Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 1: Snake and Bake!
Release Date: January 23, 2025

Hosts: Covino and Rich Davis
Produced by: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Description: A thought-provoking, opinionated, and topic-driven journey through the top sports stories of the day.

1. Welcome and Personal Updates

The episode kicks off with Covino welcoming listeners and introducing Rich Davis, who recently underwent a colonoscopy. The hosts humorously discuss Rich's experience, emphasizing the importance of men's health and encouraging listeners to prioritize medical check-ups.

• [05:30] Covino: "Rich got his colonoscopy earlier today and handled it like a pro. Men, take a cue from him and get those check-ups done."

• [07:45] Rich Davis: "I felt a bit woozy after the procedure, but it's all worth it for that clean bill of health."

2. Patrick Mahomes and the GOAT Debate

A significant portion of the discussion centers around NFL superstar Patrick Mahomes and the ongoing debate about whether he could be considered the Greatest of All Time (GOAT) if he secures a third Super Bowl victory, potentially surpassing Tom Brady's legacy.

• [12:10] Covino: "If Mahomes wins his third Super Bowl, does that automatically make him the GOAT over Brady, who never clinched three in a row?"

• [13:25] Rich Davis: "Narratives in sports are fleeting. Right now, Mahomes is on fire, but only time will tell if it solidifies his GOAT status."

The hosts delve into Mahomes' current performance, his leadership, and the strength of the Kansas City Chiefs, while also reflecting on Brady's unparalleled seven-ring legacy.

• [15:50] Covino: "Brady’s seven rings are legendary, but Mahomes brings a fresh dynamic that Brady never had. It's a tough call."

3. The Rare Baseball Card Phenomenon

The highlight of the episode is an in-depth conversation about a startling event in the baseball card community: an 11-year-old boy from Southern California pulled a highly coveted one-of-one rookie debut patch card of Paul Skeens from the Topps Chrome collection.

• [18:30] Covino: "An 11-year-old kid just pulled a one-of-one Paul Skeens rookie patch card. This isn't just any card; it's potentially a multi-million-dollar piece."

• [19:45] Rich Davis: "This reminds me of the excitement of finding a rare card from our childhood. But now, with its astronomical value, this changes the game entirely."

Discussion Points:

• Value and Significance:
  The hosts compare the Paul Skeens card to historic cards like the Honus Wagner 1909 T206 and the 1952 Mickey Mantle PSA 9, highlighting its potential worth in the collectors' market.

  • [21:15] Covino: "This card ranks up there with Mantle's rookie card and Wagner's classic. We're talking about a piece that could redefine a collector’s portfolio."

• Parental Control and Responsibility:
  They debate whether the young collector should retain the card or sell it, emphasizing the role of parents in managing such valuable assets.

  • [24:05] Rich Davis: "At 11, a kid doesn't fully grasp the financial implications. Parents need to step in to safeguard this asset for his future."

• Listener Perspectives:
  Throughout the segment, listeners call in with their opinions, echoing the hosts' sentiments about parental responsibility and the ethical considerations of managing children's newfound wealth.

  • [28:30] Caller John from Florida: "As a parent, it's crucial to manage this properly. The card should be put in a safe or a safety deposit box to ensure it's preserved and benefits the child in the long run."

4. Listener Calls and Community Opinions

The episode features multiple listener interactions, providing diverse viewpoints on the rare card scenario and broader sports topics.

• [30:45] Caller Doug from Maryland:
  Doug elaborates on the card’s potential value, comparing it to iconic cards and stressing its uniqueness due to the debut patch.

  • "This card is on par with the Honus Wagner and 1952 Mantle. Its one-of-one status makes it a diamond in the rough of baseball collectibles."

• [34:20] Caller John in Florida:
  John discusses the importance of parental guidance and suggests utilizing resources like Ken Golden's network for proper auctioning.

  • "Ken Golden has the connections to ensure this card reaches the right bidders, maximizing its value for the kid's future."

5. Midweek Major Sports Updates

Transitioning from the baseball card saga, Covino and Rich provide updates on major sports news, including:

• NBA:
  The Miami Heat plans to suspend Jimmy Butler for two games due to missing a team flight, following his recent conduct issues.

  • [37:50] Covino: "Jimmy Butler's suspension affects the Heat's lineup as they prepare for crucial matchups against Milwaukee and Brooklyn."

• NFL:
  Significant coaching changes include the New York Jets hiring Aaron Glenn as their new head coach and the Las Vegas Raiders bringing in Tampa Bay assistant GM John Spitek as their new general manager.

  • [40:15] Rich Davis: "Aaron Glenn's experience with the Lions could rejuvenate the Jets, while John Spitek's move to the Raiders signals a strategic shift for Pittsburgh."

• Other Updates:
  The Cincinnati Bengals appoint Notre Dame's Al Golden as their new defensive coordinator, and the Philadelphia Eagles make a quirky announcement about selling 'snow' at $50 a pint.

6. Final Thoughts and Closing Remarks

As the episode wraps up, Covino and Rich reflect on the day's discussions, reiterating the importance of managing rare collectibles responsibly and staying updated with ongoing sports narratives.

• [45:00] Covino: "Today's chat about the rare card is a perfect example of how passion and value intertwine in sports memorabilia."

• [46:30] Rich Davis: "Remember, whether you're a hardcore collector or a casual fan, there's always something new to learn and discuss in the sports world."

They encourage listeners to continue engaging with the show through calls and social media, teasing upcoming topics for future episodes.

• [50:10] Covino: "Stay tuned for more in-depth analysis and lively debates on the Herd with Colin Cowherd."

Notable Quotes:

• [19:00] Rich Davis: "This moment is like discovering a hidden treasure that could change the trajectory of a young collector's life."

• [24:50] Covino: "It's not just about the money; it's about preserving a piece of sports history for the next generation."

• [35:20] Caller Doug: "Managing such an asset isn't just a financial decision; it's a testament to valuing the sport and its legacy."

Conclusion

The "Hour 1 - Snake and Bake!" episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd masterfully balances lighthearted banter with serious discussions about sports legacies and the evolving landscape of sports memorabilia. Covino and Rich Davis provide insightful perspectives, engaging with listeners to explore the multifaceted world of sports, ensuring both entertainment and informative content for their audience.