Equinomics, bag fees, and leftover campaign dollars

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Indicator from Planet Money

Episode: Equinomics, bag fees, and leftover campaign dollars
Date: June 4, 2026
Hosts: Adrian Ma, Waylon Wong, Darian Woods
Format: Listener Questions Edition

---

Overview

In this lively, quick-hit episode, The Indicator crew answers three distinct listener questions that dig into surprising facets of the economy: why airlines keep hiking baggage fees, whether declining horse breeding signals a recession, and where campaign money really goes. The hosts consult experts and break down each topic, revealing the economic insights embedded in everyday curiosities.

---

1. Why Are Baggage Fees So High?

Listener Question from Danny Peña
[02:26–04:35]

Key Points

• Consumer Dilemma: Danny, waiting at an airport, asks why airlines don't just lower baggage fees to encourage more people to check their bags upfront.

  • Many travelers face the choice—pay around $50 to check a bag or try to avoid the fee altogether.

• Business Balancing Act:

  • Airlines want to set a baggage fee that makes checking a bag seem worth it, but not lose out on lucrative revenue.
  • Increasingly, flyers pay for the convenience of not hauling a bag through the airport.

• Data-Driven Decisions:

  • Nicholas Rupp, Economics Professor, East Carolina University ([03:39]):
    “Airlines have lots of data. If consumers respond surprising to them, they can always go back and lower the fee, but to my knowledge, they've not reduced bag fees.”
  • Airlines have raised fees because they haven’t seen significant customer pushback.

• Baggage Fees vs. Ticket Revenue:

  • Baggage fees enjoy tax advantages; they're not taxed as heavily as tickets, making them especially valuable to airlines ([04:02]).
  • Consumers often focus on ticket price and overlook the added cost of bag fees until late in the booking process.

• Hacks and Loopholes:

  • Some travelers (like Waylon) wait to check bags at the gate for free, leveraging gate-checking as a workaround ([02:59]).

Notable Quote:
“Baggage fee money is straight up more valuable to the airlines than ticket money.” — Adrian Ma ([04:02])

---

2. Is Low Horse Breeding a Recession Indicator?

Listener Question from John Nagle
[04:38–07:27]

Key Points

• A Surprising Metric: John observes his wife's equine vet practice and wonders if low horse breeding is a sign of economic trouble.

• Historical Decline:

  • Jill Stowe, Professor of Agricultural Economics, University of Kentucky ([05:38]):
    “In the thoroughbred industry, the number of foals peaked in 1986 and has been on a decline ever since. That was made worse in 2008 during the great recession, and then more recently again with COVID and the past few years of inflation.”
  • Multiple economic slowdowns have led to sustained drops in breeding.

• Horses as Luxury Goods:

  • Keeping and breeding horses is expensive, and generally considered a luxury expense.
  • When inflation or economic stress hits, discretionary (luxury) spending like horse breeding gets cut.
  • Some in the industry disagree, but “big picture, they tend to be luxury goods.” — Jill Stowe ([06:21])

• High Barriers for Breeders:

  • The business of breeding horses has slim margins. “It is really difficult for a breeder to recoup the funds that they've spent in selling their young stock.” — Jill Stowe ([06:39])

• Indicator Limitations:

  • Hosts caution against treating niche trends like horse breeding as reliable national recession signals.
  • There are many “personal recession indicators,” but connecting these to broader economic shifts is challenging ([07:08]).

Notable Quote:
“Horses are typically seen as luxury goods... so luxury goods require disposable income to enjoy. When disposable income shrinks... there are less funds for pursuing those activities.” — Jill Stowe ([05:54])

---

3. Where Does Campaign Money Go After an Election?

Listener Question from Brian Sipola
[07:27–09:22]

Key Points

• Spending Breakdown:

  • Huge amounts are spent in political campaigns; where does that money go?

  • Host and expert Paul Ryan (NY Campaign Finance Board) note the biggest categories:

    • Advertising (largest portion)
    • Staff and operational overhead (travel, texting, office expenses)
    • Fundraising (the costly process of raising more donations)
    • Research and polling

  • Paul Ryan:
    “It takes money to raise money, and campaigns these days raise a lot of money... and the last one that I would say is research.” ([08:19])

• Who Benefits?

  • Media companies (local and national) profit from increased ad demand
  • Behind-the-scenes professionals—ad makers, data firms, consultants—receive significant income
  • Local communities benefit from spending on local staff, organizers, and media buys
  • Paul Ryan:
    “It can be significant money flowing through a local economy.” ([09:06])

• Caveat:

  • The economic impact of campaign spending is a redistribution—donors could have spent that same money directly in the community on other goods or services ([09:07]).

