The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Hour 3 Summary Featuring Todd McShay

Release Date: April 22, 2025

Hosts:

• Colin Cowherd – Host, The Herd with Colin Cowherd
• Todd McShay – NFL Draft Expert
• Jason McIntyre – Sports Analyst
• Charlamagne Tha God – Guest Host

1. NFL Draft Deep Dive

a. Quarterback Prospects: Shador Sanders vs. Jackson Dart

The episode kicks off with an in-depth discussion on the NFL Draft’s quarterback selections, particularly focusing on Shador Sanders and Jackson Dart.

• Colin Cowherd raises the topic: “The Giants in the room are split on Shador Sanders...”

• Todd McShay responds at [03:16], emphasizing the importance of quarterback development and coaching:

  “There are so few in the league that actually are really, really good at developing quarterbacks... I’m going with the coach that believes in the quarterback.”

• McShay predicts that Jackson Dart is more likely to align with Coach Brian Daboll’s preferences, given Daboll’s history with successful quarterbacks like Jalen Hurts and Josh Allen.

  “I suspect that Brian Daboll is a Jackson Dart guy... I don't have a team where I’m like, they’re going to come and be the parachute for Shador Sanders.”

b. Running Back Class: Travy Henderson and Omari Hampton

The conversation shifts to the highly regarded running back draft class.

• Colin Cowherd describes it as a “remarkable running back draft” and asks for player comparisons.

• Todd McShay compares Travy Henderson to Jamal Gibbs, highlighting his versatility and potential impact:

  “I think Jameer Gibbs is an accurate assessment... these running backs could play early and be regular starters.”

• McShay notes the depth of the class, suggesting that even players ranked 15th to 18th may secure significant roles:

  “This class is so good at running back and it’s so deep that the running backs could fall a little bit.”

c. Notable Player Insights: Mecca Bulga and Beyond

The discussion broadens to include other draft prospects and their projections.

• Colin Cowherd mentions Mecca Bulga, stirring comparisons and projections.

• Todd McShay elaborates with analogies to underscore a player’s intrinsic value beyond statistics:

  “It’s like the friend group you have... he’s a force multiplier in your locker room.”

d. Injury Concerns: Abdul Carter

Addressing potential red flags, Abdul Carter’s reluctance to undergo surgery is analyzed.

• Cowherd expresses concern:

  “... he doesn’t want to get surgery. Drew Rosenhaus, very persuasive... is that a deal breaker?”

• McShay reassures that teams are not overly worried and are conducting thorough evaluations:

  “I haven’t gotten any word from a single team, or it’s like, yeah, that’s something that we would shy away from.”

e. Jalen Milroe’s Athletic Prowess

The panel delves into Jalen Milroe’s exceptional running abilities.

• Jason McIntyre cites feedback from coaches and scouts labeling Milroe as the greatest runner they've seen at quarterback:

  “[Tom Pelissaro] said that Milroe is... the greatest runner...”

• McShay compares Milroe to legendary players, emphasizing his unique skill set:

  “There’s nothing like Lamar Jackson, anything.”

f. Vikings’ Quarterback Decisions: Sam Darnold and J.J. McCarthy

The segment concludes with the Minnesota Vikings' quarterback strategy.

• McShay commends J.J. McCarthy’s development:

  “JJ has handled... where I think he’s ready to hit the ground running as of today.”

• Jason McIntyre expresses confidence in McCarthy’s potential to lead the Vikings:

  “I’m gonna make the Vikings my team next year... I’m all in on J.J. McCarthy.”

2. NBA MVP Candidacy and Player Rankings

a. Jason Tatum’s MVP Case

A heated debate ensues over whether Jayson Tatum deserved to be among the top three MVP finalists.

• McIntyre challenges Tatum’s placement:

  “Tatum was not among the top three MVP finalists...”

• Cowherd defends Tatum’s performance:

  “He’s disrespected and that’s okay because sometimes that’s fuel for the greater good...”

• McShay and Cowherd engage in a spirited exchange about Tatum vs. other stars like Giannis and LeBron, discussing their impact and contributions to their teams.

b. Ranking the Best American NBA Players

The conversation expands to rank the top American players in the NBA, considering factors like performance, leadership, and potential.

• Cowherd initiates the ranking, referencing players like Donovan Mitchell and Devin Booker:

  “I would say ant3 and then I would get into the SJ or Tatum.”

• McIntyre advocates for including players like Ja Morant and Paul George, acknowledging their prowess:

  “I like D book, he’s in contention for three...”

• The panel discusses the balance between seasoned veterans like Steph Curry and emerging talents, ultimately agreeing on a dynamic and competitive top tier.

3. Additional Sports Insights

a. Minnesota Vikings’ Future Prospects

Beyond quarterback discussions, the panel touches on the Vikings' overall team prospects and potential for success in the upcoming season.

• McIntyre is optimistic about the Vikings’ chances:

  “They’re going to be the team that I think has a sneaky run to, like, the NFC championship.”

• Cowherd counters with skepticism, highlighting the team’s challenges:

  “Jordan Love’s not going to get hurt again... Chicago’s going to be notably better.”

Notable Quotes

• Todd McShay [03:16]:

  “I can’t imagine Brian Daboll is kind of going all chips in on Shador Sanders...”

• Colin Cowherd [22:27]:

  “He’s not the face of the league. That’s the only thing I’ve ever pushed back.”

• Jason McIntyre [27:37]:

  “There’s nobody that could convince me that he’s a better runner than Michael Vick was at Virginia Tech.”

Conclusion

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, the panel—headed by Colin and featuring Todd McShay, Jason McIntyre, and guest Charlamagne Tha God—delves deep into the nuances of the upcoming NFL Draft, with a particular focus on quarterback and running back prospects. Additionally, the discussion extends to the NBA, debating the MVP candidacy of Jayson Tatum and ranking the league's top American players. The blend of expert insights, spirited debates, and thoughtful analysis provides listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the current sports landscape.

For those who missed the episode, this summary encapsulates the key discussions and expert opinions shared, offering a valuable resource to stay informed on the latest in NFL and NBA developments.