HR 1 - To pay Brock Purdy or not to pay, Lions don't rest starters

Summary

Podcast Summary: "HR 1 - To pay Brock Purdy or not to pay, Lions don't rest starters" The Herd with Colin Cowherd Release Date: December 31, 2024

---

Introduction

In the season finale of 2024, Colin Cowherd and co-host Doug Gottlieb delve into pivotal NFL topics, focusing primarily on quarterback compensation and the Detroit Lions' remarkable yet tumultuous season. The episode blends in-depth analysis with candid opinions, offering listeners a comprehensive look at some of the league's most pressing issues.

---

Brock Purdy: To Pay or Not to Pay

Timestamp: [04:26] Colin Cowherd

A significant portion of the discussion centers around the Las Vegas Raiders' quarterback, Brock Purdy. With one year remaining on his rookie contract, the debate intensifies: Should teams invest in Purdy early, or is his performance not warranting such commitment?

Key Points:

• Performance Analysis: Despite Purdy's impressive first-half performances under the guidance of renowned play designer Kyle Shanahan, his second-half struggles raise concerns. Purdy has recorded eight touchdowns and ten interceptions, leading to a passer rating below 75 in non-scripted game scenarios.

  "Brock Purdy has eight touchdowns and ten picks and 12 total giveaways. He's bad and trailing in the second half, he's worse." — Colin Cowherd [04:26]

• Comparison with Peers: When compared to quarterbacks like Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, Jared Goff, and Baker Mayfield, Purdy lags, especially in critical second-half performances.

  "There's a feeling that now even though he has a year left on his rookie deal, that you have to pay Brock Purdy now." — Colin Cowherd [04:26]

• Team Dynamics: The Lions' offensive prowess, bolstered by top-tier players like George Kittle and Deebo Samuel, highlights how Purdy's performance can significantly impact team success. However, his propensity for "empty calories"—easy yards after catch without significant strategic value—casts doubt on his long-term viability.

  "A big majority for all these people saying I have to pay Brock Purdy a year early, if at all. A big chunk of his yards are after the catch because Kittle is great after the catch and Debo is great after the catch." — Colin Cowherd [14:23]

---

Detroit Lions: Offensive Juggernaut with Defensive Vulnerabilities

Timestamp: [14:23] Doug Gottlieb

The Detroit Lions emerge as a central topic, celebrated for their unprecedented offensive achievements yet criticized for their defensive shortcomings.

Key Points:

• Historic Offensive Stats: The Lions have secured their fifth game with at least 40 points and no turnovers, a record surpassing even legendary teams like the "Greatest Show on Turf." Additionally, they are the first NFL team to have two running backs and two wide receivers each gain over 1,000 scrimmage yards.

  "Lions are the first team in NFL history to have two running backs and two wide receivers gain 1,000 scrimmage yards." — Colin Cowherd [25:41]

• Offensive Talent: With elite players such as Amon-Ra St. Brown, Puka Nacua, and a robust running back duo, the Lions' offense is unparalleled. The Centers, LaPorta and St. Brown, are top-ranked, contributing to their offensive dominance.

  "They have Amaran St. Brown and Puka Nakua are the best receivers not taken in the first couple rounds in the last decade." — Doug Gottlieb [27:21]

• Defensive Issues: Despite offensive brilliance, the team's defense is plagued by injuries, with eight starters missing in crucial games. This imbalance raises concerns about their ability to sustain success, especially in high-stakes playoff scenarios.

  "They're at home and the Lions are missing eight defensive starters." — Colin Cowherd [04:26]

• Coaching and Discipline: The hosts debate the role of coaching in maintaining team discipline. While Colin praises coaches like Dan Campbell for their motivational skills, Doug suggests that the team needs firmer discipline to harness its offensive strengths effectively.

  "The problem is their offense is so proficient they go down the field and score in like three minutes." — Doug Gottlieb [26:56]

---

MVP Contention: Sam Darnold vs. Josh Allen

Timestamp: [29:30] Doug Gottlieb

The conversation shifts to the MVP race, highlighting Sam Darnold's impressive statistics and debating his candidacy against established stars like Josh Allen.

Key Points:

• Sam Darnold's Performance: Darnold stands out with 14 games boasting a 100 passer rating, the first since Aaron Rodgers in 2020. His consistency and statistical prowess make a strong case for MVP consideration.

  "Sam Darnold is the only QB to finish with 14 games with a 100 passer rating, the first since Aaron Rodgers in 2020." — Doug Gottlieb [29:30]

• Josh Allen's Case: Despite similar statistics, Allen has yet to secure an MVP title. His leadership in Buffalo's top-tier offense and consistent performance make him a favorite among fans, though voters have yet to recognize his contributions officially.

  "Josh Allen has never won an MVP, has he?" — Colin Cowherd [30:42]

• Voter Perspectives: The hosts explore the disconnect between statistical leaders and MVP recognition, suggesting that the "eye test"—how impressive a player's performance appears on the field—plays a significant role in voting decisions.

  "The eye test says pretty to me. Is Josh Allen. Yes, I agree." — Doug Gottlieb [30:28]

---

Coaching and Front Office Structure in the NFL

Timestamp: [32:24] Doug Gottlieb

The discussion broadens to examine the evolving roles of coaches and front office personnel, using Bill Belichick as a focal point.

Key Points:

• Bill Belichick's Philosophy: Belichick emphasizes minimizing external influences in decision-making, advocating for a more centralized coaching approach reminiscent of coaching legends like Tom Landry.

  "Although I don't disagree with his premise, I would argue New England needed more cooks in the kitchen." — Colin Cowherd [34:40]

• Impact on Team Performance: The hosts debate whether Belichick's reduced involvement in personnel decisions has contributed to the current struggles of the New England Patriots, particularly in roster construction and draft choices.

  "But I think the truth is, and I understand the parcels, I have to make the dinner, I want to select some food." — Colin Cowherd [34:40]

• Modern NFL Dynamics: The shift towards analytics and specialized roles in front offices is discussed, contrasting "culture guys" who focus on team morale and motivation with "scheme guys" who concentrate on strategy and play-calling.

  "Culture guys, motivational guys. Dan Campbell, Vrabel, Pete Carroll, McVeigh. They may not win a trophy. Scheme guys bomb all the time if they don't have the right personnel." — Colin Cowherd [48:18]

---

LeBron James' Enduring Legacy in Basketball

Timestamp: [35:05] Colin Cowherd

While primarily focused on football, the episode also pays homage to basketball icon LeBron James on his 40th birthday, drawing parallels between his longevity and that of NFL quarterbacks like Tom Brady.

Key Points:

• LeBron's Performance: Despite approaching four decades, LeBron continues to excel, averaging 24 points, 8 rebounds, and 9 assists per game. His adaptability and high basketball IQ sustain his status as one of the league's premier players.

  "He's aged incredibly well. You know, it's very funny because the Internet is very loud and usually often very wrong." — Colin Cowherd [35:14]

• Comparative Analysis: The hosts compare LeBron's sustained excellence with that of NFL veterans, emphasizing the importance of skill development and physical conditioning in extending athletic careers.

  "He's the greatest enduring basketball player of my life." — Colin Cowherd [36:57]

---

Conclusion

As the year wraps up, Colin Cowherd and Doug Gottlieb offer a nuanced examination of key NFL narratives, from quarterback contracts to team dynamics and coaching philosophies. Their insights provide listeners with a deeper understanding of the factors shaping the league's current landscape, setting the stage for an exciting new year of sports action.

