The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Episode: Hour 2 – Old Rules (February 14, 2025)

In this engaging episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, filling in hosts Steve Covino and Rich Davis delve into a variety of compelling sports topics, intertwining them with light-hearted Valentine’s Day anecdotes and insightful commentary on athlete appearances and career moves. The episode skillfully navigates through discussions on facial hair policies in sports, the intriguing potential moves of NFL star Aaron Rodgers, the possible retirement of Travis Kelce, and humorous takes on Valentine’s Day mishaps involving NFL player Jason Kelsey.

1. The Impact of Facial Hair Policies in Sports

[03:01] Steve Covino: "If you think it's just me or Covino saying, you know, these type of things matter..."

The hosts kick off the episode by scrutinizing the stringent facial hair policies enforced by sports organizations, specifically focusing on Major League Baseball’s New York Yankees. They spotlight pitcher Devin Williams, who is reportedly being pressured to shave his beard despite a substantial contract nearly reaching $10 million per year.

[05:13] Rich Davis: "Everyone's beard is just right, big, poppy... feel good, play good."

Covino and Davis argue that such appearance mandates can undermine a player’s confidence and personal expression. They draw parallels with other sports, noting that in the NBA, players like Jimmy Butler embrace their unique styles without compromising their performance. The conversation underscores the importance of allowing athletes to maintain their personal style as a component of their confidence and overall game.

[07:17] Steve Covino: "A lot of young men are professional athletes trying to... feel good, live it up."

The discussion extends to the broader implications of appearance rules, suggesting that forcing players to conform can be counterproductive. They advocate for a balance where professional standards coexist with personal freedom, emphasizing that athlete confidence should not be stifled by superficial regulations.

2. Valentine's Day Anecdotes: The Jason Kelsey Story

[45:23] Steve Covino: "I baked air biscuits on my second date with Kylie and I'm like, kavino. Even Kelsey could cook. He cooked air biscuits."

In a humorous Valentine’s Day segment, Covino and Davis recount the story of Jason Kelsey, an NFL player known for his robust persona. The episode reveals that Kelsey’s attempt to impress his wife, Kylie, on their second date involved "baking air biscuits"—a euphemism for passing gas—a faux pas that became the focal point of their Valentine’s discussion.

[46:01] Rich Davis: "It sounds embarrassing, but how are you supposed to keep the romance alive if you're that guy that's like, honey, pull my finger to me."

This anecdote serves as a comedic exploration of relationship dynamics, highlighting how unexpected and awkward moments can become memorable stories within romantic relationships. The hosts use Kelsey’s experience to offer light-hearted advice on maintaining romance without compromising personal comfort.

3. Aaron Rodgers’ Future: Where Will He Land?

[22:08] Steve Covino: "Where does Aaron Rodgers end up? And Jason Kelsey, when he's talking about the early days of his romance..."

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to speculating on the next career move for NFL quarterback Aaron Rodgers following his departure from the New York Jets. Covino and Davis explore various possibilities, including potential signings with the Minnesota Vikings or the New York Giants, discussing the strategic fits and cultural alignments with each team.

[27:16] Steve Covino: "I think this is the team that makes the most sense... Dallas would absolutely do."

The hosts propose a unique scenario where Rodgers remains a free agent, poised to join a team mid-season as a "hero" quarterback should another team’s starter suffer an injury. This creative hypothesis aligns with Rodgers' reputation for being mentally prepared and his ability to invigorate a team's playoff aspirations.

[30:49] Rich Davis: "He'd have RFK on. He'd have Rogan on. It would be... He'd make millions."

Furthering their discussion, Covino and Davis entertain the idea of Rodgers transitioning into a broadcasting role, suggesting that his personality and intellect could make him a successful media figure. This segues into a broader conversation about the versatility of athletes beyond their playing careers.

4. Travis Kelce’s Retirement Speculations

[34:08] Steve Covino: "The Athletic is reporting that the Chiefs have given tight end Travis Kelce a soft deadline of March 14th to make his decision on whether he's going to return or retire from the NFL."

The episode transitions to discussing the future of Kansas City Chiefs' star tight end Travis Kelce. With his career milestones and achievements highlighted, Covino and Davis debate whether Kelce might consider retirement or a potential contract extension. They weigh his impact on the team against personal and professional considerations that athletes might face when contemplating the next steps in their careers.

[35:19] Rich Davis: "My answer is he is in a darkness retreat somewhere and he is looking elsewhere in the world of broadcasting."

Speculating on Kelce's choices, the hosts consider the likelihood of him continuing his athletic career versus transitioning into media roles, reflecting on how high-profile athletes often leverage their on-field success into broadcasting opportunities post-retirement.

5. Dodgers’ Management and Dave Roberts

[36:31] Ryan: "Dave Roberts is optimistic that he and the team will be able to reach an agreement on a contract extension before the end of spring training."

Shifting focus to Major League Baseball, the discussion centers on the Los Angeles Dodgers' manager Dave Roberts. Covino and Davis commend Roberts' leadership, citing his strategic acumen and pivotal moments, such as the iconic stolen base in the 2004 ALCS. They debate his legacy and potential standing among the greatest managers in baseball history, considering the Dodgers' recent successes and managerial stability.

[36:45] Steve Covino: "Do you think the Dodgers have a shot? I know that we're, we're talking way too early..."

The conversation extends to the Dodgers' prospects for the upcoming season, their managerial strategies, and the broader implications for the team’s future performance in MLB.

6. Halftime Entertainment and NFL Insights

[21:29] Steve Covino: "And we got to talk about this Jason Kelsey thing, because that's what you were talking about."

Interspersed with the main discussions are segments on halftime entertainment, with mentions of Kendrick Lamar’s performances, and updates on the Philadelphia Eagles' championship parade. These segments provide a well-rounded view of current sports events, keeping listeners informed on both on-field and off-field happenings.

[37:38] Steve Covino: "People laying around passed out with cheese. Whiz on them as the buses were passing by."

Covino and Davis provide vivid descriptions of the citywide celebrations, capturing the exuberance and occasional chaos that accompanies major sports victories, exemplified by the Eagles' triumphant parade.

7. Concluding Remarks and Listener Engagement

[39:03] Steve Covino: "We talk about everything. Life, sports, relationships, what's going on in the world."

As the episode nears its conclusion, Covino and Davis invite listeners to engage with their show through calls and social media, emphasizing the interactive nature of their program. They reiterate key topics discussed and tease upcoming segments, ensuring that the audience remains connected and anticipative of future content.

Notable Quotes:

• Steve Covino [05:13]: "Everyone's beard is just right, big, poppy... feel good, play good."

• Rich Davis [07:17]: "A lot of young men are professional athletes trying to... feel good, live it up."

• Steve Covino [22:08]: "Where does Aaron Rodgers end up? And Jason Kelsey, when he's talking about the early days of his romance..."

• Rich Davis [30:49]: "He'd have RFK on. He'd have Rogan on. It would be... He'd make millions."

• Steve Covino [35:19]: "My answer is he is in a darkness retreat somewhere and he is looking elsewhere in the world of broadcasting."

Conclusion

This episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd masterfully blends serious sports analysis with relatable personal anecdotes, offering listeners a comprehensive and entertaining exploration of current sports dynamics and athlete lifestyles. Covino and Davis provide thoughtful insights into how traditional rules and modern sensibilities intersect in the world of sports, all while keeping the tone light and engaging with their signature humor.