Summary of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd"
Episode: Hour 2 – Pittsburgh Predicament & Pete Prisco
Release Date: February 18, 2025

The Herd with Colin Cowherd delves deep into the pressing sports narratives of the day, offering insightful analysis and lively discussions. In this episode, titled "Pittsburgh Predicament & Pete Prisco," hosts Brady Quinn, Lavar Arrington, Jonas Knox, and guest Pete Prisco tackle issues ranging from quarterback controversies in the NFL to debates surrounding the NBA's evolving playstyle. Below is a comprehensive summary capturing the essence of their conversations, complete with notable quotes and timestamps for reference.

1. Introduction and Opening Banter (03:12 - 04:05)

The episode kicks off with the hosts catching up on their personal well-being. Brady Quinn mentions feeling refreshed, while Pete Prisco humorously discusses battling a cold using various homeopathic remedies like ginger shots.

Notable Quote:

• Pete Prisco [04:03]: "Everyone's getting sick. People are sneezing, coughing on each other. It's just, I feel like you're in a battle every day."

2. The Pittsburgh Steelers' Quarterback Conundrum (08:01 - 16:50)

The core of the episode centers around the Pittsburgh Steelers' ongoing struggles with their quarterback situation. Rumors have surfaced about the Steelers' interest in trading for Jacksonville Jaguars' quarterback Trevor Lawrence. However, both the Jaguars and Lawrence have downplayed these rumors.

Key Points Discussed:

• Trevor Lawrence's Position: Lawrence expressed his contentment with the Jaguars, emphasizing his commitment to winning a Super Bowl with the team. He highlighted the lack of trade calls in his contract, making a potential trade unlikely without his consent.

  Quote:

  • Brady Quinn [08:38]: "I think we can do that."

• Evaluation of Steelers' Options: The hosts debate whether the Steelers should explore other quarterback options like Justin Fields or Russell Wilson instead of pursuing Lawrence. They discuss Fields' consistency issues and Wilson's past performance, weighing their long-term suitability for the team.

  Quotes:

  • Brady Quinn [14:27]: "I think you gotta go with Russell Wilson. I think he's your best option."
  • Lavar Arrington [16:48]: "I think what you're doing is you take Trevor Lawrence and put him just to say it happened."

• Team Dynamics and Roster Needs: There's a consensus that the Steelers need to bolster their offensive firepower to support whichever quarterback they decide on. The discussion touches on the importance of having a dynamic offense to complement a strong quarterback.

3. Pete Prisco’s Controversial Stance on Eagles Fans (40:50 - 51:02)

Pete Prisco becomes the focal point as his opinions spark backlash from Philadelphia Eagles fans. He controversially ranked quarterbacks like Justin Herbert and Trevor Lawrence above the Eagles' Jalen Hurts, leading to anger among the fanbase.

Key Highlights:

• Prisco's Rankings: Prisco openly stated his preference for Herbert and Lawrence over Hurts, which many Eagles fans found offensive, especially following their Super Bowl win.

  Quotes:

  • Greg Tuohy (Pete's Segment) [41:00]: "I said yes. And so now, of course, the Philly fans are going nuts."
  • Brady Quinn [42:44]: "I 100% would [take Jalen Hurts over Dak Prescott]."

• Host Reactions: The hosts defend Prisco by distinguishing between a vocal minority of fans and the broader, more reasonable fanbase. They emphasize that only a small segment of fans reacted negatively, not representing all Eagles supporters.

  Quotes:

  • Brady Quinn [22:56]: "It's a very loud minority and it's not minorities. Don't go down that lane."
  • Lavar Arrington [47:07]: "There's mutual respect. Just mutual respect."

4. Worst-Run NFL Organizations: Focus on Jacksonville Jaguars (48:29 - 51:02)

The discussion shifts to evaluating NFL organizations' management efficacy, with a particular spotlight on the Jacksonville Jaguars.

Key Points:

• Historical Performance: The Jaguars under Trent Balker's leadership are criticized as the worst-run organization during his tenure, citing poor management decisions like hiring Urban Meyer, which led to disastrous outcomes.

  Quotes:

  • Greg Tuohy [48:43]: "The worst run organization in the league... When Trent Balky was running things, they were the worst."
  • Brady Quinn [49:46]: "He did absolutely nothing."

• Current Management Issues: Even with recent hires like Tony Vasily aimed at fixing the organization, skepticism remains about the Jaguars' ability to turn around, especially concerning their quarterback situation with Joe Burrow.

  Quotes:

  • Greg Tuohy [49:45]: "They're down to five, right? They're down to five."

5. NBA’s Three-Point Shot Debate (27:10 - 31:24)

While the primary focus remained on the NFL, the hosts briefly touch upon the NBA's increasing reliance on three-point shots and its impact on the game's traditional dynamics.

Key Points:

• Steph Curry’s Perspective: Steph Curry defends the evolution of the three-point shot, emphasizing the importance of skill development and its strategic value in modern basketball.

  Quote:

  • Brady Quinn [28:55]: "If you want to do that, then get in the gym, get your reps in and earn it."

• Impact on Game Excitement: The hosts debate whether the surge in three-point attempts detracts from the game's excitement and physicality, reminiscent of old-school NBA playstyles.

  Quote:

  • Jonas Knox [29:13]: "Nobody's become Michael Jordan yet. A lot of people tried year in and year out."

6. Mike Trout’s Position Change in MLB (31:24 - 33:19)

Shifting to Major League Baseball, the episode covers the Los Angeles Angels' decision to move star player Mike Trout from center field to right field to preserve his health.

Key Points:

• Trout’s Role Adjustment: At 33, Trout aims to reduce his physical strain by adjusting his defensive position, a move met with mixed reactions due to the Angels' overall team performance.

  Quote:

  • Jonas Knox [31:41]: "This is crazy. I mean, in reality, this should be a huge story, right, for a guy of Trout stature."

• Team Relevance: The hosts lament the Angels' declining relevance in the league, attributing it to their inability to compete effectively with powerhouse teams like the Dodgers.

  Quote:

  • Brady Quinn [32:32]: "There's no discussion. There's no difference."

7. Closing Remarks and Final Banter (53:04 - End)

As the episode nears its conclusion, the conversation shifts back to lighter topics and mutual host camaraderie. The hosts segue into promotional segments and tease upcoming discussions, maintaining the show’s engaging and personable atmosphere.

Conclusion:

In "Hour 2 – Pittsburgh Predicament & Pete Prisco," The Herd with Colin Cowherd effectively navigates through complex sports issues, providing listeners with in-depth analysis and diverse perspectives. From the Steelers' quarterback dilemmas to the repercussions of Pete Prisco's controversial opinions, the episode encapsulates the dynamic and often contentious nature of sports commentary. Additionally, brief forays into NBA and MLB topics offer a well-rounded discourse, ensuring that listeners are both informed and entertained.

Notable Quotes Recap:

• Brady Quinn [08:38]: "I think we can do that."
• Brady Quinn [14:27]: "I think you gotta go with Russell Wilson. I think he's your best option."
• Greg Tuohy [48:43]: "The worst run organization in the league... When Trent Balky was running things, they were the worst."
• Brady Quinn [28:55]: "If you want to do that, then get in the gym, get your reps in and earn it."

This episode underscores the importance of strategic decision-making in sports management and the impact of outspoken opinions within the fan communities. The Herd with Colin Cowherd continues to be a pivotal platform for sports enthusiasts seeking comprehensive and candid discussions on the latest happenings in the sports world.