Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 3: NFL Draft Talk

Release Date: April 10, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host Colin Cowherd engages in an in-depth discussion with co-host Chris "The Bear" Felica, focusing on the upcoming NFL Draft. The conversation delves into quarterback prospects, team strategies, betting insights, and broader implications for various NFL franchises.

1. Shador Sanders: Top Quarterback Prospect

Timestamp: 02:25 – 05:10

Chris Felica begins by evaluating Shador Sanders, highlighting his on-field performance and potential in the NFL:

Chris Felica (02:25): "I think he's fine. Like I look do I do I think he is a lock guaranteed franchise changing quarterback? No, I don't."

Despite Sanders' impressive stats and dynamic playmaking ability, Felica expresses skepticism about Sanders being a definitive franchise quarterback, citing concerns about offensive line performance during his college tenure.

2. Jalen Milroe: Potential and Concerns

Timestamp: 08:30 – 12:02

The discussion shifts to Jalen Milroe, another promising quarterback entrant:

Chris Felica (08:41): "He's not someone that I'm going to be rushing to take in the first round or even high in the second round."

Felica acknowledges Milroe's athleticism and potential but points out his inconsistent performance, particularly in high-pressure games. He emphasizes the importance of team schemes and offensive support in harnessing Milroe's talents.

3. Browns' Draft Strategy: Addressing Quarterback Needs

Timestamp: 03:17 – 04:30

Addressing the Cleveland Browns' quarterback dilemma, Cowherd and Felica explore possible draft moves:

Cowherd (03:17): "If you're the Browns, what I would do, I would take Travis Hunter number two, knowing you've got an impact receiver, defensive back, whatever you want, and then trade back into the end of the first round potentially to get a quarterback."

Felica suggests that the Browns focus on securing versatile players like Travis Hunter early and consider trading down to acquire a quarterback without forfeiting substantial draft capital.

4. Over/Under Betting on Quarterback Selections

Timestamp: 10:03 – 10:34

The hosts delve into betting strategies related to quarterback selections in the draft:

Felica (10:03): "Absolutely. Oh I am absolutely over two and a half and I know they posted a big price out there."

They discuss the likelihood of multiple quarterbacks being selected in the first round, endorsing an over on selecting more than two and a half QBs, reflecting confidence in the depth of quarterback talent.

5. Jets’ Considerations: Shador Sanders vs. Current QB

Timestamp: 12:02 – 14:03

Focusing on the New York Jets, Cowherd asks Felica about the potential drafting of Shador Sanders amid Justin Fields' tenure:

Felica (12:25): "No, you absolutely have to consider it because again, this is a quarterback who had a ton of run in the Bears and the Bears cut the cord knowing that he wasn't the answer."

Felica advises that while Sanders may be a valuable backup, the Jets should prioritize versatile offensive players like Tyler Warren or Colson Loveland to complement Fields' skills.

6. Arch Manning: Future Prospects and Uncertainties

Timestamp: 16:53 – 18:38

The conversation shifts to Arch Manning, exploring his potential impact in the NFL:

Felica (17:05): "We don't know if he's good yet. We know about the bloodline."

Felica highlights the uncertainty surrounding Manning's performance, emphasizing the need for a full collegiate season to accurately assess his capabilities before projecting his NFL success.

7. Brief NBA Discussion: Suns’ Struggles and Trade Speculations

Timestamp: 27:00 – 28:18

Transitioning briefly to the NBA, Cowherd and Alex Curry discuss the Phoenix Suns' disappointing performance and trade considerations:

Cowherd (28:05): "I would keep Booker and do whatever I could to move off Bradley Beal and Kevin Durant."

They debate the value of Devin Booker versus other star players, suggesting that retaining Booker while potentially trading high-impact players like Durant could revitalize the Suns' roster.

8. Steelers’ Quarterback Carousel and Potential Trades

Timestamp: 21:39 – 23:25

News updates by Alex Curry address the Pittsburgh Steelers' ongoing quarterback evaluations, including meetings with Kyle McCord and Shador Sanders:

Cowherd (23:13): "Is it poop or get off the pot? Stop sitting on the fence. Decide."

The hosts express frustration over the Steelers' indecision in securing a long-term quarterback solution, debating whether the team is genuinely considering young prospects or signaling readiness to trade veteran stars like Aaron Rodgers.

Conclusion

The episode wraps up with a recap of the key points discussed, emphasizing the complexities of the NFL Draft, team strategies in addressing quarterback needs, and the broader implications of draft choices on team dynamics and future performances. Colin Cowherd and Chris Felica provide listeners with nuanced perspectives, combining statistical analysis with strategic insights to navigate the ever-evolving landscape of professional football.

Notable Quotes

• Chris Felica (02:25): "I think he's fine. Like I look do I do I think he is a lock guaranteed franchise changing quarterback? No, I don't."

• Cowherd (03:17): "If you're the Browns, what I would do, I would take Travis Hunter number two..."

• Felica (08:41): "He's not someone that I'm going to be rushing to take in the first round or even high in the second round."

• Felica (12:25): "No, you absolutely have to consider it because again, this is a quarterback who had a ton of run in the Bears and the Bears cut the cord knowing that he wasn't the answer."

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the critical discussions and expert analyses presented in the episode, offering valuable insights for fans and followers of the NFL Draft.