Notable Quote:
“Media companies certainly benefit from all that advertising demand... political consultants and pollsters, data firms, they make some good money in this work.” — Paul Ryan ([08:50])

---

Memorable Moments & Quotes

• “I always think just carry-on only—it’s easier.” — Darian Woods ([02:55])
• “There are a lot of personal recession indicators out there... but whether something niche like horse breeding can reliably tell us... maybe a harder connection to make.” — Waylon Wong ([07:08])
• “The donations just really shifted around who benefited.” — Darian Woods ([09:07])

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Listener Questions Intro: [02:23]
• Baggage Fees Segment: [02:26–04:35]
• Horse Breeding Segment: [04:38–07:27]
• Campaign Spending Segment: [07:27–09:22]

---

Episode Tone & Style

Conversational and accessible, sprinkled with in-jokes between the hosts and a tone that’s both light-hearted and analytical. Each question receives a mix of personal reflection, expert input, and economic context—delivered in under ten minutes.

---

For More:
Sign up for The Indicator newsletter (see podcast show notes) or send your own economic curiosities to [e-mail].

Transcript

[NPR Announcer]

npr

[Adrian Ma]

this is the indicator for planet money i'm adrian ma i'm waylon wong

[Darian Woods]

and i'm darian woods uh help what

[Waylon Wong]

would you say dietrich do you need

[Adrian Ma]

assistance i said help what do you

[Darian Woods]

think gwelyn shall we help adrian out

[Waylon Wong]

this feels like the start of a kids show where the episode's mission is about to become clear

[Adrian Ma]

yeah i just i don't know i have all these dang listener questions and i need help

[Darian Woods]

answering them adrian this is something we

[Adrian Ma]

can do coming up why baggage fees cost what they do why people aren't

[Darian Woods]

breeding horses as much and what happens to campaign spending giddy up

[Capella University / LinkedIn Advertiser]

this message comes from capella university you know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you that you were meant for more that's your own drive pushing you towards what's next capella university gets that with their flexpath learning format you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause you've built experience and know what you're capable of now this is your time to turn that momentum into more the only real question is what can't you do learn more

[Progressive Insurance Advertiser]

at capella edu this message comes from progressive insurance insurance isn't one size fits all that's why drivers have enjoyed progressive's name your price tool for years now with the name youe price tool you tell them what you want to pay and they'll show you options that fit your budget so whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family they make it easy to see your options visit progressive dot com progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates price and coverage match limited by state law

[Capella University / LinkedIn Advertiser]

this message comes from linkedin owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once it's even harder to do it efficiently but with linkedin you get all

[Progressive Insurance Advertiser]

the tools you need to grow in

[Capella University / LinkedIn Advertiser]

one place with linkedin simplify your sales marketing and hiring so that you can actually run your small business learn more at linkedin dot com indicatorshow alright it

[Waylon Wong]

is listener questions first up we have

[Adrian Ma]

adrienne matt that's right my listener question comes from danny pena i'm currently at

[Danny Pena (Listener)]

the airport waiting to catch my flight back home to portland and they're calling for volunteers to check their carry on luggage for free why don't the airlines lower the baggage fees to entice more customers to check their luggage this is

[Adrian Ma]

a very good question because i mean lots of people when they go to the airport are making a decision of whether or not it's worth to shell out fifty bucks to not have to

[Darian Woods]

deal with their bag i always think just carry on only it's easier i'm

[Waylon Wong]

also carry on only but if i'm by myself i like to see if i can check my bag for free at the gate because i can't get into the overhead compartment without help and i hate asking for help fair enough

[Adrian Ma]

see this is the consumer side of the equation on the business side there's really this balancing act of how much to charge for checking a bag because danny our listener is right you could just hold onto your luggage through the whole airport and check it in for

[Waylon Wong]

free at the gate right so airlines have to find that sweet spot that makes the extra convenience of dropping it off worth your while and it turns

[Adrian Ma]

out a lot of people are willing to pay more and more for that convenience pretty much every major airline in the us has upped its baggage fees recently nicholas rupp is an economics professor at east carolina university airlines have lots

[Nicholas Rupp]

of data if consumers respond surprising to them they can always go back and lower the fee but to my knowledge they've not reduced bag fees the other

[Adrian Ma]

side of this is that baggage fees are particularly lucrative for airlines they're not taxed as much as tickets so nick says baggage fee money is straight up more valuable to the airlines than ticket

[Waylon Wong]

money and people don't tend to base their flight choice off of baggage fees anyway they're mostly looking at the ticket

[Nicholas Rupp]

price it looks appealing to the consumer who just at the time of the ticket purchase isn't factoring in that bag

[Adrian Ma]

fee cost and don't forget you could always just hold onto your luggage like waylon does till you get to the gate and just let fate do the

