenarios where this adage is put to the test.
A. Aaron Judge's Home Run Ball Incident
Steve Cavino recounts a memorable moment from a Yankees game where a fan successfully catches an Aaron Judge home run ball but loses it during celebratory chaos. Another individual swiftly retrieves the lost ball, sparking debate among the hosts.
"Aaron Judge is the bomb. That is a high net is far. That is gone. All rise." – Steve Cavino [04:13]
Rich emphasizes Judge's exceptional hitting prowess, comparing catching his home run to catching legendary players like Babe Ruth or Shohei Ohtani.
"Nowadays, Aaron Judge might be probably as the greatest right-handed hitter these eyes have ever seen." – Steve Cavino [05:09]
This incident raises questions about ownership and ethical behavior when significant items change hands unexpectedly.
B. Brinks Truck in Chicago Mishap
Rich Davis introduces a story about a Brinks truck accident in Chicago, where a forgotten latch led to $300,000 spilling into the neighborhood.
"There is a story about a Brinks truck in Chicago they forgot the latch. The back of it. $300,000 was just blowing around the neighborhood." – Rich Davis [08:40]
The hosts debate the morality of taking substantial sums of money found due to someone's oversight, discussing the potential consequences and ethical implications.
C. $43,000 Found in a Couch at Goodwill
Another intriguing story involves a customer discovering $43,000 hidden within a couch cushion at Goodwill. Despite having no legal obligation, the individual decides to return the money to its rightful owner.
"This guy felt an immense level of guilt or something because he then reached back to Goodwill to see, well, who donated this couch and returned every penny." – Rich Davis [10:07]
The co-hosts analyze whether keeping such money is justifiable, considering factors like traceability and moral responsibility.
D. Personal Anecdotes and Moral Dilemmas
Steve and Rich share personal experiences related to finding lost items, discussing instances where they chose to return items like laptops and phones, and reflecting on societal expectations versus personal morals.
"You want acknowledgement that you did the right thing. Like if you let someone cut in front of you in traffic. All I want is a little wave." – Rich Davis [27:07]
This segment delves into the complexities of ethical decision-making in everyday situations.
III. Sports Updates
A. NFL Trade: Cowboys Acquire George Pickens
Dan Byer provides an update on a notable NFL trade where the Dallas Cowboys acquire wide receiver George Pickens from the Pittsburgh Steelers in exchange for future draft picks.
"Guys, we had a trade in the NFL today as the Dallas Cowboys acquired wide receiver George Pickens in a deal with the Pittsburgh Steelers." – Dan Byer [31:52]
The hosts discuss the implications of the trade, particularly its long-term impact on team dynamics.
B. NBA News: Steph Curry's Injury Impacting Warriors
Steph Curry's Grade 1 hamstring strain is reported to sideline him for at least a week, affecting the Golden State Warriors' playoff series.
"Warriors guard Steph Curry will miss at least a week of action because of a Grade one hamstring strain suffered in last night's Game one win over the Timberwolves." – Dan Byer [32:08]
Steve Cavino and Rich Davis debate the potential outcomes for the Warriors without their star player, emphasizing Curry's significance to the team's success.
IV. Family Legacies in Sports
The discussion shifts to the influence of family legacy in professional sports, highlighting multi-generational athletes and the interplay of genetics and upbringing.
"Jaden Fielder. Already hitting bombs. 20 years old. Will could possibly be the third generation slugging fielder." – Steve Cavino [39:16]
Rich Davis and Steve Cavino explore how familial ties and nature versus nurture contribute to athletic prowess, citing examples like Cecil Fielder and his son.
V. Ethical Reflections and Personal Responsibility
Throughout the episode, the hosts emphasize the importance of personal responsibility and ethical behavior when encountering situations falling under "finders keepers, losers weepers." They discuss the balance between societal expectations and individual morals, advocating for honest actions even when not legally obligated.
"You want acknowledgement that you did the right thing." – Rich Davis [27:07]
"Finders keepers, losers weepers is a case by case thing." – Steve Cavino [30:14]
Key Quotes:
- "Are you giving it back?" – Steve Cavino [06:25]
- "I think sometimes karma works to your advantage and you gotta like live and relish in those moments." – Steve Cavino [24:29]
- "If you have a great partner in life, girlfriend, wife, whatever. They make winning easier because they're good at what they do." – Steve Cavino [34:50]
This episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd provides listeners with engaging discussions that blend sports analysis with ethical considerations, enriched by personal anecdotes and insightful debates. The hosts effectively navigate complex moral landscapes while keeping the conversation entertaining and relatable.