Waylon Wong (2:36)

All right, so here's an example. Let's say Adrian and I have our new very own crypto token.

Adrian Ma (2:42)

Get it while you can.

Waylon Wong (2:45)

Indicator Coin. Okay, so Adrian, I sell it to you, okay?

Adrian Ma (2:50)

And then I sell it back to you.

Waylon Wong (2:53)

And then I sell it back to you. And as we go back and forth, the trading volume for Indicator Coin goes up, the price goes up, and unsuspecting investors look at this and they think, wow, Indicator Coin must be a Good.

Adrian Ma (3:07)

Investment and this is how we get you. Leah says this is a classic use case for WASH trading.

Leah Foley (3:14)

So the WASH trades facilitate pump and dump schemes by creating the false appearance of a robust and active trading market with lots of holders and traders.

Waylon Wong (3:23)

But unscrupulous token creators are not the only ones who can benefit from WASH trading. Crypto exchanges, you know, the platforms where people buy and sell crypto also have an incentive to do it in order to make money.

Adrian Ma (3:35)

Crypto exchanges need users. But these users, they want to be where the action is, where a lot of trading is happening and. And many researchers believe that crypto exchanges have often engaged in WASH trading to artificially boost trading volumes and entice these users onto their platforms. Shi Li teaches finance at the University of reading in the UK and she co authored that 2023 study exploring how wash trading is used in crypto markets.

Leah Foley (4:01)

And when more traders come in, you know they will contribute a transaction fee. So that would be a very important revenue for our crypto exchanges.

Adrian Ma (4:11)

So WASH trading is one way for crypto exchanges to pump up their trading volume to fake it until they make it.

Waylon Wong (4:18)

So that's the basic idea behind WASH trading. But in the age of crypto, the way WASH trading is done has gone through a few evolutions. Yang Yang is a lecturer at the University of Bristol, also in the uk. He worked on the same study as Shi Li and he says in the early days of crypto, companies employed what he calls wash trading 1.0.

Yang Yang (4:39)

So basically, exchanges just print out fake trades on their database. So this is a very simple and effective way. But the drawback is people can spot this easily.

Adrian Ma (4:53)

Like almost as if you have an accounting ledger and you just like write.

Yang Yang (4:56)

In fake entries and demonstrate them on their front end website.

Adrian Ma (5:01)

Yeah. Because this method was so easy to spot, Yang says companies eventually moved on to what he calls wash trading 2.0. That's where a company uses bots or hires an outside firm to execute WASH trades. And he says this is harder to catch because you're not just adding numbers to a ledger. These trades, whether they're being done by humans or bots, are actually happening. But sort of like a Potemkin village, it's all a facade.

Waylon Wong (5:28)

For a while, US regulators had been slow to figure out how to tackle the growing problem of WASH trading. But Last year, the U.S. department of justice announced an approach that was at once new and old fashioned. They launched a sting called Operation Token Mirrors.

Leah Foley (5:44)

Who comes up with the names for these sting operations? Julia Joint effort.

Waylon Wong (5:51)

I would love to be in that brainstorming session, I'm just picturing everyone in like, wearing like, FBI jackets.

Adrian Ma (5:56)

Operation Whalen kicks butt.

Waylon Wong (5:58)

Ooh, I like the sound of that. By the way, that was U.S. attorney Leah Foley again talking with their producer Cooper. Leah explained how Operation Token Mirrors was designed to catch crypto companies engaged in Wash trading. Her office worked with the FBI on the case.

Leah Foley (6:14)

So they actually set up a company and created their own cryptocurrency and they included a website for the fake crypto.

Adrian Ma (6:26)

Then the FBI, posing as this crypto company, approached various people who offered volume support services, which is basically a less incriminating way of saying, we'll do Wash trading for you. And when they did, this is about the time the Feds sprang out of the bushes and yelled, gotcha.

Waylon Wong (6:44)

As a result of this operation, the DOJ charged 18 individuals and companies with fraud and manipulation in the crypto market.

Leah Foley (6:52)

Thus far, eight different defendants have pled guilty. And there are some people who pled guilty and fled the United States and others who are just outside the jurisdiction of the the United States but are still charged.

Waylon Wong (7:09)

Leah says her office will continue to pursue illegal activity in the crypto markets. But a few months ago, the Trump administration dropped a lawsuit against the largest crypto trading platform, Binance. The company had been accused of mishandling customer funds, lying to regulators, and engaging in Wash trading.

Adrian Ma (7:27)

Even without the Feds breathing down their neck, crypto companies can still exploit gray areas in the law. And one of our digital currency experts, Yang Yang, says Binance is actually a great example. Not long ago, Binance launched a program called Alpha Points. Basically, it's a system that incentivizes traders to keep actively trading. The more they trade, the more points they can earn. And the more points they get, the more they can redeem them for rewards. And this helps pump up the trading volume on Binance. Yang actually calls this wash trading 3.0.

Yang Yang (8:00)

So in this case, you can even argue, does this even count for as was trading or not? But in our opinion, the purpose of this large scale trading are still just to boost up volume.

Waylon Wong (8:14)

We reached out to Binance for comment. A Binance spokesperson, Simon Matthews, rejected the comparison to Wash Trading. He added that users can choose how to engage with Binance Alpha and that they do not have to trade.

Adrian Ma (8:27)

Which I guess brings us back to where we started. While there is certainly a lot of buzz around crypto right now, it is worth keeping in mind that this industry is still pretty unregulated and things may not always be as they appear. This episode was produced by Cooper Katz McKim with engineering by Gilly Moon. It was fact checked by Sierra Juarez and edited by Julia Richie Kanken. Ken is our editor and the indicators of production of npr.

Waylon Wong (8:55)

Can you can you do your best job?

Adrian Ma (8:56)

Bluth impression what's a line that Joe Bluth says?

Waylon Wong (9:01)

They're illusions Michael.

NPR Announcer (9:07)

This message comes from Mint Mobile. If you're tired of spending hundreds on big wireless bills, bogus fees and free perks, Mint Mobile might be right for you with plans starting from 15 bucks a month. Shop plans today@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment of 45 dollars for 3 month 5 gigabyte plan required. New customer offer for first 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details.

Sponsor Announcer (9:32)

This message comes from Bombas. You need better socks and slippers and underwear because you should love what you wear every day. One purchased equals one donated. Go to bombas.com NPR and use code NPR for 20% off.

NPR Announcer (9:50)

This message comes from Warby Parker. What makes a great pair of glasses at Warby Parker? It's all the invisible extras without the extra cost, like free adjustments for life. Find your pair@warbyparker.com or visit one of their hundreds of stores around the country.