Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 2: NFL Over - Unders
Release Date: April 1, 2025
Host: Colin Cowherd
Co-Hosts/Guests: Jason McIntyre, Albert Breer
Platform: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume

1. Introduction to NFL Developments [03:06 - 04:30]

The episode kicks off with Colin Cowherd and Jason McIntyre delving into the latest NFL news, including the upcoming Club World Cup. Colin expresses enthusiasm about the event, highlighting the participation of top clubs and star players like Mbappe and Messi.

Colin Cowherd [03:07]:
"The finals are here and the only thing for sure it's the last time to bet on college basketball."

Jason acknowledges Colin's increasing interest in soccer alongside his traditional focus on college basketball.

Jason McIntyre [03:54]:
"You know, listen, I can't take full credit, but I do like. I know you like soccer and college baske, but Colin, you have to admit you're starting to nudge a little more in the direction of those sports."

2. Analyzing NFL Over and Under Bets [04:30 - 09:58]

Colin introduces the topic of NFL over and under bets, explaining how betting companies project the number of games a team is expected to win. He outlines his personal picks for both over and under bets across various NFL divisions.

Key Points:

• AFC East:

  • Bills: 11.5 Wins
  • Dolphins: 8.5 Wins
  • Jets: 5.5 Wins
  • Patriots: 7.5 Wins (Colin leans towards the over due to coaching upgrades)

• AFC South:

  • Texans: 9.5 Wins
  • Colts: 7.5 Wins
  • Titans: 5.5 Wins (Over bet recommended due to coaching changes and quarterback performance)

• AFC West:

  • Chiefs: 11.5 Wins (Under bet recommended due to concerns about offensive line and player aging)
  • Broncos, Chargers, Raiders: Various projections with mixed betting recommendations

• NFC Divisions:

  • Commanders: Over 9.5 Wins
  • Cowboys: Under 7.5 Wins (Due to coaching and player concerns)
  • NFC North & South: Minimal standout bets
  • NFC West: Under bets on 49ers, over on Rams

Colin Cowherd [04:30]:
"I would bet the over on the Patriots."

Jason McIntyre [09:58]:
"Okay, I do like that."

3. Insights on NFL Overtime Rule Changes [10:24 - 17:40]

Colin shares his theory on the NFL's overtime rules, advocating for a quicker resolution to reduce defensive fatigue. He poses a hypothetical scenario where a team scores just before the 10-minute mark, questioning the practicality of the new rules.

Colin Cowherd [10:24]:
"I've always had a theory on overtime. You want it to be quick. I don't want my defense on the field for another 14 plays."

Albert Breer responds by discussing the implications of the rule changes, emphasizing the balance between strategy and player safety.

Albert Breer [11:03]:
"I think this is a fair compromise and it does add that element of strategy to it."

4. The Tush Push Debate in NFL Coaches' Meetings [12:20 - 35:20]

The conversation shifts to the controversial "Tush Push" play in the NFL. Colin criticizes the play for resembling rugby rather than traditional football, expressing his dissatisfaction with its impact on the game's integrity and television appeal.

Colin Cowherd [12:20]:
"Tush push doesn't look like football. It's more rugby than football to me."

Albert elaborates on the debate, highlighting concerns about player safety and the need for clearer rules.

Albert Breer [12:34]:
"There’s no injury data that says it's more dangerous. But based on the posture of the player, that could lead to major head and spine injuries."

The discussion touches upon potential rule rewrites and the NFL's efforts to address loopholes, with teams like the Packers opposing the play.

Colin Cowherd [34:08]:
"I don't think the tush push feels like a creative football player."

5. Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers Situation [14:30 - 22:16]

Colin speculates on quarterback Aaron Rodgers' future with the Pittsburgh Steelers, suggesting that while Rodgers enjoys football and his current performance, the Steelers may not fully meet his aspirations due to issues like the offensive line and team culture.

Colin Cowherd [14:30]:
"I have made the argument with Aaron Rodgers that he ideally wanted Minnesota, knew the division, loved the coach, loved Justin Jefferson."

Albert Breer provides insights into Rodgers' mindset, considering his desire to play and the Steelers' team dynamics.

Albert Breer [15:10]:
"I think he does want to play. And I think, you know, if you're in his spot, you say, okay, I got one year left. You're looking for the perfect place."

6. NFL Draft Prospects: Shador Sanders vs. Other Quarterbacks [22:16 - 35:56]

The discussion turns to the NFL Draft, focusing on quarterback prospects like Shador Sanders, Cam Ward, and Jackson Dart. Colin and Jason debate Sanders' draft stock, comparing him to previous quarterbacks like Bo Nix, and ponder why his draft position is dropping.

Jason McIntyre [23:54]:
"Is he not interviewing? Well, something's got to be going on."

Albert Breer offers his perspective, suggesting that while Sanders has talent, teams may perceive him as lacking compared to peers like Cam Ward.

Albert Breer [21:17]:
"From a talent perspective, there is a bigger separation between Cam Ward and Shador Sanders than there is between Shador Sanders and Jackson Dart."

7. Final Thoughts on Over and Under Bets [35:20 - 52:51]

Colin reiterates his over and under bets, emphasizing his confidence in picks like the Commanders over 9.5 wins and the Chiefs under 11.5 wins. He critiques teams like the Steelers for their lackluster offense and questionable identity.

Colin Cowherd [46:17]:
"Again, there is absolutely nothing there. They don't have any identity."

Jason McIntyre [37:12]:
"Brear made it sound like he's not getting by the Giants, which. And I was just texting somebody about Shador Sanders. I don't know, guy."

8. Closing Remarks and Additional Segments [54:16 - 56:29]

The episode concludes with promotional segments for various podcasts and shows, highlighting upcoming content and partnerships. Colin and Jason briefly touch upon other sports topics, maintaining their engaging banter until the end.

Colin Cowherd [56:29]:
"Listen to Politics on the iHeartRadio app."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Colin Cowherd [04:30]:
  "I would bet the over on the Patriots."

• Jason McIntyre [09:58]:
  "Okay, I do like that."

• Albert Breer [12:34]:
  "There’s no injury data that says it's more dangerous. But based on the posture of the player, that could lead to major head and spine injuries."

• Colin Cowherd [14:30]:
  "I have made the argument with Aaron Rodgers that he ideally wanted Minnesota, knew the division, loved the coach, loved Justin Jefferson."

• Albert Breer [21:17]:
  "From a talent perspective, there is a bigger separation between Cam Ward and Shador Sanders than there is between Shador Sanders and Jackson Dart."

Conclusion

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, the discussion primarily revolves around NFL over and under bets, the controversial Tush Push play, and insights into quarterback prospects for the upcoming draft. Colin and his co-hosts provide in-depth analysis, blending statistical projections with strategic evaluations of team dynamics and player performances. Notable debates include the efficacy of rule changes in overtime and the future of prominent players like Aaron Rodgers within team frameworks. The episode concludes with a blend of sports commentary and promotional content, maintaining an engaging narrative throughout.