[Darian Woods]

rest thanks danny for the question next

[Waylon Wong]

up waylon all right my question is coming from john nagle he asks i believe i've stumbled upon a weird indicator that i want to share with you all my wife is an equine veterinarian and she said that horse breeding is shockingly low right now she's never seen so few people breeding horses as a fan of your show thank you this really piqued my interest as a potential recession indicator that people are cautiously breeding horses because they suspect a recession is coming in the near future this is

[Adrian Ma]

a very well timed question for kentucky derby season i guess it's already over

[Waylon Wong]

how many mint juleps did you drink

[Adrian Ma]

i guess we'll never know

[Waylon Wong]

and you know what this question was kind of tricky too so we reached out to jill stowe she's a professor of agricultural economics at the university of kentucky and she studies equine markets so jill says first of all there has been a decline in horse breeding for a while

[Jill Stowe]

now for example in the thoroughbred industry the number of foals peaked in nineteen eighty six and has been on a

[Waylon Wong]

decline ever since that was made worse in two thousand eight during the great recession and then more recently again with COVID and the past few years of

[Jill Stowe]

inflation cost of everything has been increasing including the cost of keeping horses and you know horses are typically seen as as luxury goods or not necessities and so luxury goods require disposable income to enjoy and when disposable income shrinks due to other factors there are less funds for pursuing those activities jill says luxury

[Waylon Wong]

is a bit of a loaded term

[Jill Stowe]

those of us who are involved in the horse industry we think they're necessities but you know looking looking big picture they they tend to be luxury goods

[Waylon Wong]

either way demand is down when people aren't buying breeders and farm owners need to be honest about whether it's worth it to breed more foals it is

[Jill Stowe]

really difficult for a breeder to recoup the funds that they've spent in selling

[Waylon Wong]

their young stock so to get back to the original question here is this a recession indicator what do you guys

[Darian Woods]

think i mean it does bring into the question what is a recession indicator like will it predict the future i don't know if those really exist to be honest at least as a reliable sign of imminent recession yeah i feel

[Waylon Wong]

like there's a lot of personal recession indicators out there you can see in your own circles how people might be feeling economic pain in different ways but then whether something niche like horse breeding can reliably tell us whether the broader economy is headed into a downturn maybe a harder connection to make thank you

[Adrian Ma]

waylon and to round things out darian woods what's your question our question comes

[Darian Woods]

from brian sipola with elections wrapping up

[Brian Sipola (Listener)]

i have a question about campaign spending where does all the money actually go and who really benefits millions are poured into these races mostly for our ads i assume but does any of that cash actually make a positive impact in

[Darian Woods]

the local community so brian you asked first where does the money actually go

[Waylon Wong]

i feel like a lot of it does go to advertising like brian says and then you would also just have kind of mundane expenses like staff and overhead like travel and i don't know all that texting that i get you

[Darian Woods]

are right paul ryan of new york city's campaign finance board says advertising is often the largest expense but there is

[Paul Ryan]

plenty more door knocking phone calls get out the vote work staging rallies fundraising it takes money to raise money and campaigns these days raise a lot of money so the cost of fundraising itself is a significant expenditures and the last one that i would say is research

[Waylon Wong]

and to brian's next question who benefits

[Darian Woods]

from election spending so media companies certainly benefit from all that advertising demand paul says the professional class behind the election industry is also a winner ad makers

[Paul Ryan]

and political consultants and pollsters data firms they make some good money in this

[Darian Woods]

work paul says local communities are definitely an economic winner too campaigns are hiring local staff organisers and buying ad space from local media to reach everyone it

[Paul Ryan]

can be significant money flowing through a

[Darian Woods]

local economy of course local economies could have benefited in other ways if people hadn't donated to a political campaign and instead i don't know bought a matcha latte or potted plants the donations just really shifted around who benefited darian woods

[Adrian Ma]

thank you very much and thank you brian for that question this has been another listener questions in the bag we love getting your questions and in fact we need more the indicator now has a weekly newsletter where we feature listener questions and you can email us with whatever you're curious about at indicatorpr dot org you can also sign up for said newsletter by checking the show notes

[Waylon Wong]

in your app this episode was produced by cooper katz mckimmin engineered by sina lofredo it was fact checked by sarah juarez kitkankannon is our editor and the indicator is a production of npr

[NPR Announcer]

this message comes from mint mobile if you're tired of spending hundreds on big wireless bills bogus fees and free perks mint mobile might be right for you with plans starting from fifteen bucks a month shop plans today at mintmobile dot com switch upfront payment of forty five dollars for three month five gigabyte plan required new customer offer for first three months only then full price plan options available taxes and fees extra see mint mobile for details support for npr and the following message come from random house publisher of all we say by ben a history of the united states told through fifteen speeches ben rhodes is one of president barack obama's former speechwriters and co host of the foreign policy podcast pod save the all we say is available in hardcover ebook and audiobook everywhere books are sold