Notable Quotes:

• "There's a difference between guys who are literally tractors, you know, like they're pulling a franchise to wins, and guys that are trailers, they're mostly being pulled." — Colin Cowherd [14:23]
• "Culture guys squeeze the juice out of every player." — Colin Cowherd [28:18]
• "The idea that game didn't mean anything for Detroit, I completely push back on that." — Colin Cowherd [44:05]

---

Disclaimer: This summary encapsulates the main discussions and viewpoints presented in the podcast episode. For a more comprehensive understanding and additional context, listening to the full episode is recommended.

Transcript

[Colin Cowherd]

This is Doug Gottlieb from All Ball with Doug Gottlieb. Listen, I'm gonna get serious for a minute.

[Doug Gottlieb]

The hate in our country is getting out of control. In fact, it's sadly at an all time high.

[Colin Cowherd]

But it's gonna take all of us to stop it. I mean, we're all on the same team in this country. So let's take a break from our.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Hate so our team can regroup. We need to take a timeout against hate.

[Colin Cowherd]

Visit stand uptoallhate.org to help and join me in calling for timeout against hate by following at what's up with Hate or posting the Blue Square emoji. I'm Colin Coward from the Herd. Are you a small business owner launching a company or dreaming of starting one? Then be sure to catch up on seasons one and two of Mind the Business small business success stories from Ruby studio and Inuit QuickBooks. And stick around for season three. Launching Thursday, January 9th. Hosts Austin Henkwitz and Jenice Torres talk to small business owners about how they've grown and maintained their business. You don't want to miss these inspiring stories of small business journeys. Listen to Mind the Business small business success Stories on the iHeart app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. As we gather together during this holiday season, let me share a gift that keeps on giving. Chase Freedom With Chase Freedom Unlimited, you'll not only experience the joy of 1.5% unlimited cash back, but also the freedom to create cherished memories with your loved ones. Discover the magic and learn more@chasefreedom. And let this season be filled with love, laughter and the delight of extra cash in your pocket cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank NA member FDIC I'm partnering with PayPal. The holiday season is here and I'm going to save big with cash back offers in the PayPal app. It's easy. I browse deals from my favorite brands, save offers in the app and use PayPal checkout online. Really, really easy. Whether I'm buying gifts for my family or treating myself to something nice, I'm ear cash back and you can too. Don't just pay PayPal check offers in the app for details and exclusions. Cash back earned is points redeemable. For cash and other options, see PayPal rewards terms. It's the most wonderful time of the year for getting in on all the hoops, football and hockey action at DraftKings Sportsbook. Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app. The code is heard H E R D new customers get $150 in bonus bets if your bet wins when you bet just five bucks. Happy holidays from DraftKings. The crown is yours. Gambling problem. Call 1-800-Gambler in New York, call 877-8-Hopeny or text hopeny 467-369 in Connecticut. Help is available for problem gambling. Call 888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org Please play.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Responsibly on behalf of Boot Hill Casino.

[Colin Cowherd]

And Resort in Kansas.

[Doug Gottlieb]

21 plus.

[Colin Cowherd]

Age and eligibility varies by jurisdiction. Void in Ontario. Bet must win to receive reward. Bonus bets expire 168 hours after ISS.

[Doug Gottlieb]

And responsible gaming resources see DKNG Co.

[Colin Cowherd]

BBall thanks for listening to the Herd podcast. Be sure to catch us live every weekday on Fox Sports radio at noon to 3 Eastern, 9am to noon Pacific. Find your local station for the [e-mail] or stream us live every day on the iHeartRadio app by searching Fox Sports Radio or FSR. Thanks for listening to the Herd Podcast. Here we go on a loaded Tuesday in Los Angeles. Angeles. Urban Meyer talking about the Penn State game tonight, Ohio State, Oregon tomorrow, Nick Wright in one hour. Our herd hierarchy. Probably our final top 10 of the regular season next week. You know you're playing a bunch of backups live in Los Angeles. It's the Herd, wherever you may be, however you may be listening. Thanks for making us part of your day. Our last show of 2024 as we embark on a new year, New Year's resolutions. I have one a year. I keep it to myself. It's usually a personal thing. I don't know if I can improve, so I'm not sure what I have this year. J. Mac, anything out there you're going to blurt out about getting better?

[Doug Gottlieb]

Well, I don't need to get better since I'm great already.

[Colin Cowherd]

Yeah, yeah.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Started today playing basketball this morning. I may go to Vegas tonight. Just got an invite from some friends. Listen, let's get the new year started right. Right.

[Colin Cowherd]

