Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd
Episode: Hour 3 - Colin would trade Myles Garrett, Albert Breer
Release Date: December 23, 2024

1. Introduction to the Episode

The episode titled "Hour 3 - Colin would trade Myles Garrett" delves into various pressing topics in the sports world, primarily focusing on NFL quarterback performances, team strategies, and potential high-stakes trades. Hosted by Jason McIntyre with insights from Albert Breer, the discussion offers a deep dive into the current state of several NFL teams and key players.

2. Jaden Daniels: A Rising Star

[03:37] Jason McIntyre:
The conversation kicks off with an analysis of Jaden Daniels, an emerging quarterback who has garnered significant attention for his impressive performances.

Albert Breer:
Breer shares an anecdote highlighting Daniels' exceptional character and resilience:

"He is a very, very, very special player, prospect, person, all of it. So they feel really strongly about it. They have felt that strongly about it, you know, since camp."

Key Points:

• Daniels impressed both Kingsbury and Dan Quinn during camp, signaling high expectations.
• His extensive college experience at Arizona State and within the SEC has prepared him to handle NFL pressures.
• A notable moment in a recent game demonstrated his poise under pressure, reacting wisely to an unexpected RPO play:

  "He had to react to the receivers not being ready for it. And he actually tucked the ball and ran for the two yards that were there... he gets down, they call the timeout, and of course then they run for the first down."

Timestamp for Key Quote: [06:54]

3. Sam Darnold and the Minnesota Vikings QB Dilemma

[07:09] Jason McIntyre:
The discussion transitions to Sam Darnold and his uncertain future with the Minnesota Vikings. McIntyre raises concerns about the team's quarterback class and potential strategies to retain or trade Darnold.

Albert Breer:
Breer provides insights from a conversation with Kevin O'Connell, the Vikings' head coach:

"Kevin almost seemed like a little bit... indignant about the idea that the other shoe is about to drop, you know, with, with Sam."

Key Points:

• O'Connell defends Darnold, emphasizing his abilities and current situation.
• The Vikings are at a crossroads, needing to decide between retaining Darnold or prioritizing future quarterbacks like J.J. McCarthy.
• The franchise tag's high cost ($40 million+) poses a significant financial decision for the team.
• Historical precedent from the Chargers' decision to franchise Drew Brees is discussed, weighing the short-term benefits against long-term uncertainties.

Timestamp for Key Quote: [09:48]

4. The New York Jets: A Prime Coaching Opportunity

[10:00] Jason McIntyre:
McIntyre introduces the topic of the New York Jets as a potential head coaching destination, highlighting their team composition and management dynamics.

Albert Breer:
Breer outlines both the opportunities and challenges associated with the Jets:

"There's a good base of talent there... you can build around."

Key Points:

• The Jets boast talented players like Garrett Wilson and Quincy Williams, offering a strong foundation.
• However, ownership's previous interference in football decisions has made potential candidates cautious.
• The Jets present a unique opportunity to bring in a coaching staff that can work cohesively without excessive external influence.
• The importance of establishing a stable coaching-GM partnership is emphasized, contrasting with other teams like Chicago and New Orleans.

Timestamp for Key Quote: [11:19]

5. Ohio State's Performance and Ryan Day's Leadership

[13:03] Jason McIntyre:
The discussion shifts to college football, specifically Ohio State's recent games and the implications for head coach Ryan Day.

Albert Breer:
Breer reflects on historical context and Ryan Day's tenure:

"I think on balance, Ryan has done a really good job there."

Key Points:

• Ohio State delivered a competitive game, reminiscent of their high-caliber performances against Georgia.
• Concerns arise about potential losses in upcoming games and their impact on Ryan Day's job security.
• Breer argues that Day's positive influence, strong roster, and future potential should shield him from immediate dismissal despite occasional setbacks.
• The core talent on the team, including players like Jeremiah Smith and Caleb Downs, positions Ohio State for continued success.

Timestamp for Key Quote: [14:48]

6. Trading Myles Garrett: A Bold Move for the Cleveland Browns

[28:28] Dan Quinn:
A significant portion of the episode centers on the Cleveland Browns' quarterback and defensive dynamics, specifically focusing on Myles Garrett.

Colin Cowherd:
Cowherd expresses frustration with the Browns' direction:

"I'm trying to win right now. I want that to be apparent when the season's over."

Key Points:

• Garrett, a loyal and standout defensive player, hints at the possibility of a franchise change if the team doesn't improve.
• McIntyre proposes a controversial strategy: trading Myles Garrett to acquire a franchise quarterback, suggesting the current QB class is inadequate.
• The idea stems from the necessity to prioritize a winning culture over retaining star players without the necessary support structures.
• Comparisons are made to past trades and the high cost of retaining players like Garrett.
• The Browns face a dilemma: continue attempting to build around existing talent or make significant changes to secure long-term success.

Timestamp for Key Quote: [28:28]

7. Caleb Williams: Talent vs. Temperament

[41:21] Jason McIntyre:
The episode addresses Caleb Williams' performance as a rookie quarterback and the criticisms surrounding his temperament.

Albert Breer:
Breer critiques Williams' character and on-field demeanor:

"I haven't seen the things that I believe are really important that I believe matter for sustained success for a long career."

Key Points:

• Matt Hasselbeck, a guest on the show, has been vocal about his reservations regarding Caleb Williams, citing issues beyond his on-field performance.
• Williams is praised for his athleticism and play-making abilities but is criticized for emotional volatility and moody behavior.
• McIntyre draws parallels to other quarterbacks like Aaron Rodgers and Kyler Murray, discussing the balance between talent and emotional intelligence.
• Despite Williams' talent, concerns persist about his long-term fit and ability to maintain a positive presence within the team dynamics.

Timestamp for Key Quote: [41:49]

8. Closing Thoughts and Final Discussions

As the episode nears its conclusion, the hosts recap the discussed topics, emphasizing the ongoing challenges and potential shifts in the NFL landscape. The focus remains on strategic decisions by teams, the balance between player talent and leadership, and the implications of high-stakes trades.

Notable Final Quotes:

• Dan Quinn:

  "I'm bullish on Cam Ward. I think he got... there's a chance he's really, really good."

• Jason McIntyre:

  "I do believe and I'm serious on this. I could see If I'm the New York Giants and you gave me Miles Garrett and I gave you the number one pick."

Timestamp for Final Quotes: [45:34], [32:36]

Conclusion

This episode of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd" presents a comprehensive analysis of pivotal moments and decisions facing NFL teams, particularly focusing on quarterback performances, team management strategies, and the intricate balance between player talent and team dynamics. The discussions underscore the complexities of building a winning team in the highly competitive landscape of professional sports.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Albert Breer on Jaden Daniels:
  "[06:54] ...He is a very, very, very special player, prospect, person, all of it."

• Jason McIntyre on Trading Myles Garrett:
  "[32:18] ...I don't think these quarterbacks in this class. I don't think any of them are as good as this."

• Albert Breer on Caleb Williams' Temperament:
  "[41:49] This is a very strong rookie class of quarterbacks and I just think that like Caleb is the one guy to me that I don't see the things that I believe are really important..."

• Dan Quinn on Myles Garrett's Leadership:
  "[28:55] ...He's got to be the leader of that team."

• Jason McIntyre on Ryan Day's Job Security:
  "[14:48] I think on balance, Ryan has done a really good job there."

This summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from the podcast episode, providing a structured overview for those who haven't listened to the full episode.