Podcast Summary: The Best Of Cavino & Rich The Herd with Colin Cowherd | iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Episode: The Best Of Covino & Rich
Release Date: May 8, 2025

Introduction

In the May 8, 2025 episode of The Best Of Cavino & Rich, hosts Steve Cavino, Rich Davis, and Danny G delve into a range of engaging sports topics, blending insightful commentary with lively banter. The episode navigates through intriguing "finders keepers" dilemmas, major sports updates, and discussions on legacy within the athletic world, all punctuated with memorable quotes and humorous exchanges.

1. "Finders Keepers, Losers Weepers" Debate

The episode kicks off with a compelling discussion on the age-old adage "finders keepers, losers weepers," examining its moral implications through recent real-life instances.

• Aaron Judge’s Home Run Ball Mishap
  Rich Davis introduces the segment by recounting a viral incident where a fan at Yankee Stadium caught an Aaron Judge home run ball only for it to inadvertently slip from his glove and be snagged by a nearby individual.

  Rich Davis [04:00]: "When you catch an Aaron Judge home run in today's game, that's a big moment."
  Steve Cavino shares his personal philosophy on the matter, emphasizing the sentimental value of such memorabilia.
  Steve Cavino [05:00]: "If you caught a home run or even a foul ball, I'm not giving it to the kid next to me. I've waited my whole life for that moment."
  The conversation highlights the tension between personal attachment and social ethics, with participants debating whether the act of returning missed items stems from genuine morality or the pressure of social media scrutiny.

• Brinks Truck Overturn in Chicago
  A story emerges about a Brinks truck that forgot to latch, spilling $300,000 across the neighborhood.

  Rich Davis [07:00]: "If you pick up a stack... are you giving it back?"
  The hosts grapple with the dilemma of keeping found money versus returning it, considering factors like traceability and moral responsibility.

• $43,000 Found in a Couch Cushion
  Another intriguing tale involves an elderly man finding $43,000 tucked inside a thrift store couch, prompting him to return the money despite the lack of legal obligation.

  Steve Cavino [08:50]: "He felt like it was the right thing to do."
  The discussion extends into broader scenarios, such as finding valuable items at estate sales or garage sales, questioning the boundaries of "finders keepers."

Notable Quote:

Rich Davis [11:10]: "If you had a lottery ticket... Would you just put it in your pocket?"

2. Midweek Major: Latest Sports News

Transitioning to the "Midweek Major" segment, the hosts unpack several significant sports news stories, providing updates and personal takes.

• NFL Trade Update: George Pickens to Dallas Cowboys
  Dan Byer reports on the Dallas Cowboys acquiring wide receiver George Pickens from the Pittsburgh Steelers in exchange for future draft picks.

  Dan Byer [28:03]: "By sending Pickens to Dallas, the Steelers are focusing on DK Metcalf as their number one wide receiver."
  The trade's implications for both teams are discussed, with Steve Cavino questioning its immediate impact on star receiver Rogers.

• Pittsburgh Pirate Fan's Field Fall
  A harrowing update covers a fan, Kevin Markwood, who suffered serious injuries after falling onto the field during a game at PNC Park. The incident, captured from multiple angles, underscores safety concerns at ballparks.

  Rich Davis [53:07]: "It could have been tragic, but the guy's walking again."
  The hosts debate potential safety measures and the likelihood of MLB implementing stricter protocols to prevent similar occurrences.

• Milwaukee Brewers’ Hot Dog Club Launch
  The Brewers introduce their Hot Dog Club, offering members a free hot dog for every home game, an exclusive hat, and other perks for a subscription fee.

  Rich Davis [56:30]: "60 bucks is four hot dogs... If you get unlimited and you get a hat, that's a deal."
  The segment humorously critiques the practicality and cost-effectiveness of such fan clubs.

Notable Quote:

Steve Cavino [29:20]: "The most rated thing and valuable thing I have was Conseco's rated rookie in '86. Is it really worth getting it graded?"

3. Legacy and Generations in Sports

A thought-provoking conversation ensues about the influence of family legacies in sports, emphasizing how athletic prowess and passion are often passed through generations.

• Multigenerational Athletes
  The hosts discuss figures like Bartolo Colon and the phenomenon of sons following in their fathers' athletic footsteps.

  Rich Davis [32:40]: "He's the Arizona League. Jaden Fielder already hitting bombs, 20 years old."
  They explore the nature versus nurture debate, acknowledging that both genetic predisposition and environmental factors play crucial roles in developing sports talents.

• Justin Verlander’s Longevity
  Justin Verlander's impressive performance at 42 years old serves as a testament to the potential for extended athletic careers with proper conditioning and dedication.

  Steve Cavino [45:02]: "Last four starts, 2.727 ERA."
  The discussion celebrates such athletes while questioning the sustainability of peak performance into advanced ages.

Notable Quote:

Rich Davis [34:10]: "No doubt. And you wonder, is it nature versus nurture? It really is both."

4. Words of Wisdom and Listener Contest

In a lighthearted interlude, the hosts engage listeners with a contest centered around repeating "Mike's Wednesday Words of Wisdom."

• Words of Wisdom Quote:
  Steve Cavino [41:31]: "Always remember to be nice to anyone who has access to your toothbrush."
  Listeners were encouraged to recall and repeat the quote verbatim for a chance to win prizes, fostering audience interaction and community engagement.

Notable Quote:

Rich Davis [42:24]: "Have company over, do you tuck away your toothbrush somewhere or do you leave it in the holder right there?"

5. Closing Thoughts and Teasers

As the episode winds down, the hosts reflect on memorable sports moments, such as Bartolo Colon's unexpected home run, and tease upcoming segments like "midweek major." They also touch upon the emotional complexities of public stunts by athletes, referencing Tom Brady's reflections on his stint on a Netflix roast.

Notable Quote:

Rich Davis [35:16]: "There's nothing wrong with playing aggressive, right?"

Conclusion

The May 8 episode of The Best Of Cavino & Rich offers a rich tapestry of sports narratives, ethical debates, and personal anecdotes. From the intricacies of "finders keepers" scenarios to the celebration of athletic legacies, the hosts provide a comprehensive and entertaining exploration of contemporary sports culture. Engaging quotes and interactive segments further enhance the listener experience, making this episode a standout installment in the series.

Highlighted Quotes:

• Rich Davis [04:00]: "When you catch an Aaron Judge home run in today's game, that's a big moment."
• Steve Cavino [05:00]: "If you caught a home run or even a foul ball, I'm not giving it to the kid next to me."
• Rich Davis [11:10]: "If you had a lottery ticket... Would you just put it in your pocket?"
• Dan Byer [28:03]: "By sending Pickens to Dallas, the Steelers are focusing on DK Metcalf as their number one wide receiver."
• Steve Cavino [29:20]: "The most rated thing and valuable thing I have was Conseco's rated rookie in '86. Is it really worth getting it graded?"

Stay Tuned

Don't miss the next episode, where Cavino and Rich continue to dissect the latest in sports and pop culture, accompanied by more listener interactions and in-depth analysis.