Start the night in Vegas. Start the year in Vegas. So I want to start. I'll get to the Detroit Lions. I'll get to them in about five, 10 minutes. I want to talk about Brock Purdy because there's this feeling that now even though he has a year left on his rookie deal, that you have to pay Brock Purdy now. Oh, you got to get a discount now on this guy. And I was about two weeks ago, I'm watching all these drone videos on TikTok all these guys in New Jersey. And it's clear that men struggle telling the difference between drones and small planes and aliens. It's also clear men have a problem deciphering the difference from like Joe Burrow, who gets whatever he wants with a bad roster, and Brock Purdy, who's really good in the first half with one of the great play designers in NFL history, Kyle Shanahan. I always get left with a feeling it's a lot of empty calories and empty yards. It's one thing if you're burrow and your O line's bad and we don't love your coach and you're always playing from behind. Brock Purdy has after Andy Reid and maybe Sean Payton, the best play designer. Forget play caller. Best play designer since, you know, maybe his dad, Mike Shanahan. So. And you have the best tight end arguably in football and two good receivers and you're at home. And the Lions are missing eight defensive starters. But this league is about second halves. The first half is on script. Yes, he's great, often on script. But when Bo Nix and Justin Herbert met like a week ago, remember that game about 10 days ago, 14 days ago, Bo Nix was really good on script in the first half. Justin Herbert was great off script because Justin Herbert's a lot better right now than Bo Nixon. And in the second half this year, the more important half, brock Purdy has eight touchdowns and 10 picks and 12 total giveaways. He's bad and trailing in the second half, he's worse. He has a passer rating below 75. You know, in the non scripted half with one of the great play designers of my life, you want to know. It's not random, by the way. You want to know the top five quarterbacks right now? Second half passer rating. Oh, what a shock. Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, Jared Goff and number one pick, Baker Mayfield. More talented guys. There's a connection between the two. Just a big majority. For all these people saying I have to pay Brock Purdy a year early, if at all. A big chunk of his yards are after the catch because Kittle is great after the catch and Debo is great after the catch. And the other part is how open everybody is. I swear to God. Has George Kittle ever been covered on any catch in the last month? He's wide open. So to me, it's always, always empty calories with Brock Purdy. You got to watch the games in the second half. In a tight game, two ugly picks threw behind Juwan Jennings on a big third down. Yes, they missed field goals of 51 and 58 yards. Why did they have to kick field goals of 51 and 58 yards? Because he missed to Juwan Jennings. Or. Or he doesn't quite have the athletic ability that his backup, Josh Dobbs had to run into the end zone. I mean, every time he throws a ball over the middle, you're holding your breath. You're not with Mahomes or Herbert. I don't feel that way with Josh Allen. I do with Brock Purdy. I don't feel that way with Jared Goff. So this idea that he's a 50 million dollar quarterback. Jimmy Garoppolo won 69% of his games in San Francisco and people Niner fans couldn't get him out of town fast enough. Maybe they were jealous because he was so handsome. He won 69% of his games. He got to Super Bowls. They couldn't get him out of town fast enough. They blamed him for losing to Mahomes in the super bowl because he missed one deep route. Purdy's win in 64% of his games, it seems to me. And by the way, he's also hurt again. And he's been hurt multiple times because he's a smaller athlete. I thought it was interesting when Josh Dobbs came in, who's just a remarkable kid. I think he was like a chemical engineer at Tennessee. You can give him a playbook, he can memorize it in 15 minutes. But he ran for a touchdown because he's a super athletic kid. I don't think Brock Purdy could have run for a touchdown. Dobbs a faster, more elegant athlete. So the idea that I've got to pay him 50 million and pay him early, there is a difference. Sorry guys, but there is a difference between aliens and a small plane flying over your house or maybe your neighbor's drone. And there's a difference between guys who are literally tractors, you know, like they're pulling a franchise to wins, and guys that are trailers, they're mostly being pulled. Second half, game on the line, playing with a lead, two really ugly picks when he had to throw it over the middle. And again, here's Kyle Shanan after on his injury. I know everyone when they hear about Brock's elbow and stuff, just like me. You think of elbow injury from a couple years ago, but you know, just talking to doctors, he just got hit in the right spot. And when you get hit there, you're just. Your nerves go and you can't feel much, but hopefully it'll be all right. And let's again. I'm going to get to the Detroit Lions after the break. Herd hierarchy, top of the hour. Nick Wright, Urban Meyer. So let's talk about this whole thing about what you pay a quarterback. Because we've seen with Dak, if you pay A plus money to a B to a B plus quarterback, you can't have a legitimate roster. I mean, look at the Cowboys compared to the Eagles. How many guys would even start for the Cowboys on the Eagles? Right? Because you've been paying Dak, overpaying him for years and years and years. And so this stuff, this is a big topic. This stuff's really important. You can overpay a wide receiver, you know, you pay him 20, he's worth 15. You start overpaying a quarterback 58 and he's worth 33. One of the reasons Tampa so good is because they're getting a deal on Baker Mayfield. They're paying him 33 million. I take Baker over Brock Purdy in a second. 33 million. They're getting a deal. It's okay for teams to occasionally get deals on quarterbacks, too. Not everybody has to be overpaid. But a team that is underpaid, Tampa, with Baker, they've got a stacked roster. They got good dudes everywhere. D line, wide receiver, tight end, two good running backs. Dallas overpays their quarterback and they're stuck. So to me, there are three groups, three clubs for quarterbacks in terms of $50 million. Plus, the first club is. I'm going to pay you what I got to pay you. Mahomes, Lamar, Josh, Allen, Herbert, Stafford, Burrow, Goff, Love, you're great. I think you can get to a Super Bowl. I'm going to pay you what I'm going to pay you. And I think a lot of your success is based on you and you being great. Then there's the 50 million dollar club. We can negotiate. I'm not offended if you ask for it, but I'm going to push back a little. Jalen hurts. Sam Darnold. Baker and Jaden Daniels. Jaden, I want a little more time. Baker and Sam, let's be honest, it's the perfect season. Jalen hurts. Feels very circumstantial. Best O line, Unbelievable receivers. You know, mvp. Mvp. When he had Shane Steichen. I like him. These guys can ask for 50 million. I'm not offended. We can negotiate. And then there's the third club, which is if you ask for it, I'm hanging up the phone. Brock Purdy's in that one. Okay. It's nothing personal but we're not getting to 50 and getting to 50 a year early. What's the market? Go to the market. So you know, it's like negotiating for a new car. You can tell me that Civic is worth a hundred grand. Well we got, we got Russ proofing a sunroof and the salesman can tell me how about the sports package? Okay, I'll give you 51,000, not 100,000. I'm walking out of the dealership. If you think that Civic is worth $100,000 and it's not, nobody's picking on Brock Purdy. That's another thing. Oh this and that. When you get to a quarterback because they're paid so much now, I mean like Mahomes signed a $450 million deal. You can make mistakes over paying a little bit for a mike linebacker or overpaying for, you know, a tight end a little. You're paying him 13, he's probably 8. You start overpaying a quarterback, you get to the 50. 60 million dollar club not interested that it got your. There's only one thing that guarantees you can't win Super Bowls. Only one thing paying a B quarterback A plus money. Even Tom Brave, Drew Brees in his prime took big money for a couple years. Sean Payton and Drew Brees had two back to back mediocre years, restructured his deal, better deal, they end up in a Super Bowl. Tom Brady was never the highest paid quarterback, Kirk Cousins was and Kirk Cousins because of that didn't have the surrounding elements. So I'm just, I keep watching this thing and I'm going to keep going back. I feel with Brock Purdy and certain quarterbacks there's a lot of ifs, ands and buts. If this is healthy, if I have Christian, if I have a great play designer, if it's not wet, if I lead, if it's the first half, I can't pay that kind of money. I can't just won't do it so and I'm not, I'm not like old guy yelling at clowns here. I'm, I'll pay it. There's like eight guys in the, in the world. I'll pay whatever I got to pay you. Then there's another half a dozen guys are close to it where we can negotiate but paying them 50 large and having to pay them early, I'm not doing it. J Mac, I know he's your guy. I know you worship at the altar of the Brockster boy after the positive.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Monday you had coming off the top rope on Brock Purdy to start New Year's Eve. Colin, come on, man.

[Colin Cowherd]

Hey. The rest of the show is flowers, rainbows, just making sure and birds chirping. But I have to address that. It's a serious topic. We all watch the NFL. It's got the highest ratings by a mile and it's all centered around one position. But it's not just centered around the position, it's centered around what you pay the position.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Yeah, he had two bad throws last night on an otherwise extraordinary night. No Christian McCaffrey. No Brandon.

[Colin Cowherd]

IU alliance had no eight defensive starters. I just.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Yeah, I would move off some of those defensive starters who can't plug a hole to save their life. Jir Gibbs running wild.

[Colin Cowherd]

How about.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Listen, you got to give Dan Campbell some credit, okay? Everybody wanted him to sit as guys. The game means nothing. He plays everybody.

