Looking for love in the auto supply chain

Summary

The Indicator from Planet Money

Episode: Looking for love in the auto supply chain

Date: November 19, 2025
Hosts: Stephen Bisaha, Waylon Wong

---

Overview

This episode delves into the unexpected consequences of tariffs on the auto industry, specifically how they are sparking new relationships—or at least attempts at them—between U.S. car companies and domestic suppliers. Hosts Stephen Bisaha and Waylon Wong attend an automotive "speed dating" event in Huntsville, Alabama, where automakers and suppliers have just minutes to pitch and connect, hoping to navigate the challenges and opportunities created by rising costs due to tariffs.

---

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Tariffs Hit Car Companies Hard

• Tariff Impact: Carmakers are shouldering close to $30 billion in tariff costs this year—a burden expected to eventually trickle down to consumers through higher car prices.

  • [00:18] Waylon Wong: "That bill will likely be around $30 billion for the carmakers this year ... That will likely end up on the consumer side eventually with higher car prices."

• Buy American as Solution?

  • Automakers seek to mitigate tariffs by sourcing more parts domestically. However, transitioning to American suppliers for everything—from raw steel to finished assemblies—is far from simple.
  • [00:43] Waylon Wong: "...to avoid these costly tariffs, why not just switch to buying those parts from an American supplier? Easy, right?"

---

2. Inside the Auto Industry’s "Speed Dating"

• The Event: Southern Automotive Conference’s matchmaking event, running for 13 years, connects suppliers and buyers in rapid-fire five-minute meetings.

  • [02:46] Chris Miller (event organizer): "Come on in, find your buyers. Have a seat and happy selling."

• Supplier Perspective

  • Jack Grace (Landrum Workforce Solutions) on the "nerve-wracking" nature of five-minute pitches:
    • [03:22] Jack Grace: "Nerve wracking, you know, because you get five minutes to either get it right or not get it right."
  • The format is a welcome alternative to the chaos and inefficiency of traditional trade shows, even if chaotic in its own way.
    • [04:00] Jack Grace: "Having this environment where it's very distilled, albeit a little chaotic, is really interesting."

---

3. Real Sourcing Challenges

• Tariff Pressures for Buyers and Suppliers

  • Doug Drake (Baxter Enterprises) details skyrocketing costs for imported materials—sometimes up to 50% higher, especially for metal clips and components.
    • [04:39] Doug Drake: "I'm seeing anywhere from 15 to 50%, depending on what it is."
  • Existing tariffs: 50% on steel, 25% on auto parts.

• It's Not Just About Price

  • Doug emphasizes the importance of meeting face to face and establishing rapport:
    • [05:14] Doug Drake: "I like to be able to shake hands with them, meet them face to face, and you can get a feel for ... their personality and see if they're going to be an option."
    • [05:28] Doug Drake: "It does me." (when asked if personality matters in manufacturing)

---

4. Openness vs. Hesitance from Automakers

• More Willing to Listen—but Not Desperate

  • Marlena Mellentin (Mazda Toyota, Ala.) expresses openness to new suppliers but is not in a hurry:

    • [05:51] Marlena Mellentin: "We're looking for ways that we can maybe save money with tariffs being what they are now. So we're just open to whatever's out there."
    • [06:10] Marlena Mellentin: "We have sourced for most of the things that we procure, but we're always open to better services, better pricing."

  • Automotive consulting expert Amy Broglan Peterson compares supplier selection to dating strategies—never wanting to look too eager:

    • [06:30] Amy Broglan Peterson: "You never want to look like you're desperate. Like it's, it's like a strategy."

• The Real Hurdles: Long Commitments and Validation

  • Contracts with other suppliers, sunk costs in tooling, and the technical process of validating new suppliers all slow the pivot to new domestic partners.
    • [07:15] Amy Broglan Peterson: "...you have to validate suppliers. So that can be a very lengthy process, and it's certainly one you don't want to skip over or take lightly..."
    • [07:41] Amy Broglan Peterson: "...it can mean quality issues and thus higher cost, warranty cost, repair cost, degraded consumer perception..."

---

5. Slow Progress and Uncertain Future

• Meaningful Matches Are Rare

  • Even with these events, deals take time and most meetings don't lead immediately to business. Organizers lack hard stats on success.
    • [08:13] Stephen Bisaha: "...she does always hear from buyers that they have still found new suppliers at the event, though she doesn't have hard numbers on that."
  • The validation and ramp up for a new supplier can take a year or longer—even as companies pay tariffs while waiting.

