The Herd with Colin Cowherd – Richard Sherman Podcast: NFL Week 10 Reaction

Date: November 10, 2025
Host: Richard Sherman
Co-host: Mitchell
Presented by: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume

Episode Overview

This episode is a fast-paced and insightful recap of NFL Week 10, delivered with Richard Sherman’s signature bold takes and defensive expertise. Alongside Mitchell, they break down pivotal matchups including Cardinals-Seahawks, Rams-49ers, Bills-Dolphins, Giants-Bears, and also touch on playoff implications, standout performances, and the unpredictable state of the league. Sherman operates in his classic style—forthright, analytical, and willing to challenge prevailing narratives. The episode’s warm banter and depth make it valuable for NFL fans seeking nuanced analysis beyond the box score.

Main Discussion Points & Insights

1. Seahawks-Cardinals: Dominant Seahawks, Growing Pains for Arizona

• Opening Blitz: Seahawks explode to a 28-0 lead thanks to dynamic offensive plays and key defensive turnovers.
  • “A Jackson, Smith and Jigba 43 yard touchdown to start. The defense says oh I could do you one better sack force fumble by Tyrese Knight with Demarcus Lawrence recovering it for a touchdown.” – Richard Sherman [03:54]
• Game Recap: Despite third-quarter sloppiness, Seattle’s running game and opportunistic defense stole the show.
  • “Zach Charbonnet, 14 carries for 83 yards. K9, 14 carries for 67 yards. The defense had five sacks and two touchdowns.” – Sherman [05:29]
• Standouts:
  • Jackson Smith-Njigba for surpassing 1,000 yards;
  • DeMarcus Lawrence’s defensive touchdowns;
  • Reek Woolen’s resilience after trade rumors.
• Cardinals Woes: Jacoby Brissett’s struggles and team’s search for a franchise QB, with a tongue-in-cheek Call of Duty/Kyler Murray reference.
• Big Picture: Sherman declares Seahawks the NFL’s best, alongside the Colts, while teasing the pivotal Seahawks-Rams matchup next week.
  • “I feel great about the Seattle Seahawks team, the depth at the defensive line. ... This team is playing great football.” [13:54]

2. Rams-49ers: Stafford’s Renaissance, 49ers’ Silver Linings

• Stafford's Dominance: Matthew Stafford leads the league in touchdown passes at age 39, even after losing key receivers.
  • “Matthew Stafford just looks dynamite. I mean, the guy ... seems to be playing the best football he ever has.” – Mitchell [19:06]
• 49ers’ Woes:
  • Injuries deplete defense;
  • Mac Jones solid as QB (33/39, 319 yards, 3 TDs, 1 INT), ignites QB controversy with Brock Purdy looming.
• Sherman’s Analysis: Acknowledges the 49ers’ needs for offensive consistency and health, but captions the Rams as legitimate NFC contenders.
  • “San Francisco 49ers are 6 and 4 and the NFC is as competitive as it's ever been.” [23:53]

3. Detroit Lions’ Offensive Resurgence

• Bounce Back Win: Lions demolish the Commanders 44-22, led by Goff (320 yds, 3 TDs) and Gibbs (142 rushing & 119 receiving).
• Sherman’s Doubt: Cautions against overreacting until the Lions prove themselves against the Eagles next week.
  • “A win against the Philadelphia Eagles will do that. It will be the remedy I need and that will tell me everything I need to know.” [38:10]
• Dan Campbell’s Play Calling: Debate over head coach’s assumption of OC duties and Morton’s future.

4. Bills-Dolphins: Miami’s Statement, Buffalo’s Slide

• Bills Concerns: Offense stalls, wide receiver depth in question.
  • “The receiver by committee thing does not work in this league. ... You need a guy and big dogs. ... When you don't have a big dog like the Buffalo Bills... you don’t know where you're going.” – Sherman [45:19]
• Dolphins’ Formula: Devon Achane outshines James Cook, defense dominates.
• Mitchell: Highlights Buffalo’s “mid-tier” vibe despite early expectations.

