Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 2: Where Colin Was Right and Wrong
Release Date: April 28, 2025
Host/Authors: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Duration: Approximately 48 minutes

Episode Overview

In this engaging second hour of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd," hosts Jason McIntyre and Chris Broussard delve deep into the recent NFL and NBA developments, critically analyzing Colin Cowherd's previous opinions to determine where he hit the mark and where he missed. The episode features insightful discussions on the NFL draft, player performances, team strategies, and ongoing NBA playoffs, enriched by guest appearances and expert commentary.

Key Discussions

1. NFL Draft Analysis

A. Colin's Accurate Predictions

• Ant Edwards as a Top Young Player:
  Jason McIntyre praises Colin for recognizing Ant Edwards as a standout talent.

  “Edwards continues to be the best young player in the game... Ant Edwards is dominating fourth quarters.”
  (05:15)

• Seahawks' Draft Strategy:
  The Seahawks' decisions, aligning with their organizational needs, receive commendation.

  “The Seahawks went and got their Steve Hutchinson type offensive lineman, no nonsense, versatile... perfect fit.”
  (16:57)

B. Colin's Missed Marks

• Cleveland Browns' Quarterback Pick:
  The decision to draft Dylan Gabriel over Shador Sanders is critiqued as a significant misstep.

  “I thought Shador Sanders is a franchise quarterback... I was wrong.”
  (22:24)

• Chicago Bears' Offensive Focus:
  Despite expectations for a defensive-heavy draft, the Bears prioritized offense, which some argue was a misalignment.

  “They have so much talent on offense... no excuses for Caleb Williams.”
  (07:06)

C. Notable Quotes:

• Jason McIntyre on Shador Sanders:

  “He was the most underdrafted player in the draft. There's no way he should be going the fifth round.”
  (37:54)

• Chris Broussard on Dylan Gabriel:

  “You got one starter quarter... you got one starter quarter.”
  (45:15)

2. Guest Insights with Matt Hasselbeck

• Role of Humility in the Locker Room:
  Matt Hasselbeck emphasizes the importance of humility for team chemistry and locker room respect.

  “Humility is respected in the locker room.”
  (11:33)

• Seahawks' Draft Success:
  Matt lauds the Seahawks for their strategic draft picks, highlighting their alignment with team culture and playing style.

  “Pete Carroll views a great running game as an extension of the defense... perfect fit.”
  (17:49)

• Steelers and Aaron Rodgers Situation:
  Discussion on the Steelers' strategy with Aaron Rodgers, suggesting a potential handshake agreement to avoid drafting a replacement prematurely.

  “There was a handshake agreement, let's wait till after the draft and then we'll talk.”
  (46:27)

3. NBA Playoffs Insights

• Anthony Edwards' Performance:
  Chris Broussard and Jason McIntyre commend Edwards for his stellar performances, particularly in high-stakes moments against the Lakers.

  “Anthony Edwards did his thing on a big stage, it doesn't get much better than that.”
  (31:24)

• Lakers vs. Minnesota Timberwolves Series:
  The hosts analyze the Lakers' defensive strategies and fatigue issues, contrasting them with Minnesota's resilience.

  “The Lakers have been outscored by six or more in every fourth quarter.”
  (27:59)

• Jalen Green and Draymond Green Clash:
  Highlighting Jalen Green's confrontation with Draymond Green, showcasing the physical intensity of the playoffs.

  “Jalen Green got into it with Draymond at the end.”
  (33:05)

4. Team Strategies and Player Evaluations

• Raiders' Quarterback Pick – Ashton Genty:
  Praised for fitting Chip Kelly's offensive philosophy, leveraging Geno Smith's play-action proficiency.

  “Ashton Genty is a total backup... he's hard to get leverage on five, eight running backs.”
  (07:04)

• Chicago Bears' Offensive Line Investments:
  The strategic focus on bolstering offensive positions is discussed, with admiration for Ben Johnson's draft room leadership.

  “Ben Johnson is clearly running the draft room because they are going free agency and drafting their best picks.”
  (06:33)

5. Controversial Decisions and Speculations

• Cleveland Browns' Quarterback Depth:
  Speculation on the competitive dynamics between Shador Sanders, Kenny Pickett, and Joe Flacco, questioning the team's depth management.

  “You can't keep four and five guys around... somebody's gotta go.”
  (19:30)

• Matt Hasselbeck on Team Adaptability:
  Emphasizing the necessity for teams to adapt their draft strategies based on evolving needs and player potential.

  “They are going to have to get creative and the coaches are going to have to be the ones to adjust.”
  (13:21)

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Jason McIntyre on Ant Edwards (05:15):

  “Ant Edwards is dominating fourth quarters.”

• Matt Hasselbeck on Seahawks' Draft Strategy (17:49):

  “Pete Carroll views a great running game as an extension of the defense... perfect fit.”

• Jason McIntyre on Shador Sanders (37:54):

  “He was the most underdrafted player in the draft. There's no way he should be going the fifth round.”

• Chris Broussard on Dylan Gabriel (45:15):

  “You got one starter quarter... you got one starter quarter.”

Conclusions and Takeaways

• Draft Successes and Failures:
  The episode underscores the complexities of NFL draft decisions, highlighting instances where Colin Cowherd accurately predicted standout players and where his opinions diverged from the outcomes. The Cleveland Browns' quarterback selection emerges as a focal point of debate, emphasizing the high stakes and long-term impacts of draft choices.

• Importance of Team Fit and Culture:
  Guest Matt Hasselbeck reinforces the idea that successful drafts are not just about talent but also about how well new players integrate into a team's culture and existing strategies. The Seahawks serve as a prime example of aligning draft picks with organizational philosophy.

• NBA Playoffs Dynamics:
  Transitioning to the NBA, the discussion provides a nuanced analysis of team performances, player fatigue, and strategic confrontations, painting a vivid picture of the playoff atmosphere and its influence on game outcomes.

• Overall Impact of Host Opinions:
  By dissecting Colin's predictions, the hosts offer listeners a balanced perspective on the accuracy and foresight of sports punditry, encouraging a deeper understanding of the factors that influence team successes and failures.

Final Thoughts

This episode of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd" serves as a comprehensive analysis of recent sports events, providing listeners with expert insights into NFL drafts and NBA playoffs. Through critical evaluation of Colin Cowherd's viewpoints and enriched by Matt Hasselbeck's professional experience, the discussion offers a multifaceted exploration of team strategies, player potentials, and the ever-evolving landscape of professional sports.

For those who missed the episode, this summary encapsulates the essence of the conversations, highlighting the key areas where Colin was both right and wrong, and the implications of these judgments on the broader sports narrative.