The Herd with Colin Cowherd: Episode Summary Episode: THE HERD - Hour 1 - Don't believe Arch Manning would pass on the NFL, franchise QB traits, and distractions
Release Date: August 7, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, host Colin Cowherd delves into the evolving landscape of NFL quarterbacks, the traits that define franchise QBs, and the challenges young athletes face both on and off the field. The discussion also touches on coaching dynamics within NFL teams, the significance of preseason games, and the attributes that contribute to building a sports dynasty.

Arch Manning and NFL Prospects

Colin kicks off the episode by addressing speculations surrounding Arch Manning's future in the NFL. Highlighting the competitive nature of college football and the business acumen of the Manning family, Colin expresses skepticism about Arch opting to stay in college for additional years.

Quote:

Greg Cosell: "His work ethic is incredible. Whether it's, you know, studying tape, studying film, studying the playbook, working at his craft... his work ethic is really pretty incredible."
(Timestamp: 06:58)

Greg Cosell emphasizes Arch Manning's dedication, suggesting that his relentless work ethic, possibly inherited from his family legacy, makes him a promising prospect for the NFL.

Traits of Franchise Quarterbacks

Colin passionately discusses the characteristics that make quarterbacks successful and suitable for leading an NFL franchise. He argues that the most effective QBs possess an intense and serious demeanor, often bordering on obsession, which sets them apart from their peers.

Key Points:

• Maturity and Professionalism: Colin criticizes young quarterbacks who exhibit overly lighthearted or "silly" behavior, arguing that such traits are inappropriate for the leadership role of a QB.
• Comparison to Established Stars: He draws parallels between current QBs like Jalen Hurts and veterans like Peyton Manning, emphasizing the importance of intensity and focus.

Quotes:

"I believe the term is true, but I get tired of it woke. Well, you, you just not being honest."
(Timestamp: 07:21)

"It's totally unfair that at 23 years old as an NFL quarterback, you are held to a totally different standard."
(Timestamp: 07:21)

Colin underscores that QBs are expected to exhibit a level of maturity and responsibility that surpasses typical expectations for their age group.

Dallas Cowboys' Coaching and Leadership

The conversation shifts to the Dallas Cowboys, where Colin scrutinizes head coach Brian Schottenheimer's handling of star linebacker Micah Parsons. He expresses doubt about Schottenheimer's effectiveness, hinting at interference from the Cowboys' ownership and the complexities of managing top-tier talent.

Key Points:

• Micah Parsons' Role: Colin discusses the strategic importance of Parsons and the challenges in utilizing his full potential within the team's framework.
• Coaching Challenges: He highlights the difficulties Schottenheimer faces, including player management and external pressures from ownership.

Quotes:

"But I think one of the reasons this is an easier job than some of the other jobs is Dak Prescott. Dak is the Honda Civic of this league. You never have to worry about getting to work. It will not break down."
(Timestamp: 25:21)

This analogy emphasizes the reliability and steady presence of Dak Prescott, contrasting with the tumultuous coaching environment surrounding Brian Schottenheimer.

Josh Allen: MVP vs. Super Bowl Rings

Colin examines quarterback Josh Allen's preference for Super Bowl rings over MVP titles, contrasting it with former QB Cam Newton's stance. He appreciates Allen's team-first mentality, viewing it as a sign of genuine commitment to winning over personal accolades.

Quotes:

"I like this attitude from Allen, as I'm sure you as well."
(Timestamp: 27:07)

"Winning is the difference. And I love the fact that... it brings a smile to my face."
(Timestamp: 28:28)

Colin commends Allen for valuing team success above individual recognition, aligning with his philosophy that winning trumps personal achievements.

Philadelphia Eagles' Defensive Strength

The discussion moves to the Philadelphia Eagles' defense, particularly the impact of rookie linebacker Jihad Campbell. Saquon Barkley's praise of Campbell underscores the defensive improvements the Eagles have made this season.

Key Points:

• Jihad Campbell's Potential: Seen as a formidable player likened to Micah Parsons, Campbell is expected to pose significant challenges to opposing offenses.
• Draft Strategy: Colin praises Howie Roseman's drafting decisions, highlighting the Eagles' ability to secure top talent without succumbing to public pressure.

Quotes:

Saquon Barkley: "I think he's going to be a problem, a real big problem for a lot of guys in this league who have to block him. He's kind of built like Micah Parsons."
(Timestamp: 29:00)

This comparison positions Campbell as a key asset for the Eagles' defensive lineup.