[Colin Cowherd]

Are people crazy? The game means nothing. First of all, this is the Detroit. I'm going to get into this. The idea that game didn't mean anything for Detroit, I completely push back on that. I'll talk about that coming up. Be sure to catch live editions of the Herd, weekdays at noon Eastern, 9am Pacific, on FO Sports Radio, FS1, and the iHeartRadio app. Hey, it's Steve Covino and I'm Rich Davis, and together we're Covino and Rich on Fox Sports Radio. You can catch us weekdays from 5 to 7pm Eastern, 2 to 4 Pacific, on Fox Sports Radio. And of course, the iHeartRadio app. Why should you listen to Covino and Rich? We talk about everything, life, sports, relationships, what's going on in the world. We have a lot of fun talking about the stories behind the stories in the world of sports and pop culture, stories that, well, other shows don't seem to have the time to discuss. And the fact that we've been friends for the last 20 years and still work together, I mean, that says something, right? So check us out. We like to get you involved, too. Take your phone calls, chop it up, as they say. I'd say the most interactive show on Fox Sports Radio, maybe the most interactive show on planet Earth. Be sure to check out Covino and Rich live on Fox Sports radio and the iHeartradio app from 5 to 7pm Eastern, 2 to 4 Pacific. And if you miss any of the live show, just search Covino and Rich wherever you get your podcast. And of course, on social media, that's Covino and Rich from the Delta Sky Club. Welcome back, Ms. Klein, to the JetBridge Delta Air Lines relies on 5G solutions from T Mobile for business to power operations and serve customers faster. Together, we're putting 5G into the hands of ground staff so they can better assist on the go travelers with real time information throughout the airport. This is elevating customer experience. This is Delta Air Lines with T Mobile for Business. Take your business further@t mobile.com now. This podcast is sponsored by PayPal. We partnered with them to make this holiday season even better. With all the shopping, gifting and holiday prep, my PayPal debit card is my go to for getting more out of my purchases. Here's how it works. I choose my monthly category Gas, restaurants, apparel, groceries, health and beauty or just for the holiday season tech. And I earn 5% cash back on up to a thousand bucks in the purchases in those categories. Yeah, 5% cash back this month I'm gonna go with tech. It's my category. It's a no brainer, right? Everybody loves the latest tech gifts, so whether it's stuff for the fam or adding new gadgets to my personal collection, that cash back adds up fast. So this holiday season, let the PayPal debit card do the heavy lifting. Sign up for the card when you download the PayPal app, then pay in store and online and get cash back with a PayPal debit card. Don't just pay PayPal terms and limits apply. See paypal.com rewardspal the PayPal Debit MasterCard is issued by the Bancor Bank N.A. pursuant to a license by MasterCard International, Inc. And may be used everywhere MasterCard is accepted. What makes the holiday special are the details from Genesis. And every little detail in a Genesis is another gift to you. Like during winter, you'll be thankful for the available heated steering wheel and the available snow mode to help get you through the snowiest of snow days. And the available all wheel drive is helpful all year round, but especially during the winter. I mean, Genesis has put a lot of thought into the details. And of course the best gifts are thoughtful ones like the available Nappa leather seating. Oh, speaking of gifts, you'll have plenty of room to haul around everything you've picked up for family and friends, no matter which Genesis you're driving. And with a lineup featuring SUVs, EVs, Sedans, something for everybody, experience the Genesis Signature event. And as one big final gift, Genesis is offering you a $1,000 bonus on select Genesis vehicles. The deal ends January 2nd. See participating Genesis retailers for details. Visit genesis.com to see how Genesis can make your holidays even brighter. Details make the Holidays. Hey, y'all know the Aflac commercials, right? With the famous duck and the coaches. Great commercials. But did you know that Aflac is a leader in supplemental insurance? That's what the duck is quacking about, helping cover gaps. So, like, this is how I think of Aflac. Let's say you have an all pro linebacker. Anytime there's a gap in the defensive line, you know he's going to fill it, no problem, because he's an all pro. Aflac does the same thing. If there's a gap in your health insurance, Aflac wants to better protect you by helping close the gap. You're sick, you're injured. Aflac can pay cash to help fill the gaps your health insurance can leave behind. You can use the cash, put it towards whatever you need. Rent, mortgage payments, medical bills. It's completely up to you. Look, life can be tough. Fortunately, Aflac is tougher. I mean, we're talking middle linebacker, tough. To learn more about how Aflac can help fill the gaps health insurance can leave behind, visit aflac.com I'm not a weatherman, but I'll give you my forecast. Snow and ice are coming, and they're gonna make driving a challenge. Thankfully, the experts at Tire Rack know a thing or two about conquering winter's worst. Rain, sleet, slush, whatever winter means to you. Tire Rack has tires that elevate traction and braking and keep you and your family safe all season. Tires, all weather tires. And if you live where it snows a lot, dedicated winter tires. Just go to tirerack.com easy to use shopping tools will guide you to a personalized recommendation. The right tires for how, what, and where you drive. Choose from a full line of Kumo tires, shipped fast and free and backed by two years of free road hazard protection. Go to TireRack.com Colin to see their Kumo test results and special offers. Tire Rack has thousands of recommended installers and offers the convenience of mobile tire installation. I love that. Great tires, great deals, and great people. What more could you ask for? That's tirerack.com Colin the way tire buying should be. All right, welcome back. So there was this sense last night that, you know, San Francisco, they got nothing to play for, but either does Detroit. And my takeaway is. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. Detroit had all sorts of motivation last night. They were the only undefeated team on the road all year. They could go eight. No on the road. They're the Detroit Lions, for God's sakes. Why would they ever mail one in. And the other thing is, they play Minnesota next week, that's red hot. Why would you want to be playing coming off a loss? It was money, Night football, big stage. Your secondary's got guys who are backups to backups. There was wide open 49ers the entire game. Those guys need reps. They look lost on some of their coverages. So, I mean, this idea that they didn't have anything to play for, I thought last night's win was a huge win for Detroit. So, I mean, you got to be honest about Detroit, too. They have been kind of the team everybody's America's pulling for, right? And they've been the most talked about team arguably in the league this year because of Dan Campbell. The story, the culture. They're going to lose both their coordinators. Ben Johnson and Aaron Glenn, rock stars. This could be the year. Go ask Philadelphia. Nick Sariani, with that roster, what happens when you hire the wrong coordinators? You almost never get brilliant coordinators. Both of them. I mean, look at San Francisco since they've lost D'Ameco. Ryan's defense isn't the same and they've hired guys with Nice resumes, but D'Ameco was better than both. 5% of this country is great at what they do. Doctors, pilots, defensive coordinators, offensive coordinators. Truly great. How many great quarterbacks do we have? Six. Five. 32 teams. Each one's got two. Maybe some have three. Five. And how many great coaches? Five. So they're going to lose their coordinators. And if they lose to Minnesota next week, who, by the way, is red hot. So again, I love them coming from behind and winning a game on the road, growing confidence, especially with backups playing on defense that need the reps. If they lose to Minnesota, this team that we've talked about all year and was the best team in football in September and October and early November, they could go to Tampa for a playoff game if they lose next weekend. Tampa, red hot. Baker Mayfield and Mike Evans. Who that lion secondary can't cover? Or the healthiest team in the league, the Rams, who, by the way, almost beat the Lions early in the year. It was like week one. And at that time, Detroit's defense had all its starters. Now it's got about four of them, five of them. So the idea that it didn't mean much last night. That secondary is going to face Justin Jefferson and either Mike Evans or Puka Nukua. They needed reps. Ricky Pearsall is not in that class and he was open a lot George Kittle was open a lot. You needed to play your dudes. You need to win that football game. Windows close very quickly in the NFL. Niners window was open for about four years. Look at their roster. You take out Christian McCaffrey, that offense is not the same offense. You take out Bosa from the defensive line, that's not the same defense. Here's Dan Campbell. After I thought about it leading up to the game, I thought about it last night. I told the staff, but I ended up settling on. The right thing to do was play these guys and, and because we owed it to the team. And it's not fair to ask guys to play that haven't been prepared to play, you know, so, so, yeah, that was tough. And I think the biggest thing is there were things we wanted to do better than we did last week. And we did. Yeah, come from behind. Monday night win against The San Francisco 49ers and Kyle Shanahan. Just ask yourself, as a Lions fan, weren't you angry at half and weren't you really happy after the game? So if it meant that to you as a fan, what do you think it meant to the players? You, you were banging your head against the wall at your house or condo or apartment in the first half because the game meant something to you. Even though. Yeah, I mean, it didn't mean anything. And yet in the second half, how happy were you? Well, what if you're a coach or a player? Motivation matters. Momentum inertia matters. I thought it was a great win for Detroit. J. Mac with the news. No, no, no. Turn on the news. This is the Herd line news.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Let's continue with the Detroit Lions. Colin, Unbelievable. They had their fifth game with at least 40 points and no turnovers, which is the most in NFL history. We're talking like better than the greatest show on turf and stuff like that. Colin Lions are the first team in NFL history to have two running backs and two wide receivers gain 1, 000 scrimmage yards. We're talking historic stuff here from the Lions. I mean, Ben Johnson calling up hook and ladder, third and 12 plays that result in touchdowns.

