Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 2: Eagles Sit Saquon Barkley

Release Date: January 1, 2025

Overview

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, hosted by iHeartPodcasts and The Volume, the primary focus centers around the Philadelphia Eagles' controversial decision to rest their star running back, Saquon Barkley, in the final game of the season. The conversation delves deep into the implications of this decision, the potential impact on Barkley's career, and broader NFL strategies regarding player health and record-breaking opportunities. Additionally, the show touches upon a tragic incident in New Orleans affecting the Sugar Bowl and provides updates on the Peach Bowl and notable NFL team movements.

1. Saquon Barkley’s Resting Decision

Timestamp: 02:08 – 19:59

The episode kicks off with co-hosts Lavar Arrington and Jonas Knox dissecting the Philadelphia Eagles' decision to sit Saquon Barkley in their final game against the New York Giants. The move, aimed at preserving Barkley’s health for the postseason and avoiding injury during a game with minimal playoff implications, has sparked widespread debate among fans and analysts alike.

Nick Sirianni’s Stance

The conversation references comments made by Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni, who explained his decision-making process:

"I'll talk to our staff, I'll talk to the players, I'll talk to Howie... to make sure I'm making the best decision for the football team."
— Nick Sirianni (04:05)

Sirianni emphasized prioritizing the team’s success and individual player well-being over individual accolades, drawing parallels to previous instances where team success overshadowed record-breaking pursuits.

Hosts’ Perspectives

Jonas Knox initially leaned towards believing that Sirianni would allow Barkley to play, given the opportunity to break a significant rushing record. However, after analyzing Sirianni’s comments and the team's official stance, co-hosts express skepticism and disappointment.

"That is crazy. Well, I, that's crazy."
— Lavar Arrington (07:02)

Arrington criticizes the decision, arguing that the allure of historical records should take precedence over conservative play, especially when the team isn’t in contention for a higher playoff seed without the record chase.

Knox concurs, highlighting that such a decision likely reflects Barkley’s own perspective on the matter, suggesting that Barkley prioritized team success and his postseason viability over personal milestones.

"I just feel like they wouldn't have done this unless Saquon wasn't."
— Jonas Knox (09:22)

Arrington further elaborates on the emotional and professional aspects, comparing Barkley’s situation to hypothetical scenarios involving other legendary players, underscoring the perception that the decision undermines the significance of individual achievements.

2. Tragic Incident in New Orleans Impacting the Sugar Bowl

Timestamp: 23:09 – 27:06

The hosts shift focus to a heartbreaking incident in New Orleans, where a suspect drove a truck into a crowd celebrating New Year's Eve, leading to multiple casualties and injuries. This act of violence has cast a shadow over the Sugar Bowl scheduled to take place in the city.

Potential Postponement

Jonas Knox reports initial rumors from WDSU indicating that the Sugar Bowl might be postponed by 24 hours to ensure safety and allow authorities to manage the aftermath of the tragedy.

"We are waiting on a second confirmation of that, but that is at least what the initial report from WDSU is saying."
— Jonas Knox (24:35)

Lavar Arrington expresses solidarity and concern, emphasizing the importance of prioritizing safety over sporting events.

"Thoughts and prayers, obviously, and positive thoughts to them and everyone involved."
— Lavar Arrington (25:26)

The hosts underline the unpredictability of such events and the necessity for event organizers to adapt to unforeseen circumstances, ensuring the well-being of all participants and attendees.

3. Peach Bowl Update: Texas vs. Arizona State

Timestamp: 27:06 – 39:42

Continuing with college football coverage, the episode provides an update on the Peach Bowl matchup between the Texas Longhorns and the Arizona State Sun Devils.

Current Game Status

Jonas Knox details the early lead by Texas, highlighting their aggressive gameplay with a score of 7-3 within the opening minutes of the first quarter.

"Texas has just scored eight minutes and change left to go in the opening quarter there."
— Jonas Knox (27:06)

He notes Texas’s dominant performance, including a pivotal punt return for a touchdown, and forecasts continued pressure from the Longhorns throughout the game.

Meanwhile, Arrington offers analysis on Arizona State's efforts to keep the game competitive, referencing key players like Cam Scatterboo and drawing parallels to previous defensive challenges faced by the team.

4. New York Jets' Future with Aaron Rodgers and Devonte Adams

Timestamp: 39:42 – 36:53

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the New York Jets' rumored decision to part ways with veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers and standout wide receiver Devonte Adams.

Breaking News

Jonas Knox reveals sources indicating that the relationship between Jets owner Woody Johnson and Rodgers has deteriorated beyond repair, leading to expectations that both Rodgers and Adams will exit the team following the season.

"Source tells us that the relationship between Woody Johnson, the owner and Rodgers is irreparable."
— Jonas Knox (27:52)

Hosts' Reactions

Arrington expresses skepticism about the Jets' decision, debating the implications for Rodgers’ legacy and the potential impact on Adams' career. He contemplates the challenges Rodgers might face in finding a new team willing to integrate him, considering the media attention and drama he brings.

"He has been a brilliant football player throughout his career, but you got to think about the idea that... he generated this constant media attention that's driven by drama."
— Lavar Arrington (30:40)

Knox speculates that Rodgers may retire after achieving personal milestones, such as reaching his 500th touchdown pass, suggesting that Rodgers might prefer leaving on a high note rather than extending his career in a less favorable environment.

"I think he walks away. I don't think he plays again."
— Jonas Knox (31:56)

Devonte Adams' Future

The discussion also touches upon Devonte Adams' prospects, with Arrington questioning whether Adams will find a stable position in the NFL after navigating multiple team changes and the fallout from the Las Vegas situation.

"He now still becomes like a de facto... journeyman."
— Lavar Arrington (32:23)

5. Additional NFL and College Football Insights

Timestamp: 43:06 – 48:09

Beyond the main topics, the episode briefly covers other NFL news, including potential international games for the Pittsburgh Steelers in Dublin, Ireland, and evaluates fan cultures surrounding teams like the Steelers and the Packers.

Additionally, the hosts discuss MVP races within the NFL, specifically highlighting Joe Burrow's aspirations and humility regarding the title, juxtaposed against his on-field performance and division-leading efforts.

Conclusion

This episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd offers a comprehensive analysis of pivotal moments in current NFL and college football landscapes. From the strategic decisions impacting player careers to unforeseen tragedies influencing major sporting events, the hosts provide insightful commentary enriched with firsthand quotes and engaging discussions. Listeners gain a nuanced understanding of the complexities surrounding team decisions, player legacies, and the ever-evolving dynamics of football.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Nick Sirianni on Resting Barkley
  "I'll talk to our staff, I'll talk to the players, I'll talk to Howie... to make sure I'm making the best decision for the football team."
  (04:05)

• Lavar Arrington on Sirianni’s Decision
  "That is crazy. Well, I, that's crazy."
  (07:02)

• Jonas Knox on Team’s Motive
  "I just feel like they wouldn't have done this unless Saquon wasn't."
  (09:22)

• Lavar Arrington on Player Records vs. Team Success
  "You're a professional. It's the game, it's the season. And you work towards things like greatness, you work towards immortality."
  (12:28)

• Jonas Knox on Aaron Rodgers’ Future
  "I think he walks away. I don't think he plays again."
  (31:56)

This structured summary captures the essence of the podcast episode, providing a detailed and engaging overview for listeners who may not have tuned in, while highlighting key discussions and insights shared by the hosts.