NFL Draft Strategies: Eagles vs. Others

Colin analyzes how the Philadelphia Eagles' drafting approach, particularly their focus on selecting top defensive talent, sets them apart from other teams. He references historical draft decisions to illustrate the long-term benefits of such strategies.

Key Points:

• Defensive Focus: Emphasis on drafting inside linebackers and safeties, securing high-impact defensive players early in the draft.
• Comparison to Other Teams: Contrasts the Eagles' strategy with the Detroit Lions' initial struggles and eventual success with strategic picks.

Quotes:

"But a lot of people were intimidated. They had a very weak inner scoreboard. They had a bigger... they worry about what people think about them and Howie Roseman does not."
(Timestamp: 30:08)

Colin highlights Howie Roseman's confidence in his draft choices, noting the Eagles' disregard for external criticism when selecting top defensive prospects.

Preseason Games: To Play or Not To Play Starters

Colin shares his views on the role of preseason games in the NFL, weighing the benefits of giving starters game time against the risks of potential injuries and burnout.

Key Points:

• Player Readiness: The necessity for quarterbacks and key players to engage in preseason games to assess their form and readiness.
• League Implications: Discusses how preseason performances can influence team strategies and player evaluations.

Quotes:

"Joe Burrow always worries me about previous injuries, but I don't know, I just think he's... If college football, if Texas and Ohio State can play a game with no preseason, with limitations on practice hours, college kids who are 19, 20, 21... pro football guys need a preseason."
(Timestamp: 32:23)

Colin emphasizes the importance of preseason for professional athletes in assessing their performance and readiness for the upcoming season.

NFL Dynasties and Competitive Balance

Drawing parallels with other sports, Colin explores what defines a dynasty in the NFL, focusing on sustained success, strategic player acquisitions, and the ability to dominate weaker divisions.

Key Points:

• Home Field Advantage: The role of playing in strong divisions that allow teams to secure home playoff games through consistent victories.
• Comparative Analysis: Comparing the Kansas City Chiefs' potential dynasty to historical dynasties like the New England Patriots and the dominance of players like Tom Brady and Michael Jordan in their respective sports.

Quotes:

"Nothing's everything. But remember that little piece of video? Do we have the sound up on that?"
(Timestamp: 43:21)

"All of them are Pro Bowlers. Just go get the best players. Get the best players. The smart teams do that, right?"
(Timestamp: 31:42)

Colin asserts that building a dynasty requires smart team management, strategic drafting, and leveraging home field advantages within competitive divisions.

AFC West Division Analysis

Concluding the episode, Colin provides an in-depth analysis of the AFC West division, forecasting the performance of teams like the Kansas City Chiefs and Denver Broncos. He discusses factors such as coaching quality, team rosters, and quarterback performance in determining the division's dynamics.

Key Points:

• Kansas City Chiefs vs. Denver Broncos: While acknowledging the Chiefs' strong coaching and quarterback play, Colin contends that the Broncos boast a superior roster, positioning them as formidable contenders.
• Coaching Influence: The impact of coaches like Andy Reid and their ability to maximize team potential.

Quotes:

"I don't think Kansas City's getting."
(Timestamp: 50:22)

Colin predicts a competitive AFC West, highlighting Denver's roster strength as a key factor in their potential to outperform historically dominant teams like the Chiefs.

Conclusion

Colin wraps up the episode by teasing upcoming discussions and segments, maintaining engagement with listeners. He hints at more in-depth analyses and provocative takes in future episodes, ensuring that the audience remains eager for forthcoming content.

Notable Quotes Recap

• Greg Cosell on Arch Manning's Work Ethic:
  "His work ethic is incredible..." (06:58)

• Colin on MVP vs. Super Bowl Rings:
  "Winning is the difference..." (28:28)

• Saquon Barkley on Jihad Campbell:
  "I think he's going to be a problem..." (29:00)

• Colin on Preseason Importance:
  "Pro football guys need a preseason..." (32:23)

This episode provides a comprehensive exploration of the qualities that define successful NFL quarterbacks, the strategic decisions behind team rosters, and the intricate balance required to build and maintain a sports dynasty. Colin Cowherd's insightful analysis offers listeners a nuanced understanding of the current state and future trajectory of the NFL.