[Colin Cowherd]

I mean, Jameson Williams, they rarely, they rarely use Williams, the fastest receiver in the NFL. He's almost a gadget player for them. He would be a primary for every other team. But they have armor on st. Brown and LaPorta and running backs. They're getting Montgomery back, the running back, hopefully. Yeah, yeah, he, I, I think that because the defense has been weakened, the run game has to be empowered because what you want to do. If you're Detroit, you want to shrink games now, your defense is a liability. It's the same with Baltimore. I don't trust their defense. I don't trust. So what happens if you can eat the clock, shorten the game, run the ball. You give a team nine possessions, not 11. And when you get to the playoffs, I don't want to give Matt Stafford and Baker Mayfield and Jalen hurts extra possessions.

[Doug Gottlieb]

The problem is their offense is so proficient they go down the field and score in like three minutes. I mean, Colin, listen, you know, comparison is the thief of joy, they like to say. But I'm just, I'm just being an honest question question. Watching this juggernaut all season, this Detroit Lions offense or any offense Patrick Mahomes has had with the Chiefs, which is better because the number clearly Detroit.

[Colin Cowherd]

Yes.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Better than any offense Mahomes has ever had.

[Colin Cowherd]

Well, yes, this offense has more talent than any offense Patrick Mahomes has had.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Absolutely no offense that Lamar Jackson's ever had or Josh Allen has ever had.

[Colin Cowherd]

I agree.

[Doug Gottlieb]

I mean we're talking, this is like.

[Colin Cowherd]

Now we're talking personnel, no question.

[Doug Gottlieb]

We're talking everything, play calling, personnel and Jared Goff. Nobody thinks he's like a top five.

[Colin Cowherd]

Think about this. They have Amaran St. Brown and Puka Nakua are the best receivers not taken in the first couple rounds in the last decade, arguably. I mean literally. Puka is a star and Omaron St. Brown and I'm a Trojan fan, I never thought he would be this as a pro. They have two starting backs and they have two backs who are not only starters but like high end starters. They have an elite tight end, the best right tackle in football, maybe the best or second best, third best center in football. This is an all star team. This is a Pro Bowl. Now defensively, all sorts of issues this year but offensively it's an all time.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Personnel offense and it doesn't assume they beat the Vikings. I, they won't have to go outdoors for any playoff games.

[Colin Cowherd]

Right?

[Doug Gottlieb]

They'll be hosting everything at home. I, maybe we ruled them out of the super bowl mix too early. I, I don't know. Now, now that you said the defense is bad, the niners average like 7.9 yards.

[Colin Cowherd]

Yeah.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Brock Purdy for despite the interception up.

[Colin Cowherd]

And down the field, the Niners were induced into a couple of big mistakes. So you can say what you want about the Lions, but they did make two big interceptions, kicker missed two field.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Goals and two extra points. Draft pick of John lynch, an early that Was like Belichickian almost list. Do you like to blast Belichick? Next story, let's go to Lamar Jackson. He's having, I don't know if it's quietly a great year. Everybody's giving the MVP to Josh Allen. Sam Darnold's right there and talking about Sam Darnold, quarterback. He is the only QB to finish with 14 games with a 100 passer rating, the first since Aaron Rodgers in 2020. And wouldn't you know it, Aaron Rodgers in 2020 won the MVP. So there's, there is a, there's a small case for Darnold as the mvp. Lamar has a small case. I don't know. I don't know what to do with Sam Darnold. These numbers are staggering.

[Colin Cowherd]

Colin, I know what to do with him. Franchise tag him. That's what you do with him. You don't let him walk out the door again. The Vikings have been a very, very good team for a long time. Most of my life I go back to the 70s, 80s when it was like Tarkenton and they were getting to Super Bowls and losing with Bud Grant. But they don't have a ring. Don't mess around. You don't let great walk out the door. Is Sam Darnold as good as this year's numbers? Probably not. But he was never as bad as his numbers in Carolina and the Jets. So I, you know, I mean, when he was bombing, I kept saying, I don't. I used to say this all the time. Go watch a three minute YouTube clip of Sam Darnold. You'd think he's a poor man's Josh Allen. There's talent there. He's probably not as good as his numbers this year because Justin Jefferson isn't traveling with him and neither is Kevin O'Connell. Contextualize it. My thing is, I wouldn't give Darnold the mvp, but the fact that he wasn't being mentioned until now is kind of ridiculous. The numbers tell you he's absolutely in the top two or three class.

[Doug Gottlieb]

The problem is the last one is the eye test, okay? We can look at these numbers all day. Josh Donald has the most games with a 100 passer rating. He and Lamar are tied with 13. Passer rating is one metric. But the eye test says pretty to me. Is Josh Allen.

[Colin Cowherd]

Yes, I agree. And also, Josh Allen's never won an mvp, has he? Yeah, never has.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Well, that's where it becomes like, that's a little bit in the NBA. Hey, Joel, Embiid's never Won an mvp. Let's give it to him.

[Colin Cowherd]

Beat. Well, no, but at Buffalo, since Josh Allen entered the NFL, I think Buffalo has the number one offense. Isn't it kind of time? I mean, seriously, think about that. And he never had a run game to rely on until James Cook. I mean, and he didn't really have great tight end play until Kincaid. And he only briefly had Stefan Diggs. So, like, when Russell Wilson wasn't winning MVPs or getting votes, it was like, yeah, but there's a lot there behind him. Josh Allen has carried this offense for years. The fact that he hasn't won is a little bit of an indictment on the voters.

[Doug Gottlieb]

And so to your point, on the open market, you think if the Vikings say, sam, thank you for your service, we're gonna.

[Colin Cowherd]

We're gonna. He'll have an incredibly healthy market.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Give me the top two teams that are bidding on Sam.

[Colin Cowherd]

Raiders. Raiders are winning games. They don't have a top one or two pick. And they're not. Tom Telesco is not giving away the farm for these quarterbacks. These are not move up and give away seven picks for these quarterbacks.

[Doug Gottlieb]

So Raiders are coming in with Baker Mayfield offer.

[Colin Cowherd]

I think they'll offer Baker and Sam.

[Doug Gottlieb]

But that type money that that Baker Mayfield got from, you're not.

[Colin Cowherd]

You can't do that. Sam's going to get into bigger numbers. I have. I have been told that by an executive in the league that Sam has moved into a different category over the last three or four weeks.

[Doug Gottlieb]

And you, you feel okay about that?

