Podcast Summary: The Herd with Colin Cowherd Episode: Hour 3 - Tom Pelissero
Release Date: June 5, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host Colin Cowherd engages in an in-depth discussion with NFL Network's Tom Pelissero. They delve into pressing NFL quarterback scenarios, injury updates, and broader team dynamics within the league. The conversation offers listeners expert insights into the current state of NFL teams and player performances.

NFL Quarterback Analysis

Shador Sanders' Performance and Prospects

At [02:42], Colin brings up concerns regarding Shador Sanders' lack of first-team reps despite being a fifth-round pick. Highlighting the rarity of fifth-rounders getting significant playing time, especially in their rookie seasons, Colin questions the Colts' confidence in Sanders.

Tom Pelissero responds at [03:09], emphasizing that "Shador Sanders, a fifth-round pick, shouldn't be expected to garner first-team reps in his debut." He draws comparisons to other late-round picks like Sam Howell, noting that while some have succeeded over time, Sanders' current position is still precarious. Pelissero explains, "The Browns have drafted higher-rated quarterbacks and have existing players like Dylan Gabriel and Joe Flacco, making it logical to prioritize them over Sanders."

Anthony Richardson's Shoulder Injury

The discussion shifts to Anthony Richardson's shoulder issue at [05:52]. Colin mentions that Shane Steichen revealed Richardson is dealing with a shoulder injury, raising concerns given Richardson's injury history.

At [05:52], Pelissero clarifies, "This isn't a huge blinking red light type of warning. He's been advised to rest his shoulder, and he's expected to be ready by training camp." However, he notes the emergence of Daniel Jones as a potential starter complicates Richardson's position. Pelissero asserts, "Daniel Jones has the opportunity to influence his standing in training camp."

CJ Stroud's Shoulder Soreness

Colin also inquires about CJ Stroud's shoulder soreness at [08:49]. Pelissero provides a nuanced view at [09:04], stating, "Reports suggest it's a peck or general body soreness—not serious enough to warrant immediate concern." He advises monitoring Stroud's condition as training camp approaches, emphasizing the importance of availability over minor injuries.

Minnesota Vikings' JJ McCarthy Recovery

The conversation transitions to the Minnesota Vikings' quarterback, JJ McCarthy, at [10:19]. Colin seeks an update on McCarthy's recovery from surgeries and his progress in throwing NFL passes.

Pelissero responds at [10:19], noting McCarthy's physical improvements and increased weight as positive signs. He says, "He's full go in terms of football activities through the spring, with no contact during this period." Pelissero highlights the support from teammates like Justin Jefferson and the front office's belief in McCarthy, concluding, "If JJ McCarthy can elevate his game once live plays resume, he could be a significant asset for the Vikings."

NFC North Quarterback Rankings

At [11:49], Colin asks Pelissero to rank the quarterbacks in the NFC North as the season approaches. Pelissero provides a comprehensive analysis:

• Jordan Love (Packers): Despite battling injuries, Love has shown promising growth. Pelissero states, "The Jordan Love we saw down the stretch in 2023 is a really, really good quarterback."

• Jared Goff (Lions): With Super Bowl experience, Goff remains a reliable option.

• JJ McCarthy (Vikings): Still an unknown with limited regular-season experience.

• Caleb Williams (Bears): Although showing improvement, Williams remains in the "unknown bucket" due to inconsistent performance.

Pelissero concludes at [14:04], "Jordan Love has the highest trajectory within the division, but with multiple young quarterbacks still developing, rankings could shift by September."

News Segment

Colts Quarterback Situation

During the news segment at [17:46], Alex Curry discusses the ongoing situation with the Colts' quarterback Anthony Richardson. Reports indicate that Richardson is experiencing soreness post-surgery, with no immediate timeline for his return. The conversation touches on the implications of Richardson's injury on the Colts' quarterback hierarchy, including the presence of Daniel Jones as a contender for the starting position.

Colin and Alex engage in a spirited exchange about Richardson's future with the team, reflecting on his injury-prone career and the challenges he faces in securing a stable starting role.

NBA Discussions: Draymond Green's Take and Player Comparisons

The discussion briefly shifts to the NBA, where Draymond Green's perspectives on winning and losing championships are debated. Alex Curry expresses disagreement with Green's mentality, advocating for resilience and the drive to improve after losses.

Additionally, Colin and Alex engage in a playful segment titled "Kevin or Kev Out," where they debate the merits of various NBA players, ultimately favoring LeBron James and other dependable stars over injury-prone or inconsistent players.

Final Segment: Kevin or Kev Out

In the final portion of the episode, Colin and Alex participate in the "Kevin or Kev Out" segment, posing hypothetical scenarios to choose between different NBA players. Highlights include:

• Kevin Durant vs. Carl Anthony Towns: Colin prefers Durant due to his experience and impact on the game.

• Steph Curry vs. Kevin Durant: Both agree on Curry's exceptional skills and leadership.

• LeBron James vs. Kevin Durant: Both hosts ultimately favor LeBron James, citing his unparalleled performance and leadership qualities.

This segment showcases the hosts' enthusiasm and deep knowledge of NBA talent, providing listeners with entertaining insights into player evaluations.

Conclusion

Throughout the episode, Colin Cowherd and Tom Pelissero offer a blend of analytical insights and engaging discussions on NFL quarterback dynamics, player injuries, and team strategies. The episode concludes with lighthearted NBA debates, ensuring a well-rounded and informative listening experience for fans of both football and basketball.

Notable Quotes:

• Tom Pelissero on Shador Sanders:
  "The Browns have drafted higher-rated quarterbacks and have existing players like Dylan Gabriel and Joe Flacco, making it logical to prioritize them over Sanders."
  [03:09]

• Tom Pelissero on Anthony Richardson's Injury:
  "Daniel Jones has the opportunity to influence his standing in training camp."
  [07:04]

• Tom Pelissero on JJ McCarthy:
  "If JJ McCarthy can elevate his game once live plays resume, he could be a significant asset for the Vikings."
  [10:19]

• Colin Cowherd on Championship Losses:
  "Losing in the championship is so painful. You lose in the first round, it's like, who cares?"
  [22:28]

• Colin Cowherd on LeBron James:
  "He's the greatest player in NBA history. I've been saying that since he brought the title to the Lakers."
  [37:58]

This summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from The Herd with Colin Cowherd featuring Tom Pelissero, providing listeners with a comprehensive overview of the episode's main topics.