• Tariff Policy Instability

  • If tariffs disappeared suddenly, current budding domestic supplier deals could unravel overnight—demonstrating how uncertainty undermines widespread change.

---

6. The Human Side of the Supply Chain

• Supplier Competition Isn’t Just International

  • Chris Miller (Olympic Steel) notes sometimes you find out your competitor is the very company with whom you’re meeting—not a foreign rival:
    • [09:01] Chris Miller: "We're under a one minute meeting. ... you can kind of get that feel pretty quick because you heard what she said. They do the same thing that we do."

• Defining Success: The Follow-Up, Not the First Date

  • Realist takeaways: The speed dating event is about making an initial connection—“getting that card,” not closing deals on the spot.
    • [09:37] Waylon Wong: "...it's about getting that card, making that connection. It's about the chance at a longer second date because when it comes to changing up supply chains, even the car world takes things slow."

---

Notable Quotes

• On five-minute supplier pitches:
  “[The event is] nerve wracking, you know, because you get five minutes to either get it right or not get it right.”
  — Jack Grace, [03:22]

• On openness (and limits) to new suppliers:
  “We have sourced for most of the things that we procure, but we’re always open to better services, better pricing.”
  — Marlena Mellentin, [06:10]

• On the complexity of switching suppliers:
  “...you have to validate suppliers. So that can be a very lengthy process, and it's certainly one you don't want to skip over or take lightly because it can mean quality issues and thus higher cost, warranty cost, repair cost, degraded consumer perception and things like that.”
  — Amy Broglan Peterson, [07:15]

• On the real goal of networking:
  “It’s about getting that card, making that connection. It's about the chance at a longer second date because when it comes to changing up supply chains even the car world takes things slow.”
  — Waylon Wong, [09:37]

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [00:12] – How tariffs are impacting carmakers and consumers
• [02:46] – Inside the automotive speed dating event
• [03:22] – Jack Grace on the challenge of pitching in five minutes
• [04:39] – Doug Drake on soaring materials costs
• [05:51] – Marlena Mellentin on openness to new suppliers
• [06:30] – Amy Broglan Peterson on supplier selection strategy
• [07:15] – Validation and commitment hurdles for new suppliers
• [09:01] – Chris Miller on rapid supplier meetings
• [09:37] – The realistic goal: making connections, not closing deals

---

Conclusion

The episode highlights how tariffs are forcing automakers and suppliers to reevaluate their partnerships, but “love” in the auto supply chain is hard-won. Fast introductions at matchmaking events seldom yield quick deals; instead, they’re just the first spark in what must be a careful and deliberate relationship-building process. Even with mounting incentives from tariffs, trust, compatibility, and the inertia of existing contracts keep true change slow—a reminder that in this business, it’s always a long courtship, not a whirlwind romance.

Transcript

[Marlena Mellentin]

Npr.

[Stephen Bisaha]

One of the big economic surprises this year is how long it took tariffs to hit consumer wallets.

[Waylon Wong]

The key word here is consumer wallets. If you're say a car company, then, well, tariffs have been expensive. That bill will likely be around $30 billion for the carmakers this year, according to Mo. And that will likely end up on the consumer side eventually with higher car prices.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Now there is a solution for carmakers and it gets to one of the main objectives behind Buy American.

[Waylon Wong]

Foreign automakers already have huge assembly plants in the US but lots of parts and materials come from overseas. So to avoid these costly tariffs, why not just switch to buying those parts from an American supplier? Easy, right?

[Stephen Bisaha]

But how do you actually meet those US Companies for everything from raw steel to finished parts to staffing? Well, there's always speed dating. This is the indicator from Planet Money. I'm Stephen Bisaha.

[Waylon Wong]

And I'm Waylon Wong. On today's show, we go to an auto manufacturing speed dating event to see if tariffs can really lead to a spark between carmakers and US Suppliers.

[Stephen Bisaha]

And we learn why supply chain matchmaking is less quick playing than long courtship.

[Waylon Wong]

I gotta pitch this to Netflix.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Steven Love is blind. Move on over.

