Colin Cowherd (5:38)
He continued to play at a high level. So we have every interest in him being around. Okay, so it's really interesting. The Niners used to be a have and now it looks like, oh, this year they're a have not. So what we know is the eight teams that won their division all had the best quarterback. First time I can remember. Do you think Brock Purdy is the kind of guy that will be a best quarterback in a division? I do not. You have to reframe the discussion on Brock Purdy. It has to go from ooh, look what he's done to what can he do? Because once he gobbles up a big chunk of the salary, he plays with less talented players. Remember Jared Goff before he got paid in LA? Sean McVeigh loved him and then he paid him and he didn't love him so much. If you ever wonder if you should pay a quarterback, ask yourself one question. What does our rival think? Because Buffalo loved it when Miami paid Tua big boy money. Buffalo loved it. He's 1 and 8 against the bills and he can't play when it's cold. Buffalo loved Tua signing a long term deal, by the way. The Eagles loved Daniel Jones signing up for more money with the New York Giants. What do you think Sean McVeigh thinks with Matt Stafford? Ooh, scary. Brock purdy? Nope. Sean McVay this year, next, probably the following year, will have the best quarterback. So ask yourself it's not about what he's done, it's about what can he do once you take people away from him. Scheme and stats. This is where Tua and Purdy are very similar. The scheme and the stats make you go, ooh. Eye test. Hammond Egger little, small, weather affected, need certain weapons, lose weapons, not as good. And what's interesting with the Niners is you already have the answer. How many games you win this year without Christian McCaffrey? Trent Williams hurt, Brandon Aiyuk hurt. You got the answer. Would you win six, seven, eight games? He got the answer in front of you. So if you're the Niners, you have to reframe the question. And here's something else because you want to be playing this weekend, the halves. There's 14 halves and that means there's. What do you got? 18 have nots. And the Niners are in the have nots. And one thing we know, if you have a great quarterback and Purdy's not that, in my opinion, you're not going to be winning your division going forward. I mean, good God. Kyle Shanahan, boy genius, has a losing record in San Francisco. Without Christian McCaffrey, Sean McVay doesn't have losing seasons often. Shannon's had him. So one of the disturbing trends is that Stafford needs McVeigh, but is he totally reliant on McVeigh? Because the stats this year for Brock Purdy are disturbing. In the first and second quarter, the schemed quarter, his passer rating is excellent. In the third and fourth quarters, the non schemed quarters, he has a. He has a passer rating that should pay you about $16 million a year, not 58. And so it is an interesting time for the San Francisco 49ers. They used to be in one group, now they're in the other. And the only thing that guarantees no Super Bowls is paying a B quarterback a money. You win a bunch of games, so does Dallas, but nobody will take you serious come January. Big decisions. The idea of paying him early has never made any sense. I would let it play out. Oh, by the way, he got hurt again this year. So I saw this story yesterday. Belichick. Bill Belichick made sure, as he's on the recruiting trail, he made sure to get a hold of a couple of sources or his people did to say, hey, I am not going back to the NFL because it's hurting recruiting. And here's the thing. Bill Belichick did such a great job, and you've had this before in your life. Somebody does such a great job doing something, it's the only way I can see them. It's like the Rock. The Rock is an action star. He could do a rom com. But if you're trying to convince me he's going to give up action films for Rom coms. His personality is an action film. His experience with wrestling, he's action. His physique is an action film star. The Rock does action films. I don't want him crying a lot on screen. I don't want Rock being too tender and huggable. That's not who he is and that's not what he is. And that's not what he's built to be. Bill Belichick is a pro coach. He is much more ROTC than Nil. He is rigid. He doesn't pander. He doesn't have time for small talk. And that's what college football is. Hi, volleyball coach. Hey, recruit. Nice to meet you, Mr. Donor. I've always thought it's easier, although the coaching is much better in pro football than college. It's much easier to go psychologically college to pro. Just more football and less nonsense. It's very difficult to be a great pro coach and have to go backwards to college. A lot of handshakes, a lot of pandering, a lot of small talk. I mean, Bill hates mistakes. What do 18 and 19 and 20 year old boys do? Make a lot of mistakes in football and out of it. There's a reason Belichick is an NFL historian. He loves great players. And great players play at Georgia and, and they play at Notre Dame and they play at Ohio State and they play at Alabama and lsu. And a lot of great players don't play at Carolina. Now Bill has the advantage of being a big brand and some kids may want to play for him, especially defensive players. But, but Bill was so great at the NFL. I just can't buy into. I don't care what sources say about, you know, Bill because I saw the story this morning. Bill's got no interest going back to the NFL. Yeah, and the Rock would have no interest going back to action films if somebody offered him 30 large for one. I'm sorry, that's who Bill is. That's his experience, that's his personality. That's who he is. And so I, I would love to see Bill because, because, you know, some of these offensive coaches, they age well. Sean Payton ages well. Drew Brell is yesterday. Andy Reid is aging well. You see, these old offensive go, old defensive coaches don't generally age as well because they don't necessarily, you know, they're, they're, they're, they're not necessarily always the best adapters. And college football, nil Portal is all about adapting. So I, it just, it's almost like Belichick staying in college. It's like, you know, New Year's resolutions. You can tell me you're going to go to the gym every day. You, you can tell me you're going to keep your New Year's resolution and you're going to eat better. You know, about three weeks in, you start to kind of fade off. That nine weeks in, you drive by the gym and think you should go and 12 weeks, and you just don't. You take a different way to work. Like, like. So you're, you're getting me to buy into. Belichick's going to love this college football thing. I can't. I just can't do it. He was so great at one thing. I don't buy the other thing. That's where I stand on it. And I still contend Philadelphia or Buffalo get bounced early in the playoffs, and I don't think they will. I think Philadelphia is going to beat Green Bay. I think Buffalo is going to win at home against Denver. I do. But if they got bounced, you are having absolute phone calls to Belichick. My belief is he would pick up the phone for both. And with that, I bring on my friend. He's a former NFL scout. John Middelkoff has a very popular podcast and he's been on our show several times before. I want to talk about several things. Tom Telesco, who I know very well and like and admire, just got fired the Raiders gm, so they got rid of Antonio Pierce. I thought the team played very hard considering their quarterback situation in a division with Mahomes and Herbert and Vonix. I thought they were very competitive. They beat the Chiefs last year. They could have beaten them again this year at Arrowhead. So now they fire Tesco. That, that means they've had three different coaches in four years. What is this signal? Wait, Brady's involved now? You hear stories about. He, you know, he's talking to candidates. What is this signal, John, to you?