[Colin Cowherd]

Well, I'm not hanging the phone up. We're going to have to negotiate. I may not get the number I like.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Pushover as a negotiator, I hear.

[Colin Cowherd]

I don't know that's for sure.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Final story now. This is really spicy, Colin. I never liked Bill Belichick as a Jets fan. Rooted against him for years. I'm starting to love this guy. Listen to what Bill Belichick says about the current structure in NFL front offices.

[Colin Cowherd]

He look back at great coaches like Tom Landry, who probably never would have had a chance to do what he did. In today's environment, there's a lot of cooks in the kitchen. You know, between the general manager, personnel directors, head coach, coaches, owners, owners, families and so forth. Sometimes from the outside, it's a little blurry as to who's really making the decision, whether owner has deferred it to somebody, whether he's making it him or herself or, you know, whether it's a committee or how all that works. Okay, okay, Wait, wait.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Let me. Before we go to. Who's he talking about? I'm just wondering, is any of this at all a veiled shot at the Patriots and what happened at the end, and who's being blamed for almost all the ills of New England?

[Colin Cowherd]

So let me say this. Although I don't disagree with his premise, I would argue New England needed more cooks in the kitchen, and that's why the roster is so damn awful, because Bill wouldn't let anybody else have real decision making. Go look at their last seven drafts, and don't tell me Nick Casario didn't know what he was doing, because the guy went to Houston. Nick Casserole went to Houston, and his first two drafts have been very strong. So in. I think Bill's premise is right, but the truth is, and I understand the parcels, I have to make the dinner, I want to select some food. But Parcells, like Jimmy Johnson and Sean Payton, is excellent with personnel. Bill Parcells was excellent with personnel. Sean Payton's good. McVeigh has an opinion, is very good. I don't think Kyle Shanahan's as good. I think Shanahan's a schemer and a play designer. I don't think he's the great culture guy and the personnel guy. Jimmy Johnson's legendary for personnel knowledge. Belichick's not good at it. Everybody's got a hole in life. That's not Bill's thing, and he took it over. So I would argue Bill needed a cook in the kitchen on personnel, not coaching. And also, Robert Kraft, one time in Bill's entire reign, said, hey, you're not trading Tom. Move. Garoppolo. I'm sorry. It seems like he was right.

[Doug Gottlieb]

One that we know about. I think part of this goes back to last year's Atlanta Falcons disaster, where the owner, like Belichick and the front office kind of got together and, yeah, was like, no. And I think some of this is. I would not be surprised if behind the scenes, Colin, Chicago Bears kicked the tires on Belichick and he found out that. That. That situation. There's a mess. Owners, families. He said that in the quote. I don't only think that's theirs.

[Colin Cowherd]

Oh, by the way, you know New.

[Doug Gottlieb]

York jets as well.

[Colin Cowherd]

You knew who's having a great year this year. The Chargers. A couple of the Charger kids work in the front office. Harbaugh likes them, gets along with them.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Well, here's the other thing. You don't read stories about them getting in the locker room after the game. No, they do a good job of that.

[Colin Cowherd]

That's right. Other teams, I'm not against your kids working in the front office. As long as they know the boundaries of they didn't play, they didn't coach. I don't know if I, if I owned an NFL team and my son wanted to do something the front office, I'd be like, yeah, you're not a gm, you're not going to be a coach, you're not going to talk about schemes. But if you can be a part.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Something to the table.

[Colin Cowherd]

Bring something to the table. Yeah.

[Doug Gottlieb]

And in these days it's not that hard to bring something to the table with all the stats that, that's out there available. Some new, new fangled stats, if you will. There's a lot, I mean people are, front offices are hiring guys from Pro Football Focus and some of these statistical websites. It's a new regulation regime now in the NFL. It's not the, not the old school football guy.

[Colin Cowherd]

Still dominate JMAC with the news. Well, that's the news and thanks for stopping by the herd lie news. You know, I was thinking about this. So Tom Brady At 45 years old, he retired. He could have played. He was still one of the top six or seven quarterbacks in the league. And you know, you people retire for different reasons, right? Could be a family thing, could be a time thing, could be, I don't, you don't want to put in the work at practice thing. You love the games. So LeBron James was basically, he just turned 40 on Monday. Happy birthday to LeBron James, who's been the best overall player in my life watching pro basketball. Michael Jordan was a different player, a different mindset. Michael, maybe in a one game set I'd take Michael maybe, maybe not. But I think LeBron's making Michael Jordan's career look like a pit stop. It's lasted so long. But here was LeBron on turning 40, on his playing future.

[Doug Gottlieb]

It's kind of laughable really to know.

[Colin Cowherd]

Where I am, to see where I.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Am still playing the game at a.

[Colin Cowherd]

High level, still being such a young.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Man, but old in the scheme of how many years I got in this profession.

[Colin Cowherd]

But just think back to when I came into the league. Obviously that's like the first thing I thought about when you came into 18 year old kid. And now he's in here as a 40 year old, you know, 23 year.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Old vet, you know, with a, with a 20 year old and NBA as well.

[Colin Cowherd]

