Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 3: The Most Entertaining

Release Date: May 27, 2025

In the third hour of "The Herd with Colin Cowherd," listeners are treated to an array of engaging sports discussions, spanning topics from consumer product feedback to deep dives into player performances and legacy debates. Below is a detailed summary capturing the key points, insights, and conclusions from the episode.

1. Consumer Product Update: Degree Deodorant Reverts to Original Scent

Colin Cowherd opens the episode with a surprising turn of events in the consumer goods sector:

Colin Cowherd [01:04]: "Last year, Degree changed the formula for their Cool Rush deodorant, and their fans rebelled and wanted the old scent back. Degree listens. That doesn't happen often. They admitted they effed up and they're bringing back the original Cool Rush scent."

This move by Degree highlights the significant impact of consumer feedback on product formulations, emphasizing the brand's responsiveness to loyal customers.

2. WNBA Ticket Prices Drop Due to Caitlin Clark's Injury

Shifting focus to basketball, Colin addresses the economic implications of player injuries:

Colin Cowherd [03:36]: "Caitlin Clark's injury has sent WNBA ticket prices for her games tumbling. The Indiana Fever Chicago Sky game, which right now maybe is the best rivalry in the league, tickets are down 7.71%."

Colin and guest Rick Bucher delve into Caitlin Clark's immense popularity and marketability within the WNBA, discussing how her absence affects ticket sales and the league's visibility.

3. NBA Player Performance: SGA vs. Anthony Edwards

A substantial portion of the discussion centers on NBA players, specifically focusing on SGA (Scottie Barnes) and Anthony Edwards:

Colin Cowherd [05:19]: "When I hear the criticism of FGA, I'm like, he's not here to entertain us. He's just a tremendous all-time player."

Rick Bucher responds by defending SGA's abilities, highlighting his versatile scoring and defensive skills:

Rick Bucher [06:10]: "SGA is a three-level scorer and he's got the ability to get a step on guys, going either direction, and he can score in a multitude of ways."

The conversation contrasts SGA's multifaceted game with Anthony Edwards' reliance on three-point shooting, questioning the impact of analytics on player development.

4. The Influence of Politics and Analytics on Sports

Colin draws parallels between political strategies and sports analytics:

Colin Cowherd [07:50]: "In politics today, you have to win primaries. It basically doesn't play to moderates in common sense either. You're far left or far right, and that will get you in the running right."

He connects this to how analytics may be pushing players like Anthony Edwards to adopt specific playing styles, potentially to their detriment.

5. Luka Doncic's Conditioning and Off-Season Habits

The episode touches upon NBA star Luka Doncic's physical conditioning:

Colin Cowherd [17:31]: "What do you make of the Luka? I just, in the end, I think he is what he is, right?"

Rick Bucher emphasizes the challenges athletes face during the season, such as maintaining discipline amidst travel and irregular schedules, which affect their conditioning and performance.

6. Packers’ Receiver Acquisition: Matthew Golden

Shifting to football, Colin and co-host J. Mac discuss the Green Bay Packers' recent draft pick:

J. Mac [19:26]: "Jordan Love has a new weapon on the outside, a young fellow named Matthew Golden out of Texas. He's a burner."

Colin analyzes the Packers' strategy, suggesting that the team may use this acquisition to either enhance their receiving corps or leverage Golden in future trades to strengthen other areas.

7. Giannis and the USA vs. World All-Star Game Proposal

The conversation then moves to a proposed change in the NBA All-Star Game format:

J. Mac [21:14]: "Giannis is endorsing this USA versus the World All-Star Game. It's been floated before, but Giannis is now active on social media ahead of potentially his trade summer."

Colin expresses strong support for the idea, arguing it would add meaningful competition to the event:

Colin Cowherd [22:10]: "I would absolutely in one second take this over the current NBA All-Star Game. Not even without question."

The hosts discuss the challenges of garnering buy-in from players and fans, especially with star players like Steph Curry and LeBron James approaching the twilight of their careers.

8. Aaron Judge's MLB Achievement

Transitioning to baseball, J. Mac highlights Aaron Judge's remarkable season:

J. Mac [22:51]: "Aaron Judge is hitting .398 right now, chasing 4.400. He's first or second in almost every major batting category, trying to break Babe Ruth's record for total bases which has stood since 1921."

Judge's exceptional performance is lauded, and Colin discusses the potential excitement of a Yankees-Dodgers World Series rematch featuring Judge versus Shohei Ohtani.

9. Aaron Rodgers' NFL Legacy and Top 10 Debate

In a deep dive into NFL quarterback legacies, Colin and Rick debate Aaron Rodgers' standing among the all-time greats:

Colin Cowherd [32:46]: "Nick says he's top 10. And I struggle with it because the stuff that matters is Super Bowl appearances and wins, division titles."

Rick agrees but highlights Rodgers' statistics and impact despite fewer championships:

Rick Bucher [35:02]: "He's right there with them [top quarterbacks]."

They compare Rodgers to other legends like Dan Marino, John Elway, and modern stars like Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes, weighing factors such as Super Bowl victories, individual performance, and team dynamics.

Conclusion

The episode effectively balances a variety of sports topics, providing listeners with in-depth analysis and lively debate. From the resurgence of a beloved deodorant scent to the nuanced discussions of player performance and legacy, Colin Cowherd and his guests offer a comprehensive and engaging exploration of the most entertaining aspects of today's sports world.

Notable Quotes:

• Colin Cowherd [01:04]: "Degree listens. That doesn't happen often."

• Rick Bucher [06:10]: "SGA is a three-level scorer and he's got the ability to get a step on guys, going either direction."

• Colin Cowherd [22:10]: "I would absolutely in one second take this over the current NBA All-Star Game."

• J. Mac [22:51]: "Aaron Judge is absolutely cooking with the Yankees."

• Rick Bucher [35:02]: "He's right there with them [top quarterbacks]."

This summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from the episode, providing a comprehensive overview for those who haven't tuned in.