[US Bank Announcer]

This message comes from US Bank As a small business owner, you're used to doing it all, but US Bank Business Essentials is here to help. It's a powerful combination of checking and card payment processing that gets you fast access to the money you've earned with no monthly maintenance fee, checking and unlimited digital transactions. They even have small business specialists that work together with you to help your business reach its full potential. That's the power of US Deposit products are offered by US Bank national association member fdic. This message comes from Vanguard. Capturing value in the bond market is not easy. That's why Vanguard offers a suite of over 80 institutional quality bond funds actively managed by a 200 person global team of sector specialists, analysts and traders. And they're designed for financial advisors looking to give their clients consistent results year in and year out. See the [e-mail] audio that's vanguard.com audio all investing is subject to risk. Vanguard Marketing Corporation Distributor.

[Chris Miller]

Come on in, Find your buyers. Have a seat and happy selling.

[Stephen Bisaha]

If you were looking to pick a romantic spot for a first date, you'd probably skip the ballrooms in Huntsville, Alabama's Von Braun Center. Between the fluorescent lights, those gray conference room dividers and the more than 180 salespeople in loud pitching mode, it's not exactly a candlelit dinner.

[Waylon Wong]

But one thing it does have in common with actual dating are the jitters.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Jack Grace is with Landrum Workforce Solutions and is the director of sales for its workforce management team. The company provides staffing and consulting. So how's the speed dating been going?

[Jack Grace]

Nerve wracking, you know, because you get five minutes to either get it right or not get it right.

[Waylon Wong]

And he's right. Sellers like Jack get just five minutes to pitch many of the biggest car companies like Honda, Mercedes and Hyundai, until the beat means it's on to the next date.

[Stephen Bisaha]

The Southern Automotive Conference has been doing this matchmaking event for 13 years. The big idea here is just making networking easier.

[Waylon Wong]

And yes, it is only five minutes, but Jack says that's way better than the typical conference experience where you're running around the trade floor trying to find a buyer and then only end up pitching to another salesperson.

[Jack Grace]

You know, you're both wasting each other's time. You know, they're selling your product to somebody who can't buy it. Having this environment where it's very distilled, albeit a little chaotic, is really interesting.

[Waylon Wong]

And one thing that's got just about everyone's interest this year is tariffs.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Yeah. On the buyer side, there are a lot of foreign car companies feeling that tariff sting. And American companies have not been spared either. Like Baxter Enterprises out of Tennessee, it provides tools and finished parts for automakers like Mercedes and BMW.

[Waylon Wong]

Doug Drake is here representing Baxter. He says the cost of materials he gets from overseas are just so starting to go up.

[Doug Drake]

A lot of. I'm seeing anywhere from 15 to 50%, depending on what it is.

[Stephen Bisaha]

15 to 50%. 50% is pretty high.

[CIDQ Announcer]

Yeah.

[Doug Drake]

Yeah, that's some. On some of the metal clips and components. Yeah, it's 50%.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Now, we don't know if that's all tariffs, but there is currently a 50% tariff on steel from most countries. For auto parts, it's 25%. And don't expect any Supreme Court tariff relief here. These tariffs are not the reciprocal tariffs the court could get rid of.

[Waylon Wong]

Now, Doug's not here just looking for the supplier with the lowest price. He wants to meet someone he actually wants to work with.

[Doug Drake]

I like to be able to shake hands with them, meet them face to face, and you can get a feel for kind of what they're. You know, I can get a feel generally for their personality and see if they're going to be an option.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Does personality matter in the manufacturing world?

[Doug Drake]

It does me.

[Waylon Wong]

Does Doug like pina coladas and getting lost in the rain?

[Stephen Bisaha]

He kind of gave me more Guinness kind of vibe. I don't think that, but it's still, yeah, hopeless romantic at the heart there of Doug. And he is not the only one there being picky. Marlena Mellentin represented the joint Mazda Toyota factory in Alabama.

[Marlena Mellentin]

We're looking for ways that we can maybe save money with tariffs being what they are now. So we're just open to whatever's out there.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Yeah, that's what I heard, was that maybe companies are more open to some of these pitches because of tariffs right now. And that's your case.

[Marlena Mellentin]

That's exactly true. Absolutely more open.

[Waylon Wong]

But Marlena's not rushing into anything.

[Marlena Mellentin]

We have sourced for most of the things that we procure, but we're always open to better services, better pricing.