He's aged incredibly well. You know, it's very funny because the Internet is very loud and usually often very wrong. Some will lead you to believe LeBron's not a popular player. Once again, the most watched game in the NBA this year, LeBron James and Steph Curry. Oh, by the way, the most viewed NBA player on social clips. We talked about it last week. LeBron James, the number two selling jersey in the NBA last year with all these young stars. LeBron James, the Lakers road attendance for a pretty mediocre team is number two. And no, Steph's team isn't number one. LeBron wasn't in the NBA cup this year. The ratings absolutely tanked. So like Tom Brady, he's still a top 10 player, no question. And he could play for years. I mean, LeBron right now is averaging 24, 8 and 9. And if he stuck stuck around for four or five more seasons, I, I think he'd still be averaging 20 because his game age as well, because he's a brilliant passer, an excellent ball handler, and has a basketball IQ that is through the roof. He's aged well, but he is the greatest enduring basketball ball player of my life. But if you. It's always interesting to me. There's so much pushback on LeBron because the Internet's loud and wrong. His jersey, the ratings, the NBA cup without him. Yes, he can be polarizing because he took a stand on politics. And I do admit I don't watch sports for escapism. I watch it because it's entertainment. I prefer sports over movies. So I. I've never watched sports for escapism. I do understand that many of you do, and you don't like any politics with your basket. But I got news for you. Whether it's the Olympics, whether it's the NBA, we've seen it in the NFL. Politics seeps into everything. You have an opinion in your Office on politics. LeBron briefly did as well. So be it. But the idea that he's not popular and couldn't be great for mostly as long as he wanted to is just utter nonsense. You know, the chosen one, the king. It can be off putting whatever the guy's still giving you like 25, 8 and 9 a night. Number two in road attendance. A lot of stuff today. So this is for. I mentioned something last week on the Chicago Bears job, and it is now gaining steam. Herd hierarchy, Nick, right, top of the hour. It's New Year's Eve, last day of 2024 in LA. The herd. Be sure to catch live editions of the Herd, weekdays at noon Eastern, 9am Pacific from the Delta Sky Club. Welcome back Ms. Klein to the JetBridge. Delta Air Lines relies on 5G solutions from T Mobile for business to power operations and serve customers faster. Together we're putting 5G into the hands of ground staff so they can better assist on the go travelers with real time information throughout the airport. This is elevating customer experience. This is Delta Air Lines with T Mobile for Business. Take your business further@t mobile.com now. This podcast is sponsored by PayPal. We partnered with them to make this holiday season even better. With all the shopping, gifting and holiday prep, my PayPal debit card is my go to for getting more out of my purchases. Here's how it works. I choose my monthly category Gas, restaurants, apparel, groceries, health and beauty or just for the holiday season, tech. And I earn 5% cash back on up to 1,000 bucks in the purchases in those categories. Yeah, 5% cash back this month. I'm gonna go with tech. It's my category. It's a no brainer, right? Everybody loves the latest tech gifts, so whether it's stuff for the fam or adding new gadgets to my personal collection, that cash back adds up fast. So this holiday season, let the PayPal debit card do the heavy lifting. Sign up for the card when you download the PayPal app, then pay in store and online and get cash back with a PayPal debit card. Don't just pay PayPal terms and limits apply. See paypal.com rewardspal the PayPal Debit MasterCard is issued by the Bancor Bank N.A. pursuant to a license by MasterCard International, Inc. And may be used everywhere MasterCard is accepted. What makes the holiday special are the details from Genesis, and every little detail in a Genesis is another gift to you. Like during winter, you'll be thankful for the available heated steering wheel and the available snow mode to help get you through the snowiest of snow days. And the available all wheel drive is helpful all year round, but especially during the winter. I mean, Genesis has put a lot of thought into the details. And of course the best gifts are thoughtful ones like the available Nappa leather seating. Oh, speaking of gifts, you'll have plenty of room to haul around everything you've picked up for family and friends, no matter which Genesis you're driving. And with a lineup featuring SUVs, EVs, Sedans, something for everybody. Experience the Genesis Signature event. And as one big final gift, Genesis is offering you a $1,000 bonus on select Genesis vehicles. The deal ends January 2nd. See participating Genesis retailers for details visit genesis.com to see how Genesis can make your holidays even brighter. Details make the holidays hey, y'all know the Aflac commercials, right? With the famous duck and the coaches. Great commercials. But did you know that Aflac is a leader in supplemental insurance? That's what the duck is quacking about, helping cover gaps. So like, this is how I think of Aflac. Let's say you have an all pro linebacker. Anytime there's a gap in the defensive line, you know he's going to fill it, no problem because he's an all pro. Aflac does the same thing. If there's a gap in your health insurance, Aflac wants to better protect you by helping close the gap. You're sick, you're injured. Aflac can pay cash to help fill the gaps your health insurance can leave behind. You can use the cash, put it towards whatever you need, rent, mortgage payments, medical bills. It's completely up to you. Look, life can be tough. Fortunately, Aflac is tougher. I mean, we're talking middle linebacker tough. To learn more about how Aflac can help fill the gaps health insurance can leave behind, visit aflac.com I'm not a weatherman, but I'll give you my forecast. Snow and ice are coming and they're going to make driving a challenge. Thankfully, the experts at Tire Rack know a thing or two about conquering winter's worst rain, sleet, slush, whatever winter means to you. Tire Rack has tires that elevate traction and braking and keep you and your family safe all season. Tires, all weather tires. And if you live where it snows a lot, dedicated winter tires. Just go to tirerack.com easy to use shopping tools will guide you to a personalized recommendation. The right tires for how, what and where you drive. Choose from a full line of Pirelli tires shipped fast and free and backed by two years of free road hazard protection. Go to TireRack.com Colin to see their Pirelli test results and special offers. Tire Rack has thousands of recommended installers and offers the convenience of mobile tire installation. I love that. Great tires, great deals and great people. What more could you ask for? That's tirerack.com Colin the way tire buying should be this week.

[Doug Gottlieb]

FOX College Hoops Friday features 18th ranked Michigan State taking on an Ohio State at 8 Eastern only on Fox.

[Colin Cowherd]

Urban Meyer last hour, our big bets next hour, top of the hour, the herd hierarchy. This is very interesting. Mike Sando, very respected writer. We bring him on the show once, twice a year from the athletic. So I had mentioned this Last week in one of my commentaries, he's doubling down on it. He said, why not Pete Carroll in Chicago? Let me read this, he said. Over the course he studied the 17 quarterback team relationships spanning at least a decade since Peyton Manning entered the league. And here's what he found. You don't need an offensive play calling head coach for your quarterback to win. There are no magic schemes. And that brings us to Carroll and and Jim Harbaugh. Both are masters at installing instilling confidence in their quarterbacks. Both create run games to take pressure off quarterbacks. So Drew Bledsoe with the Patriots. He had his career best passer rating in 1997 and other top stats in 98, 99. Pete Carroll was his coach. Young Russell Wilson Seahawks 2012-21 he entered as a third round pick, developed a run game, became a superstar. Geno Smith has gotten worse since Pete Carroll left. Pete Carroll gave him a run game. What's happened to Geno in the last year? He's bad this year. So with young quarterbacks, Geno I guess doesn't classify as young. Pete Carroll and this is what I argued last week. He has a history of developing strong run games and defenses and kind of detailed culture which are really beneficial to young quarterbacks. Drew Bledsoe in New England, Russell Wilson in Seattle and Caleb Williams. And there's nothing against Ben Johnson. He's very smart. But I gotta be honest, when you watch Detroit last night, they got like seven Pro bowl level players. They got multiple hall of Fame level guys, the best running back room, excellent tight end, two great receivers, the best offensive line in football. There's a lot of coordinators that would look really, really good with Detroit's personnel. And let's be fair about this, they're stacked. I mean, it's amazing. They're paying golf good money and they're still stacked because they've drafted so well. They've hit on virtually all of their offensive draft picks, picks they've missed on a couple defensive picks. They have nailed offensive picks and then made smart moves. So, you know, and I, I'm a big believer. If you go back and look at culture guys like Harbaugh's a culture guy name, you know, Tomlin's a culture guy. Pete Carroll's a culture guy. Culture guys may not win a trophy, but they rarely bomb. Scheme guys bomb all the time. And I'll give you an example, even really good scheme guys. Kyle Shanahan, J. Mac, listen to this. Kyle Shanahan is considered a top scheme guy in San Francisco. Four losing seasons. McVeigh is considered a culture guy. One losing season, even his rebuild season, he got to the playoffs. Culture guys, motivational guys. Dan Campbell, vrabel, Pete Carroll, McVeigh. They may not win a trophy. McVeigh finally did. Shouldn't say finally. He's still young. But scheme guys whiff all the time if they don't have the right personnel. So basically what happens is a culture guy squeezes the juice out of every player. A scheme guy doesn't. A scheme guy can squeeze the juice out of his particular scheme. He's a defensive coordinator, the edge rusher the corners will have. Rex Ryan was great at squeezing juice out of the defensive side, but he hurt the offensive side. Right? So you know this idea that, oh, there's magic potion, this elixir with Ben Johnson. Go look at Detroit's personnel. Good God, they got all stars, Pro Bowlers everywhere. A lot of people would look good with their personnel. So on our show yesterday, we brought in Michael Irvin, who is always enlightening, interesting, and entertaining. So I would Bring back Mike McCarthy. I think you can make an argument. Unless I could get Vrabel, I'd probably Bring back Mike McCarthy. But Michael Irvin wanted no part of bringing back Mike McCarthy.

