Podcast Summary: THE HERD - Hour 3 - Arch Manning Isn't Going Anywhere, Shedeur Sanders Debut Tonight, Geoff Schwartz

Podcast Information:

• Title: The Herd with Colin Cowherd
• Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts and The Volume
• Description: The Herd with Colin Cowherd is a thought-provoking, opinionated, and topic-driven journey through the top sports stories of the day.
• Episode: THE HERD - Hour 3 - Arch Manning Isn't Going Anywhere, Shedeur Sanders Debut Tonight, Geoff Schwartz
• Release Date: August 8, 2025

Introduction

In this episode, Doug Gottlieb steps in for Colin Cowherd to discuss significant developments in college and professional football. The primary topics include Arch Manning's decision to remain at Texas, the anticipated debut of Shedeur Sanders with the Cleveland Browns, and insights from Geoff Schwartz, a seasoned NFL and college football analyst.

Arch Manning's Commitment to Texas

Discussion Highlights:

• Arch Manning, the highly touted quarterback and grandson of the legendary Archie Manning, has decided to stay another year at the University of Texas.
• Doug Gottlieb emphasizes the importance of experience: “Arch Manning isn't going anywhere” reflects confidence in Manning's development at Texas.

Notable Quotes:

• Doug Gottlieb [08:20]: “He could just explode this year and be projected number one overall. And of course, you got a choice to make at that point.”
• Doug Gottlieb [08:12]: “This is what playing the numbers is all about. It's about making calculated decisions based on performance and projections.”

Insights:

• The discussion highlights the trend of elite quarterbacks staying multiple years in college before entering the NFL, contrasting with the increasing number of one-and-done players.
• Noah [09:21]: Highlights historical precedents where top NFL quarterbacks like Peyton and Eli Manning played their senior years in college, underlining the value of extended collegiate play for development.

Shedeur Sanders' Debut with the Cleveland Browns

Discussion Highlights:

• Shedeur Sanders, son of NFL legend Barry Sanders, is set to make his professional debut with the Cleveland Browns.
• The conversation centers on the expectations and potential impact Sanders could have on the Browns' offense.

Notable Quotes:

• Doug Gottlieb [21:03]: “What should we expect from tonight’s debut? He's a talented player, and even though it's preseason, it's about seeing if he can execute under real game conditions.”
• Noah [22:35]: “He’s accurate and confident out there. He holds the ball a little long, which is something he'll need to adjust.”

Insights:

• Geoff Schwartz provides analysis on Sanders' composure and decision-making abilities in his debut game, emphasizing the importance of his accuracy and confidence.
• Doug Gottlieb suggests that while preseason performances aren't definitive, Sanders has the potential to secure a starting role based on his calm demeanor and precise throws.

Analysis of Current NFL Quarterbacks

Discussion Highlights:

• The panel delves into the performance and expectations of other NFL quarterbacks, comparing them to Arch Manning's situation.
• Anthony Richardson of the Indianapolis Colts is scrutinized for his lack of readiness and decision-making issues.

Notable Quotes:

• Doug Gottlieb [23:38]: “Anthony Richardson just doesn't see the field, doesn't see a blitz, dislocates a pinky finger. Where are you on how much opportunity the Colts should give him heading into the season?”
• Noah [25:43]: “He’s not accurate when he does throw the football. I don't know how you justify playing him.”

Insights:

• The conversation underscores the necessity for consistent performance and experience for young quarterbacks entering the NFL.
• Comparisons are made to other quarterbacks like Joe Burrow and Daniel Jones, highlighting the fine line between potential and actual performance.

Geoff Schwartz's Insights

Discussion Highlights:

• Geoff Schwartz shares his extensive background in college and professional football, providing a nuanced perspective on the current quarterback landscape.
• He discusses the strategic decisions teams make regarding quarterback development and the balance between patience and performance expectations.

Notable Quotes:

• Geoff Schwartz [30:17]: “Portals are nice for a couple of years, but eventually, the high school kids you've developed should be the ones contributing significantly.”
• Geoff Schwartz [31:42]: “I’m excited to see these young guys early in the season. The talent is there; it’s a matter of execution.”

Insights:

• Schwartz emphasizes the importance of player development and the long-term vision teams should have when nurturing young talent.
• He also touches upon the challenges of integrating new players from portal transfers and the impact on team dynamics.

Expectations for the Current NFL Season

Discussion Highlights:

• The hosts and guest analyze the upcoming NFL season’s potential impacts, focusing on teams like the San Francisco 49ers, who are dealing with key player injuries.

Notable Quotes:

• Noah [37:07]: “He’s the one and only Jeff Schwartz. May the Schwartz be with you, Jeff.”
• Geoff Schwartz [35:13]: “You need to see him get better every quarter of the season.”

Insights:

• The implications of injuries on team performance are discussed, particularly how the 49ers might navigate their offensive strategy with key players like Brandon Aiyuk and Juwan Jennings sidelined.
• The importance of coaching decisions and player health in determining a team's success is a recurring theme.

Closing Remarks

Doug Gottlieb wraps up the episode by reiterating the key points discussed, particularly Arch Manning’s decision and Shedeur Sanders’ upcoming debut. The hosts express optimism about the young talent entering the league and the strategic moves teams are making to remain competitive.

Notable Quote:

• Doug Gottlieb [48:57]: “We’re going to look back in 25 years and see how these decisions shaped the future of the league.”

Final Insights:

• The episode underscores the delicate balance between nurturing young talent and meeting immediate team performance expectations.
• The panel anticipates a dynamic and competitive NFL season, driven by the development of promising quarterbacks like Arch Manning and Shedeur Sanders.

Conclusion This episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd provides an in-depth analysis of emerging quarterbacks in college and the NFL, focusing on strategic decisions that could shape their careers and their teams' fortunes. Featuring expert insights from Geoff Schwartz and engaging discussions between Doug Gottlieb and fellow hosts, the episode offers valuable perspectives for sports enthusiasts looking to understand the evolving landscape of American football.