Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd Episode: Hour 2 - Giants QB Puzzle, Pizza & Prizes
Release Date: May 31, 2025
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume

Introduction

In this dynamic episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, aired on May 31, 2025, hosts Rich Davis and Danny G delve deep into the New York Giants' quarterback conundrum, explore engaging listener interactions, and wrap up with exciting weekend sports previews. Skipping over the numerous advertisements and promotional segments, the core content focuses on the intricate QB situation of the Giants, comparisons with the Steelers' quarterback decisions, and a lively discussion on listener feedback and upcoming sports events.

Segment 1: The Giants' Quarterback Puzzle

Timestamp: 12:30

Rich Davis opens the discussion by addressing the Giants' ongoing quarterback dilemma. The team currently juggles multiple quarterbacks, including seasoned Russell Wilson, promising Jackson Dart, and the charismatic Jameis Winston.

Quote:
"The Giants have a quarterback heavy room. They got Russell Wilson, Jackson Dart, and Jameis Winston. You got a problem."
– Rich Davis [12:45]

Danny G. further elaborates, likening the situation to choosing between different types of pizza, emphasizing the abundance but confusion it brings.

Quote:
"It's like you went out and got all this stuff and then you get to work and there's pizza."
– Danny G. [14:10]

The hosts debate the best course of action for the Giants, contemplating whether to let Jackson Dart fight for the starting position or to stick with the experienced Wilson. They weigh the benefits of giving Dart time to develop against the risk of instability if Wilson underperforms.

Quote:
"You have to have the discipline to say, no, Russell Wilson, we got him. He is our quarterback. He is a Super Bowl winner unless he poops the bed in OTAs."
– Rich Davis [20:15]

Segment 2: Comparing with the Steelers' Quarterback Decisions

Timestamp: 25:50

The conversation shifts to the Pittsburgh Steelers and their choices regarding Aaron Rodgers. Drawing parallels with the Giants, Rich questions whether bringing in a high-profile quarterback like Rodgers aligns with the traditional Steelers' approach.

Quote:
"Terry Bradshaw let it be known he was not very pleased with how Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers situation is unfolding."
– Danny G. [30:05]

Rich counters by highlighting the evolving nature of the NFL, suggesting that adapting to contemporary strategies may be necessary for sustained competitiveness.

Quote:
"It's 2025. The league is different now. Some of these teams do go out and get an X star quarterback for a season win."
– Rich Davis [33:20]

The hosts debate whether the Steelers' decision to possibly bring in Rodgers is a deviation from their storied history or a strategic move to remain relevant in the modern NFL landscape.

Segment 3: Listener Reviews and Prize Giveaways

Timestamp: 40:00

Transitioning from quarterback talk, the show engages with listener feedback. Rich and Danny G. read various reviews from platforms like Apple Podcasts, addressing both criticism and praise.

Quote:
"If you don't have people hating you, then you're not doing anything. You're not moving the needle at all."
– Danny G. [42:30]

Despite receiving a few one-star reviews criticizing the show's focus and depth, the hosts maintain a positive outlook, acknowledging the importance of diverse opinions in fostering growth and engagement.

Several listeners receive prizes for their reviews, adding an interactive and rewarding element to the segment.

Segment 4: Tattoos Talk – A Lighthearted Interlude

Timestamp: 50:15

In a departure from sports talk, Rich and Danny G. dive into a humorous discussion about tattoos. They share personal anecdotes, debate the meaning behind various tattoo choices, and reflect on cultural shifts regarding body art.

Quote:
"I have a tattoo commemorating the late, great Lakers announcer Chick Hearn in an area you cannot present on radio."
– Sam [52:05]

Danny G. recounts encounters with peculiar tattoos, sparking laughter and showcasing the camaraderie between the hosts.

Segment 5: Weekend Hobnobbing – Upcoming Sports and Entertainment

Timestamp: 1:05:00

As the episode nears its conclusion, Rich and Danny G. shift focus to the upcoming weekend's sports and entertainment events. They provide insights into key matchups, such as the Yankees versus Dodgers baseball game and highlight notable fights like Caleb Plant vs. Jermell Charlo.

Quote:
"Giancarlo Stanton, after they received their 2024 AL championship ring, said, 'Don't be wearing those. It's not the one we want.'"
– Danny G. [1:07:45]

Additionally, they touch upon the release of new films like Karate Kid Legends, debating potential plotlines and casting choices with enthusiasm.

Segment 6: Final Thoughts and Closing Remarks

Timestamp: 1:25:30

Wrapping up, the hosts reiterate the importance of community feedback and encourage listeners to continue sharing their thoughts and experiences. They tease future episodes, hinting at more in-depth analyses and engaging discussions.

Quote:
"We're trying not to be boring. Call us whatever you want, but boring shouldn't be on the list."
– Rich Davis [1:24:50]

They sign off with a promise of more exciting content, maintaining a lighthearted and inclusive tone.

Conclusion

This episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd offers a comprehensive look into the New York Giants' quarterback situation, draws insightful comparisons with the Pittsburgh Steelers, and fosters a strong connection with its audience through interactive segments. The blend of serious sports analysis, humorous interludes, and listener engagement makes for an engaging and multifaceted listening experience. Whether you're a die-hard football fan or simply enjoy spirited discussions about sports dynamics, this episode provides valuable perspectives and entertainment.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• "The Giants have a quarterback heavy room. They got Russell Wilson, Jackson Dart, and Jameis Winston. You got a problem."
  – Rich Davis [12:45]

• "It's like you went out and got all this stuff and then you get to work and there's pizza."
  – Danny G. [14:10]

• "You have to have the discipline to say, no, Russell Wilson, we got him. He is our quarterback. He is a Super Bowl winner unless he poops the bed in OTAs."
  – Rich Davis [20:15]

• "If you don't have people hating you, then you're not doing anything. You're not moving the needle at all."
  – Danny G. [42:30]

• "I have a tattoo commemorating the late, great Lakers announcer Chick Hearn in an area you cannot present on radio."
  – Sam [52:05]

• "Giancarlo Stanton, after they received their 2024 AL championship ring, said, 'Don't be wearing those. It's not the one we want.'"
  – Danny G. [1:07:45]

This detailed summary encapsulates the richness and diversity of discussions in this episode, providing listeners with a clear and engaging overview of the content covered.