[Doug Gottlieb]

I just think it's time to go.

[Colin Cowherd]

In another direction, you know, And I hear these late. This late surge to maybe go in.

[Doug Gottlieb]

To stay with Mike McCarthy.

[Colin Cowherd]

I'm not on that. I'm not on that bandwagon. I just.

[Doug Gottlieb]

What I believe is this team needs more discipline.

[Colin Cowherd]

I don't. I'm not saying Mike McCarthy is not a good coach.

[Doug Gottlieb]

X is an old coach, you know, But. But I think the team needs more discipline. And sometimes, and it's hard to bring.

[Colin Cowherd]

That in when you say, okay, this.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Guy who doesn't have that firm hand and discipline is now going to either bring somebody else in to help him with discipline, and that doesn't work. You can't come in soft and then.

[Colin Cowherd]

Try to get tough. It's a wrap.

[Doug Gottlieb]

You. You got to come in tough and then.

[Colin Cowherd]

And then lighten up, because then the.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Guys will feel like they've earned some respect and earned you lightning lighting up.

[Colin Cowherd]

That I agree with. But I don't think Mike McCarthy, now, he may not be the solution, but I don't think he's the problem. Here's what I'd say is your problem. You know how good the running back room is for Philadelphia and Detroit and Baltimore. The Cowboys have the worst running back room in the league. That's not on Mike McCarthy, Dax. Contract is not on Mike McCarthy. The NFC, frankly, has just gotten better over the last two years. The defense got worse when Dan Quinn left the o line. Right 25th rebuild. They've missed on a couple of picks and they've been chasing the number two wide receiver in Dallas seemingly forever. So I'll give you an example. We can blame Mike McCarthy, but let's say I think we would all agree on this. You'd agree. I agree. Philadelphia and Detroit have the best, most talented offensive rosters in the nfc. I won't even count afc, just in the nfc. So I combined the Eagles, the Lions offensive rosters because it's an offensive league now. Nobody's winning with defense by the time you get to the end of the season. And guys are banged up. Offense win Super Bowls. Here is the Eagles, Lions offense. Tell me the Cowboy that starts. And don't give me Zach Martin because he's hurt. And the two guards, Landon Dickerson and Kevin Zeitler, are both top 10 in the PFF rankings. Well, what about CD Lamb? You think I'm starting him on the perimeter over A.J. brown? No shot. A.J. brown is arguably the second best receiver in the league. The Justin Jefferson. I don't think there's a Dallas Cowboy that would start. And for a radio audience, it goes. Jared Goffer, hurts at quarterback, take your pick. Saquon Barkley, Jameer Gibbs, again, take your pick. They're both great. A.J. brown, Omaron St. Brown at receiver, Sam LaPorta, tight end. The tackles are two of the best tackles in the league. Left tackle for the Eagles, right tackle. Panay still probably is the best right tackle. So you tell me a Cowboy that starts with that Zach Martin, but he's old and injured. And so if you told me I had to take one, I wouldn't take the old, expensive injured guy. And CD Lamb would absolutely be in the rotation, but I wouldn't start him. Amaran Saint Brown's my slot, and AJ Brown is. And again, you take out Justin Jefferson, he's one of the great receivers in the league. So you can blame Mike McCarthy. Andy Reid, if he coached the Dallas Cowboys is not beating Detroit. And Philadelphia, he didn't have the. He didn't have the personnel. I mean, I don't think people realize how well Detroit has drafted over the last four years offensively. God, they just don't miss. And Howie Roseman's probably the best GM in the league. Those teams are all time stacked. Now, Detroit may have defensive issues because injuries and Philadelphia this year finally went and drafted a couple great corners and for years they were kind of shaky in the back end. But I, I don't think That's a Mike McCarthy issue. I, I, I, I think that's upstairs. And ownership. What say you?

[Doug Gottlieb]

Yeah, no, I'm largely with you. I, I feel like you're this, this bear's job is clouding your judgment just a little bit. So you've been taking some jabs at Kyle Shanahan. Oh, he's got four losing seasons. McVeigh. McVeigh doesn't have that many, so I was just doing some research. Colin. So Shanahan gets here in 2017.

[Colin Cowherd]

Yeah.

[Doug Gottlieb]

His quarterbacks, Brian Hoyer, C.J. beathard, Jimmy Garoppolo. His quarterbacks in 2018, Nick Mullins, Beathard Garoppolo. You go down the list. McVeigh had Goff a number one overall pick. Pick.

[Colin Cowherd]

Right. Who was seen as a bustle 49ers.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Jenna never had any quarterback in the first round pick except for Trey Lance, who.

[Colin Cowherd]

Yeah, it didn't work.

[Doug Gottlieb]

Take it easy on Shanahan.

[Colin Cowherd]

I like him. I'm just saying. McVeigh's my guy. I'm partnering with PayPal. The holiday season is here and I'm gonna save big with cash back offers in the PayPal app. It's easy. I browse deals from my favorite brands, save offers in the app and use PayPal checkout online. Really, really easy. Whether I'm buying gifts for my family or treating myself to something nice, I'm earning cash back and you can too. Don't just pay PayPal check offers in the app for details and exclusions. Cashback earned as points redeemable for cash and other options, see PayPal rewards terms from the Delta Sky Club. Welcome back, Ms. Klein, to the JetBridge. Delta Air Lines relies on 5G solutions from T Mobile for business to power operations and serve customers faster. Together, we're putting 5G into the hands of ground staff so they can better assist on the go travelers with real time information throughout the airport. This is elevating customer experience. This is Delta Air Lines with T Mobile for business. Take your business further@t mobile.com now. Whether you're ordering wings for the game, whipping up a seven layer dip, or ordering pizza, there's something about football that makes me want to eat. And this football season, Uber Eats has the best deals for me on game day. Food no matter what I'm craving. From two for one pizza. To buy one, get one wings. Uber Eats. We'll be dropping new deals each week all season long I'm in. Uber Eats, the official on demand delivery partner of the NFL. Order now for game day. Terms and conditions apply. See app for details.

[Doug Gottlieb]

This is Malcolm Gladwell from Revisionist History. Picture this. You're halfway through a DIY car fix, tools scattered everywhere, and boom. You realize you're missing a part. It's okay because you know, whatever it is, it's on ebay. They've got everything. Brakes, headlights, cold air intakes. Whatever you need. And it's guaranteed to fit. Which means no more crossing your fingers and hoping you ordered the right thing. All the parts you need at prices you'll love. Guaranteed to fit every time. Ebay Things People Love what's on your.

[Colin Cowherd]

List of popular game day foods? Probably multiple dishes with the bold flavor of the original Louisiana brand hot sauce. You can't beat the original with a 90 year history of great taste and quality. Tailgate, house party, game day gatherings, whatever. Include real flavor sliders with the original Louisiana brand hot sauce. The beer cheese with that hit of Louisiana peppers. There has to be original Louisiana brand hot sauce on your game day food list. It's the perfect everyday hot sauce that complements every meal. There's a rich food tradition in Louisiana bringing bold peppery flavor with just the right amount of heat. Pigs in a blanket. Pigs not in a blanket. Spinach Artichoke dip Artichoke spinach dip Wings are wingier than ever with the original Louisiana brand wing sauce. Perfect for self appointed flavor experts. The original Louisiana brand hot sauce the game day flavor changer Flavor favors the bold. Available at a store near.