5. AFC East Power Shift: Patriots’ Rise

• Drake Maye’s Emergence: Sherman places the second-year Patriots QB as a top-10 talent.
  • “Oh, no question about it. He’s a top 10 guy. … Drake Maye is cemented himself into that conversation this year.” [52:14]
• Mike Vrabel’s Culture Change: Praise for Vrabel’s coaching impact on the resurgent 8-2 Patriots.
• Rest-of-Season Outlook: Patriots have a soft schedule ahead and could challenge for the #1 seed.

6. Indianapolis Colts: Jonathan Taylor for MVP

• Colts Surge to 8-2: Jonathan Taylor rushes for 244 yards and 3 TDs.
  • “If he does not win the MVP, something is wrong with the MVP voting because there’s no player more dominant in football right now than him.” – Mitchell [57:29]
• Sherman Echoes MVP Case:
  • “You cannot tell me there's more that Jonathan Taylor could be doing for his team. ... The biggest piece right now is Jonathan Taylor and that’s why he deserves the most valuable player.” [59:40–61:13]
• Sauce Gardner Trade: Sherman breaks down schematic fit and trade value.
  • “In order for him to be most effective, you have to … give him that matchup and they’re going to have to … allow him to thrive.” [63:16]

7. Around the League – Two-Minute Drill

Ravens: Uninspired, In Need of Help

• “Anytime it’s a situation where a team needs help, it’s unpredictable.” – Sherman [71:10]

Bears-Giants: Jackson Dart Shines, Injury Sways Game

• “He looks like he should’ve been the number one pick last year … he has transformed this New York Giants team.” – Mitchell [73:40]
• “A bought lesson is better than a taught lesson. And he just bought a lesson this game.” – Sherman on Dart’s learning from tough hits [79:45]

Texans-Jaguars: Houston’s Grit

• Davis Mills leads a comeback vs. Jacksonville; Derek Stingley Jr. earns high praise for his game-winning INT.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Seahawks’ Power:
  “It’s better to be early than late. That’s what my coaches always said.” – Sherman [13:53]
• On the NFL’s Unpredictability:
  “If there’s anybody sitting there saying, I know who’s going to make the Super Bowl this year ... I don’t think you know what you’re talking about because there’s no predicting anything this year. The only thing predictable about this season is the unpredictability of it.” – Sherman [29:26]
• On Colts’ Defensive Scheme:
  “If you’re getting a guy like [Sauce Gardner] and the offense can dictate when he covers their best receiver and when he doesn’t, it’s going to be tough for him to have the kind of impact … to make him worthy of two first round picks being traded.” [62:20]
• On Jackson Dart’s Style:
  “A bought lesson is better than a taught lesson. And he just bought a lesson.” – Sherman [79:45]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Seahawks-Cardinals Deep Dive: [03:50–10:39]
• Mitchell’s Seahawks Revelations: [10:40–15:09]
• 49ers-Rams Recap: [19:05–27:51]
• Lions-Offensive Resurgence: [35:45–40:38]
• Bills-Dolphins Breakdown: [41:31–46:27]
• Patriots’ Top-10 QB Drake Maye Conversation: [51:48–56:00]
• Colts’ MVP Case for Jonathan Taylor: [57:45–63:15]
• Defensive Scheme, Sauce Gardner Discussion: [61:56–66:08]
• Rapid-Fire Game Recaps: [70:27–85:55]

Tone & Takeaways

• Sherman is unwavering in his opinions—championing the Seahawks, calling out the Lions for inconsistency, and demanding MVP justice for non-quarterbacks.
• Mitchell provides balanced counterpoints and local insights, notably representing the voice of cautious Lions and Rams optimism.
• Both hosts highlight the league’s parity and unpredictability as the signature of the 2025 season.
• The episode blends Xs and Os insight with lively debate and familiar NFL talk show banter.
• For listeners seeking sharp, defensive-minded analysis and a quick-hitting yet thorough Week 10 review, this episode captures all the NFL’s volatility and drama, plus plenty of bold predictions for the weeks ahead.