[Waylon Wong]

So a bit of a mixed message here. Tariffs are leading these carmakers to look at American suppliers, but some are saying they don't really, really need them. Amy Broglan Peterson says this is like actual dating.

[Amy Broglan Peterson]

You never want to look like you're desperate. Like it's, it's like a strategy.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Amy knows that strategy well. She used to be a buyer for Ford and now does her own consulting along with teaching at Michigan State University.

[Waylon Wong]

Of course, Amy says not all carmakers are playing hard to get just as a strategy.

[Amy Broglan Peterson]

Truly, though, there are some other reasons why they would kind of come off that way. And number one, a lot of it could be tied up in long term.

[Waylon Wong]

Agreements, agreements with other suppliers that they would have to drop to switch to an American company.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Ooh, Waylon, we got some drama stealing someone else's carmaker.

[Waylon Wong]

Save it for the Netflix pitch, Steven. Amy doesn't believe these car companies would agree to contracts with big penalties for changing suppliers. So that's not the issue with switching.

[Amy Broglan Peterson]

But still, you've sunk capital into tooling, typically with suppliers, and then more importantly, perhaps in many cases, you have to validate suppliers.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Validating suppliers. Think of this as the phase past that first date, past the flirting. It's the serious relationship talk. Can the supplier meet the company's specs? Will their parts mesh well with parts from other suppliers?

[Amy Broglan Peterson]

So that can be a very lengthy process, and it's certainly one you don't want to skip over or take lightly because it can mean quality issues and thus higher cost, warranty cost, repair cost, degraded consumer perception and things like that. So there's a lot of reasons that they aren't just eagerly saying, yeah, let's strike a deal and we want to move.

[Waylon Wong]

Right.

[Stephen Bisaha]

I spoke with the auto speed dating events organizer and she said she does always hear from buyers that they have still found new suppliers at the event, though she doesn't have hard numbers on that.

[Waylon Wong]

She also said the industry could use more breathing room on tariffs. It can take more than a year to get a supplier's parts onto a car. In the meantime, car companies are still paying those tariffs.

[Stephen Bisaha]

At the same time, if tariffs went away tomorrow, that could pull the rug out from some of these deals in the works.

[Chris Miller]

Chris Miller, nice to meet you. Pleasure to meet you.

[Waylon Wong]

Chris Miller understands how hard it is to make a deal with these carmakers. He's here representing Olympic Steel out of Georgia. He wants to see if any of the buyers want the steel or some of the other materials he has to sell.

[Stephen Bisaha]

And if not, well, sometimes a five minute meeting is more like a one minute meeting.

[Chris Miller]

We're under a one minute meeting. So it's kind of, you kind of can get that feel pretty quick because you heard what she said. They do the same thing that we do.

[Waylon Wong]

That's the other challenge. So someone like Chris might not be competing against a foreign still supplier, but the company itself. And he might not know that until he sits down and asks.

[US Bank Announcer]

Perfect.

[Chris Miller]

Thank you so much for your time.

[Waylon Wong]

Pleasure.

[Stephen Bisaha]

Hey, so last meeting, how did it go? Went good.

[Chris Miller]

Yeah. Got a card and that could be a potential good one.

[Waylon Wong]

Chris says the matchmaking is not about getting to a deal in five minutes. Instead, it's about getting that card, making that connection. It's about the chance at a longer second date because when it comes to changing up supply chains, even the car world takes things slow.

[Stephen Bisaha]

This episode was produced by Angel Carreras and engineered by Robert Rodriguez. It was fact checked by Tyler Jones. Kid Concannon is our editor and the indicator is a production of npr.

[CIDQ Announcer]

This message comes from the Council for Interior Design Qualification. Interior designer and CIDQ president Siyavash Madani explains the value of having an NCIDQ certification.

[Siyavash Madani]

An NCIDQ certified interior designer must complete a minimum of six years of specialized education and work experience and pass the three part NCIDQ exam. All three exams emphasize and focus on health, safety and welfare of the occupants. It's really about the implementation of design. Good design is never just about aesthetics. It's about intention, safety and impact. We take the responsibility of protecting the public seriously. The space needs to be functional, safe and accessible.

[CIDQ Announcer]

To learn more about NCIDQ certification or to hire a Certified Designer, visit CIDQ.org NPR this message comes from Capital One. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums. On checking accounts, what's in your wallet? Terms apply. See capitalone.combank for details. Capital One NA Member, FDIC.